{"version":"1.0.0","segments":[{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":0.84,"endTime":3.48,"body":"The shine a light"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":0.84,"endTime":3.48,"body":"on anti semitism. Civic Courage"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":3.48,"endTime":6.18,"body":"Award is now open for"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":3.48,"endTime":6.18,"body":"nominations. This is your"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":6.18,"endTime":9.3,"body":"opportunity to recognize someone"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":6.18,"endTime":9.3,"body":"who is actively combating the"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":9.3,"endTime":12.48,"body":"rising tide of anti semitism."},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":9.3,"endTime":12.48,"body":"This prestigious award"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":12.54,"endTime":15.54,"body":"celebrates individuals across"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":12.54,"endTime":15.54,"body":"eight categories, including"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":15.54,"endTime":19.2,"body":"students and educators, offering"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":15.54,"endTime":19.2,"body":"a $2,000 prize and national"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":19.2,"endTime":22.34,"body":"recognition. If you have someone"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":19.2,"endTime":22.34,"body":"to nominate, visit shine the"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":22.34,"endTime":26.06,"body":"light on.com forward slash"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":22.34,"endTime":26.06,"body":"awards, to nominate someone"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":26.06,"endTime":32.66,"body":"whose activism spreads light by"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":26.06,"endTime":32.66,"body":"November 25 Hi everybody, and"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":32.66,"endTime":36.32,"body":"we're recording today's episode"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":32.66,"endTime":36.32,"body":"of adapting on october 29 2024"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":37.58,"endTime":40.54,"body":"and today's a bit of a change in"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":37.58,"endTime":40.54,"body":"direction for some of our"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":40.54,"endTime":43.42,"body":"previous conversations, we're"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":40.54,"endTime":43.42,"body":"talking to a Jewish educator in"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":43.42,"endTime":46.72,"body":"a public school environment who,"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":43.42,"endTime":46.72,"body":"especially in the last year, has"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":46.72,"endTime":49.9,"body":"decided to take a stand against"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":46.72,"endTime":49.9,"body":"some of the incidents of anti"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":49.9,"endTime":52.78,"body":"semitic or perceived anti"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":49.9,"endTime":52.78,"body":"semitism by by teachers and"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":52.78,"endTime":55.06,"body":"other students in her school,"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":52.78,"endTime":55.06,"body":"and also been able to make"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":55.06,"endTime":58.3,"body":"systemic change where necessary"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":55.06,"endTime":58.3,"body":"in the New York Public School"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":58.3,"endTime":61.68,"body":"System. Why is this so important"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":58.3,"endTime":61.68,"body":"for all of us to be talking"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":61.68,"endTime":65.58,"body":"about, because the majority of"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":61.68,"endTime":65.58,"body":"Jewish youth in North America"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":65.58,"endTime":68.64,"body":"and dare I say, around the"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":65.58,"endTime":68.64,"body":"world, attend schools in their"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":68.64,"endTime":72.12,"body":"in their public sphere, and that"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":68.64,"endTime":72.12,"body":"is where our educators are"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":72.12,"endTime":74.94,"body":"feeling many of the issues that"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":72.12,"endTime":74.94,"body":"are taking place, especially in"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":74.94,"endTime":77.88,"body":"a post October 7 world they're"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":74.94,"endTime":77.88,"body":"often scared of what they're"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":77.88,"endTime":80.52,"body":"talking about and how to talk"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":77.88,"endTime":80.52,"body":"about the issues, especially for"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":80.52,"endTime":82.88,"body":"history and social studies"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":80.52,"endTime":82.88,"body":"teachers like, how is it"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":82.88,"endTime":86.24,"body":"possible to be objective on"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":82.88,"endTime":86.24,"body":"these issues? This is the fabric"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":86.24,"endTime":89.0,"body":"of the world in which we live"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":86.24,"endTime":89.0,"body":"in, and I think as a Jewish"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":89.0,"endTime":92.06,"body":"community, we need to be as"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":89.0,"endTime":92.06,"body":"committed to the education of"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":92.12,"endTime":94.82,"body":"all of our students, no matter"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":92.12,"endTime":94.82,"body":"where they are receiving it, to"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":94.82,"endTime":97.7,"body":"be aware of the challenges that"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":94.82,"endTime":97.7,"body":"people are having, and also to"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":97.7,"endTime":101.5,"body":"really shine a light on some of"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":97.7,"endTime":101.5,"body":"the real success stories where"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":101.5,"endTime":104.68,"body":"it's taking place for individual"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":101.5,"endTime":104.68,"body":"educators who are really making"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":104.68,"endTime":107.26,"body":"a difference, for not just the"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":104.68,"endTime":107.26,"body":"Jewish students in their"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":107.26,"endTime":110.32,"body":"schools, but for all students."},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":107.26,"endTime":110.32,"body":"And remembering importantly, and"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":110.32,"endTime":113.14,"body":"Shaina talks about this for"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":110.32,"endTime":113.14,"body":"many, many students, the first"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":113.14,"endTime":115.54,"body":"time they will meet and have"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":113.14,"endTime":115.54,"body":"interactions with a Jewish"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":115.54,"endTime":118.54,"body":"student or a Jewish educator is"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":115.54,"endTime":118.54,"body":"first and foremost in their"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":118.54,"endTime":121.74,"body":"public school environment. So"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":118.54,"endTime":121.74,"body":"this episode is one which speaks"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":121.86,"endTime":124.26,"body":"about specific examples, but I"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":121.86,"endTime":124.26,"body":"think it's got broad"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":124.26,"endTime":127.44,"body":"implications for all of us, and"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":124.26,"endTime":127.44,"body":"we can all gain something from"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":127.44,"endTime":129.96,"body":"this really remarkable,"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":127.44,"endTime":129.96,"body":"impressive conversation with"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":129.96,"endTime":132.6,"body":"Shayna Dworkin. So thank you, as"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":129.96,"endTime":132.6,"body":"always, for listening today,"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":133.86,"endTime":137.4,"body":"this is adapting the future of"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":133.86,"endTime":137.4,"body":"Jewish education, a podcast from"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":137.4,"endTime":139.98,"body":"the Jewish education project"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":137.4,"endTime":139.98,"body":"where we explore the big"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":139.98,"endTime":142.94,"body":"questions, challenges and"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":139.98,"endTime":142.94,"body":"successes that define Jewish"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":142.94,"endTime":144.98,"body":"education. I'm David breifman."},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":152.18,"endTime":155.84,"body":"Shayna Dworkin is a 15 year"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":152.18,"endTime":155.84,"body":"veteran social studies teacher"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":155.84,"endTime":158.72,"body":"in the New York public school"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":155.84,"endTime":158.72,"body":"system, and I'm not going to"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":158.72,"endTime":161.2,"body":"give too much more of a bio,"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":158.72,"endTime":161.2,"body":"because as soon as we get to"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":161.2,"endTime":163.48,"body":"chatting, you'll understand"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":161.2,"endTime":163.48,"body":"exactly why I've asked Shayna to"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":163.48,"endTime":165.82,"body":"join us here on adapting. So"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":163.48,"endTime":165.82,"body":"Shaina, thanks so much for"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":165.82,"endTime":166.48,"body":"joining us."},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":166.54,"endTime":168.94,"body":"Thank you so much for"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":166.54,"endTime":168.94,"body":"inviting me. And we really"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":168.94,"endTime":169.96,"body":"excited to be here."},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":170.02,"endTime":172.24,"body":"So just tell the"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":170.02,"endTime":172.24,"body":"audience a bit about your your"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":172.24,"endTime":175.12,"body":"current job, I mean the official"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":172.24,"endTime":175.12,"body":"job that you actually do. Yeah."},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":175.12,"endTime":175.78,"body":"So"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":176.32,"endTime":179.92,"body":"I am a New York City"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":176.32,"endTime":179.92,"body":"public school teacher. I teach"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":179.92,"endTime":182.46,"body":"in a small public school, and I"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":179.92,"endTime":182.46,"body":"teach ninth grade global"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":182.46,"endTime":185.1,"body":"history, and I'm also the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":182.46,"endTime":185.1,"body":"advisor of the Jewish student"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":185.1,"endTime":185.64,"body":"union. And"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":185.76,"endTime":187.2,"body":"how long have you"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":185.76,"endTime":187.2,"body":"been doing that work?"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":187.439,"endTime":191.519,"body":"I have been in the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":187.439,"endTime":191.519,"body":"system for almost 20 years now."},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":191.64,"endTime":194.88,"body":"So you and I met"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":191.64,"endTime":194.88,"body":"each other first at a at a"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":194.88,"endTime":197.58,"body":"public forum where you were"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":194.88,"endTime":197.58,"body":"talking about almost anything"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":197.58,"endTime":201.2,"body":"other than social studies and"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":197.58,"endTime":201.2,"body":"and Global Studies in a school."},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":201.2,"endTime":204.56,"body":"So talk to us a bit about what"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":201.2,"endTime":204.56,"body":"other roles you've taken on"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":204.56,"endTime":206.72,"body":"recently and how that's come to"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":204.56,"endTime":206.72,"body":"fruition."},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":207.5,"endTime":210.26,"body":"You know, I'm a social"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":207.5,"endTime":210.26,"body":"studies teacher by training, but"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":210.26,"endTime":214.22,"body":"one of my passions as an"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":210.26,"endTime":214.22,"body":"educator is creating inclusive"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":214.22,"endTime":217.58,"body":"classroom spaces, and so that's"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":214.22,"endTime":217.58,"body":"what brought me into that"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":217.58,"endTime":222.58,"body":"conversation where I met you,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":217.58,"endTime":222.58,"body":"and it was right after October"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":222.58,"endTime":226.78,"body":"7, but the conversations were"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":222.58,"endTime":226.78,"body":"already brewing about anti"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":226.78,"endTime":230.86,"body":"semitism in schools, and"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":226.78,"endTime":230.86,"body":"personally, I spent a lot of"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":230.86,"endTime":235.72,"body":"time doing diversity and equity"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":230.86,"endTime":235.72,"body":"initiatives, leading the equity"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":235.72,"endTime":238.42,"body":"team at one of the largest high"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":235.72,"endTime":238.42,"body":"schools in the country. The"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":238.42,"endTime":241.5,"body":"conversations were not"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":238.42,"endTime":241.5,"body":"necessarily focused on anti"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":241.5,"endTime":244.74,"body":"semitism, but it's always been"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":241.5,"endTime":244.74,"body":"something that's been important"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":244.74,"endTime":246.18,"body":"to me specifically."},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":246.24,"endTime":248.28,"body":"So we'll talk a"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":246.24,"endTime":248.28,"body":"bit about what happened after"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":248.28,"endTime":251.82,"body":"October 7. But the reality is"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":248.28,"endTime":251.82,"body":"for you, your your Jewish"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":251.82,"endTime":256.2,"body":"awakening as a social studies"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":251.82,"endTime":256.2,"body":"teacher in a public school was"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":256.26,"endTime":260.12,"body":"prior to prior to that day. So"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":256.26,"endTime":260.12,"body":"talk a bit about some of the"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":260.12,"endTime":262.52,"body":"things that raise your own"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":260.12,"endTime":262.52,"body":"consciousness about being a"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":262.52,"endTime":264.56,"body":"Jewish educator in a public"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":262.52,"endTime":264.56,"body":"school."},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":264.98,"endTime":268.34,"body":"Yeah, that's right. So"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":264.98,"endTime":268.34,"body":"my Jewish identity was always"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":268.34,"endTime":272.6,"body":"driving my work for inclusive"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":268.34,"endTime":272.6,"body":"classrooms and for the values"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":272.6,"endTime":277.1,"body":"that are centered in diversity"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":272.6,"endTime":277.1,"body":"initiatives. So I was doing"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":277.1,"endTime":280.3,"body":"trainings through the Department"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":277.1,"endTime":280.3,"body":"of Education as a lead social"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":280.3,"endTime":284.14,"body":"studies teacher and culturally"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":280.3,"endTime":284.14,"body":"responsive education. I went to"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":284.14,"endTime":287.5,"body":"a training called courageous"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":284.14,"endTime":287.5,"body":"conversations about how to have,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":287.56,"endTime":290.38,"body":"you know, these difficult"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":287.56,"endTime":290.38,"body":"conversations, and I started to"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":290.38,"endTime":295.0,"body":"notice that anti semitism was"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":290.38,"endTime":295.0,"body":"never part of the conversation."},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":295.0,"endTime":298.18,"body":"In fact, at one of the trainings"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":295.0,"endTime":298.18,"body":"that I went to, the facilitator"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":298.18,"endTime":301.44,"body":"was talking about"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":298.18,"endTime":301.44,"body":"Charlottesville. All and how,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":301.5,"endTime":305.58,"body":"you know, awful it was. He never"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":301.5,"endTime":305.58,"body":"mentioned Jews or anti semitism."},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":305.58,"endTime":309.36,"body":"And I went up to him after, and"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":305.58,"endTime":309.36,"body":"I said, you know, I understand,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":309.48,"endTime":311.88,"body":"you know, we're here to talk"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":309.48,"endTime":311.88,"body":"about race, but there was an"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":311.88,"endTime":314.64,"body":"opportunity to mention that. And"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":311.88,"endTime":314.64,"body":"he was just like, that's not"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":314.64,"endTime":319.08,"body":"what we're here for. So that was"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":314.64,"endTime":319.08,"body":"part of, you know, this growing"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":319.08,"endTime":322.4,"body":"awareness. And then,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":319.08,"endTime":322.4,"body":"unfortunately, I had a bad"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":322.4,"endTime":325.7,"body":"experience with an administrator"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":322.4,"endTime":325.7,"body":"who specifically targeted me"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":325.7,"endTime":328.94,"body":"because of my identity and my"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":325.7,"endTime":328.94,"body":"Jewish identity. And that was a"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":328.94,"endTime":332.9,"body":"real personal wake up moment,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":328.94,"endTime":332.9,"body":"and started to make me think"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":332.9,"endTime":335.78,"body":"about what's going on in my"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":332.9,"endTime":335.78,"body":"school with the students in that"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":335.78,"endTime":341.02,"body":"in my particular school setting."},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":335.78,"endTime":341.02,"body":"So it was kind of a slow"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":341.14,"endTime":345.4,"body":"awakening, I would say, before"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":341.14,"endTime":345.4,"body":"October 7, and an awareness that"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":345.4,"endTime":348.94,"body":"in these kind of progressive"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":345.4,"endTime":348.94,"body":"spaces, I couldn't really show"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":348.94,"endTime":352.72,"body":"up as my full self. Nobody was"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":348.94,"endTime":352.72,"body":"saying no Zionists allowed, or"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":352.72,"endTime":356.44,"body":"anything about Jews not being"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":352.72,"endTime":356.44,"body":"welcomed. But there was an"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":356.44,"endTime":360.9,"body":"undertone where I just didn't"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":356.44,"endTime":360.9,"body":"feel like I could be comfortable"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":360.9,"endTime":361.56,"body":"anymore."},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":361.74,"endTime":363.84,"body":"So the New York"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":361.74,"endTime":363.84,"body":"public school system has a long"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":363.84,"endTime":367.74,"body":"history of Jewish educators,"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":363.84,"endTime":367.74,"body":"Jewish administrators. In fact,"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":367.86,"endTime":371.28,"body":"many of the laws relating to for"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":367.86,"endTime":371.28,"body":"example, like Rosh Hashanah and"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":371.28,"endTime":374.28,"body":"Yom Kippur being holidays in New"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":371.28,"endTime":374.28,"body":"York schools is because largely"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":374.28,"endTime":377.34,"body":"of the Jewish faculty over time."},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":374.28,"endTime":377.34,"body":"But I digress. Can you talk a"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":377.34,"endTime":379.98,"body":"bit about some of the specifics"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":377.34,"endTime":379.98,"body":"of what made you feel"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":379.98,"endTime":383.18,"body":"marginalized as a as a Jewish"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":379.98,"endTime":383.18,"body":"educator in these schools, or is"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":383.18,"endTime":385.4,"body":"that? I don't want to throw"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":383.18,"endTime":385.4,"body":"anyone under the bus, but what"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":385.4,"endTime":386.96,"body":"can you talk about? Yeah,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":386.96,"endTime":390.38,"body":"so I so that's the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":386.96,"endTime":390.38,"body":"thing. Is that, you know, every"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":390.44,"endTime":393.98,"body":"Jewish teacher in has a"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":390.44,"endTime":393.98,"body":"different experience within"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":393.98,"endTime":396.56,"body":"their schools, because there are"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":393.98,"endTime":396.56,"body":"so many schools in New York"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":396.56,"endTime":400.96,"body":"City. So you know, my personal"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":396.56,"endTime":400.96,"body":"experience was really related"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":401.02,"endTime":406.06,"body":"to, you know, a specific person"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":401.02,"endTime":406.06,"body":"in a specific situation. But"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":406.06,"endTime":410.02,"body":"overall, I could say that the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":406.06,"endTime":410.02,"body":"marginalization is that when you"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":410.02,"endTime":413.14,"body":"show up to these spaces that are"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":410.02,"endTime":413.14,"body":"so called inclusive, and they're"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":413.14,"endTime":415.9,"body":"not meaning a lot of these"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":413.14,"endTime":415.9,"body":"trainings were run by the DOE,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":415.9,"endTime":420.12,"body":"but not doe administrators, so"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":415.9,"endTime":420.12,"body":"they hired people to come and do"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":420.12,"endTime":423.0,"body":"these trainings, it wasn't that"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":420.12,"endTime":423.0,"body":"they were saying anything"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":423.0,"endTime":426.78,"body":"particular. It was kind of more"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":423.0,"endTime":426.78,"body":"the absence of what was being"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":426.78,"endTime":432.0,"body":"talked about and this oppressor"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":426.78,"endTime":432.0,"body":"oppressed dynamic. So I can give"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":432.0,"endTime":436.32,"body":"you another example of having to"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":432.0,"endTime":436.32,"body":"line up according to your white"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":436.32,"endTime":440.04,"body":"privilege, and then having to"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":436.32,"endTime":440.04,"body":"form these affinity groups. So"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":440.04,"endTime":443.78,"body":"I'm sitting at a table with all"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":440.04,"endTime":443.78,"body":"of these other white teachers"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":443.78,"endTime":449.18,"body":"sharing our experiences, and I'm"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":443.78,"endTime":449.18,"body":"one of the only people who has"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":449.18,"endTime":453.98,"body":"been bullied or teased because"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":449.18,"endTime":453.98,"body":"of my Jewish identity. None of"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":453.98,"endTime":457.7,"body":"the other people at my table,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":453.98,"endTime":457.7,"body":"the other, quote, unquote, white"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":457.7,"endTime":461.26,"body":"teachers, had that experience,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":457.7,"endTime":461.26,"body":"and that was kind of that wake"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":461.26,"endTime":463.6,"body":"up moment, that feeling of"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":461.26,"endTime":463.6,"body":"marginalization, like I don't"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":463.6,"endTime":467.02,"body":"belong in this space, and I"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":463.6,"endTime":467.02,"body":"don't belong at those other"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":467.02,"endTime":471.4,"body":"tables, right? And it got to the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":467.02,"endTime":471.4,"body":"point where, like, two years"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":471.4,"endTime":474.1,"body":"ago, I did another one of these"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":471.4,"endTime":474.1,"body":"trainings, and I finally said to"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":474.1,"endTime":476.86,"body":"the facilitator, I said, Look,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":474.1,"endTime":476.86,"body":"I'll sit at that table with the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":476.86,"endTime":480.06,"body":"white teachers, because they"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":476.86,"endTime":480.06,"body":"understand, you know, I"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":480.06,"endTime":483.72,"body":"understand how this work gets"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":480.06,"endTime":483.72,"body":"done in these spaces, but I'm"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":483.72,"endTime":487.5,"body":"not comfortable with that"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":483.72,"endTime":487.5,"body":"anymore. And he appreciated that"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":487.5,"endTime":490.86,"body":"I voiced that. So I definitely"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":487.5,"endTime":490.86,"body":"had these experiences. But I"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":490.86,"endTime":493.98,"body":"don't want to make it seem like,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":490.86,"endTime":493.98,"body":"you know, all over the New York"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":493.98,"endTime":496.62,"body":"City public school system,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":493.98,"endTime":496.62,"body":"there's this ideology that's"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":496.62,"endTime":501.2,"body":"being pedaled down. It really"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":496.62,"endTime":501.2,"body":"varies, I think, from space to"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":501.2,"endTime":505.34,"body":"space, but the overall"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":501.2,"endTime":505.34,"body":"ideologies of the oppressed and"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":505.34,"endTime":509.42,"body":"oppressors and that kind of"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":505.34,"endTime":509.42,"body":"ideology is around, and it's"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":509.42,"endTime":512.6,"body":"clear that Jews are not fitting"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":509.42,"endTime":512.6,"body":"into that dynamic."},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":512.72,"endTime":514.82,"body":"All right, so we"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":512.72,"endTime":514.82,"body":"are going pretty deep, pretty"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":514.82,"endTime":519.14,"body":"quickly, into some pretty murky"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":514.82,"endTime":519.14,"body":"territory. Let's but let's you"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":519.14,"endTime":522.52,"body":"and I take it for an assumption"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":519.14,"endTime":522.52,"body":"and correct me if my assumption"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":522.52,"endTime":526.18,"body":"is wrong, that you and I both"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":522.52,"endTime":526.18,"body":"believe that diversity, equity,"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":526.18,"endTime":529.54,"body":"inclusion as a concept is a good"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":526.18,"endTime":529.54,"body":"thing in public school"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":529.54,"endTime":532.36,"body":"education, that all people,"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":529.54,"endTime":532.36,"body":"regardless of their ethnicity,"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":532.36,"endTime":534.94,"body":"race, religion, should be made"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":532.36,"endTime":534.94,"body":"to feel welcome in the public"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":534.94,"endTime":535.96,"body":"school environment."},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":536.08,"endTime":539.38,"body":"Absolutely, that is"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":536.08,"endTime":539.38,"body":"exactly you know what I am"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":539.38,"endTime":543.72,"body":"committed to doing and why I was"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":539.38,"endTime":543.72,"body":"asked to speak at that panel."},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":543.84,"endTime":544.26,"body":"And your"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":544.26,"endTime":547.8,"body":"point here is"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":544.26,"endTime":547.8,"body":"that the DEI movement, so to"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":547.8,"endTime":551.1,"body":"speak, or the DEI curriculum"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":547.8,"endTime":551.1,"body":"professional development, were"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":551.1,"endTime":554.52,"body":"often adopted in particularly in"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":551.1,"endTime":554.52,"body":"public school environments, and"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":554.52,"endTime":558.06,"body":"we now know this across the"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":554.52,"endTime":558.06,"body":"country, often failed or"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":558.06,"endTime":562.58,"body":"omitted. We're not sure whether"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":558.06,"endTime":562.58,"body":"it's intentional or implicit,"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":562.64,"endTime":566.24,"body":"the Jews did not fit under the"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":562.64,"endTime":566.24,"body":"category of a diverse ethnic"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":566.24,"endTime":568.94,"body":"group in American society, which"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":566.24,"endTime":568.94,"body":"led to a whole lot of these"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":568.94,"endTime":570.2,"body":"issues beginning to evolve"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":570.32,"endTime":574.64,"body":"exactly and I"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":570.32,"endTime":574.64,"body":"absolutely said I believe in the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":574.64,"endTime":580.24,"body":"diversity and inclusion values,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":574.64,"endTime":580.24,"body":"but I wasn't experiencing that"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":580.66,"endTime":584.26,"body":"personally when I went to these"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":580.66,"endTime":584.26,"body":"trainings, and then"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":584.26,"endTime":587.5,"body":"October 7"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":584.26,"endTime":587.5,"body":"happens, and the dynamic begins"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":587.5,"endTime":591.76,"body":"to change, and you no longer can"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":587.5,"endTime":591.76,"body":"remain silent with what's taking"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":591.76,"endTime":594.7,"body":"place around you. So maybe"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":591.76,"endTime":594.7,"body":"describe to the audience what"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":594.7,"endTime":598.84,"body":"took place for you around and"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":594.7,"endTime":598.84,"body":"after October 7, that led to"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":598.84,"endTime":601.08,"body":"your so called away. In these"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":598.84,"endTime":601.08,"body":"events,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":601.86,"endTime":605.16,"body":"yeah, October 7, I"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":601.86,"endTime":605.16,"body":"would say for me, personally,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":605.16,"endTime":608.16,"body":"and I'm only speaking for"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":605.16,"endTime":608.16,"body":"myself. I'm not speaking on"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":608.16,"endTime":612.36,"body":"behalf of the Department of"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":608.16,"endTime":612.36,"body":"Education or any organization."},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":612.36,"endTime":616.14,"body":"For me, it was very personal"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":612.36,"endTime":616.14,"body":"awakening. Because not only did"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":616.14,"endTime":619.44,"body":"I consider myself a progressive"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":616.14,"endTime":619.44,"body":"educator, an anti racist"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":619.44,"endTime":623.24,"body":"educator, I mean, I really went"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":619.44,"endTime":623.24,"body":"all in on of the this. I was"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":623.3,"endTime":627.56,"body":"doing community organizing, you"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":623.3,"endTime":627.56,"body":"know, where I live, I was full"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":627.56,"endTime":633.38,"body":"in on this. And October 7 kind"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":627.56,"endTime":633.38,"body":"of really woke me up to what was"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":633.38,"endTime":637.34,"body":"happening in the public school"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":633.38,"endTime":637.34,"body":"system, not just in New York"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":637.34,"endTime":639.86,"body":"City, but really what we found"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":637.34,"endTime":639.86,"body":"out, like you said, is really"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":639.86,"endTime":642.58,"body":"kind of happening everywhere,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":639.86,"endTime":642.58,"body":"because I started to talk to"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":642.58,"endTime":646.54,"body":"more teachers, and we were"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":642.58,"endTime":646.54,"body":"hearing a lot of the same things"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":646.54,"endTime":649.9,"body":"and sharing a lot of the same"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":646.54,"endTime":649.9,"body":"stories, where we had incidents"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":649.9,"endTime":653.26,"body":"in our school where we felt"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":649.9,"endTime":653.26,"body":"targeted, where colleagues were"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":653.26,"endTime":656.14,"body":"saying things or things that"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":653.26,"endTime":656.14,"body":"were showing up in lesson plans."},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":656.2,"endTime":660.66,"body":"And so October 7, for me,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":656.2,"endTime":660.66,"body":"personally, made me realize that"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":660.66,"endTime":664.14,"body":"this is a problem is a lot"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":660.66,"endTime":664.14,"body":"bigger than me and my personal"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":664.2,"endTime":669.0,"body":"experience. But around the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":664.2,"endTime":669.0,"body":"beginning of November, we"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":669.0,"endTime":673.86,"body":"started to see union UFT members"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":669.0,"endTime":673.86,"body":"organize. This is there's a"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":673.86,"endTime":676.98,"body":"caucus within our union called"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":673.86,"endTime":676.98,"body":"more, and they're a very"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":676.98,"endTime":680.6,"body":"progressive caucus. And then"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":676.98,"endTime":680.6,"body":"there's a group of New York City"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":680.6,"endTime":684.26,"body":"teachers not affiliated with the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":680.6,"endTime":684.26,"body":"DOE, but you know, assuming many"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":684.26,"endTime":688.76,"body":"of them are doe teachers called"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":684.26,"endTime":688.76,"body":"Nico, and they started to"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":688.76,"endTime":693.44,"body":"organize a walkout, and that's"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":688.76,"endTime":693.44,"body":"really what got a lot of us"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":693.44,"endTime":698.18,"body":"engaged. And we said, we have a"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":693.44,"endTime":698.18,"body":"problem, and that's really what"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":698.18,"endTime":701.44,"body":"kind of launched me in the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":698.18,"endTime":701.44,"body":"forefront of speaking up and"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":701.44,"endTime":706.24,"body":"saying, I can't do this and or"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":701.44,"endTime":706.24,"body":"this can't happen. So I had met"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":706.24,"endTime":709.12,"body":"the chancellor, actually,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":706.24,"endTime":709.12,"body":"Chancellor banks, at this panel,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":709.18,"endTime":713.2,"body":"and then I followed up. I sent"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":709.18,"endTime":713.2,"body":"an email to him. I didn't hear"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":713.2,"endTime":716.56,"body":"anything back. So that's when me"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":713.2,"endTime":716.56,"body":"and some other teachers decided"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":716.56,"endTime":718.12,"body":"that we need to speak up,"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":718.18,"endTime":720.54,"body":"all right, so I"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":718.18,"endTime":720.54,"body":"can skip right to the conclusion"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":720.54,"endTime":722.76,"body":"here, where Shayna has become"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":720.54,"endTime":722.76,"body":"one of the leading voices in"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":722.76,"endTime":725.52,"body":"fighting against anti semitism"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":722.76,"endTime":725.52,"body":"in New York public schools. But"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":725.52,"endTime":727.56,"body":"before I get straight to the"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":725.52,"endTime":727.56,"body":"punch line, let's go through"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":727.56,"endTime":730.02,"body":"this in a bit more detail. So"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":727.56,"endTime":730.02,"body":"describe to the audience what a"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":730.02,"endTime":732.84,"body":"walkout actually is and what"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":730.02,"endTime":732.84,"body":"it's intended to do."},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":733.5,"endTime":735.9,"body":"So you know, over the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":733.5,"endTime":735.9,"body":"years, there have been a variety"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":735.9,"endTime":739.98,"body":"of different student walkouts"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":735.9,"endTime":739.98,"body":"for climate for gun safety, so"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":739.98,"endTime":744.74,"body":"the idea is that students around"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":739.98,"endTime":744.74,"body":"New York City, public and"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":744.74,"endTime":748.76,"body":"private schools walk out of"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":744.74,"endTime":748.76,"body":"their classes. It's an act of"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":748.76,"endTime":751.94,"body":"civil disobedience. Essentially,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":748.76,"endTime":751.94,"body":"they walk out of their their"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":751.94,"endTime":757.1,"body":"classes. They gather together"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":751.94,"endTime":757.1,"body":"off site in protest, and"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":757.16,"endTime":759.62,"body":"in general,"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":757.16,"endTime":759.62,"body":"that's probably a good example"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":759.62,"endTime":762.28,"body":"of teaching young people freedom"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":759.62,"endTime":762.28,"body":"of speech and the right to"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":762.28,"endTime":765.82,"body":"protest that of itself is a good"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":762.28,"endTime":765.82,"body":"thing, I would assume, yeah, I'm"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":765.82,"endTime":768.52,"body":"definitely not opposed"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":765.82,"endTime":768.52,"body":"to civil disobedience, and"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":768.52,"endTime":774.46,"body":"students do have the right to do"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":768.52,"endTime":774.46,"body":"that. Our issue was the adults"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":774.46,"endTime":779.14,"body":"that were getting involved and"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":774.46,"endTime":779.14,"body":"promoting this, and the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":779.2,"endTime":783.3,"body":"contractual obligations that"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":779.2,"endTime":783.3,"body":"teachers have in terms of doing"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":783.3,"endTime":788.1,"body":"political work on their school"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":783.3,"endTime":788.1,"body":"time, but also the materials"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":788.16,"endTime":792.48,"body":"that they were publishing that"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":788.16,"endTime":792.48,"body":"were chanting about Free"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":792.48,"endTime":796.32,"body":"Palestine from the river to the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":792.48,"endTime":796.32,"body":"sea. We don't want Zionists"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":796.32,"endTime":799.2,"body":"here. I don't have it all in"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":796.32,"endTime":799.2,"body":"front of me, but this is all"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":799.2,"endTime":803.72,"body":"public knowledge. They've posted"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":799.2,"endTime":803.72,"body":"this out there, and that, to me,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":803.72,"endTime":808.64,"body":"is a problem when you have kids"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":803.72,"endTime":808.64,"body":"being encouraged to go out and"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":808.64,"endTime":813.14,"body":"chant these things by educators"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":808.64,"endTime":813.14,"body":"that they trust. And in fact, we"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":813.2,"endTime":817.76,"body":"we do have evidence that"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":813.2,"endTime":817.76,"body":"students who went with a teacher"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":817.76,"endTime":820.12,"body":"who we don't know if the teacher"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":817.76,"endTime":820.12,"body":"walked out, we don't know if the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":820.12,"endTime":824.68,"body":"teacher met them there was"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":820.12,"endTime":824.68,"body":"holding up a sign of a trash can"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":824.74,"endTime":827.92,"body":"with the Star of David in it, a"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":824.74,"endTime":827.92,"body":"New York City public school"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":827.92,"endTime":829.18,"body":"student. And"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":829.18,"endTime":831.52,"body":"just to be clear,"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":829.18,"endTime":831.52,"body":"at least for the initial"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":831.52,"endTime":834.16,"body":"walkouts in New York public"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":831.52,"endTime":834.16,"body":"schools, there were actually no"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":834.16,"endTime":837.4,"body":"consequences, either for the"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":834.16,"endTime":837.4,"body":"teacher or for the students who"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":837.4,"endTime":839.8,"body":"worked out. And I think one of"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":837.4,"endTime":839.8,"body":"the definitions of civil"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":839.8,"endTime":842.64,"body":"disobedience means it needs to"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":839.8,"endTime":842.64,"body":"be some form of consequence in"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":842.64,"endTime":845.34,"body":"order for it to actually be"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":842.64,"endTime":845.34,"body":"disobedient. And the students"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":845.34,"endTime":847.86,"body":"were given a free pass on these"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":845.34,"endTime":847.86,"body":"to attend these protests, these"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":847.86,"endTime":849.18,"body":"walkouts, yeah. Well,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":849.18,"endTime":851.34,"body":"so that's, you know, I"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":849.18,"endTime":851.34,"body":"mean, that was kind of the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":851.34,"endTime":854.16,"body":"culture at my old school. It was"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":851.34,"endTime":854.16,"body":"kind of like, okay, like you're,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":854.34,"endTime":857.7,"body":"you know, we'll mark you late or"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":854.34,"endTime":857.7,"body":"whatever. But I think what for"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":857.7,"endTime":861.98,"body":"us, what we were focused on, is"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":857.7,"endTime":861.98,"body":"the accountability piece that"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":861.98,"endTime":865.94,"body":"what is anti semitism? What is"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":861.98,"endTime":865.94,"body":"political activity? So the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":865.94,"endTime":871.34,"body":"schools can enforce the code how"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":865.94,"endTime":871.34,"body":"they want. But is it okay for"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":871.34,"endTime":875.18,"body":"New York City students and"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":871.34,"endTime":875.18,"body":"teachers to be promoting a"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":875.18,"endTime":880.1,"body":"walkout that is promoting anti"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":875.18,"endTime":880.1,"body":"semitic ideas? And that's what"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":880.1,"endTime":883.12,"body":"we were trying to get the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":880.1,"endTime":883.12,"body":"Chancellor's team to really"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":883.12,"endTime":887.68,"body":"understand what is anti semitism"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":883.12,"endTime":887.68,"body":"and how it's showing up in the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":887.68,"endTime":890.32,"body":"form of anti Zionism in our"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":887.68,"endTime":890.32,"body":"public schools."},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":890.68,"endTime":893.62,"body":"So Shaina stands"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":890.68,"endTime":893.62,"body":"up with a few of her colleagues,"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":893.62,"endTime":897.28,"body":"and obviously everybody says,"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":893.62,"endTime":897.28,"body":"Thanks for enlightening us, and"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":897.28,"endTime":899.92,"body":"the whole situation changes"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":897.28,"endTime":899.92,"body":"straight away, overnight. Now."},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":899.999,"endTime":900.839,"body":"Yes, of course."},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":901.38,"endTime":904.14,"body":"No joke. So what"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":901.38,"endTime":904.14,"body":"happens to you as a teacher, a"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":904.14,"endTime":906.9,"body":"respected veteran teacher in the"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":904.14,"endTime":906.9,"body":"public schools, when you do"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":906.9,"endTime":908.52,"body":"raise your voice to these"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":906.9,"endTime":908.52,"body":"issues?"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":908.76,"endTime":912.24,"body":"So you know, this is"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":908.76,"endTime":912.24,"body":"really my first time doing this"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":912.24,"endTime":916.08,"body":"kind of work within the doe. So"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":912.24,"endTime":916.08,"body":"it was definitely a learning"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":916.14,"endTime":919.56,"body":"experience. We did find, I"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":916.14,"endTime":919.56,"body":"personally found the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":919.56,"endTime":922.1,"body":"Chancellor's team to be"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":919.56,"endTime":922.1,"body":"receptive. We had a press"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":922.1,"endTime":926.12,"body":"conference on the steps of"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":922.1,"endTime":926.12,"body":"tweed, and shortly after, we"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":926.12,"endTime":932.06,"body":"were able to get a meeting with"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":926.12,"endTime":932.06,"body":"the Chancellor's team, with the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":932.06,"endTime":936.98,"body":"UJA, the Jewish education"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":932.06,"endTime":936.98,"body":"project, helping us get to that"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":936.98,"endTime":941.92,"body":"table. I on our own, it would"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":936.98,"endTime":941.92,"body":"have been very hard were the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":941.92,"endTime":946.48,"body":"worker bees in this large"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":941.92,"endTime":946.48,"body":"bureaucracy, but they did sit"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":946.48,"endTime":951.28,"body":"down with us, and it was a"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":946.48,"endTime":951.28,"body":"productive meeting. We laid out"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":951.34,"endTime":956.08,"body":"our concerns, we gave evidence."},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":951.34,"endTime":956.08,"body":"I handed over evidence to the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":956.08,"endTime":959.62,"body":"deputy chancellor of safety and"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":956.08,"endTime":959.62,"body":"security of a girl who was being"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":959.62,"endTime":962.76,"body":"targeted and bullied online in a"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":959.62,"endTime":962.76,"body":"high school some of the worst"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":962.76,"endTime":965.28,"body":"things I've ever seen in my"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":962.76,"endTime":965.28,"body":"life. And they were very"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":965.28,"endTime":969.36,"body":"receptive, and I felt like they"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":965.28,"endTime":969.36,"body":"were open. That opened the door"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":969.36,"endTime":973.68,"body":"to more meetings. And we we"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":969.36,"endTime":973.68,"body":"tried as hard as we could as"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":973.68,"endTime":978.42,"body":"teachers to lay out our"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":973.68,"endTime":978.42,"body":"concerns, to provide them with"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":978.48,"endTime":981.8,"body":"the evidence that we could, to"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":978.48,"endTime":981.8,"body":"show them this is a demonstrated"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":981.86,"endTime":984.56,"body":"problem, and then Chancellor"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":981.86,"endTime":984.56,"body":"came out with his meeting the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":984.56,"endTime":989.24,"body":"moment plan, as many people"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":984.56,"endTime":989.24,"body":"might know, which incorporated"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":989.42,"endTime":993.68,"body":"feedback that we asked for, not"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":989.42,"endTime":993.68,"body":"everything, but it certainly"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":993.74,"endTime":997.22,"body":"addressed some of our concerns."},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":993.74,"endTime":997.22,"body":"There's still a lot more that"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":997.22,"endTime":1001.2,"body":"needs to get done, but it was a"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":997.22,"endTime":1001.2,"body":"starting point in getting"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1001.38,"endTime":1003.9,"body":"systemic change, which is really"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1001.38,"endTime":1003.9,"body":"what we need."},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1004.14,"endTime":1006.24,"body":"Tell us a few of"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1004.14,"endTime":1006.24,"body":"those stories. Tell us a few of"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1006.24,"endTime":1009.0,"body":"the things that you handed over"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1006.24,"endTime":1009.0,"body":"as evidence. What you can share."},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1009.18,"endTime":1012.6,"body":"Because when you talk at a high"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1009.18,"endTime":1012.6,"body":"level about the conflation of"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1012.6,"endTime":1015.48,"body":"anti semitism and anti Zionism,"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1012.6,"endTime":1015.48,"body":"when you talk about teachers"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1015.48,"endTime":1018.42,"body":"encouraging a walkout, when you"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1015.48,"endTime":1018.42,"body":"talk about all the things that"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1018.42,"endTime":1021.56,"body":"you're speaking about, you"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1018.42,"endTime":1021.56,"body":"internalize that as one level of"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1021.56,"endTime":1024.38,"body":"understanding at the moment at"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1021.56,"endTime":1024.38,"body":"which you began to personalize"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1024.38,"endTime":1026.84,"body":"these stories. And it wasn't"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1024.38,"endTime":1026.84,"body":"just one, it wasn't just two."},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1026.84,"endTime":1029.18,"body":"There were literally dozens of"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1026.84,"endTime":1029.18,"body":"stories that you shared and"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1029.18,"endTime":1031.88,"body":"could continue sharing. It takes"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1029.18,"endTime":1031.88,"body":"on a different tenor, because"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1031.88,"endTime":1034.28,"body":"you realize that each one of"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1031.88,"endTime":1034.28,"body":"these stories is about an"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1034.28,"endTime":1037.76,"body":"individual an individual child,"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1034.28,"endTime":1037.76,"body":"an individual student, an"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1037.76,"endTime":1041.38,"body":"individual teacher. So tell us"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1037.76,"endTime":1041.38,"body":"some of those stories, if you"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1041.38,"endTime":1041.56,"body":"can."},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1042.22,"endTime":1044.74,"body":"Yeah. So a lot of these"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1042.22,"endTime":1044.74,"body":"stories, you know, have been"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1044.74,"endTime":1049.18,"body":"documented, and many of them"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1044.74,"endTime":1049.18,"body":"have been exposed in the media,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1049.18,"endTime":1052.84,"body":"because the public deserves a"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1049.18,"endTime":1052.84,"body":"right to know what's going on in"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1052.84,"endTime":1057.58,"body":"our schools. So you know, the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1052.84,"endTime":1057.58,"body":"example of this girl in a high"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1057.58,"endTime":1061.5,"body":"school in Brooklyn, in class,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1057.58,"endTime":1061.5,"body":"kind of behind her back"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1061.86,"endTime":1065.16,"body":"students, girls would be saying"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1061.86,"endTime":1065.16,"body":"things like, we're Hamas, we're"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1065.16,"endTime":1068.4,"body":"going to come and get you. And"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1065.16,"endTime":1068.4,"body":"then they took it online and"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1068.4,"endTime":1073.14,"body":"used sexual violence threats"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1068.4,"endTime":1073.14,"body":"against her and targeted her on"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1073.14,"endTime":1077.22,"body":"Instagram that that was a very"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1073.14,"endTime":1077.22,"body":"egregious, you know, example, we"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1077.22,"endTime":1082.46,"body":"have teachers who are writing"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1077.22,"endTime":1082.46,"body":"lesson plans about Aaron Bush"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1082.46,"endTime":1087.5,"body":"now, the protester who committed"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1082.46,"endTime":1087.5,"body":"suicide, who burned himself, to"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1087.5,"endTime":1092.36,"body":"what extent was this a turning"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1087.5,"endTime":1092.36,"body":"point in the Israel Gaza war and"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1092.42,"endTime":1097.34,"body":"all of the links were about how"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1092.42,"endTime":1097.34,"body":"awful Israel is, more lessons"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1097.34,"endTime":1101.02,"body":"like that the knock, but"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1097.34,"endTime":1101.02,"body":"presented as factual"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1101.08,"endTime":1105.28,"body":"information, not asking the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1101.08,"endTime":1105.28,"body":"students to come to conclusions"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1105.28,"endTime":1109.96,"body":"on anything. I personally had a"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1105.28,"endTime":1109.96,"body":"friend who was in a school where"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1109.96,"endTime":1114.88,"body":"kids rioted protest. The DOE"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1109.96,"endTime":1114.88,"body":"says these kids were running"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1114.88,"endTime":1118.66,"body":"rampant through the school with"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1114.88,"endTime":1118.66,"body":"red paint on their hands,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1118.72,"endTime":1122.22,"body":"banging on the doors she's"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1118.72,"endTime":1122.22,"body":"hiding. This is not Hillcrest."},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1122.22,"endTime":1125.22,"body":"This is a different school, my"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1122.22,"endTime":1125.22,"body":"friend, you know, scared."},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1125.22,"endTime":1128.16,"body":"Obviously we, many of us, are"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1125.22,"endTime":1128.16,"body":"familiar with the Hillcrest"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1128.16,"endTime":1131.46,"body":"situation. And that was, again,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1128.16,"endTime":1131.46,"body":"one of the earlier incidents"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1131.46,"endTime":1135.48,"body":"back in November that really,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1131.46,"endTime":1135.48,"body":"really gave us momentum and the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1135.48,"endTime":1140.9,"body":"urgency of what we're doing. We"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1135.48,"endTime":1140.9,"body":"get swastikas written on, you"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1140.9,"endTime":1145.34,"body":"know, in school bathrooms, kids"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1140.9,"endTime":1145.34,"body":"being targeted. A lot of stuff"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1145.34,"endTime":1148.7,"body":"is happening online, where"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1145.34,"endTime":1148.7,"body":"they're, you know, fake"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1148.7,"endTime":1151.76,"body":"announcements for Jewish clubs,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1148.7,"endTime":1151.76,"body":"and they're targeting the Jewish"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1151.76,"endTime":1152.54,"body":"kids. I"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1152.54,"endTime":1155.12,"body":"guess what"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1152.54,"endTime":1155.12,"body":"doesn't make sense to me is that"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1155.18,"endTime":1159.56,"body":"all of these incidents are"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1155.18,"endTime":1159.56,"body":"reportable. So a kid, a kid or a"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1159.56,"endTime":1161.78,"body":"teacher, experiences one of"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1159.56,"endTime":1161.78,"body":"these things, and you would"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1161.78,"endTime":1164.44,"body":"expect there's an official way"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1161.78,"endTime":1164.44,"body":"for someone to actually, you"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1164.44,"endTime":1167.44,"body":"know, report on that particular"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1164.44,"endTime":1167.44,"body":"event. The students are then"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1167.44,"endTime":1170.74,"body":"suspended or expelled. The"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1167.44,"endTime":1170.74,"body":"teachers who, you know, teach"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1170.74,"endTime":1173.5,"body":"egregious curriculum are"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1170.74,"endTime":1173.5,"body":"reprimanded or whatever it might"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1173.5,"endTime":1175.6,"body":"be, and that's an end to it,"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1173.5,"endTime":1175.6,"body":"because, you know, this is a"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1175.6,"endTime":1177.88,"body":"school, and it's part of an"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1175.6,"endTime":1177.88,"body":"institution, and there's a"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1177.88,"endTime":1181.14,"body":"system. Why didn't that happen"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1177.88,"endTime":1181.14,"body":"straight away? What? What's,"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1181.14,"endTime":1183.6,"body":"what's taking place here? And,"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1181.14,"endTime":1183.6,"body":"you know, I don't want to. Maybe"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1183.6,"endTime":1186.72,"body":"I do. I'm not sure if this had"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1183.6,"endTime":1186.72,"body":"happened to any other ethnic,"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1186.72,"endTime":1189.78,"body":"religious or racial group, the"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1186.72,"endTime":1189.78,"body":"response would have been"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1189.78,"endTime":1193.14,"body":"different. So in your mind, I"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1189.78,"endTime":1193.14,"body":"think maybe I'm wrong. We hope,"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1193.38,"endTime":1193.68,"body":"but I"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1193.68,"endTime":1196.68,"body":"don't. Unfortunately,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1193.68,"endTime":1196.68,"body":"that has not always been my"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1196.68,"endTime":1200.54,"body":"experience either. But that's a"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1196.68,"endTime":1200.54,"body":"great question. It's a great"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1200.54,"endTime":1203.24,"body":"question, because we still want"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1200.54,"endTime":1203.24,"body":"to know the answers. I mean,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1203.24,"endTime":1206.84,"body":"we've been asking this question."},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1203.24,"endTime":1206.84,"body":"We you know, we think we have"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1206.84,"endTime":1209.48,"body":"some ideas why this is not"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1206.84,"endTime":1209.48,"body":"happening. So number one,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1209.54,"endTime":1212.96,"body":"parents are afraid. The number"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1209.54,"endTime":1212.96,"body":"one thing we hear is that the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1212.96,"endTime":1215.66,"body":"parents are afraid that there's"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1212.96,"endTime":1215.66,"body":"going to be retribution,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1215.66,"endTime":1218.66,"body":"especially in the high school"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1215.66,"endTime":1218.66,"body":"level, that kids are not going"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1218.66,"endTime":1221.86,"body":"to get college recommendations,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1218.66,"endTime":1221.86,"body":"they're not going to get the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1221.86,"endTime":1226.18,"body":"schedule they want. So parents"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1221.86,"endTime":1226.18,"body":"are scared. In some cases,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1226.24,"endTime":1229.24,"body":"there's not a lot of other"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1226.24,"endTime":1229.24,"body":"Jewish students, so they don't"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1229.24,"endTime":1234.76,"body":"want to draw attention to their"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1229.24,"endTime":1234.76,"body":"child a lot of times, what I"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1234.76,"endTime":1237.82,"body":"found in my last school, because"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1234.76,"endTime":1237.82,"body":"I will say, thankfully, you know"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1237.82,"endTime":1241.62,"body":"my school, I've not experienced"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1237.82,"endTime":1241.62,"body":"anything like what I experienced"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1241.62,"endTime":1246.6,"body":"at my previous school. So kids"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1241.62,"endTime":1246.6,"body":"are a little skeptical that"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1246.6,"endTime":1249.54,"body":"anything is going to change."},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1246.6,"endTime":1249.54,"body":"Sometimes they're not sure that"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1249.54,"endTime":1251.88,"body":"if they speak up, it's going to"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1249.54,"endTime":1251.88,"body":"be worth it. They don't trust"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1251.88,"endTime":1255.06,"body":"that it's going to get taken"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1251.88,"endTime":1255.06,"body":"care of. So that happens a lot."},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1255.06,"endTime":1258.06,"body":"I mean, I definitely know of one"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1255.06,"endTime":1258.06,"body":"incident that was reported where"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1258.06,"endTime":1261.86,"body":"kids did go and they reported it"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1258.06,"endTime":1261.86,"body":"to the guidance counselor, I"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1261.86,"endTime":1265.28,"body":"believe, and then, or the maybe,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1261.86,"endTime":1265.28,"body":"was the dean, but the student"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1265.28,"endTime":1269.66,"body":"never heard from the Dean again."},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1265.28,"endTime":1269.66,"body":"So people need training. That's"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1269.66,"endTime":1272.9,"body":"kind of one of the things that"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1269.66,"endTime":1272.9,"body":"we have. We were talking to the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1272.9,"endTime":1276.92,"body":"DOE about the deans, the RFA,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1272.9,"endTime":1276.92,"body":"the respect for all counselors."},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1276.92,"endTime":1280.16,"body":"These are people who are there"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1276.92,"endTime":1280.16,"body":"to respect the Chancellor's"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1280.16,"endTime":1283.72,"body":"regulations on this kind of"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1280.16,"endTime":1283.72,"body":"discrimination, they need to"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1283.72,"endTime":1288.34,"body":"have training on what anti"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1283.72,"endTime":1288.34,"body":"semitism is in all of its forms."},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1288.46,"endTime":1292.66,"body":"We were guaranteed by Mark"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1288.46,"endTime":1292.66,"body":"rampersant that when there's a"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1292.66,"endTime":1296.38,"body":"swastika, it is dealt with. And"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1292.66,"endTime":1296.38,"body":"I, I have, we have seen that,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1296.5,"endTime":1299.62,"body":"but that's not what we're"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1296.5,"endTime":1299.62,"body":"dealing with anymore. It's not"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1299.62,"endTime":1303.9,"body":"just the swastikas. So that's"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1299.62,"endTime":1303.9,"body":"one piece of it, and that's kind"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1303.9,"endTime":1307.38,"body":"of the problem, in a way, is"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1303.9,"endTime":1307.38,"body":"that the alliance team that I"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1307.38,"endTime":1310.32,"body":"was working with kind of filled"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1307.38,"endTime":1310.32,"body":"this gap. People were coming to"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1310.32,"endTime":1314.76,"body":"us to report it because they"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1310.32,"endTime":1314.76,"body":"felt safer doing that, and that"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1314.76,"endTime":1319.02,"body":"was how we were able to expose"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1314.76,"endTime":1319.02,"body":"and collect and understand the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1319.02,"endTime":1323.6,"body":"level of what's happening in the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1319.02,"endTime":1323.6,"body":"public schools. The second point"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1323.66,"endTime":1327.8,"body":"that I want to make is that the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1323.66,"endTime":1327.8,"body":"reporting procedure is very"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1327.8,"endTime":1331.76,"body":"Byzantine. It's not very clear"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1327.8,"endTime":1331.76,"body":"when I had to file my own"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1331.76,"endTime":1335.9,"body":"discrimination papers granted."},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1331.76,"endTime":1335.9,"body":"It was during COVID. It was very"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1335.9,"endTime":1340.24,"body":"confusing about who to file"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1335.9,"endTime":1340.24,"body":"with, where to file. The DOE did"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1340.24,"endTime":1343.6,"body":"just roll out a reporting"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1340.24,"endTime":1343.6,"body":"hotline, which, you know, those"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1343.6,"endTime":1346.9,"body":"of us who have been advocating"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1343.6,"endTime":1346.9,"body":"for accountability definitely"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1346.96,"endTime":1351.1,"body":"see that as a win. It's not a"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1346.96,"endTime":1351.1,"body":"perfect system, because teachers"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1351.1,"endTime":1355.06,"body":"can't report anonymously, but"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1351.1,"endTime":1355.06,"body":"parents and families can, and"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1355.12,"endTime":1359.5,"body":"that was something that parents"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1355.12,"endTime":1359.5,"body":"had been asking for so that"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1359.5,"endTime":1363.72,"body":"hopefully will help with the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1359.5,"endTime":1363.72,"body":"reporting problem. The third"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1363.72,"endTime":1368.1,"body":"part is oversight. Schools are"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1363.72,"endTime":1368.1,"body":"different, but most of the time,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1368.1,"endTime":1370.8,"body":"especially in the high school"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1368.1,"endTime":1370.8,"body":"level, teachers are"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1370.8,"endTime":1374.16,"body":"professionals. They have"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1370.8,"endTime":1374.16,"body":"autonomy over their classroom,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1374.16,"endTime":1376.62,"body":"in their curriculum, because we"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1374.16,"endTime":1376.62,"body":"should be treated like"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1376.62,"endTime":1380.16,"body":"professionals, right?"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1376.62,"endTime":1380.16,"body":"Unfortunately, that leaves room"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1380.22,"endTime":1384.08,"body":"in some schools for these"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1380.22,"endTime":1384.08,"body":"lessons to slip through the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1384.08,"endTime":1387.56,"body":"cracks, and that is something I"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1384.08,"endTime":1387.56,"body":"think the Department of"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1387.56,"endTime":1391.76,"body":"Education really needs to figure"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1387.56,"endTime":1391.76,"body":"out how to balance the autonomy"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1391.76,"endTime":1395.18,"body":"of teachers, the trust in"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1391.76,"endTime":1395.18,"body":"teachers, but also to know"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1395.18,"endTime":1397.58,"body":"what's going on in their"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1395.18,"endTime":1397.58,"body":"classrooms. So"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1397.58,"endTime":1399.44,"body":"many questions"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1397.58,"endTime":1399.44,"body":"for you, okay, do you believe"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1399.44,"endTime":1402.28,"body":"that the New York Public School"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1399.44,"endTime":1402.28,"body":"System is anti semitic."},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1402.46,"endTime":1406.54,"body":"I absolutely do not"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1402.46,"endTime":1406.54,"body":"believe it is anti semitic. I do"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1406.54,"endTime":1410.62,"body":"believe there are systemic"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1406.54,"endTime":1410.62,"body":"problems within the Department"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1410.62,"endTime":1414.52,"body":"of Education, just like there"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1410.62,"endTime":1414.52,"body":"are in our larger society, and"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1414.52,"endTime":1418.72,"body":"it just mirrors that. But I"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1414.52,"endTime":1418.72,"body":"don't think the leadership is"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1418.72,"endTime":1423.3,"body":"anti semitic. That's I don't, I"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1418.72,"endTime":1423.3,"body":"don't hold by that. I don't just"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1423.3,"endTime":1427.2,"body":"believe that the whole system is"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1423.3,"endTime":1427.2,"body":"anti semitic, but there are"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1427.2,"endTime":1430.68,"body":"problems, and there, there are"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1427.2,"endTime":1430.68,"body":"some major problems that"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1430.68,"endTime":1433.74,"body":"absolutely need to be addressed."},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1430.68,"endTime":1433.74,"body":"And I think there are blind"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1433.74,"endTime":1436.98,"body":"spots when it comes to anti"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1433.74,"endTime":1436.98,"body":"semitism. And I think, I do"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1436.98,"endTime":1440.9,"body":"think that does have to do with"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1436.98,"endTime":1440.9,"body":"leadership. And you mentioned"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1440.9,"endTime":1444.26,"body":"the Jewish teachers are"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1440.9,"endTime":1444.26,"body":"foundational to the Department"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1444.26,"endTime":1448.4,"body":"of Education, if you look at the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1444.26,"endTime":1448.4,"body":"leadership positions, not always"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1448.4,"endTime":1453.02,"body":"the case. So who's making the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1448.4,"endTime":1453.02,"body":"decisions? Who's designing the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1453.02,"endTime":1456.56,"body":"training? Are there Jews"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1453.02,"endTime":1456.56,"body":"involved in that? That's what"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1456.56,"endTime":1459.92,"body":"that was, again, some of the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1456.56,"endTime":1459.92,"body":"questions that we tried to get"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1459.92,"endTime":1463.42,"body":"the Department of Education to"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1459.92,"endTime":1463.42,"body":"think about to help improve the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1463.42,"endTime":1467.26,"body":"situation, not to admonish them,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1463.42,"endTime":1467.26,"body":"but to say, where can we do"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1467.26,"endTime":1469.3,"body":"better? You know, where are your"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1467.26,"endTime":1469.3,"body":"blind spots?"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1469.48,"endTime":1472.12,"body":"I've heard some"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1469.48,"endTime":1472.12,"body":"teachers in public schools,"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1472.24,"endTime":1475.12,"body":"especially those who teach"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1472.24,"endTime":1475.12,"body":"politics, global history, social"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1475.12,"endTime":1478.42,"body":"studies, say that I need to"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1475.12,"endTime":1478.42,"body":"avoid October 7 and what's"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1478.42,"endTime":1481.2,"body":"taking place in Israel,"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1478.42,"endTime":1481.2,"body":"Palestine, Gaza. It's just too"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1481.2,"endTime":1484.44,"body":"complicated. I can't possibly"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1481.2,"endTime":1484.44,"body":"get it right, therefore I'm not"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1484.44,"endTime":1487.2,"body":"going to talk about it at all."},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1484.44,"endTime":1487.2,"body":"And they'll, they'll talk about"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1487.2,"endTime":1489.6,"body":"Russia and Ukraine, because"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1487.2,"endTime":1489.6,"body":"that's a heck of a lot easier."},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1489.72,"endTime":1493.38,"body":"It's fascinating that teachers"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1489.72,"endTime":1493.38,"body":"are, I think, taking this stance"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1493.38,"endTime":1496.68,"body":"because of all of these concerns"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1493.38,"endTime":1496.68,"body":"that they have, maybe they're"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1496.68,"endTime":1499.38,"body":"being directed to avoid it."},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1496.68,"endTime":1499.38,"body":"Maybe they feel like they can't"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1499.38,"endTime":1499.92,"body":"win, or they can."},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1800.0,"endTime":1803.06,"body":"Spaces, because the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1800.0,"endTime":1803.06,"body":"kids need them, they need"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1803.12,"endTime":1806.36,"body":"support, and they need teachers"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1803.12,"endTime":1806.36,"body":"who can support them through"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1806.36,"endTime":1807.14,"body":"this time."},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1807.2,"endTime":1809.06,"body":"Shaina, I'm going"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1807.2,"endTime":1809.06,"body":"to ask you a question you can"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1809.06,"endTime":1813.02,"body":"choose to ignore it. Have you"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1809.06,"endTime":1813.02,"body":"lost or have you strengthened"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1813.02,"endTime":1815.96,"body":"your commitment to public school"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1813.02,"endTime":1815.96,"body":"education? I mean, I'm asking"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1815.96,"endTime":1818.6,"body":"this question because I'm going"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1815.96,"endTime":1818.6,"body":"to guess that it's crossed your"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1818.6,"endTime":1821.32,"body":"mind that it could be a heck of"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1818.6,"endTime":1821.32,"body":"a lot easier for you to go work"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1821.32,"endTime":1824.08,"body":"for a Jewish Day School. And I'm"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1821.32,"endTime":1824.08,"body":"sure some Jewish day schools"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1824.08,"endTime":1826.78,"body":"have tried to recruit you as"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1824.08,"endTime":1826.78,"body":"well, and that your state firm"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1826.78,"endTime":1829.36,"body":"to New York public school"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1826.78,"endTime":1829.36,"body":"education. So talked a bit about"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1829.36,"endTime":1831.88,"body":"your commitment to public school"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1829.36,"endTime":1831.88,"body":"education, yeah."},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1831.88,"endTime":1834.34,"body":"Well, I would say that"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1831.88,"endTime":1834.34,"body":"I would love a tuition break."},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1834.34,"endTime":1838.0,"body":"That would be lovely, but I am a"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1834.34,"endTime":1838.0,"body":"product of public schools. My"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1838.0,"endTime":1842.94,"body":"mother was a public school"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1838.0,"endTime":1842.94,"body":"teacher as well. And I think"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1842.94,"endTime":1847.44,"body":"more than ever we need Jewish"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1842.94,"endTime":1847.44,"body":"students and Jewish teachers in"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1847.44,"endTime":1850.38,"body":"our public schools. You know,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1847.44,"endTime":1850.38,"body":"this is a big conversation that"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1850.38,"endTime":1853.14,"body":"is happening on all these chats,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1850.38,"endTime":1853.14,"body":"you know, should that all the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1853.14,"endTime":1856.8,"body":"Jews go to the private schools,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1853.14,"endTime":1856.8,"body":"you know? And I believe we need"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1856.8,"endTime":1860.24,"body":"to be in these spaces. This is"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1856.8,"endTime":1860.24,"body":"where some kids meet a Jewish"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1860.24,"endTime":1864.14,"body":"person for the first time. So I"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1860.24,"endTime":1864.14,"body":"am fully committed to public"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1864.14,"endTime":1868.64,"body":"education. I think it every kid"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1864.14,"endTime":1868.64,"body":"in New York City deserves a"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1868.64,"endTime":1872.0,"body":"quality education. And the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1868.64,"endTime":1872.0,"body":"beauty of it is that you are"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1872.0,"endTime":1876.02,"body":"learning in a diverse"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1872.0,"endTime":1876.02,"body":"environment and engaging. And I"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1876.02,"endTime":1880.12,"body":"really believe that our"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1876.02,"endTime":1880.12,"body":"education system, like my"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1880.12,"endTime":1883.54,"body":"training. I went to teachers"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1880.12,"endTime":1883.54,"body":"college. It's a social justice"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1883.54,"endTime":1886.66,"body":"program that I was fully in. I'm"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1883.54,"endTime":1886.66,"body":"going to be a social studies"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1886.66,"endTime":1890.56,"body":"teacher for social justice. And"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1886.66,"endTime":1890.56,"body":"I really had that shift that"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1890.62,"endTime":1895.0,"body":"it's not my job to teach these"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1890.62,"endTime":1895.0,"body":"kids to be social justice. You"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1895.0,"endTime":1898.96,"body":"know, warriors, I want my kids"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1895.0,"endTime":1898.96,"body":"to be empowered, yes, but I want"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1898.96,"endTime":1904.38,"body":"them to believe in liberal"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1898.96,"endTime":1904.38,"body":"values of democracy, of freedom,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1904.44,"endTime":1908.82,"body":"of equality of rights, and that"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1904.44,"endTime":1908.82,"body":"has to happen in our public"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1908.82,"endTime":1913.26,"body":"schools. We cannot see this"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1908.82,"endTime":1913.26,"body":"space. We are fighting against"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1913.32,"endTime":1917.82,"body":"Nazi like ideology in our"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1913.32,"endTime":1917.82,"body":"schools, misinformation,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1917.82,"endTime":1921.74,"body":"disinformation, like I said, you"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1917.82,"endTime":1921.74,"body":"know, just presenting kids with"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1921.74,"endTime":1925.94,"body":"one side of the story. We can't"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1921.74,"endTime":1925.94,"body":"see those spaces. So I think"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1925.94,"endTime":1929.6,"body":"more than ever, not just Jewish"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1925.94,"endTime":1929.6,"body":"teachers need to stay there. But"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1929.84,"endTime":1933.5,"body":"I've said this before to anyone"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1929.84,"endTime":1933.5,"body":"who will listen to me, is that"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1933.5,"endTime":1938.12,"body":"the Jewish education space, the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1933.5,"endTime":1938.12,"body":"Jewish Agency space, has to"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1938.12,"endTime":1942.94,"body":"invest in our public schools"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1938.12,"endTime":1942.94,"body":"because a majority of Jewish"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1942.94,"endTime":1946.18,"body":"kids in this country are not in"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1942.94,"endTime":1946.18,"body":"these schools. They are in"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1946.18,"endTime":1949.78,"body":"public schools. So we have to"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1946.18,"endTime":1949.78,"body":"remember that Jewish education"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1949.78,"endTime":1952.96,"body":"happens. What meaning I'm"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1949.78,"endTime":1952.96,"body":"teaching Jewish history"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1952.96,"endTime":1955.84,"body":"tomorrow. Actually, my lesson"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1952.96,"endTime":1955.84,"body":"tomorrow is about the Jewish"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1955.84,"endTime":1960.24,"body":"nation and the Jewish people and"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1955.84,"endTime":1960.24,"body":"the attachment to Israel and the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1960.24,"endTime":1964.32,"body":"Assyrian captivity and how that"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1960.24,"endTime":1964.32,"body":"impacted them. I insert that"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1964.32,"endTime":1966.84,"body":"because I want them to"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1964.32,"endTime":1966.84,"body":"understand. And then later, next"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1966.84,"endTime":1969.84,"body":"week, I'm going to follow up"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1966.84,"endTime":1969.84,"body":"with a lesson about Cyrus and"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1969.84,"endTime":1974.16,"body":"use the book of Ezra and other"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1969.84,"endTime":1974.16,"body":"sources to take a look at and"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1974.16,"endTime":1978.3,"body":"corroborate history. So we"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1974.16,"endTime":1978.3,"body":"cannot see this space to people"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1978.3,"endTime":1981.92,"body":"who do have agendas. And"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1978.3,"endTime":1981.92,"body":"unfortunately, there are those"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1981.92,"endTime":1984.38,"body":"people. There are a lot of"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1981.92,"endTime":1984.38,"body":"amazing public school teachers"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1984.38,"endTime":1988.16,"body":"out there that I've worked with."},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1984.38,"endTime":1988.16,"body":"Most of them, almost 100% of"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1988.16,"endTime":1991.34,"body":"them have been fantastic. But"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1988.16,"endTime":1991.34,"body":"unfortunately, we know that"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1991.34,"endTime":1993.86,"body":"there are teachers out there who"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1991.34,"endTime":1993.86,"body":"think they're doing the right"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1993.86,"endTime":1997.64,"body":"thing, but it's really, it"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1993.86,"endTime":1997.64,"body":"really is scary about what's"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":1997.64,"endTime":1998.24,"body":"happening. I"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1998.24,"endTime":2000.4,"body":"want to ask you"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":1998.24,"endTime":2000.4,"body":"another question, and then we"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2000.4,"endTime":2002.64,"body":"could just digress and keep"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2000.4,"endTime":2002.64,"body":"talking, but our listeners"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2002.64,"endTime":2005.1,"body":"eventually need to turn off"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2002.64,"endTime":2005.1,"body":"their podcast and go continue"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2005.1,"endTime":2007.38,"body":"cooking dinner. I want to talk a"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2005.1,"endTime":2007.38,"body":"bit about objectivity,"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2007.38,"endTime":2009.78,"body":"especially as a social studies"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2007.38,"endTime":2009.78,"body":"teacher, like, what you just"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2009.78,"endTime":2013.08,"body":"said is not objective. Like"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2009.78,"endTime":2013.08,"body":"you're bringing your personal"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2013.14,"endTime":2015.72,"body":"viewpoints, your personal"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2013.14,"endTime":2015.72,"body":"pieces, to your curriculum, to"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2015.72,"endTime":2018.66,"body":"your outlines. Like, is it such"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2015.72,"endTime":2018.66,"body":"a thing as an objective social"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2018.66,"endTime":2021.56,"body":"studies teacher, is that what"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2018.66,"endTime":2021.56,"body":"we're looking for is"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2021.56,"endTime":2024.68,"body":"subjectivity, something we"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2021.56,"endTime":2024.68,"body":"should just embrace. And does it"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2024.68,"endTime":2027.32,"body":"only work when we agree with"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2024.68,"endTime":2027.32,"body":"someone's subjectivity and it's"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2027.32,"endTime":2029.72,"body":"when we get upset with the other"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2027.32,"endTime":2029.72,"body":"side, so to speak, then it"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2029.72,"endTime":2032.06,"body":"becomes, oh, no, all history"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2029.72,"endTime":2032.06,"body":"needs to be objective,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2032.42,"endTime":2035.36,"body":"right? Oh, I mean, see,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2032.42,"endTime":2035.36,"body":"that's part of the challenge. Is"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2035.36,"endTime":2041.38,"body":"that there are facts and there's"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2035.36,"endTime":2041.38,"body":"facts that can't be changed, but"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2041.38,"endTime":2045.16,"body":"there are narratives, and"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2041.38,"endTime":2045.16,"body":"narratives are often not based"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2045.16,"endTime":2048.46,"body":"on facts. They're based on"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2045.16,"endTime":2048.46,"body":"feelings, but they also play a"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2048.46,"endTime":2052.18,"body":"role in how we understand the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2048.46,"endTime":2052.18,"body":"past. So you know, for example,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2052.18,"endTime":2056.14,"body":"there's a lot of debate within"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2052.18,"endTime":2056.14,"body":"the Jewish education space. And"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2056.14,"endTime":2059.2,"body":"you know, K through 12 public"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2056.14,"endTime":2059.2,"body":"schools, should we teach dual"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2059.2,"endTime":2062.16,"body":"narrative? Should we teach the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2059.2,"endTime":2062.16,"body":"Palestinian narrative. And some"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2062.16,"endTime":2065.28,"body":"people think no, because"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2062.16,"endTime":2065.28,"body":"narratives are not necessarily"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2065.28,"endTime":2068.4,"body":"factual. So there's different"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2065.28,"endTime":2068.4,"body":"opinions about that, and"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2068.4,"endTime":2071.7,"body":"there's, I've seen different"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2068.4,"endTime":2071.7,"body":"ways to do it, but this is the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2071.7,"endTime":2075.66,"body":"challenge. I fully believe, you"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2071.7,"endTime":2075.66,"body":"know, that we should embrace"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2075.66,"endTime":2078.84,"body":"hard history. So I know, you"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2075.66,"endTime":2078.84,"body":"know we talked about the DEI"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2078.84,"endTime":2082.88,"body":"before. I like the idea is not"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2078.84,"endTime":2082.88,"body":"the ideology, right? The same"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2082.88,"endTime":2086.78,"body":"thing with this hard history"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2082.88,"endTime":2086.78,"body":"concept. We cannot shy away from"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2086.78,"endTime":2091.64,"body":"hard history. It is our job to"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2086.78,"endTime":2091.64,"body":"teach students how to understand"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2091.76,"endTime":2097.4,"body":"the two sides of a conflict by"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2091.76,"endTime":2097.4,"body":"presenting them with the facts"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2097.4,"endTime":2099.92,"body":"and, in cases, the narratives."},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2097.4,"endTime":2099.92,"body":"Now here's the question, though."},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2100.0,"endTime":2104.86,"body":"Kind of what you brought up, we"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2100.0,"endTime":2104.86,"body":"would never, ever ask if Hitler"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2104.86,"endTime":2108.16,"body":"was a good leader, right? We"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2104.86,"endTime":2108.16,"body":"would never ask our students to"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2108.16,"endTime":2112.9,"body":"debate if slavery was good or"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2108.16,"endTime":2112.9,"body":"bad. We have to have things that"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2112.9,"endTime":2118.06,"body":"we agree on in history that are"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2112.9,"endTime":2118.06,"body":"bad or in the past. And that is"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2118.06,"endTime":2122.82,"body":"where I think it the training"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2118.06,"endTime":2122.82,"body":"comes in, the training comes in,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2122.82,"endTime":2126.6,"body":"and having those conversations"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2122.82,"endTime":2126.6,"body":"as a department, and having the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2126.6,"endTime":2130.26,"body":"administrator, you know, the or"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2126.6,"endTime":2130.26,"body":"the teacher leader, have that"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2130.26,"endTime":2133.74,"body":"training to navigate that and to"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2130.26,"endTime":2133.74,"body":"train the teachers on this."},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2133.74,"endTime":2137.1,"body":"Because you can get it really"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2133.74,"endTime":2137.1,"body":"wrong and you can get it right."},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2137.1,"endTime":2141.08,"body":"And I'll admit I made mistakes"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2137.1,"endTime":2141.08,"body":"along the way, you know, because"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2141.08,"endTime":2144.2,"body":"there are things that I believe"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2141.08,"endTime":2144.2,"body":"are are important, that students"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2144.2,"endTime":2146.54,"body":"need to know. And then I said,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2144.2,"endTime":2146.54,"body":"You know what? Maybe it's a"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2146.54,"endTime":2150.02,"body":"little bit too leading, but this"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2146.54,"endTime":2150.02,"body":"is one of the challenges of"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2150.02,"endTime":2153.32,"body":"being a social studies teacher."},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2150.02,"endTime":2153.32,"body":"But I can tell you know, for"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2153.32,"endTime":2156.86,"body":"example, this, you know,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2153.32,"endTime":2156.86,"body":"examples of is Israel committing"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2156.86,"endTime":2159.86,"body":"a genocide. You see a lot of"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2156.86,"endTime":2159.86,"body":"those lesson plans or ethnic"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2159.86,"endTime":2165.46,"body":"cleansing, they're using the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2159.86,"endTime":2165.46,"body":"terminology ethnic cleansing in"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2165.46,"endTime":2168.52,"body":"a misleading way. And the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2165.46,"endTime":2168.52,"body":"question I would have to that"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2168.52,"endTime":2170.62,"body":"teacher is, well, you know,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2168.52,"endTime":2170.62,"body":"what's your agenda here? You"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2170.62,"endTime":2172.84,"body":"know, what's the intention,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2170.62,"endTime":2172.84,"body":"what's your learning goals? I"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2172.84,"endTime":2175.3,"body":"think that's kind of the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2172.84,"endTime":2175.3,"body":"questions we need to be asking"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2175.3,"endTime":2178.66,"body":"these teachers, because is it to"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2175.3,"endTime":2178.66,"body":"get the students to think a"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2178.66,"endTime":2182.4,"body":"certain way, and we don't want"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2178.66,"endTime":2182.4,"body":"the students to come away"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2182.46,"endTime":2186.12,"body":"thinking that ethnic cleansing"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2182.46,"endTime":2186.12,"body":"is a good thing, right? Like"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2186.12,"endTime":2189.78,"body":"that's not on the table, but we"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2186.12,"endTime":2189.78,"body":"need to get them to understand"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2189.84,"endTime":2192.48,"body":"how it's happened when it's"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2189.84,"endTime":2192.48,"body":"happened. We have to have those"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2192.48,"endTime":2193.5,"body":"conversations."},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2193.8,"endTime":2195.96,"body":"I'll tell you."},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2193.8,"endTime":2195.96,"body":"For me, one of the most complex"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2195.96,"endTime":2199.44,"body":"phrases in recent months has"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2195.96,"endTime":2199.44,"body":"been the right side of history."},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2199.5,"endTime":2201.8,"body":"The people come to me saying"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2199.5,"endTime":2201.8,"body":"we're teaching about the"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2201.8,"endTime":2204.92,"body":"genocide in Gaza because this is"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2201.8,"endTime":2204.92,"body":"the right side of history. And"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2204.92,"endTime":2207.38,"body":"just like you said before, when"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2204.92,"endTime":2207.38,"body":"we're teaching about the Civil"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2207.38,"endTime":2209.96,"body":"Rights in New York public school"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2207.38,"endTime":2209.96,"body":"systems, we weren't bringing in"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2209.96,"endTime":2212.72,"body":"the Ku Klux Klan to speak about"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2209.96,"endTime":2212.72,"body":"the other, so called other side,"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2212.72,"endTime":2215.9,"body":"and giving them legitimacy"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2212.72,"endTime":2215.9,"body":"somewhere in this whole"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2215.9,"endTime":2218.48,"body":"discussion, in this whole past"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2215.9,"endTime":2218.48,"body":"year. And I think one of the"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2218.48,"endTime":2221.44,"body":"biggest pain points we face as"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2218.48,"endTime":2221.44,"body":"Jewish community is we've lost"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2221.44,"endTime":2225.04,"body":"control over many aspects of"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2221.44,"endTime":2225.04,"body":"what you've eloquently put as"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2225.1,"endTime":2227.62,"body":"not just the narrative. We've"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2225.1,"endTime":2227.62,"body":"lost control over some of the"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2227.62,"endTime":2230.86,"body":"facts as well. And in our school"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2227.62,"endTime":2230.86,"body":"system, it's being manipulated"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2230.86,"endTime":2234.46,"body":"by some against Jewish students."},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2230.86,"endTime":2234.46,"body":"And I'm just like, so thankful"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2234.46,"endTime":2237.58,"body":"that someone like yourself is"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2234.46,"endTime":2237.58,"body":"able to stand up and literally,"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2237.58,"endTime":2240.96,"body":"to highlight what needs to be"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2237.58,"endTime":2240.96,"body":"done and your your indications"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2240.96,"endTime":2243.6,"body":"before about some of the"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2240.96,"endTime":2243.6,"body":"incremental changes that you've"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2243.6,"endTime":2246.96,"body":"made, sometimes even impacting"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2243.6,"endTime":2246.96,"body":"the system as a whole, are truly"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2246.96,"endTime":2249.3,"body":"remarkable. And I think you"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2246.96,"endTime":2249.3,"body":"should take a moment and pause"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2249.3,"endTime":2252.18,"body":"and just like reflect on what"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2249.3,"endTime":2252.18,"body":"you've been able to teach. As"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2252.18,"endTime":2256.08,"body":"someone said to me, as just a"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2252.18,"endTime":2256.08,"body":"teacher, as if just a teacher is"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2256.08,"endTime":2260.04,"body":"a minimization of someone's"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2256.08,"endTime":2260.04,"body":"work. So really credit to you"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2260.04,"endTime":2262.34,"body":"and all of the work. You didn't"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2260.04,"endTime":2262.34,"body":"have to do this. You didn't have"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2262.34,"endTime":2263.78,"body":"to stand up. No,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2263.84,"endTime":2267.14,"body":"I didn't, but I have a"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2263.84,"endTime":2267.14,"body":"hard time staying quiet. It's"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2267.14,"endTime":2270.62,"body":"always been one of my quote,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2267.14,"endTime":2270.62,"body":"unquote, bad qualities. But I do"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2270.62,"endTime":2273.92,"body":"want to say, and I want you know"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2270.62,"endTime":2273.92,"body":"that it's not just me. You know,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2273.92,"endTime":2278.84,"body":"I have no problem raising my"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2273.92,"endTime":2278.84,"body":"voice. I'm really good at kind"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2278.84,"endTime":2282.1,"body":"of galvanizing, but there are a"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2278.84,"endTime":2282.1,"body":"lot of people who are doing this"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2282.1,"endTime":2285.4,"body":"work day in and day out. I'm not"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2282.1,"endTime":2285.4,"body":"going to name them all publicly,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2285.4,"endTime":2288.22,"body":"but the women of the New York"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2285.4,"endTime":2288.22,"body":"City public Alliance who are"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2288.22,"endTime":2290.74,"body":"leading that, Karen and tovo,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2288.22,"endTime":2290.74,"body":"for example, I mean, they are"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2290.74,"endTime":2294.16,"body":"putting in hours of"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2290.74,"endTime":2294.16,"body":"uncompensated work. There's"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2294.16,"endTime":2298.84,"body":"other teachers, parents. We've"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2294.16,"endTime":2298.84,"body":"had students, and the beautiful"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2298.84,"endTime":2301.98,"body":"thing now is that we're"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2298.84,"endTime":2301.98,"body":"connecting to other teachers"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2301.98,"endTime":2306.9,"body":"around the country, and it took"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2301.98,"endTime":2306.9,"body":"a maybe a year, but the movement"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2306.9,"endTime":2312.18,"body":"is growing, and I'm I'm hopeful,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2306.9,"endTime":2312.18,"body":"but I know we have a lot to do,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2312.18,"endTime":2316.08,"body":"and it can't just be one teacher"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2312.18,"endTime":2316.08,"body":"here or one teacher there. We"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2316.08,"endTime":2320.3,"body":"need the Jewish community to get"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2316.08,"endTime":2320.3,"body":"involved in their local"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2320.3,"endTime":2323.9,"body":"districts especially support"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2320.3,"endTime":2323.9,"body":"the, you know, the public"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2323.9,"endTime":2327.56,"body":"schools, and this is a societal"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2323.9,"endTime":2327.56,"body":"problem, because our public"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2327.56,"endTime":2332.36,"body":"schools, you know, they train"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2327.56,"endTime":2332.36,"body":"future leaders. So I appreciate,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2332.36,"endTime":2336.26,"body":"you know, I appreciate that, but"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2332.36,"endTime":2336.26,"body":"I really am appreciative also,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2336.26,"endTime":2339.68,"body":"of all the people that have that"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2336.26,"endTime":2339.68,"body":"are doing this work and that"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2339.68,"endTime":2343.0,"body":"have inspired me to keep going"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2339.68,"endTime":2343.0,"body":"when we hit those roadblocks."},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2343.12,"endTime":2346.06,"body":"Shana, is there"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2343.12,"endTime":2346.06,"body":"an educator in your life that"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2346.06,"endTime":2348.82,"body":"you're able to pay tribute to"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2346.06,"endTime":2348.82,"body":"someone who's helped create you"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2348.82,"endTime":2351.64,"body":"into the incredible role model"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2348.82,"endTime":2351.64,"body":"that you are today? Oh,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2351.64,"endTime":2355.12,"body":"thank you, absolutely."},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2351.64,"endTime":2355.12,"body":"Mr. Davies, you keep saying,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2355.12,"endTime":2359.74,"body":"call me Mark, but Mr. Davies was"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2355.12,"endTime":2359.74,"body":"like the cool social studies"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2359.74,"endTime":2363.12,"body":"teacher. Kind of look like Marty"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2359.74,"endTime":2363.12,"body":"McFly, but he actually wasn't my"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2363.18,"endTime":2366.72,"body":"classroom teacher, but he was my"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2363.18,"endTime":2366.72,"body":"Amnesty International advisor."},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2366.72,"endTime":2369.72,"body":"So when I was 15, I got"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2366.72,"endTime":2369.72,"body":"interested in Amnesty"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2369.72,"endTime":2373.86,"body":"International through the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2369.72,"endTime":2373.86,"body":"Tibetan human rights issue, and"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2374.1,"endTime":2378.06,"body":"Mr. Davies advised me for three"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2374.1,"endTime":2378.06,"body":"years in this club, and he"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2378.06,"endTime":2382.34,"body":"really made me feel like my"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2378.06,"endTime":2382.34,"body":"voice mattered. He believed in"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2382.34,"endTime":2387.26,"body":"me, he coached me, but he let me"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2382.34,"endTime":2387.26,"body":"lead, and I absolutely would not"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2387.26,"endTime":2391.76,"body":"be here today if it were not for"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2387.26,"endTime":2391.76,"body":"Mr. Davies, and he really"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2391.76,"endTime":2395.78,"body":"inspired me to become a teacher"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2391.76,"endTime":2395.78,"body":"and to be the kind of teacher"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2395.84,"endTime":2399.08,"body":"that I needed at that time"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2395.84,"endTime":2399.08,"body":"because I was bullied in eighth"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2399.08,"endTime":2402.94,"body":"grade for being Jewish. Ish"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2399.08,"endTime":2402.94,"body":"actually really bad, like I was"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2402.94,"endTime":2407.5,"body":"physically accosted, and not one"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2402.94,"endTime":2407.5,"body":"teacher spoke up that I knew of."},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2407.56,"endTime":2410.62,"body":"I didn't hear of any teacher"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2407.56,"endTime":2410.62,"body":"speaking up. One teacher once"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2410.62,"endTime":2413.56,"body":"asked me if I was okay, but I"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2410.62,"endTime":2413.56,"body":"never felt like I had a teacher"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2413.56,"endTime":2415.72,"body":"on my side until Mr. Davies"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2416.619,"endTime":2419.319,"body":"Shaina. Thank"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2416.619,"endTime":2419.319,"body":"you. Thank you for joining us on"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2419.319,"endTime":2421.679,"body":"adapting. Thank you for all the"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2419.319,"endTime":2421.679,"body":"work that you do. Thank you for"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2421.679,"endTime":2425.399,"body":"your commitment to the students"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2421.679,"endTime":2425.399,"body":"of New York and beyond, and your"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2425.399,"endTime":2429.599,"body":"voice is being heard loud and"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2425.399,"endTime":2429.599,"body":"clear. And I just wish you. And"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2429.599,"endTime":2433.139,"body":"now to be totally transparent,"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2429.599,"endTime":2433.139,"body":"we're working in a similar space"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2433.139,"endTime":2436.379,"body":"now to make sure that we can, we"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2433.139,"endTime":2436.379,"body":"can bring about systemic changes"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2436.379,"endTime":2438.539,"body":"to what you're talking about,"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2436.379,"endTime":2438.539,"body":"but the teachers are really the"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2438.539,"endTime":2441.119,"body":"essence of all of the education"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2438.539,"endTime":2441.119,"body":"taking place, and without people"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2441.119,"endTime":2443.959,"body":"like yourself, we couldn't even"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2441.119,"endTime":2443.959,"body":"be dreaming of a better world in"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2443.959,"endTime":2446.119,"body":"which to live. So really, thank"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2443.959,"endTime":2446.119,"body":"you so much for all that you do,"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2446.12,"endTime":2448.7,"body":"absolutely. And I'm"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2446.12,"endTime":2448.7,"body":"just gonna add in there, if I"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2448.7,"endTime":2451.88,"body":"can, that I really want to thank"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2448.7,"endTime":2451.88,"body":"the Jewish education project."},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2451.88,"endTime":2456.38,"body":"Also the New York Education"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2451.88,"endTime":2456.38,"body":"Initiative has really given me"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2456.38,"endTime":2460.96,"body":"hope that we can make change"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2456.38,"endTime":2460.96,"body":"through working together as a"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2460.96,"endTime":2464.56,"body":"Jewish community, and so you"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2460.96,"endTime":2464.56,"body":"know that that work that the"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2464.8,"endTime":2468.04,"body":"Jewish education project has"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2464.8,"endTime":2468.04,"body":"been doing is really going to be"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2468.04,"endTime":2470.02,"body":"essential to making the changes"},{"speaker":"Unknown","startTime":2468.04,"endTime":2470.02,"body":"we need."},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2470.62,"endTime":2472.84,"body":"Today's episode"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2470.62,"endTime":2472.84,"body":"of adapting was produced by Dina"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2472.84,"endTime":2475.78,"body":"nussenbaum and Miranda Lapides."},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2472.84,"endTime":2475.78,"body":"The show's executive producers"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2475.78,"endTime":2478.6,"body":"are myself, Karen Cummins and"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2475.78,"endTime":2478.6,"body":"nessa lieben. Our show is"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2478.6,"endTime":2482.82,"body":"engineered and edited by Nathan"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2478.6,"endTime":2482.82,"body":"j1 of njv media. If you enjoyed"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2482.82,"endTime":2485.34,"body":"today's episode of adapting,"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2482.82,"endTime":2485.34,"body":"please share it with a friend,"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2485.46,"endTime":2487.68,"body":"especially someone who might"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2485.46,"endTime":2487.68,"body":"send their child to public"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2487.68,"endTime":2489.84,"body":"school, because I think they"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2487.68,"endTime":2489.84,"body":"need to hear about the work that"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2489.84,"endTime":2492.24,"body":"Shane is doing, and if there are"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2489.84,"endTime":2492.24,"body":"any problems occurring with"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2492.24,"endTime":2494.64,"body":"them, that they know how to"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2492.24,"endTime":2494.64,"body":"reach out to others to try and"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2494.64,"endTime":2497.04,"body":"bring about some change in their"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2494.64,"endTime":2497.04,"body":"schools as well. To learn more"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2497.04,"endTime":2499.32,"body":"about the Jewish education"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2497.04,"endTime":2499.32,"body":"project, visit us at Jewish"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2499.32,"endTime":2501.8,"body":"edproject.org, there you can"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2499.32,"endTime":2501.8,"body":"learn more about our mission"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2501.8,"endTime":2504.92,"body":"history and our staff. We're a"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2501.8,"endTime":2504.92,"body":"proud partner of UGA Federation"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2504.92,"endTime":2507.5,"body":"of New York. Thank you always"},{"speaker":"David Bryfman","startTime":2504.92,"endTime":2507.5,"body":"for listening today. You."}]}