Box in the Basement

A Christmas Eve Tragedy: The 2015 Unsolved Murder of Henry Gutierrez

Share episode

Henry Gutierrez Jr., a 71-year-old prominent businessman from Schertz, Texas, was known for his charisma, generosity, and success as a real estate mogul and former nightclub owner. Described as hardworking and deeply connected to his community, Henry was known for helping those in need and living with vibrancy. But on Christmas Eve 2015, his life was tragically cut short when he was found brutally murdered in the garage of his upscale home.

Discovered by his son, Henry’s death stunned the quiet town. Evidence suggested the crime was targeted, but the motive remained unclear. The violent nature of the attack pointed to a personal vendetta, yet years of investigation failed to identify suspects or answers. Despite his larger-than-life personality, Henry’s murder became an unsolved cold case, leaving his family heartbroken and his community searching for justice.

Eight years later, with Schertz Police forming a cold case unit and public appeals for information ongoing, the question lingers: Who killed Henry Gutierrez, and why?

Join Arlene & Leah on the anniversary of Box in the Basement as they discuss Henry's life, the theories, and the suspects and shed light on this mysterious cold case. 

Show Notes:
Schertz Slaying Stumps Investigators
Unsolved Murder of Prominent Businessman Henry Gutierrez on Christmas Eve 2015
Cold Case Files: Schertz Police Seek Info on 2015 Unsolved Murder of Henry Gutierrez
Schertz Businessman’s Murder Case Turns Cold, Sparks New Unit for Police Department
Murder of Schertz Businessman Henry Gutierrez Jr. Now a Cold Case
Schertz Businessman’s Murder Remains Unsolved
Henry Gutierrez: Cold Case Updates
Christmas Eve Murder of Prominent Businessman Still Unsolved
The Texas Millionaire Murder: Who Killed Henry Gutierrez?

Support Box in the Basement & Our Causes