Oh My Word with Katie
"Oh My Word with Katie" is the show where we hear from Christian writers, chat about classics and new releases for your TBR list, and marvel at all the ways God shows up in words and stories. Join our email list: https://mschristianliving.us4.list-manage.com/subscribe?u=339b6e33ab1f6a8ad0e44aa39&id=c6daf71a58
Oh My Word with Katie
The Divided Soul: Heidi White on Duty, Desire, and the Prodigal Son
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
'Reader's Digest Condensed' Show Notes
Katie welcomes author, teacher, and Close Reads co-host Heidi White to discuss her book The Divided Soul: Duty and Desire in Literature and in Life.
Together they explore why the tension between what we "ought" to do and what we "want" to do lies at the heart of both great literature and everyday Christian life.
Heidi shares how Anne of Green Gables shaped her moral imagination, why the parable of the prodigal son became the framework for her book, and how stories help us understand the fractured human condition after the Fall.
They discuss older-brother and younger-brother tendencies, the healing of desire, the role of joy in the Christian life, and why characters like Odysseus continue to resonate across centuries.
Unabridged Show Notes
Katie sits down with author, classical educator, therapist, and Close Reads co-host Heidi White to discuss The Divided Soul: Duty and Desire in Literature and in Life.
Heidi shares the childhood reading experience that changed her life when she discovered Anne of Green Gables during a difficult season of grief and loneliness. Together, she and Katie explore how stories shape our moral imagination and why literature often forms character more deeply than rules alone.
They discuss the central premise of The Divided Soul: that since the Fall, human beings have lived with a fracture between duty and desire. Drawing from the parable of the prodigal son, Heidi explains how both the younger brother's disordered desires and the older brother's joyless duty reveal different aspects of the same divided heart.
The conversation ranges from psychology and spiritual formation to Homer and The Odyssey, examining how great stories illuminate the struggles of real life. Heidi also shares practical signs that we may be slipping into older-brother self-righteousness, why joy matters in the Christian life, and what it means to pursue the healing of a unified soul.
Along the way, they discuss Anne Shirley, Odysseus and Penelope, Lonesome Dove, Christopher Nolan, classical education, and the enduring power of stories to help us understand ourselves and the world.
In This Episode
Reading, imagination, and formation
- How Anne of Green Gables changed Heidi's life
- Literature as moral formation rather than mere entertainment
- Why stories often shape us more deeply than rules
The divided soul
- The conflict between duty and desire after the Fall
- The prodigal son as a framework for understanding human nature
- Why both younger-brother and older-brother tendencies need healing
Duty, desire, and everyday life
- Recognizing self-righteousness and resentment
- The danger of joyless duty
- Recovering rightly ordered desire
The Odyssey and the harmonious soul
- Why Odysseus serves as a powerful literary example
- Temptation, perseverance, and the longing for home
- Thoughts on modern adaptations of classic stories
Books, stories, and the Christian imagination
- Why great literature remains relevant
- Reading as a way of understanding ourselves
- How stories reveal spiritual realities
Books and Authors Mentioned
- The Divided Soul - Heidi White
- Anne of Green Gables - L.M. Montgomery
- Little House on the Prairie - Laura Ingalls Wilder
- The Odyssey - Homer
- Lonesome Dove - Larry McMurtry
- The Feast - Margaret Kennedy
Who This Episode Is For
- Readers who love classic literature
- Fans of Close Reads and literary podcasts
- Christians interested in spiritual formation
- Teachers, homeschoolers, and classical educators
- Anyone wrestling with duty, desire, burnout, temptation, or joy
Enjoying Oh My Word with Katie?
- Would you consider leaving a rating and review on Apple Podcasts? Reviews help more readers discover thoughtful Christian conversations about books, faith, and the stories that shape us.
- Follow @ohmywordpod on Facebook and Instagram for episode updates and bookish content.
A Question to Reflect On
When have you felt the tension between what you "wanted" to do and what you knew you "ought" to do — and what helped bring those two desires back into alignment?