A Parish in Mourning: The Murder of Father Paul Artwork

Welsh Mysteries and Histories

Behind Wales’ sweeping landscapes and proud traditions lies a darker, more unsettling story — one written in whispers, rumours, and cases that refuse to rest.

Welsh Mysteries and Histories uncovers the crimes, disappearances and unexplained events that have slipped through the cracks of mainstream true crime. From chilling unsolved murders to baffling local mysteries, each episode explores stories that still linger in the shadows of valleys, towns and coastlines.

But the unease doesn’t end with crime. Wales is a land shaped by myth, folklore and forgotten histories — tales that blur the line between legend and reality, and continue to haunt the present.

Meticulously researched and told with care, context and deep respect, this is where Wales’ hidden stories are finally brought into the light.

All Episodes

Welsh Mysteries and Histories

A Parish in Mourning: The Murder of Father Paul

July 14, 2025 • Kay Page • Season 2 • Episode 2

0:00 | 47:22

Send us Fan Mail

In this gripping episode of Welsh Mysteries and Histories, we delve into one of Wales’ most haunting crimes — the brutal 1984 murder of Father Paul Hughes, a beloved Catholic priest found dead in his Carmarthenshire presbytery.

Titled A Parish in Mourning, this episode uncovers the chilling details surrounding Father Paul’s final hours, the community’s shock, and the strange silence that followed. Was it a robbery gone wrong, or something far more sinister cloaked in secrecy? We explore the police investigation, examine key suspects, and ask why—over four decades later—this case remains cold despite whispers of motive and opportunity.

Through archive accounts, local insight, and careful research, this episode paints a vivid picture of a parish gripped by fear, loss, and lingering suspicion. Join us as we revisit this tragic mystery and consider what it means when justice is never served.

Perfect for true crime lovers and history enthusiasts, A Parish in Mourning is a must-listen for anyone drawn to Wales’ most perplexing unsolved cases.

Where you can find us?

**Our brand new website is coming soon**

For more information on the podcast and the hosts, make sure you check out this link.

Work with us?

If you have a particular case that you would like us to cover, please feel free to contact us via the email below.

We are also open to discussing business and sponsorship opportunities via this email - hello@welsh-mysteries.co.uk.