Why Dad? The Hard Question Every Father Must Answer w/ Paul Wandrey Artwork

The DAUGHTERED Podcast

The Daughtered Podcast is a fatherhood podcast for men who are committed to becoming stronger, more mindful, and more present—especially in the lives of their daughters.

Built for girl dads and intentional fathers, this show explores what it really means to grow as a man and raise strong daughters. We dive into parenting daughters, modern masculinity, leadership at home, and the emotional intelligence required to build deep, lasting father–daughter relationships.

Fatherhood is a journey of growth. Every stage—from toddler tantrums to teenage talks—brings new challenges, deeper lessons, and opportunities to rise. Each conversation on this podcast is designed to help you reflect, level up, and lead with purpose—not just as a dad, but as a husband and man.

Being Daughtered means embracing the lessons our daughters are constantly teaching us—and allowing those lessons to shape us into better fathers, partners, and role models. It means slowing down, listening more, and showing up with intention.

We challenge current misconceptions of masculinity and lead with strength, presence, vulnerability, and purpose. Because presence is power. Vulnerability is strength. And love is the legacy we leave.

This isn’t a space for perfect dads. It’s a space for growing dads.

Through real stories, honest conversations, and practical tools, The Daughtered Podcast supports men who want to father with intention, lead with integrity, and raise confident, capable daughters.

Whether you’re new to fatherhood or decades in—you belong here.

This is more than a podcast.
It’s a mindset. A movement. And a community of fathers choosing to lead at home.

Want to be a guest on The DAUGHTERED Podcast? Want to collaborate? Send Oscar Pena a message on PodMatch, here: https://www.podmatch.com/hostdetailpreview/daughteredpodcast

All Episodes

The DAUGHTERED Podcast

Why Dad? The Hard Question Every Father Must Answer w/ Paul Wandrey

February 17, 2026 • Oscar Peña • Season 3 • Episode 2

0:00 | 1:01:42

Send us Fan Mail

Why are you a father?
Why should you show up when it’s hard?
Why does being a dad actually matter?

In this powerful conversation, I sit down with Paul Wandrey of the Why Dad Podcast to unpack the question most men never slow down enough to answer.

We talk about grief, miscarriage, losing a child, emotional exhaustion, anger, therapy, and the pressure to be the “strong oak” for your family. But what if real strength isn’t about being unbreakable?

This episode dives into:

How loss reshapes a man’s identity as a father
The myth of emotional stoicism in men
Processing grief without shutting down
Holding boundaries without losing connection
How to redefine strength as a husband and dad
Why defining your “why” changes everything

If you’ve ever felt tired, frustrated, disconnected, or unsure how to lead your family well… this one is for you.

Stronger. Mindful. Present.

Instagram

Youtube

Podcast

00:00 Becoming a Dad: The Steeper Learning Curve & the Big “Why?”

00:37 Welcome to The Daughter Podcast + Meet Paul

01:48 What “Why Dad?” Really Means (Kids’ Questions, Future Fathers, Showing Up)

04:10 Intentional Fatherhood & Paul’s Co-Host Perspective (Before You Have Kids)

06:07 Sponsor Break: People Will Hunt

06:53 Paul’s Origin Story: 1 of 9, Military/Catholic Upbringing, Seminary Years

08:43 Loss, Grief, and Fatherhood Tested: Miscarriage & Isla’s 22-Week Birth

12:38 Turning Pain Into Purpose: Becoming the Best Dad + Starting a Podcast

14:47 Processing Miscarriage as a Couple: Dad vs. Mom Experience

23:21 Honoring Amelia: Naming, Art, and Learning How to Support Sarah

26:55 The “newborn smell” & instant bonding as a dad

29:32 Racing to the hospital: unexpected labor at 22 weeks

31:02 In the OR: helplessness, waiting, and Isla’s final moments

33:31 After the loss: choosing to heal together (not break apart)

35:47 Redefining strength for dads: grief, pressure, and leading as one

41:01 Tools that helped: therapy, anger triggers, and parenting with empathy

46:48 Modeling growth (not perfection) + the host’s own dad journey

52:47 Looking 50 years ahead: health, presence, and lasting connection

56:16 Advice to dads in grief: find your “why” and keep recentering

58:42 Where to find Why Dad + final thanks, subscribe, and newsletter outro

Guest Disclaimer:

The views and opinions expressed on this podcast are solely those of the guests. They do not necessarily reflect the views or opinions of the host, any organizations, companies, or institutions mentioned, or corporate entities represented by the host.

Our aim is to provide a platform for diverse perspectives and open dialogue. While we strive for accuracy and balance, it's important to recognize that opinions may vary. We encourage critical thinking and further exploration of the

Support the show

Catch up w/ The Daughtered Podcast

Oscar on Instagram

Few Will Hunt. 10% OFF use GIRLDAD

Want to be a guest on The DAUGHTERED Podcast? Want to collaborate? Send Oscar Pena a message on PodMatch, here: https://www.podmatch.com/hostdetailpreview/daughteredpodcast