Send us Fan Mail

A five-run hole, a swaggering ace on the mound, and a clubhouse tired of almost. We sit down with Michael McHenry to relive April 14, 2013—an afternoon that turned a would-be stumble into a sweep and revealed how the Pirates’ identity had finally hardened into something playoff strong. McHenry takes us inside the arc from 2011–2012 foundation-building to a 2013 culture defined by shared leadership, sharper preparation, and a bullpen that made the last nine outs feel inevitable.

You’ll hear how Russell Martin’s arrival shifted everything without swallowing the room. From AJ Burnett’s grip on the rotation to Jason Grilli’s Shark Tank swagger, and Clint Barmes’ infield calm, the team moved from good vibes to clear standards. McHenry also opens up about embracing a reduced role behind Martin: what it took to stay razor-ready after four or five days off, and how trust grew when a veteran star asked questions first. That mindset met the moment against Matt Latos, who’d owned McHenry for years—until a 2-0 heater met a ready barrel for a center-field jolt.

The comeback tightened again versus Jonathan Broxton, a towering slider machine. McHenry breaks down picking up spin, getting the ball in the air, and watching the left fielder nearly topple into the seats as the game turned. From there, the formula that defined the 2013 Pirates took hold: get to the bullpen, turn to Mark Melancon, hand the ninth to Jason Grilli, and close the book. We trace the line from that April sweep to late July, when the roster kept winning even on off nights and belief became habit.

If you love baseball strategy, clubhouse chemistry, and the way a single game can forecast a season, this one’s for you. Tap play, subscribe for more behind-the-plate stories, and leave a review with the comeback that made you a believer.

THANK YOU FOR LISTENING!!!!

www.holdmycutter.com