51. What To Do With Your UK Pensions Once You Settle In The US: Maximise The Potential And Avoid The Landmines | Ask An Expert with Holly Caulder

We're The Brits In America

We're The Brits In America
51. What To Do With Your UK Pensions Once You Settle In The US: Maximise The Potential And Avoid The Landmines | Ask An Expert with Holly Caulder
Jun 25, 2025
Richard Taylor - Plan First Wealth

If you're an expat of means in America and you don't have a good cross-border team around you - financial, tax, and estate – there’s a high chance you’re in non-compliance. That’s especially true with UK pension holders in the US. 

This week’s Ask An Expert is with Holly Caulder, partner at Buzzacott. Holly specialises in planning and advice solutions for US residents with non-US pensions, shareholders of controlled foreign corporations and beneficiaries of non-US trusts. If this is you, you won’t want to miss this episode. 

The potential landmines are significant, so you’ll hear how Holly and Richard would advise you to:

  • Report UK Pensions Correctly in the US

 If you have a UK pension, it must be reported on key US tax forms like the FBAR and Form 8938, even if it’s inactive and no new contributions are being made. Holly stresses that failing to do this can lead to serious IRS penalties.

  • Use the US-UK Tax Treaty to Your Advantage

 The US-UK tax treaty can help reduce your tax bill. Filing Form 8833 lets you claim treaty benefits, such as excluding UK pension growth from US tax. Richard points out that doing this every year can save money and avoid trouble.

  • Plan Pension Moves Carefully

 Thinking about rolling over your pension or taking a distribution (e.g. transferring to a SIPP)? Talk to a tax advisor first. Holly notes that claiming treaty exemptions early and knowing state tax rules (like in California vs. New York) can prevent surprise taxes. Get advice before making any moves to stay compliant and minimise tax.

If you're enjoying the show, please follow it wherever you’re listening to it now, and consider leaving a 5 star rating and review to help the mission, which is to help expats and immigrants thrive in America. Visit planfirstwealth.com to learn more about our services and connect with Richard Taylor on LinkedIn.

We're the Brits in America is affiliated with Plan First Wealth LLC, an SEC registered investment advisor. The views and opinions expressed in this program are those of the speakers and do not necessarily reflect the views or positions of Plan First Wealth.

Information presented is for educational purposes only and does not intend to make an offer or solicitation for the sale or purchase of any specific securities, investments, or investment strategies. Investments involve risk and unless otherwise stated, are not guaranteed. Be sure to first consult with a qualified financial adviser and/or tax professional before implementing any strategy discussed herein. Plan First Wealth does not provide any tax and/or legal advice and strongly recommends that listeners seek their own advice in these areas.

Episode Artwork 51. What To Do With Your UK Pensions Once You Settle In The US: Maximise The Potential And Avoid The Landmines | Ask An Expert with Holly Caulder 48:49 Episode Artwork 50. Turning Market Volatility Into Tax Savings - 50th Episode Special | From The Trenches with James Boyle 41:03 Episode Artwork 49. Everything You Need To Know About Tax Compliance – From An IRS Veteran | Ask An Expert with Dan Price 43:06 Episode Artwork 48. Mastering The Art of Doing Nothing | From The Trenches with James Boyle 33:28 Episode Artwork 47. PFICs: The Number One Expat Landmine That Can Easily Be Avoided 40:16 Episode Artwork 46. Trump, Tariffs, Mayhem - The Week From Investing Hell | From The Trenches with James Boyle 29:25 Episode Artwork Trailer: What Can You Expect From We're The Brits In America? 1:24 Episode Artwork 45. Leaving the USA: Relinquishing Green Card / Renouncing US Citizenship - Beware The Exit Tax | Ask an Expert with Virginia La Torre Jeker, J.D. 1:01:54 Episode Artwork 44. Retirement Strategies Amid S&P 500 Fluctuations: What Are Your Options? | From The Trenches with Richard Taylor and James Boyle 46:04 Episode Artwork 43. UK Domicile & Tax Changes: What You Need to Know About the Changes to Worldwide Assets 48:49 Episode Artwork 42. Bubbles, Tariffs & General Chaos | From The Trenches with James Boyle 41:13 Episode Artwork 41. Finding Peace in Uncertainty: What Two Cancer Diagnoses Taught Keith Hunt | Always An Expat 41:21 Episode Artwork 40. Welcome the Wobble | From The Trenches with James Boyle 42:23 Episode Artwork 39. There Are SEVERE Penalties for Tax Non-Compliance. Here’s How to Avoid Them | Ask An Expert with Ishali Patel 38:47 Episode Artwork 38. Hope Springs Eternal - 2024 in Review | From The Trenches with James Boyle 50:00 Episode Artwork 37. IRS Penalty Abatement: How Reasonable Cause Works | Ask An Expert with Virginia La Torre Jeker 50:36 Episode Artwork 36. Retiring in America: What You Need to Know About Healthcare | Ask An Expert with Misty Kimbrough 44:42 Episode Artwork 35. Decisions, Dollars and Domicile: How US Elections and UK Tax Shifts Impact Expats | From The Trenches with James Boyle 36:30 Episode Artwork 34. How FX Brokers Help You Avoid Thousands In Fees | Ask An Expert with David Nixon 44:46 Episode Artwork 33. Don't Just Do Something, Stand There | From The Trenches with James Boyle 36:41 Episode Artwork 32. Swapping Notes With An Aussie Financial Planner | From The Trenches with GFPI Founder Ashley Murphy 58:29 Episode Artwork 31. You Come To The US To Make It, Don’t Jeopardize That By Making Mistakes | From The Trenches with James Boyle 39:40 Episode Artwork 30. How to Get a US/UK Cross-Border Estate Plan Done | Ask An Expert with Paula Jones 1:00:58 Episode Artwork 29. No One’s Built Weath In A Savings Account | From The Trenches with James Boyle 39:44 Episode Artwork 28. US/UK Estate Planning 2 - Living Trusts | Ask An Expert with Aidan Grant 40:31