Vacated, Reinstated — How New York Took Back a Man’s Freedom: The Story of Baby Sam

LFTG Radio

LFTG Radio
Vacated, Reinstated — How New York Took Back a Man’s Freedom: The Story of Baby Sam
Dec 17, 2025 Season 2 Episode 42
Elliott Carterr

Send us a text

For more than 33 years, Samuel “Baby Sam” Edmondson lived inside a conviction the courts would later acknowledge was broken.

In 2022, a Brooklyn Supreme Court judge vacated that conviction after finding unreliable witnesses, suppressed evidence, and investigative misconduct tied to NYPD Detective Louis Scarcella. Baby Sam walked free and began rebuilding his life.

Three years later, the State of New York reinstated part of that same conviction — without a new trial — sending him back to prison.

In this exclusive interview, Baby Sam speaks in his own words about:

  • Having his conviction vacated after three decades
  • What the court acknowledged about his case
  • Living free, then being ordered back into custody
  • The role of police misconduct and prosecutorial decisions
  • Why he believes the system is still refusing full accountability

This conversation is not about mythology or headlines.

It is about due process, state power, and what happens when the justice system reverses its own admission of error.

👉🏾 Read the full reporting:

The Gutter Report: Vacated, Reinstated — How New York Took Back a Man’s Freedom

👉🏾 Take action:

Sign the petition calling for accountability and transparency

Not for clicks — for clarity.

— Elliott Carterr, LFTG Radio

📱 TikTok: @elliott_carterr

📺 YouTube: @lftgradio

🌐 Website: LFTGRadio.com

Support the show

Subscribe to our YouTube @LFTGRadio and check out the website LFTGRadio.com for live updates!

Episode Artwork Vacated, Reinstated — How New York Took Back a Man’s Freedom: The Story of Baby Sam 53:26 Episode Artwork The Syracuse Setup: Inside the Case of Nahkeen Lewis-Bush 23:10 Episode Artwork The System vs. Jekai Reid-John: When Innocence Beats the Odds 30:28 Episode Artwork Live From the Feds: Trag Speaks on Loyalty, Lyrics & The Rap Act 12:07 Episode Artwork Staten Island Gangsterism: Penn & Perry's Criminal Empire Uncovered 40:17 Episode Artwork Unmasking The Kings of The Hill 34:03 Episode Artwork Off the Grid: ST’s Last Message to Staten Island 26:20 Episode Artwork For the Record: A Call from Tek Money 19:24 Episode Artwork Confrontations and Allegations 17:53 Episode Artwork Who Really Told? Unraveling Staten Island's Street Allegations 29:41 Episode Artwork Collect Call from History: The Chuckie Taylor Interview - Part 1 15:01 Episode Artwork Betrayal Within the Family: The Bugatti and Double M Feud Exposed 13:28 Episode Artwork Staten Island Bonds: E Carterr and Chunk Reconnect Through Music and Comedy 13:12 Episode Artwork Prison Pens & Publishing Dreams: One Man's Journey to Creative Freedom 17:46 Episode Artwork From Boston to Liberia: Chuck Taylor's Journey 15:05 Episode Artwork Backstage Brawl at Summer Jam: The Truth About C-Black's Altercation with the Dream Chasers 15:28 Episode Artwork The Fall of a Fake Kash Money Rep: A Vermont Crime Story 18:08 Episode Artwork Staten Island Blood Leader Exposed: Crimes, Cooperation, and Controversy 20:11 Episode Artwork How Richmond County's Justice System Railroaded an Innocent Man 1:04:36 Episode Artwork Gutter to Greatness: The Unfiltered Debo Story 15:16 Episode Artwork The Truth Behind the Urban Legends: Dee Billy Sets the Record Straight 5:59 Episode Artwork From Propaganda to Truth: Chuckie Taylor Speaks Out 7:35 Episode Artwork Behind Prison Walls: How the DOJ Built a Conspiracy Against Me 31:58 Episode Artwork Wolves Got Up On You: Tales from the Other Side 3:28 Episode Artwork Staten Island Chronicles 30:31