Curiosity Over Control: Redefining Recruiting in the Age of AI

We're Only Human - An HR Podcast

We're Only Human - An HR Podcast
Curiosity Over Control: Redefining Recruiting in the Age of AI
Dec 01, 2025 Episode 219
Ben Eubanks

🎧 Episode 219 

Guest: Amandeep Shergill

In this episode, we explore the realities of modern recruiting, the pressure of “doing more with less,” and the challenge of navigating uncertainty in today’s global talent market. Ben and Amandeep discuss how economic shifts, evolving business priorities, and organizational ambiguity shape the day-to-day experience of recruiters.

Amandeep shares practical examples from his career—ranging from prioritizing high-impact roles to building stronger partnerships with business leaders. This conversation dives deep into what it truly means to be a strategic advisor instead of a reactive firefighter in talent acquisition.

You’ll hear insights on:
 • Market uncertainty and its effect on TA planning
 • Productivity vs. unrealistic “do more” expectations
 • The role of tech and efficiency in the future of TA
 • How recruiters can better understand business impact & prioritization
 • Real-world examples of shifting from reactive to proactive hiring
 • Why understanding revenue, OKRs, and leadership goals changes recruiting outcomes

Whether you're a recruiter, hiring leader, or people leader, this episode provides immediately applicable frameworks for better decision-making in TA.

⏱️ Timestamps

00:03 – Welcome to Episode 219
00:16 – Introducing guest Amandeep Shergill
00:55 – Amandeep’s background and global role at Automattic
01:59 – Life outside of work: parenting, sports, and model building
03:16 – Creativity, hobbies & high performance
04:49 – The biggest recruiting challenges today
05:11 – How economic uncertainty shapes hiring plans
05:54 – Productivity, efficiency & “doing more with less”
06:28 – The disconnect between expectations and TA bandwidth
07:22 – Why “doing more” isn’t a real strategy
08:06 – What investment vs. volume actually means for TA
09:46 – Moving from reactive to proactive recruiting
10:26 – Practical strategies for strategic partnership
10:30 – Amandeep’s story from Intuit: prioritizing 38 open roles
11:48 – Understanding business impact behind hiring requests
12:49 – Revenue today vs. revenue tomorrow: prioritizing for impact
13:58 – Why recruiters must understand OKRs, revenue, and strategy
14:46 – Pausing hiring until business impact is clear
15:13 – How proactive planning creates better long-term outcomes

🔗 Connect with Amandeep

LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/amandeepsshergill/?originalSubdomain=uk

🎓 Learn more about HR Summer School

https://hrsummerschool.org


Episode Artwork Curiosity Over Control: Redefining Recruiting in the Age of AI 28:56 Episode Artwork Driving Impact: Why Every HR Leader Needs Coaching Skills 31:46 Episode Artwork Joy Is Now: Finding Purpose and Positivity at Work 18:20 Episode Artwork How AI Can Make HR More Human, Not Less 33:25 Episode Artwork Inside the Circle: Empowering 14,000 Employees Through Storytelling 21:44 Episode Artwork The New Rules of Hiring: Tech, Trust, and the Human Touch 26:25 Episode Artwork The Future of HR: Human First, AI Second 14:05 Episode Artwork Behind the Front Desk: Real Stories of Frontline HR 19:38 Episode Artwork Seeing the HR Matrix: A Conversation with Nicole Eisdorfer on Curiosity, Data, and the Future of HR 32:39 Episode Artwork 🎙 Why Employee Experience Is Every Company’s Priority 33:03 Episode Artwork Unpacking Talent Acquisition Strategy with Kelly Burlage of Lineage 28:11 Episode Artwork Key Strategies for Mastering the HR Business Partner Role with Alicia Jones 29:24 Episode Artwork AI in Talent Acquisition: How Mastercard and Leonardo Screen for Success 41:56 Episode Artwork Workplace Transformation Thrives with Performance, Recognition, and Trust 34:09 Episode Artwork Navigating HR Classification Compliance with Michael Cleavely of CoComply 25:55 Episode Artwork HR isn't the Center of Attention, The Workforce Is: Insights from Cenikor Foundation 33:21 Episode Artwork Building a Sweet Culture of People-First Leadership at Milo's Tea Company 39:05 Episode Artwork Navigating HR and Business Challenges: Insights from Insperity’s HR Experts 32:51 Episode Artwork Fostering Growth Mindsets and Embracing AI in Learning with the CEO of TalentLMS 21:19 Episode Artwork Building Trust and Community in HR with Jason Lawson 34:39 Episode Artwork Navigating HR Challenges and Building Connections with Jeff Palkowski 29:41 Episode Artwork Building Better Leaders: Lessons from The Mayo Clinic 25:50 Episode Artwork Unlocking Customer Eminence: The Power of Personal Stories 18:25 Episode Artwork Leveraging Labor Market Analytics for EVP Analysis, Strategic Workforce Planning, and More 19:39 Episode Artwork Throw Out the PowerPoint Deck and Do This Instead Says Former Pfizer Head of HR 30:26