What Went Wrong in Afghanistan? Understanding the Taliban to Shape U.S. Policy

At The Boundary

At The Boundary
What Went Wrong in Afghanistan? Understanding the Taliban to Shape U.S. Policy
Aug 18, 2025 Season 3 Episode 95

Text the ATB Team! We'd love to hear from you!

In this episode of GNSI’s “At the Boundary” podcast, Arman Mahmoudian, PhD, interviews Marvin G. Weinbaum, PhD, who is senior fellow at the Middle East Institute and professor emeritus of political science at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign. Drawing on his recent article, “Our Knowledge of the Taliban as Guide for US Policy” ( which was recently published in the Journal of Strategic Security), Dr. Weinbaum offers a detailed assessment of the collapse of the Afghan state and the return of the Taliban in 2021.

This episode discusses:

  • Why the U.S. failed at state-building and counterinsurgency in Afghanistan
  • The shift from counterterrorism to democratic nation-building
  • Weinbaum’s analysis of Afghan leadership under Karzai and Ghani, and how their governance choices helped shape the state’s collapse
  • Fragmentation within the Taliban leadership
  • How the presence of ISIS-K pressures Taliban unity and policy
  • The collapse of U.S. military support and Afghan troop morale
  • Dangers of a failed Taliban state and the regional risk of civil war
  • Weinbaum’s direct message to Afghans affected by the regime change

Throughout the interview, Weinbaum emphasizes that U.S. disengagement has reduced its leverage on critical issues like human rights, warning that effective diplomacy with the Taliban requires long-term engagement, not conditional demands. He also argues that continued absence risks ceding influence to regional powers already moving toward recognition.

 Links from the episode:

Register for CyberBay Here!

GNSI Tampa Summit 5 Report (March 2025) The Russia-Ukraine War: Lessons for Future Conflicts

The Latest Journal of Strategic Security (JSS)

GNSI’s Axis of Resistance Research Initiative Playlist

At the Boundary from the Global and National Security Institute at the University of South Florida, features global and national security issues we’ve found to be insightful, intriguing, fascinating, maybe controversial, but overall just worth talking about.

A "boundary" is a place, either literal or figurative, where two forces exist in close proximity to each other. Sometimes that boundary is in a state of harmony. More often than not, that boundary has a bit of chaos baked in. The Global and National Security Institute will live on the boundary of security policy and technology and that's where this podcast will focus.

The mission of GNSI is to provide actionable solutions to 21st-century security challenges for decision-makers at the local, state, national and global levels. We hope you enjoy At the Boundary.

Look for our other publications and products on our website publications page.

Episode Artwork What Went Wrong in Afghanistan? Understanding the Taliban to Shape U.S. Policy 48:51 Episode Artwork Did Syria Prepare Russia for Hybrid Warfare in Ukraine? 48:48 Episode Artwork Syria After Assad: What Led Here and What Lies Ahead 45:30 Episode Artwork Preparing for Tomorrow’s Wars: Resilience, Resistance in the 21st Century 36:37 Episode Artwork Can BRICS Gold Reserves Challenge the US Dollar? 24:54 Episode Artwork What's Next for Afghanistan: U.S. Interests or Compromise with the Taliban? 44:38 Episode Artwork Political Polarization Feels Unstoppable. Will it Destroy Democracy? 47:19 Episode Artwork The History of American Intelligence — Jeff Rogg on The Spy and the State 41:16 Episode Artwork SPECIAL EPISODE Iran's Breaking Point: Missiles, Miscalculation and Reckoning 28:17 Episode Artwork Could the U.S. Bring Back the Draft? 42:44 Episode Artwork Can Deep Sea Mining Meet the World’s Critical Mineral Demand? 32:54 Episode Artwork Cybersecurity Without Borders: USA and France 25:36 Episode Artwork From Deep Sea to Deep Policy: What's Fueling the Modern Energy Race? 37:18 Episode Artwork The Coalition You’ve Never Heard Of—But Can’t Afford to Ignore 36:50 Episode Artwork Battlefield Medical Lessons from Ukraine: Adapting to Future Conflict 39:44 Episode Artwork The 5 Signs a Nation Is Headed Toward Collapse 37:27 Episode Artwork From Battlefield to Battery: The Critical Mineral Supply Crisis 39:05 Episode Artwork Iran’s Axis of Resistance: Can It Shift the Balance of Power? 36:25 Episode Artwork The Hidden Risks of a Ukraine Ceasefire 47:33 Episode Artwork Is Yemen Losing the War Against the Houthis? 34:01 Episode Artwork Are U.S. Sanctions Helping the Enemy? 37:43 Episode Artwork Why NATO Can’t Afford to Ignore Africa: The Key to Global Security Amid Rising Threats 54:28 Episode Artwork AI-Powered Cyber Attacks: How Hackers Are Exploiting Human Error 39:10 Episode Artwork Inside the Secret World of the Five Eyes: A Conversation with Richard Kerbaj 50:14 Episode Artwork Why Shifting Focus from Europe to China Could Backfire on the U.S. | Summit Roundtable 48:22