202: You Think You’re Failing, I Think You’re Quitting Too Soon

The Well Nourished Podcast

The Well Nourished Podcast
202: You Think You’re Failing, I Think You’re Quitting Too Soon
Nov 12, 2026 Episode 202 Melissa Eich

Click here to save your seat for the masterclass: https://melissaeichwellness.com/masterclass

You had a rough day. You skipped breakfast, grabbed something quick, and by the time you walk in the door you’re exhausted, hungry, and telling yourself you’ve already blown it, so you’ll just start fresh tomorrow. In this episode, I’m teaching you the skill I teach every client inside Well Nourished: making your next best decision. It’s how you stop starting over, build real self-trust, and stay with yourself long enough to create results that last.

IN THIS EPISODE, YOU’LL LEARN:

  • Why millennial and Gen X women learned they had to do everything, and do it perfectly, and how that shows up in weight loss
  • What your NBD (next best decision) is, and why it also stands for “no big deal”
  • The difference between being restrictive and being committed
  • How you can have boundaries around your decisions without creating a restrictive relationship with food
  • Why eating very little Monday through Thursday can erase your results by Sunday
  • How much of your effort is happening in your mind versus in your actual life
  • Why it’s better to be overwhelmed by your solutions than by your problems
  • How to be disappointed by the scale without abandoning yourself
  • Why you still need a plan, and how your next best decision works inside of it

TIMESTAMPS:

00:18 — Why we learned we had to do it all, and do it well
 02:37 — People pleasing and the pressure to do weight loss perfectly
 04:38 — Introducing your NBD: your next best decision
 07:00 — Restriction vs. commitment
 09:20 — Nutrition, energy deficits, and the weekday to weekend cycle
 11:44 — When your nutrition becomes a last minute decision
 12:33 — Is your effort happening in your mind or in your life?
 14:49 — Be overwhelmed by your solutions, not your problems
 15:55 — Putting your readers on to see what’s really happening
 17:24 — Why we need the full week of data
 18:03 — When you’ve been trying and nothing has changed
 20:20 — Being disappointed without abandoning yourself
 22:43 — The hardest moment of your day is your NBD moment
 24:16 — “What can I do right now?” and building self-trust
 26:49 — Why you still need a plan
 28:57 — What the Reset teaches us about following through
 30:33 — Imagine getting your mental energy back
 32:26 — Getting good at the foundations instead of the next new thing
 34:26 — Join me for the Midlife Weight Loss Masterclass

RESOURCES:

🎓 Free Midlife Weight Loss Masterclass: Join me live on Tuesday, November 17th at noon CST. I’m teaching the two mistakes keeping women from losing weight in midlife and the four things to focus on instead so you can lose body fat, build muscle, and create results that last. If you’re in your 40s or 50s and navigating perimenopause or menopause, this class is for you. Can’t make it live? Register anyway and you’ll get the replay. Save your seat at melissaeichwellness.com/masterclass 🎧 Related Episode: Episode 201, What If You’re Doing Too Many Things to Lose Weight? https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/200-200-episodes-four-years-and-everything-youve/id1650475536?i=1000798684393

CONNECT WITH ME:

📱 Instagram: @melissa_eich | DM me “MASTERCLASS” for the link | 🌐 Website: melissaeichwellness.com | 💌 Email: melissa@melissaeichwellness.com

ABOUT THE SHOW:

The Well Nourished Podcast (formerly Body Led by Design) is for midlife women who are ready to feel good in their bodies again. Hosted by Melissa Eich, RN, functional health coach, and nervous system and somatic practitioner, each episode explores nourishment, hormones, digestion, muscle, and weight loss resistance so you can stop fighting your body and start working with it.

LEAVE A REVIEW:

If this episode resonated with you, I’d be so grateful if you’d leave a 5-star review. Your reviews help more midlife women find this podcast and learn how to truly nourish their bodies.

Keywords: next best decision, stop starting over, all or nothing thinking, midlife weight loss, restriction vs commitment, self-trust and weight loss, perimenopause weight loss, midlife weight loss masterclass


Episode Artwork 202: You Think You’re Failing, I Think You’re Quitting Too Soon 33:22 Episode Artwork 201: What If You’re Doing Too Many Things to Lose Weight? 33:16 Episode Artwork 200: 200 Episodes, Four Years, and Everything You’ve Wanted to Ask Me 38:16 Episode Artwork 199: GLP-1s After 40 - Are You Getting Healthier or Just Smaller? 28:03 Episode Artwork 198: What Happened Before the Weight Gain? 24:35 Episode Artwork 197: How to Stop Overcomplicating Weight Loss 28:09 Episode Artwork 196: How Do I Know If I’m Eating Too Little or Too Much? 22:25 Episode Artwork 195: The Two Reasons You Can't Get the Workout Done 21:59 Episode Artwork 194: You Don't Need More to Do, You Need Support 11:10 Episode Artwork Replay: The Midlife Weight Loss Masterclass 1:08:48 Episode Artwork 192: Is It Your Gut? Why You're Bloated, Tired, and Not Losing Weight 23:47 Episode Artwork 191: Are Your Hormones Why You Can't Lose Weight? 21:46 Episode Artwork 190: A GLP Is Neither Mandatory Nor Magic 19:02 Episode Artwork 189: Why Stress Keeps Weight on Your Body 22:37 Episode Artwork 188: Sleep is When You Shift Body Fat: The Sleep S of 6S Method 28:56 Episode Artwork 187: Your Muscle is Your 401k — The Strength S of the 6S Method 15:37 Episode Artwork 186: Why Perfect Macros Keep You Stuck - Nutrition of the 6S Method 29:36 Episode Artwork 185: Emotional & Mental Weight Loss Resistance: How to Think & Feel Your Way to Results 17:23 Episode Artwork 184: Labs & Weight Loss Resistance for Midlife Women 32:42 Episode Artwork 183: Why You're Stuck — The Physical Root Causes of Weight Loss Resistance 26:47 Episode Artwork 182: What is Weight Loss Resistance & Do You Have It 21:07 Episode Artwork 181: Food Noise, Tapering, and Plateaus with GLP's - Part 3/3 35:47 Episode Artwork 180: How To Make A GLP1 Work Hard For You 42:34 Episode Artwork 179: GLP-1 for Midlife Women & Where to Begin | Part 1/3 33:36 Episode Artwork 178: PMOS, Weight Loss Resistance & the Dutch Test 27:48