Polyphonic Press: Classic Album Reviews

Either/Or by Elliott Smith - Ep. 80

Jeremy Boyd & Jon VanDyk Episode 80

Either/Or is Elliott Smith's third studio album, released on February 25, 1997. Widely considered a seminal work in his discography, it bridges the intimate lo-fi charm of his earlier albums with the more polished, orchestral sound of his later works. The album's title references Søren Kierkegaard’s philosophical text of the same name, reflecting themes of existential struggle and duality.

Musically, Either/Or combines Smith’s fingerpicked acoustic guitar, whispery vocals, and understated melodies with occasional flourishes of electric guitar, layered instrumentation, and subtle percussion. The production maintains a raw, home-recorded feel, which complements the album's introspective tone.

Lyrically, the record delves into themes of alienation, addiction, love, and self-doubt, encapsulating the melancholy and poetic lyricism for which Smith is known. Tracks like “Between the Bars,” “Angeles,” and “Say Yes” are among its most celebrated, showcasing his ability to craft emotionally resonant and hauntingly beautiful songs.

Either/Or earned critical acclaim upon its release and has since been hailed as a masterpiece of 1990s indie rock. Its enduring influence is evident in its role in shaping the sound of lo-fi and singer-songwriter music in the decades following its release.

Listen to the album on Spotify
Listen to the album on Apple Music

What did you think of this album? Send us a text!

Support the show

Patreon
Website
Polyphonic Press Discord Server
Follow us on Instagram
Contact: polyphonicpressmusic@gmail.com

DISCLAIMER: Due to copyright restrictions, we are unable to play pieces of the songs we cover in these episodes. Playing clips of songs are unfortunately prohibitively expensive to obtain the proper licensing. We strongly encourage you to listen to the album along with us on your preferred format to enhance the listening experience.


People on this episode

Podcasts we love

Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.

State of Amorica: A Black Crowes Podcast Artwork

State of Amorica: A Black Crowes Podcast

State of Amorica: A Black Crowes Podcast
1001 Album Complaints Artwork

1001 Album Complaints

The Chop Unlimited
Sloancast Artwork

Sloancast

Rob Butcher and Ken Gildner