Old Scratch Pizza leads with 'Midwesternly Neapolitan' pizza

Pizza Marketplace Podcast

Pizza Marketplace Podcast
Old Scratch Pizza leads with 'Midwesternly Neapolitan' pizza
Oct 08, 2025
Networld Media Group

In this episode of the Pizza Marketplace Podcast, Mandy Detwiler, editor of Pizza Marketplace and QSRweb.com, talks to Eric Soller, founder of Old Scratch Pizza in Dayton, Ohio.

With a formal culinary background and years working with mixer giant Hobart, Soller said he was primed and ready to open his own restaurant.

"I love pizza," Soller said. "I was thinking about a lot of things, but I kept coming back to pizza. In my experience with Hobart and then later in sort of corporate world, I traveled quite a bit for work. And when I would go to a city, I would go to three or four pizza places in a night. I'm more of a student of the business.

"I'm more of a restaurateur than I am a pizza chef. I love pizza. I can make pizza. My team is much better at it now than I am. But I saw some concepts out in the world that I thought I could morph into what would be a really great opportunity would eventually turn into Old Scratch Pizza."

The brand uses wood-fired ovens, and Soller calls his pizza "Midwesternly Neapolitan." Soller opened in a mostly industrial area, which he drove past every day coming home from work.

"And I saw that it was a couple of blocks away from our big hospital," Soller said. "It was right around the corner from University of Dayton. It was the it's right on the edge of downtown. It was close enough to University of Dayton Stadium to be one of the closest places with a parking lot to UD Stadium. And I just saw that I saw the potential in it. And, you know, we were pretty busy from day one. We took off right off the bat."

To learn more about Old Scratch Pizza, listen to the podcast in its entirety.

Episode Artwork Old Scratch Pizza leads with 'Midwesternly Neapolitan' pizza 25:03 Episode Artwork How Papa Murphy's '$10 Tuesdays' promotion evolved 20:48 Episode Artwork How Saroki's Crispy Chicken & Pizza pairs great food, service with mega pavilions 21:15 Episode Artwork Bright Penny Brewing Co. pairs signature craft beer with pizza 22:25 Episode Artwork Blue Moon Pizza ready to take center stage 27:24 Episode Artwork &pizza CEO doubles down on franchising efforts, increasing growth 22:27 Episode Artwork Donatos Pizza president, CEO wants it to be the household name in pizza 20:09 Episode Artwork Pizza Factory CEO talks acquisition of company, future of brand 19:39 Episode Artwork Stoner's Pizza Joint CEO talks economy, that kitschy name 22:45 Episode Artwork Crust Pizza Co. CEO explains operations, building own tech 21:28 Episode Artwork Mountain Mike's Pizza CEO talks tight operations, growth 21:20 Episode Artwork Hunt brothers talk launching their brand Via 313, rise of Detroit-style pizza 22:45 Episode Artwork Little Caesars franchisee gone to the dogs 19:49 Episode Artwork TailGate Brewery owner talks perfect pizza, beer pairings 24:51 Episode Artwork Cicis Pizza leads buffet-style pizza concept with customer-focused tech 18:42 Episode Artwork Pizzaiolo launches signature brand in Dana Point, California 16:13 Episode Artwork Gen "Zee" - How one pizza franchise is gaining the attention of next-gen entrepreneurs 12:57 Episode Artwork PizzaForno founder talks food vending machine market in North America 13:03 Episode Artwork Chef-driven menu makes Willow Street Pizza stand out 18:53 Episode Artwork Maintaining a legacy brand paramount for Cicis Pizza president 23:41 Episode Artwork The art of pizza boxes: Guinness World Record holder a pizza box expert 18:35 Episode Artwork Buddy's Pizza on the rise of Detroit-style in the pizza industry 20:15 Episode Artwork Text marketing highly effective for pizzerias 25:15 Episode Artwork How to make, sell creative pizzas in modern industry 18:08 Episode Artwork Pizzaiolo shares tips to make dough stand out 19:19