Christy Monaco [00:00:11 - 00:00:57]
Win it, lose it, fight it all the way to federal court. Most people think a Social Security disability claim is a yes or no decision, but the truth is it's a journey with twists and setbacks and second chances. Today, we're going to break down what really decides whether your case gets approved, denied, or revived on appeal. Welcome back to Winning Isn't Easy: Social Security Disability Benefits, the podcast where we break down everything you need to know about navigating the Social Security system. I'm your host, Attorney Christy Monaco. Before I get started, I have to give you a legal disclaimer. This podcast is not legal advice. The Florida Bar Association says I have to say this, so I've said it.
Christy Monaco [00:00:58 - 00:02:15]
But nothing prevents me from giving you an easy-to-understand overview of the Social Security disability claims process, the games that are played during it, and what you need to know to get the disability benefits you deserve. So off we go. If you've ever applied for Social Security disability benefits or even thought about it, You've probably wondered what actually makes a case succeed or fail. Is it your medical condition, your doctor, the judge, or something else entirely? In this episode, we're walking you through the Social Security disability claims possibilities. First, we're going to break down what it takes to win, then the 6 critical elements that can make or break your case from the, from the beginning. Then we're going to talk about what happens when you lose and how attorneys analyze decisions to spot legal errors and decide whether an appeal is even worth the fight. Finally, we'll take it one step forward into federal court where the rules change, the stakes get higher, and a judge can reverse or remand a denial based on key legal missteps. Whether you're filing your first claim, facing a denial, or deep in the appeals process, This episode is going to give you a clear roadmap of what to expect and what matters most at each stage.
Christy Monaco [00:02:15 - 00:02:52]
So again, we're going to talk about 3 things today. 1, what are the 6 things that make a winning Social Security Disability case? 2, so you've lost your Social Security Disability case and are appealing. How do the Appeals Council and/or federal district courts decide to reverse a decision denying a Social Security claim? And 3, what are the big issues for a federal judge in a Social Security disability claim that can result in a reversal or a remand of your denied claim? We'll take a break for a moment before we really dive into this episode.
Speaker B [00:02:54 - 00:03:20]
Are you considering filing for Social Security disability, or has your claim been denied already? Either way, you require a copy of Your Rights to Social Security Disability Benefits, which will cover everything you need to know about the Social Security disability Welcome back to Winning Isn't Easy.
Christy Monaco [00:03:21 - 00:04:16]
Let's talk about what the 6 things that can make a winning Social Security disability case. The Social Security Administration uses a 5-step sequential evaluation test to determine a person's entitlement to Social Security benefits. They ask at every stage the following questions. First, they're going to figure out whether or not you've been working over substantial gainful activity. In 2026, that number is $1,690. Second, they're going to ask, do you have a medically determinable impairment? That means they want to know if you have a condition that has lasted or is expected to last at least 12 months. Third, they're going to ask, do you meet a medical listing? Now, Social Security has a Blue Book of impairments that lists the criteria of you meeting a listing, and not many people meet it. However, a no here is not an automatic denial.
Christy Monaco [00:04:17 - 00:05:27]
You simply go to step 4. Step 4, they're asking, can you return to the lightest job you've held in the 5 years before your case is decided? And finally, they're going to ask if you can do other work in the mythical, hypothetical, not real-world national economy in view of your age, education, transferable skills and restrictions and limitations, or alternatively, if you're over 50, whether you meet the Grid tests. Now that you know the 5-step sequential evaluation, let's talk about the 6 things that can make or break your Social Security disability claim. First, most important, your medical records. They should tell a story of your symptoms and functionality and about how your symptoms impact your ability to not only do work But to do activities around the house. 2, your work history form. Now, that blasted form, although a pain to fill out, it is going to explain the physical, cognitive, and psychological duties that each of the jobs you've done in the last 5 years required you to do. You should pay particular attention to those activities that you have difficulty doing now or can no longer perform as you fill out that work history form.
Christy Monaco [00:05:28 - 00:06:36]
3, your adult function report. This is going to ask you many questions about your physical, cognitive, and psychological functioning. Accuracy and consistency with your medical records here is key. 4th, the Social Security Administration is going to ask for names of third parties who can give Social Security information about your function despite your problems. It's key that both the adult function report and the third-party function reports are consistent and have no exaggerations. 5, your physician should complete a residual functional capacity form based on your applicable disabling condition so that it's documented objectively and that you can explain very clearly to Social Security what your restrictions and limitations are due to your symptoms. And 6, if you are going before a judge, your testimony can make or break your claim. It is crucial that you explain the location, duration, intensity, and frequency of your symptoms with examples so that the judge can understand the impact of your disabling conditions on your ability to do both your past work and other work.
Christy Monaco [00:06:37 - 00:07:51]
Once again, credibility and consistency here are key. Let's take a quick break. Welcome back to Winning Isn't Easy. So you've lost your Social Security Disability case and you're appealing. How do the Appeals Council and/or a federal district court decide to reverse a decision denying your claim? Okay, so if an administrative law judge has ruled against you, you have some big decisions to make. You have to decide whether you want to give up Start a new application giving up all of your back benefits you claim, or file an appeal with the Appeals Council. Whether your lawyer recommends that you file an appeal with the Appeals Council or even take an unfavorable Appeals Council decision to the federal district court is based on their analysis of whether legal error was made denying your benefits. So let's talk a little bit about how a Social Security disability lawyer analyzes a Unfavorable Social Security judge's decision.
Christy Monaco [00:07:51 - 00:09:11]
Now, no one likes to lose a Social Security disability claim, as we've put in a tremendous amount of time and energy throughout the years into representing our clients, from meeting with them, developing their files, preparing them for trial, preparing a memorandum of law for the judge, potentially contacting their physicians, and being there with our clients during the hearing. So after the anger has passed, the Social Security attorney will get down to doing what Social Security attorneys do. First, they should read the administrative law judge's decision not once but several times. As they do, take notes and highlight things that are the basis of legal errors. Just reading the decision should give your attorney enough information to decide whether it's an appealable case. A legal error can include such things as ignoring the Social Security regulations, common Social Security Um, call it case law, giving improper weight to treating physicians, failure to explain why they're rejecting those opinions, misclassifying your past relevant work, hypotheticals not supported by medical evidence, or improper vocational testimony. Your lawyer is then going to determine whether any new evidence can be submitted. But I want you to understand that only new evidence can be submitted if it's new, material, and timely.
Christy Monaco [00:09:12 - 00:10:11]
Or if there's good cause. And then the attorney is going to write a brief which will be submitted to the Appeals Council that is short and detailed, but we want to make sure it has all of the relevant legal arguments in it. Now, what does the Appeals Council do with an appeal from an unfavorable law judge decision? Well, they can do one of 3 things. One, they can uphold the denial, in which your lawyer is then going to decide if there is an appropriateness for an appeal to a federal district court. 2, they can remand the case back to the administrative law judge telling them what their mistakes were, and then your next hearing with that judge is going to focus specific on those legal errors. Or 3, reverse the denial and just issue a fully favorable decision. Now, number 3 is rare, but it does happen. Unfortunately, you cannot file concurrently an appeal to the Appeals Council and a new application.
Christy Monaco [00:10:13 - 00:10:56]
Now that can be an additional financial hardship because the process can take up to a year to get a decision from the Appeals Council. Ouch. So we want to make sure that you understand the basis of your denial, your attorney's theory of the appeal, and really understand the delay and your options moving forward. When considering your options for, let's say, filing an appeal with the Appeals Council, or starting a new application and just giving up that back pay, we really want to know, has your date last insured expired? That is going to be a big factor in deciding whether or not appealing to the Appeals Council is the right issue or starting over is the right issue. So we always want to keep that in mind. Let's take a quick break.
Speaker B [00:10:59 - 00:11:26]
Struggling with your Social Security Disability case? The right attorney can make all the difference. Get our booklet, The Key to Hiring a Great Attorney for Your Social Security Disability Case. Discover how to find an experienced attorney who will fight for your rights and navigate the process with ease. Don't leave your future to chance. Request your free copy at kvlaw.com today and ensure you have the expert support you deserve.
Christy Monaco [00:11:30 - 00:12:13]
Welcome back to Winning Isn't Easy. Let's talk about the big issues for a federal judge in a reversal or a remand of your denied Social Security claim. Now, losing your Social Security disability benefits in front of a judge and then losing again in front of an appeals counsel can be incredibly frustrating. Believe me, we know. However, we as your attorney may suggest that you take a third swing by filing an appeal of the unfavorable administrative law decision into federal district court. So what the big issues are for a federal judge in appeals from an appeals counsel. Before we start talking about these big issues, let me explain the process. One of two things needs to happen.
Christy Monaco [00:12:14 - 00:13:32]
Your lawyer must be licensed in the federal district court in that state that they're going to file in, or they can find local counsel, and then once the complaint is filed, they can file something called a pro hac vice motion, which allows them to practice in that court. Now, I do have some good news. When you are at the federal level, you can file a new application for benefits claiming your date of disability as of the day after your unfavorable administrative law judge's decision. Now, if your appeal is successful with the federal court, then your benefits should be awarded. Based on your original alleged onset date, and the concurrent claim that you had filed would kind of just disappear. If the attorney is successful at the federal district level, they can actually seek additional payment of a fee known as an EAJA fee, an Equal Access to Justice fee, which is actually paid at the expense of the federal government. So let's get down to the nitty-gritty. What are the issues that can result in a reversal, a remand, or an award of benefits? First, a failure to follow the law and the regulations.
Christy Monaco [00:13:33 - 00:14:41]
This is a big one. We're going to be looking at all of the Social Security regulations or SSRs and try to decide, did the judge ignore any or simply flat out not use any at all? Mischaracterization of the evidence by the ALJ. How they interpreted doctors' opinions versus state agency opinions, inconsistencies in the judge's decision or inconsistencies between conflicting medical evidence, cherry-picking the medical evidence, failing to properly evaluate opinions from non-acceptable medical sources, failing to address supportability and consistency of medical opinions, failing to consider side effects of medication. Failing to consider the use of a cane or an assistive walking device. Failing to order a consultative examination to develop the medical records. Substituting their lay opinion in lieu of a professional medical opinion by playing doctor. Failing to address the impact of poverty or failure to provide or failure to follow prescribed treatment regimen. Improper assessment of your credibility.
Christy Monaco [00:14:42 - 00:16:08]
Improper determination of medically determinable impairments. Failed to properly evaluate Listings, failed to properly consider time off and absenteeism, failed to consider waxing and waning medical conditions, failing to consider reaching limitations such as bilateral reaching limitations or inability to use your bilateral hands or fingers, improper basis for the hypothetical given to the vocational evaluator, improper assessment of third-party function reports and your functional restrictions and limitations. Improper and unsupported vocational testimony. I could go on and on and on. Any one of these or a combination of these can result in a reversal or a remand or even an outright award by the federal government. So what happens after my lawyer prepares a brief in federal court for the judge to review? Well, the federal court is going to consider the entire record, and generally no new evidence can be added unless it's new material and there's good cause for adding it. Your lawyer is going to prepare a legal brief which will be between 15 and 20 pages long depending on the court's rules, and they're going to set forth all of the legal arguments that have resulted in the unfavorable decision. The brief is going to have a table of contents with an introduction, a statement of elements, and undisputed material facts summary, and of course, a summary of the administrative proceedings.
Christy Monaco [00:16:08 - 00:16:54]
A statement of the relevant facts, issues presented, and the explanation of the statutory and regulatory framework, and an argument as to why the administrative law judge's decision is just wrong. Your attorney is also going to file a motion to reverse the decision. But guess what? The Social Security Administration, through their federal attorney, will write a reply brief and oppose your motion to reverse the decision. The federal judge will then take all of these what are called pleadings and decide your case. Now, unfortunately, it can take as long as a year to get a decision from the federal court. But remember, during this time, your new Social Security Disability application is being considered by the Social Security Administration. So right now, both are on track. Well, that's our time today, folks.
Christy Monaco [00:16:54 - 00:17:23]
Thank you so much for joining me. If you found this episode helpful, please take a moment to like our page, leave a review, and share it with your friends and family. Don't forget to subscribe to the podcast so you'll be notified whenever a new episode drops. We'd also really love to hear from you. At the beginning of each episode description, you'll find a link where you can send us questions or comments, and we may even feature them in a future episode. Join us next week for another insightful discussion, and thank you so much for listening.