Challenge Your Mind, Change The World

For Parents: Harnessing the Power of Critical Thinking in Modern Family Decision-Making

• The Classic Literature Teacher

Share episode

Send us a text

The Essay Clinic - learn more here

Unlock the full potential of your mind and the minds of the teenagers in your life with the art of critical thinking, a skill that transcends textbooks and test scores. I'm Francesca Hudson, and this week on Challenge your Mind Change the World, we delve into real-life scenarios to showcase how a sharpened analytical edge can protect, empower, and transform. From Lucy's quick thinking that dodged an online scam to Mark's compelling arguments in a class debate, we unravel the threads of critical thinking that weave through the fabric of our daily decisions and interactions. By fostering an environment of curiosity and open-mindedness, we can better navigate the complexities of modern life and cultivate a generation of well-informed, responsible citizens.

As we navigate the bustling intersection of media, relationships, and consumerism, the beacon of critical thinking guides us toward clarity and away from the fog of misinformation. We'll explore why it's essential to peer behind the curtain of celebrity endorsements and flashy advertising, questioning the true value of products like the latest smartphones. Communication breakdowns, like the text message tangle between Alex and Jordan, serve as a cautionary tale about the pitfalls of assumptions and the power of perspective. Join me as we champion the transformative effect of blending healthy skepticism with an open mind—keys to unlocking deeper understanding, respect, and productivity in all walks of life.

**Brand New Course for Students on How To Write a Basic Literary Essay**
If your child is struggling in class with understanding how to write a literary essay - for their exams or other assignments where they can't use any other technology except for their good ol' brain, I have just launched my brand new digital course, The Essay Clinic. I'm offering super special launch pricing (but hurry as it won't be priced this good for long!) Come and take advantage of my 20+ years of teaching and education and give your child the extra boost they might need with their essay writing. I've got you with a full 3 module digital course! See you over at The Essay Clinic! (Oh, and it's open all hours too, as I know how busy every fa

If you enjoyed today's episode, please take the time to rate our podcast. Your rating means the world to us and it allows us to continue to share and grow our message of support to other fabulous humans out there!

Confidence to Lead Academy is coming soon! This is THE subscription your teen needs to be on if they are shy, full of potential yet lack the confidence to explore it, or dream of having a life where they can learn how to step up and be heard, but just need that little extra nudge to do so. The Confidence to Lead Academy is all about giving your teen a voice that helps them speak up in class, push themselves out of their comfort zone and begin to develop real leadership skills that will help them long after school finishes. The waitlist has opened - learn more here!


Follow us on:
Instagram
Facebook
Or visit our website: www.classicliteratureteacher.com

Speaker 1:

Hello, hello, all my wonderful listeners out there, welcome back to another episode of Challenge your Mind Change the World. We are running a special five-part episode series on AI and how it can potentially impact our wonderful teenagers' learning abilities, how it can affect their academic success, how it can affect their mental well-being and how it can affect their life beyond the classroom. So we are diving deep into how AI and critical thinking because, remember, critical thinking is the backbone of everything that we do here at the Classic Literature Teacher and we are looking at how both AI and critical thinking in this series are transforming students' lives. I'm your host, francesca Hudson, and I'm thrilled to have you join us for another enlightening discussion. So let's have a quick look at what we've already discussed. In the first three episodes, we started with looking at what critical thinking was in the AI-driven world in our new digital age, what critical thinking was in the AI-driven world in our new digital age, and then we looked at how, in episode two, how we can help our teens balance AI, software and technologies in education. And in the last episode it was a big one we looked at how do we raise questioners, how do we raise our teenagers to question and to look at things critically in AI contexts, so it's about guiding them through the AI maze.

Speaker 1:

While we have seen how AI can be a powerful tool in education, today we're shifting gears slightly. We'll explore how the critical thinking skills honed in the classroom are not just academic exercises, but they're actually essential tools for navigating the complexities of everyday life and about developing kindness in our teenagers and our young people. Today, we're going to be looking at how they can be making informed decisions through to interacting socially and understanding the media around us. Remember, critical thinking is a skill that transcends school boundaries and it enters every part of our daily existence. We do it without even thinking most of the time, and you can imagine if we get it wrong. Our children are learning all the time and they are learning from us. We model our behavior on them. So critical thinking is a super important skill, especially in this digital age. In today's episode, we'll go beyond the classroom to see how critical thinking applies to real world scenarios, and that's what our teens love, isn't it? It's always about making things relevant and how does it actually apply to them in real world settings. So we'll share stories and insights on how to use these skills, these critical thinking skills in daily decision making, in social interactions and even in critically evaluating the media we consume every day is a hot topic, that one.

Speaker 1:

Our goal is to show you that these skills are not just for academic success, but they are vital in becoming a well-informed and engaged citizen. Isn't that what we want for our children? Absolutely. So let's jump in, and I want to start with an engagement question. So I want you to think about a recent decision you made or a news article that you've read recently. Did you stop to ask questions about the reliability of the information or consider multiple perspectives? Maybe Keep that in mind as you dive into today's discussions. My friends, have a think.

Speaker 1:

Let's begin by defining what we mean by critical thinking. Simply put, it's the ability to analyze facts to form a judgment. It's not just about being critical in a negative sense. It's not about criticizing somebody at all. It's about being curious, it's about questioning and it's about being analytical. So when we talk about teaching our children and our young people critical thinking skills, it's not about teaching them how to be critical of people. It's about getting them to, or it's about teaching them to, look at the world through a fresh perspective. It's about opening their mind really to foster open-mindedness. The word critical is not a negative word at all in this context.

Speaker 1:

There's a few key components to critical thinking and we've touched on this in episode one right back at the start. But just to recap, we've got analysis, evaluation and inference to give a fuller picture of what critical thinking entails. In other words, critical thinking involves several components Firstly, analyzing information to understand its true nature. Secondly, it's evaluating the information to see how valid or how useful it is. And then, finally, it's about drawing conclusions and making informed judgments based on that evaluation. So there's three parts to it. Really, we use it in everyday decision making, whether we know it or not, subconsciously or consciously.

Speaker 1:

Consider a simple everyday decision like buying a smartphone. A critical thinker doesn't just go for the most popular brand or the latest model. Instead, they might analyze different models based on features or price or user reviews, and even the manufacturer's reputation, before making an informed decision. And how many people out there do we know are you nodding right now? We know somebody that is like this in our household. That will sit there on the laptop and they will study every single model. They will weigh up the pros and cons of each. They'll look at all different aspects of what it is they want to buy. They'll read the reviews. They will look at the price. They'll see where they can get it cheaper or where it's got it more expensive, or what the delivery times are. You name it. We have all got people on our lives In fact, we might even be people like that that we know of that are looking at products that we buy with a critical thinking hat on, and we don't even know it. So that is critical thinking.

Speaker 1:

Now think about social interactions. In social interactions, critical thinking can help you understand the perspectives of others better. For instance, when a friend expresses an opinion that differs from yours, for example, instead of dismissing it, you might critically evaluate their points, you might ask insightful questions and you might consider why they might think that way. This not only broadens your perspective, but it also strengthens your relationships. And when was the last time you did that?

Speaker 1:

If you were talking to somebody, you were talking to a friend. They had an opinion. Did you jump right in and did you say, no, I disagree. Or did you get what they were saying? And sort of? You know, maybe nod your head a little bit and ask a few more questions, to probe a little bit more deeper, to see where they're coming from and where they're getting their information from, because it's the consideration of other people's opinions which is the starting point of critical thinking, rather than just shutting somebody down and dismissing what they're saying and not even willing to understand a little better the point of which they're coming from. It's so easy just to dismiss it and to shut them down immediately. But to be able to understand why they have come to their opinion and why they have embraced it as their own, that's the part which is fascinating and that is the part, as a friend, you want to honour and acknowledge that they have an opinion. So I think with critical thinking, it's the ability to be able to ask more questions. If there's something that you might not necessarily agree with, ask more questions. That's where it starts from. In last episode, we talked about how to raise our teens to become questioners in life, and this is a great place, as adults, that we can start with our own friendships and our own relationships.

Speaker 1:

The third place that we use critical thinking without even realizing is in our media consumption. Okay, when it comes to media consumption, whether it's news or blogs or social media posts. Critical thinking is crucial. It enables you to distinguish between facts and opinions, it allows you to identify bias and it also assesses the credibility of sources. So, for example, when you come across a sensational news headline, critical thinking might kick in and it might prompt you to check other sources before accepting the story is true. Or you might look at other sources of information. If you're on social media, for example Facebook or Instagram, the algorithm is going to be bringing up more articles of the same type of content, so a critical thinker will look at that and go. Maybe I need to go to another source of information, not just on social media. Maybe I need to go and look at other types of newspaper websites or the radio or whatever it is, so that you can see if you can begin to get a fuller picture of this opinion rather than always just being slanted in one particular way.

Speaker 1:

It is really hard in this day and age to be able to have a non-biased news story because obviously the media empires always have their own sort of agendas, if you like, behind the news that they are producing. Whether it's a financial agenda or a political agenda, or a social agenda there's all sorts of agendas, obviously that publications can have. So we just have to be mindful of that and we have to be conscious of that. Whether or not we agree with what they produce, it's up to you, depending on where your perspective is on things. But always have that in the back of your mind that there is always more than one opinion, and sometimes the information that you surround yourself always look for the bias, or could there be a potential bias.

Speaker 1:

As we see, critical thinking is not just an academic exercise. It's a valuable life skill that plays a vital role in how we make decisions, how we interact with others and how we consume information, and it empowers us to navigate the world more effectively, making us more informed citizens and thoughtful individuals. So you can see that we are using critical thinking without even realizing it. Most of the time it can be a very subconscious skill, but our teens are still growing and they are still developing these skills, and so it's really important that we really embrace critical thinking and we show them, we model it in front of them. If we can see something that we are doing using a critical thinking skill, then we can shout it out. We can call it out and say to our teens hey look, do you see how I did that? We were at the supermarket and we were looking at different types of pasta and we were weighing up which one was on special and which one was the better tasting and which had the highest salt content. That's critical thinking. That's evaluating the products in front of us and making an informed decision. Every day we're faced with numerous decisions, from what to buy to whom to trust, and these choices might seem minor, but the way we make these decisions can have big impacts on our lives.

Speaker 1:

Let me give you a little scenario for this Choosing a mobile phone. So imagine you're in the market for a new mobile phone. You see an ad for the latest smartphone model in a flashy commercial somewhere, with your favorite celebrity endorsing it. It's tempting to go straight to the store to buy it right, and a few of us probably would. But let's apply some critical thinking here.

Speaker 1:

So firstly, ask yourself why is this celebrity endorsing this phone? Are they really using it themselves? What might they be getting paid for this endorsement? Adverts are designed to sell by creating appeal, but not necessarily to inform. And my children, especially at the moment, are going through this with seeing celebrities endorsing products and then immediately wanting them and this is the part that we are going through as parents at the moment is trying to allow our children to pause and to look at the products and to look at the celebrity that's endorsing them, and to sort of look at more of the motivations behind what's going on with the adverts. So you've asked yourself these questions about why is a celebrity endorsing this phone? And then look beyond the adverts to user reviews and performance metrics, for example. So maybe sort of think, okay, well, it's all great, they've got this beautiful showy advert, they've spent a lot of money on publicity and they've got this amazing celebrity promoting it.

Speaker 1:

But what's the reviews behind it and how well is this product performing? So, instead of taking the ad at face value, look up reviews from actual users who have purchased the phone. What are they saying about its performance, its battery life, camera quality, their common complaints? And we all do this, or most of us are doing this anyway, but this is a good way to call it out to our teens and young people and to teach them about how to use critical thinking. So then, once you've looked at the reviews, then check out the professional reviews from tech websites or comparison videos on YouTube. These sources often provide more detailed and objective evaluations of the phone's capabilities compared to its competitors. And then, once you've done that so it doesn't just stop there, but then you can look at questioning the sources of the reviews.

Speaker 1:

In our scenario, questioning the source means understanding that advertisements are biased towards positive aspects. Reviews and professional analysis offer a more rounded perspective. And then look for the evidence. In the reviews, both user and professional. Do they provide actual data on performance, like benchmark tests or camera samples? So this evidence can help make you a more informed decision. I feel like I've just taught a lesson in class here with how to evaluate a mobile phone. But you can see how, rather than rushing straight out to the shop to buy a mobile phone, by looking at the product and asking these questions with our young people. It's allowing them to stop and realize that there might be some sort of almost bias towards trying to get them to buy the product because of all the fancy celebrity endorsements and the really cool music or graphics the adverts used. And it's about getting them to look beyond that. So questioning the ad, researching the reviews, comparing the sources, questioning the sources and looking for the evidence. Therefore, by applying critical thinking, you're moving beyond the superficial factors and you're making decisions based on thorough analysis and real evidence. And this approach doesn't just apply to buying phones, obviously. It's a way to navigate all sorts of choices more effectively.

Speaker 1:

Looking at critical thinking and social interactions, they are often more complex than they appear, and we talked about this in the intro, about having a friend that might have an opinion that you automatically just want to shut down. But whether we're discussing opinions, resolving conflicts or simply chatting with our friends, critical thinking can significantly enhance our understanding and our communication. We can be better communicators, we can be better friends, we can be better partners. It helps us to navigate the subtleties of human relationships by encouraging us to consider multiple perspectives and question our assumptions. So when we engage with others, especially in discussions or debates, it's easy to become entrenched in our own views right, but critical thinking pushes us to step back and consider the other person's perspective, not just change our mind necessarily, especially if we're very entrenched in our own beliefs, but it's to understand where they're coming from. We don't need to feel threatened, we don't need to feel like if we consider their opinions and suddenly our own will become shaky. It's about understanding where they're coming from, and this understanding can lead to more respectful and productive interactions.

Speaker 1:

So let me give you a little scenario. Imagine two friends, alex and Jordan. Jordan sends Alex a text saying we need to talk. So Alex reads the message late at night and then spends a sleepless night worrying about the serious tone. And I would be the same. So this is where texts can be misconstrued and read in so many different ways and, funnily enough, my husband and I nearly didn't go out on our very first date because of a text message that went back and forth and I took it one way and he took it the other. I thought we were going out for dinner, just the two of us, and he mistook my reply to say, oh, it must be a group of us going out. And so he then went off with his friends. And anyway, it's a very long story, I won't bore you with it, but it's an example of how texts can be taken in so many different ways, and I guarantee you will have your own funny stories of how text messages have been totally misconstrued.

Speaker 1:

So anyway, back to the text message between Alex and Jordan. So Jordan sends Alex a text saying we need to talk. Alex has a really sleepless night. Now Alex's perspective is he might assume that quote we need to talk implies something negative or serious, possibly, about their friendship, based on the vague yet ominous nature of the text. But Jordan's intent, so Jordan's the one that sent the text. Jordan's intent was simply to discuss plans for the upcoming weekend, not realizing how the message came across. So Jordan, I think, needs to put a little emoji or something in his text next time. But anyway, when they finally got talking the next day, they discussed how the message could have been phrased better and agree on more clear and direct communication in the future, especially when texting about what matters.

Speaker 1:

So in this case, it all ended well. Sleman texting about what matters. So in this case it all ended well. Nothing serious happened. There was nothing serious about the text, but the tone of the text opened up doubt in poor old Alex's mind.

Speaker 1:

So the lessons that we've learned from the text story? It illustrates how critical thinking can prevent small misunderstandings from escalating into significant conflicts. Why? Because by questioning their initial assumptions and communicating openly, alex and Jordan not only resolved the misunderstanding, but they also strengthened their friendship through better communication practices. They talked about it, they didn't just bury it under the carpet and ignore it, and then both went off on their separate ways, and then Alex let it build up and build up and build up. They talked about it.

Speaker 1:

So communication that's how critical thinking can help in social interactions. Communication is a great way. As we can see from Alex and Jordan's experience, critical thinking and social interactions helps us navigate misunderstandings and deepen our relationships, and it encourages us to remain open and inquisitive about others' thoughts and feelings, and that, in turn, leads to more meaningful and comfort-free interactions. How do we do that, then, with the media? How do we look at the media with a critical eye? Well, in today's digital age, we are constantly bombarded with information, right From social media, from news outlets, from other online platforms, and these sources have a profound impact on shaping our opinions and our beliefs Huge, huge, huge, huge impact. However, not all information is created equal, as we know, and this is where critical thinking becomes crucial. I'm going to teach you how to do it, how to use your critical thinking skills with the media.

Speaker 1:

So media, both social and traditional, often serve not just to inform, but to persuade and to influence. Whether it's through the headlines we read or the posts we scroll past on our feeds. The media can shape our understanding of the world. Recognizing this influence is the first step in thinking critically about the content we might consume. So to identify bias in the media, look at the language used in the article or the post. Is it emotive meaning? Does it create emotion in you? Does it favour one side disproportionately? Also, consider the source who owns the media outlet and what might be their political or commercial interests? Understanding these elements can help you gauge the objectivity of the information presented right. And then you also need to evaluate the source.

Speaker 1:

So assessing the credibility involves checking the reputation of the source. Are they known for rigorous journalism or are they known for sensationalism? Do they cite their sources and can those sources be verified? Reliable media organizations uphold standards of accuracy and accountability, so these can often be safer bets for credible information. They're not the light-hearted social media feeds, but you know that you're getting a more balanced perspective when you read these sources.

Speaker 1:

So to give you an example in real life, imagine a teenager named Sam who sees a viral story on social media claiming that a celebrity has made an outrageous statement. This story is everywhere and it's stirring up a lot of reactions. How do you think Sam would use critical thinking in this scenario. This is how they do it. Instead of accepting the story at face value or sharing it immediately, sam starts by checking multiple reliable news sites to see if any of them have reported on it. Finding no such reports, sam visits the celebrity's official social media pages and discovers a post clarifying that the statement was taken out of context and misreported. Okay, that is key. Sam has gone beyond the headline to actually see if it's true or not.

Speaker 1:

By taking the time to research and question the initial story, sam avoids spreading misinformation and learns an important lesson about the spread of false news. This critical approach does not only keep Sam informed, but also prevents the spread of false information amongst their peers, and I am so keen on this at home with our two boys. We've got two boys and it's very easy for them just to take a piece of news and accept it as fact. And I'm always saying to them where did you get this information from? How do you know? It's true, just asking those questions, digging a little bit deeper, because there's nothing worse than Chinese whispers picking up one piece of information and just passing it on without even thinking. And it's not even true. We have to be so careful of that. This shows how vital it is to approach media with a critical eye. By learning to identify bias, assessing source credibility and verifying information, we can empower ourselves and our young people to make informed decisions and not be swayed by misinformation. While it's valuable to understand theories and techniques of critical thinking, seeing these skills in action can be even more enlightening, like we've seen with the text message chat between Alex and Jordan and the fake news from Sam.

Speaker 1:

So let's look really quickly at a few more examples of how critical thinking has been used and have saved people from a lot of hassle in the real world. We've got the consumer who avoided a scam, lucy. Imagine a scenario where Lucy, who is a regular online shopper, receives an incredibly tempting offer via email from a brand new online store. The offer promises high quality products at a fraction of the usual price Wow, awesome. But instead of immediately clicking the purchase button, what do you think Lucy did? She decides to research the company. She looks for customer reviews, she checks the company's content information and her search reveals several red flags. The website has no physical address, for example, and she finds multiple complaints about non-delivery of products on various consumer forums. So what do you think the outcome is? Well, thanks to her diligence and critical thinking, lucy avoids falling for a scam and she's saving not only her money but also her personal information. Another example is the student who challenged a popular opinion information. Another example is the student who challenged a popular opinion.

Speaker 1:

Consider Mark, a high school student. In a debate class, the topic of discussion is a popular yet very controversial environmental policy. Most of his classmates support the policy, echoing popular sentiments that they've heard in the media. Mark decides to delve deeper into the topic, spending hours researching academic articles, data from environmental organizations and government reports. Wow, this student is thorough. His research uncovers that while the policy is popular no doubt about that its actual environmental benefits are questionable and the economic drawbacks are significant. So during the debate, mark presents his well-researched findings, challenging the popular opinion with facts and data. He cites his sources, explains the methodology behind the data and then respectfully addresses the counter-arguments. Mark's thorough research and respectful presentation prompt his classmates to reconsider their positions. They can see how much evidence Mark has found, and this not only enriches the class discussion, because they haven't all blindly just agreed with each other because that's what the media has been saying, but it also demonstrates the importance of researching and questioning before forming opinions. So these stories from Lucy and Mark show how critical thinking can be a powerful tool in our personal and academic lives. By questioning, researching and evaluating information critically, they were able to make informed decisions and influence others positively. Their experiences underline the practical impact of critical thinking in everyday situations.

Speaker 1:

So I want to finally end on one final note, and that is the importance of skepticism and open-mindedness, a topic very close to my heart. As we cultivate our critical thinking skills, two key attitudes we must develop are skepticism and open-mindedness. While these might seem contradictory at first glance, they actually complement each other really well in helping us think critically and make well-informed decisions. How do they do that? Well, let's look at skepticism to start with. Skepticism is often misunderstood. It isn't about doubting everything or being cynical. Rather, it's about being thorough in our evaluation of information. A skeptic asks questions, they seek evidence, and is not easily satisfied by superficial explanations. This doesn't mean rejecting information outright, but rather suspending judgment until sufficient proof is presented. Now looking at the role of open-mindedness, on the other hand, is the willingness to consider new ideas and perspectives, even those that challenge our existing beliefs. It involves being receptive to different viewpoints and not letting our bias cloud our judgment. This doesn't imply that we accept every new idea uncritically, but rather we give them a fair hearing. So can you see how these two concepts, skepticism and open-mindedness, begin to come together.

Speaker 1:

Balancing skepticism and open-mindedness is key to effective critical thinking. Too much skepticism can turn into cynicism, which shuts down productive discussion. On the flip side, too much openness without skepticism can lead to gullibility. Too much openness without skepticism can lead to gullibility. The goal is to be open to consider new ideas, but skeptical enough to demand good reasons before accepting them. In practice, this might look like listening attentively to someone's argument while also asking thoughtful questions to probe deeper.

Speaker 1:

Coming back to our friendship chat we had at the start of the podcast, even though you might feel that your friend has informed ideas or opinions based on very shallow information, it's about listening to them while also asking thoughtful questions. Or when reading the news. It might mean being open to the perspectives presented, but also cross-checking facts with other reliable sources. Is presented, but also cross-checking facts with other reliable sources. By embracing both scepticism and open-mindedness, it enriches our understanding and it enhances our ability to engage constructively in debates and discussions. These qualities ensure that our judgments are well-founded and that we remain intellectually flexible, able to adapt our views when presented with compelling evidence. Today, we've explored how critical thinking extends far beyond the classroom walls, influencing decisions in our everyday lives, shaping our social interactions and guiding us through the complex media landscape. We discussed how being skeptical helps us avoid scams and make informed decisions, and how open-mindedness allows us to understand and respect different viewpoints. These stories and discussions highlight that critical thinking is an essential skill for navigating the modern world and one that we can really model to our young people.

Speaker 1:

I encourage each of you to take a challenge this week. Apply critical thinking in the new area of your life. Perhaps question a long-held belief, analyze a decision at your job or school, or critically assess a news article before sharing it. See how these skills can change the outcome and deepen your own understanding. Thank you all for tuning in today. I hope you're finding these discussions enlightening and applicable in your daily lives and also helping with your young people and teenagers. I'd love to hear about your experiences with the challenge or any thoughts on today's episode. So please reach out through our social media channels or you can email us directly. And also a reminder don't forget to subscribe for more insights and join us next time as we continue to explore the powerful combination of critical thinking and AI. Until then, keep thinking critically and questioning deeply. Have a great week everyone.

People on this episode

Head Shot

The Classic High School Teacher

Host