Chat out of Hell
How did two massive dorks create some of the most bombastically stupid rock opera of all time? Join equally massive dorks Emma Crossland and Sam Wilkinson as they delve into the works of Meat Loaf and Jim Steinman.
Every episode our intrepid pair both brings one of Loaf or Steinman's works to the table to dissect in meticulously lazy detail, exploring the torrid lives of music's most on-again off-again best pals one week at a time.
Chat out of Hell
Episode 6.6 - Torna a Sorrento | Like a Rose
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
From high-culture to the lowest of the low, it's Chat out of Hell!
As we close out series six with listener requests, Sam pays attention to what Meat Loaf was up to when he sang with Pavarotti for the children of Bosnia, while Emma draws the short straw and has to listen to some sexist crap he did with Jack Black. But we still answer other Meat Loaf-adjacent questions, like:
- What kind of song would convince the Prime Minister of Italy to build a sewer system?
- What did that cheeky scamp Bono get up to when Pavarotti's people told him he couldn't smoke cigarettes around the maestro?
- How exactly are women like roses?
PLUS some good chat about first dances, a brief apology to the people of Ireland for Oliver Cromwell, and Sam's been allowed to send emails again.
We're off for a break now but we'll be back on May 25th with a Film Club all about Jim Steinman's Wuthering Heights. Sorry about that.
Chat out of Hell is a is a review podcast: all music extracts are used for review/illustrative purposes. To hear the songs in full please buy them from your local record shop or streaming platform. Don't do a piracy. Music extracts on this episode:
Torna a Sorrento by Luciano Pavarotti and Meat Loaf from Pavarotti and Friends for the Children of Bosnia (1995)
Like a Rose by Meat Loaf from Hang Cool Teddy Bear (2010)
Like a Rose by New Medicine from Breaking the Model (2014)
What is this?
SamThis is Chat Out Of Hell, the podcast where we discuss the works of Meat Loaf, Jim Steinman, and the good people at Heck's Sausages. Hashtag the chicken ones are really nice.
EmmaAnd who's
SamMeat Loaf? Meat Loaf was a singer and actor from Texas who used to get annoyed at his record labels when they spelled his name Meatloaf, all one word. It's two words. Meet last name Loaf. Who's Jim Steinman?
EmmaJim Steinman was a musician, composer, producer, and writer who most definitely would not have given either Sam or I a part in any of his musicals, even the really dodgy ones.
SamWow, that's an ego deflation.
EmmaThere's reason
SamWho are we?
EmmaWe? We're Emma and Sam Wilkinson, and we are comedians who absolutely regret our decision to sing Paradise by the Dashboard Light last weekend at our friend's party. We've not got the range for it, Sam. This again, Emma. We've not got the confidence either.
SamYo, you don't have the confidence No.
EmmaOr the skill.
SamI'm worried about your self-confidence.
EmmaYeah, me too. But it's okay because my therapist is here to prop me up. Not here tonight. Here in a general sense.
SamWelcome to Chat out of Hell. Bow. Now. Now, Now.
Emmading. Sorry. Am
Samjust, karaoke, mate. It's fine.
EmmaIt's not. It's to be
SamIt was rubbish.
EmmaIt was awful.
Samkaraoke is rubbish.
EmmaHow you doing, Sam?
SamOh, hello? Hello, Steve Wright in the afternoon. Yeah, I'm all right. Thanks, Emma. How are you?
EmmaI'm alright, thanks. I'm just trying to up the enthusiasm
Samup. Z
Emmaup.
SamWhat did I say?
EmmaZ
SamThey're both made up words. Anyway. Chat out of Hell. Series six, episode six.
EmmaYep. Ready for a break.
SamThis is the 36th mainstream Chat out of Hell
Emmathat's a fair ol' whack of songs covered, isn't it? Yet, still so far to go.
SamIt means we've triggered a certain number of spam bots.
EmmaOh, congratulations.
SamWhich like to contact our official email address to say Hi. You've hit 40 episodes. Wow, that's incredible. But we can't find you. YouTube has no clear signal when your episodes ati. I fucking, I don't care. Spam bots go away. So, yeah, we've made it Emma.
EmmaOh, if we're getting that kind of spam,
Samthen we'd better take a break after this to recover.
EmmaBut it's okay.'cause we will be back after the
SamWe'll be back. Yes. I just wanna address that now.'Cause we got an email from Claire Muncaster yesterday who was, I think we maybe had phrased something badly and implied that this was the last series of Chat out of
EmmaIt's not, we're going
Samwe're barely halfway through. But we have already planned out a lot of what will go into the final series when we get there. But this is still series six. And this is Chat Out of Hell. It's the podcast where we both bring a song performed or written by Meat Loaf for Jim Steinman to our podcast workshop, and we take all the screws off the case and have a look inside at what makes it work and realise we can't put it back together again at the end. So Emma, what song have you brought?
EmmaI have brought Like a Rose from Hang Cool. Teddy Bear. What have you brought? Sam? I
SamI have brought Meat Loaf's performance of Tona a Sorento or Come Back to Sorento, which he sang with Luciano Pavarotti in 1995. that was requested by Jay,
EmmaLovely stuff. And that's what we're going to start with
Samtoday. We are gonna start with that one today. You can find that on YouTube it was released on CD also, so you should be able to find it on like Spotify and Apple Music Deezer, although I think Deezer might be pod, I'm not sure. You know what, like
Emmacould you find it on Napster,
SamYeah. Find is what is Deezer old.
EmmaI don't know. I feel like
SamFind it on Limewire. Don't do that. That's a crime
EmmaAnd will inevitably just be a virus that you're downloading anyway.
SamGo find yourself a virus on Limewire and we'll see you in a few minutes. There is a video on YouTube. It's vaguely educational. What did you think, Emma?
EmmaVery dramatic, isn't
Samit?
EmmaWhat's it about?
SamIt's a traditional song from, would you believe it? Sorento. Okay. Yeah. Written around the turn of the 19th century, which is to say when it became the, is that the right way around the turn of the 20th century? I don't written around 1900.
EmmaOkay. Gotcha. yeah.
SamThis is from Wikipedia, tradition holds that the origin of the song dates to 1902. When, forgive me, Italians Gomo. Oh, no, I'm not.
EmmaIt's
Samokay. Emma. You can do this. I'm so glad it's not me. When the Mayor of Sorento asked his friend Giambattista de Curtis to write a song for the visiting Prime Minister Giuseppe Zanardelli, I couldn't say the mayor's name, I'm very sorry. So the Prime Minister was staying at the Mayor's hotel and it was claimed that he'd asked his friend to write a song for the Prime Minister. Some claimed that the song's a plea to Zanardelli to keep his promise to help the impoverished city of Sorento, which was especially in need of a sewage system. So it's this beautiful song about how lovely Sorento is, with the implication that it won't be for long, mate,
EmmaIf we don't turn the sewage out, it's gonna smell.
SamEnglish translation."Look at the sea. How beautiful it is. It inspires so many emotions like you do with the people you look at, who you make to dream while they are still awake. Look at this garden and the scent of these oranges, such a fine perfume. It goes straight into your heart and you say,'I am leaving. Goodbye.' You go away from this heart of mine, away from this land of love and have you not the heart to come back", et cetera et cetera You are nice. This place is nice. Why you, nice person, leaving this, a nice place. PS can we have a sewage system? So that's what it's about. Okay. Just to give you some framing on this, that performance there came from the 1995 version of Pavarotti's annual Pavarotti and Friends concert. Okay? So, between 92 and 2003, he would put on an annual concert to raise money for various humanitarian causes. So this one was for the children of Bosnia. Massive deal. Televised. This is Pavarotti's height of his fame. Yeah. Just after Meat Loaf performed Pavarotti did Ave Maria with Dolores o R Okay. Bringing Princess Diana to tears. It's this massive occasion other people involved. And this is a weird sort of split because obviously Meat Loaf just sang a traditional Italian folk song. Yeah. Dolores Sang Ave Maria. Also involved that year we had there's a variety of Italian pop musicians as you might think, Simon LeBon was there singing Ordinary World. Michael Bolton was involved. Brian Eno. Bono, the Edge and Brian Eno formed a super group called The Passengers it is a weird thing, Emma. Yeah. But these concerts were absolutely massive at the time. Prior to singing this Meat Loaf had done a lovely rendition of Heaven Can Wait. And then came into this, what did you think of Meat Loaf singing there?
EmmaI thought he sang pretty well.
SamOkay.
EmmaIt was from, what, 95?
Sam95.
EmmaSo
SamJust after Bat Two. Yeah, just before Neighbourhood.
EmmaHe he seemed to still be rocking a ponytail.
SamHe was rocking a ponytail,
Emmaso it was before he did the Samson thing of cutting off his hair and losing all of his power. Mm-hmm.
SamI thought it was a little bit weird.
EmmaIt's really weird,
Samall No, but I thought his voice sounded a bit off and I found out why. So I came across a really good article by the journalist, Jim Shelley who was doing a bio piece on Meat Loaf just before and during the concert. Right. Meat Loaf was plugging his upcoming Welcome to the Neighbourhood album. But it's quite an eye-opener to Meat Loaf's inner life. We've talked a little bit about it, but we don't touch on it a lot. Meat Loaf's famously quite a, I guess shy is probably the word. Yeah. he's not his stage personality. No. Not an outgoing person. He feels very uncomfortable in company. And he's been pitched into this massive fundraising show with all of these other huge artists crammed into the backstage of some place. The piece from Jim Shelley opens up the day before, during rehearsal"on the day Meat Loaf is due to sing with Pavarotti, sits slumped on a hotel sofa and describes his present state of mind as stressed. It was real nerve wracking singing with Pavarotti.' He gushes like a child.'I was real jumpy. I get silly when I'm nervous. I get like a little kid.'" But he had a really bad rehearsal,
Emmaright?
SamAt the rehearsals it's a weird kind of atmosphere for Meat in particular. Pavarotti's got all these different artists lined up and doing their songs with them, and he's having a great time with loads of them. So there's this Italian rap star called Jovanotti where he's so enjoying his duet with him that Jim Shelley says he enters into the spirit of his duet so enthusiastically that at one point that seems a very real danger that Pavarotti was gonna start break dancing." And then he is hanging out with Bono after that. Bono's been told that he's not allowed to smoke cigarettes around Pavarotti. And Bono pulls out a cigar and smokes that, which Pavarotti finds really funny. Yeah. Pavarotti's like, yo, oh, great bantz. And then Meat Loaf comes on and does his rehearsal and he fucks it. Yeah. It doesn't go well at all. And as he's leaving, somebody tells Meat Loaf that he's offended Pavarotti in some way. Yes. Yeah. And Meat Loaf offers to go home. I know. yeah.
EmmaA lot of the time the things that Meat Loaf says or does come across as really dickish.
SamYeah.
EmmaBut this is a real insight into that.
SamLinked to this the article mentions another anecdote from Meat where he had a really bad show in I think Berlin at one point. Yeah. And he said to his promoter, is there any way we can give all these people their money back? yeah. Uhhuh.
EmmaOh. I don't really know what to say
SamI know. Me neither.
EmmaBecause The man that we've been painting a picture of for a little while now is a dick, a difficult guy to get on with. Yes. A of a man baby a lot of the time. But then to turn it on his head and to see this insecurity. Loads of people have bad rehearsals.
SamOne of the reasons the rehearsal was bad, and the reason I thought this sounded a little bit off, is'cause Pavarotti asked him not to sing in his natural key. He's had his key changed on him. And the reason that's happened is'cause he did sing in his natural key in rehearsals and Pavarotti thought he was taking the piss. yeah. And then the other thing is they're in front of an orchestra. Yeah,"'I've never sung with an orchestra in my life,' he exclaims. It, scared the hell out of me. As soon as I started singing, I couldn't hear them. And I turned to the guy and said, can you turn them up?'" Which is funny in the rock world,'cause Yeah, obviously we've got the, he's, he'll have a monitor. But yeah,"it's okay for him. Pavarotti, he just knows where the notes are". He follows the conductor and Meat Loaf's, so totally out of his element here. Yeah. So, yeah, it's yeah.
EmmaI feel quite bad for him.
Samhim. I do as well. He doesn't feel comfortable with celebrity as a concept and he doesn't feel comfortable hanging out with all these celebrities. But he's got to. He talks about his relationship with Jim being on the way down again and that is because,'Jim's a bit strange, we're completely different except for artistically. On Bat Two we would sit there not saying anything, then suddenly turn to one another and say the same thing.' And the relationship changed when Steinman turned to him and said,'I hate you.' And when asked why, he said,'because we did these albums together and you became a star. And I didn't.' Jim always wanted to be famous. Jim likes the circus. I don't like the circus.'" Massive caveat, of course, that Jim and Meat lie about
EmmaYes, And everything else.
Samelse. Later on, right, day of the show, here's a nice bit. He's backstage. His wife Lesley's there. Lesley pulls a snakes on a can prank on Jim Shelley. You know they open the cans, bring loaded snakes everywhere. Oh. Bit of fun. Meat's enjoying that. Princess Di stops by to wish him luck and Meat is gesturing to Leslie to give her the can. Give her the can.
EmmaMeat Loaf's not a sophisticated man, is he? I love that.
SamBut Di disappears. Before we can find out what would've happened
EmmaI think that would've been amazing.
SamSo that's two princesses Meat Loaf's hung out with.
EmmaOh.
Samcause of course he's got that photo with Sarah Ferguson from It's a Royal Knockout.
EmmaI'd forgotten about It's a Royal Knockout.
SamThat's a little bit of a background.
EmmaIt sounds very uncomfortable.
SamIt does sound uncomfortable. These concerts, are absolutely massive. Raising loads and loads of cash. There's a CD released it's a big deal. Yeah. To be invited to, to play in these, but for him to have such a difficult experience when fucking Bono's out there puffing cigar, smoking in Pavarotti's face, it's so, so unfortunate.
EmmaIt does make you feel for the guy. Yeah. And I'm not usually brought to No. these days. He
Sam'cause he makes it very hard sometimes. Yeah.
Emmait makes me think of desperately wanting to fit in with the cool kids and not quite managing it. Yeah. Trying to do your best and not being able to pull it off despite everybody else somehow seeming It's a really uncomfortable, it's to be in. No wonder he offered to go home.
SamDo you wanna do a quiz to clear your palette? Luciano Pavarotti. Meat Loaf one is a tall, heavy set genre busting singer with a powerful tenor voice, a reputation for being a little bit unreliable and hard to deal with, a loving family man with a surprising link to now former Royals and so is the other one. So, Emma, are these Pavarotti facts true or false? Pavarotti loved riding motorbikes.
EmmaThat's so tricky. Fuck it. True. he's not got the frame for it, has he?
SamFact number two, Pavarotti's stage costume in the seventies was a dinner jacket or tuxedo worn with a frilly shirt and a white handkerchief while he sweated all over the stage.
EmmaWe know that Meat Loaf preferred a red handkerchief, so I'm going True.
SamOh, you big nerd. Yes. got it right on the handkerchief. Back to Jim Shelley's article. That was Pavarotti's outfit that he'd been wearing since about 68. Meat Loaf had pretty much bang on the same stage outfit with hanky, but with a different colour hanky. The funny thing is, says Meat Loaf, that the first time he saw Pavarotti in January 79, he thought Pavarotti had ripped him off.
Emmat
SamThis was'cause ever since he started playing live in 68, Meat Loaf had gone on stage wearing a tuxedo and waving a red scarf. Pavarotti's is white. I mentioned it to him last night. Meat Loaf smiles. Yeah. Asked him if he'd stolen my act. He just looked at me and went like this" taps his index finger to his temple."So who knows? Maybe he did." Jim Shelley, does go on to point out that tapping an index finger to your temple can either mean'you are very smart,' or it can mean'you are crazy'. One, right one wrong. Fact number three. Pavarotti was a successful high school footballer.
EmmaFalse. Oh, really?
SamOh, really? Yeah when he'd graduated from school, he was interested in pursuing a career as a goalkeeper. But his mother convinced him to train as a teacher, and through that, he eventually went into singing. Pavarotti fact number four. So, I believe you are one right two wrong. Fact number four, Pavarotti holds the world record for most curtain calls of any performer with a total of 65 in one performance.
EmmaI'm gonna say true. I don't like it, but I
SamIt's false.
EmmaIt's not Meat Loaf, is it?
SamHere's the quote from Guinness. On the 24th of February, 1988. Luciano Pavarotti received 165 curtain calls and was applauded for one hour, seven minutes.
EmmaOh. That's
Samafter singing the part of Nemorino in Donzietti's La Lisia D'amour at the Deutsche Opera in Berlin. That is exhausting. a an Hour and seven minutes of applauding.. It's too much, Emma. One curtain call is fine. Yeah, I'm happy with that. Well done you, that was, do you know what, that was especially good acting. Come back and we'll just,
EmmaI know how you feel about things like applause and ovations. Don't feel
Samdon't feel badly about applause. I do feel a bit annoyed that every fucking West End has to feature an ovation now. I would give Pavarotti an ovation. He was very good. I will not stand there for half the runtime of the show. I've just seen
EmmaOh God. No, no, no.
SamSeven minutes.
EmmaI think I would be out in the car park by then.
SamHow? You're not getting out, Emma.
EmmaYou'd clamber through. I've got sharp elbows.
SamYou've missed your last bus home.
EmmaOh, you had to pay extra on the parking?
SamYeah. You probably got a ticket.
EmmaAnd back then there's no app to top up your parking
SamAn hour and seven minutes. 165. once you've passed 20, how do you stop?
EmmaSurely Pavarotti could have said, no, I'm not going back out. That's it. That's enough now. This is stupid. I'm tired. I've been singing all night. It's lovely that they like me, but I want, want a cup of tea or a biscotti. I don't know.
SamBloody hell. I'll pass the emails on to you.
EmmaNo, I regret that already. Is it ever gonna end? Is this my life now? These are the things that will be going through my head and It's very indulgent to keep doing that. Sure. Because surely he could have just said, that's it. Let's all go home.
SamOh, come on, would you?
EmmaYes. Yeah.
SamYou've You've got a show on tomorrow night. If you got 165 curtain calls, do you keep getting back? No.
EmmaI'm usually desperate to get off by that point. We've done the raffle.
SamYeah. Pavarotti's not even got to the raffle
EmmaWe've done the raffle. I've gotta turn the lights off so they can cool down so that we can pack them away. I'm thinking practically, Sam, no fucking curtain call. Rubbish. No, Encore. Let's just go home. We're all tired.
SamOh, I don't know though. I think there's a certain madness of crowds in it that once you've hit that 20, it's like, you know what? Fucking, yeah, we're keeping going lads. We're keeping going.
Emmaoh,
SamHow much would your hands hurt? hurt?
EmmaOh, so much. This is stupid. It's
Samstupid
Emmaand it's made me angry.
SamIt's stupid how good you were at opera, Pavarotti
EmmaBut is it even about how good he is at that point, or is it just about continuing to see what we can do as a crowd?
SamPavarotti fact number five. On his death, Pavarotti owned three apartments in New York
EmmaI don't... true?
SamThree, three apartments. Why have you got three flats in one city? Pavarotti,
Emmabecause you've had how many curtain calls? I'm sorry. How many? The guy likes things in numbers.
SamBut that does mean that Pavarotti matches Jim Steinman for number of mattresses owned by a single man across New York City.
EmmaI wonder if they're in the same state.
SamOh. Pavarotti facts, born 1935, died 2007. His first singing success, he was a member of a choir from Moderna which won first prize at the International Eisteddfod in Llangollen. Yeah, so that's two languages I've been able to butcher in one piece. Trained as an opera singer, blah, blah, blah. Performed around the place. His big breakthrough was he hit nine high Cs in the signature area of La fille du Regiment which was apparently very good. And he got the nickname, the King of the High Cs, which is a good pun. He also had the nickname, the King of the Cancellations because he pulled out of performances a lot. was only mid-tier popular in the opera fraternity'cause he was very good, but also very unreliable. But then he became famous worldwide in, do you remember how he became famous?
EmmaNot really. No.
SamNo. Okay. It was 1990, his rendition of Nessun Dorma. I just wanted to sing it. That was the theme song to the BBC's coverage of the Italia 90 World Cup. Yeah. And whatever dumb reason, the BBC's theme tune to football tournaments often becomes a massive seller in the charts. Because my goodness, do you remember Des Lynam reading out the poem If
EmmaYeah. Yeah, I do. That was
SamI believe over the top of Pavanne by Fauré, maybe wrong. Anyway, that helped him achieve pop status. But there was also he and the Three Tenors, their first concert was on the eve of the World Cup final. That performance became the biggest selling classical record of all time. So it was football what brought him to fame.
EmmaIt's always bloody football.
SamAnd he was a massive football fan. Yeah. I think he was a Liverpool fan, because I was at Proms in the Park 2007. And the opera singer, Leslie Garrett, got the crowd to sing You'll Never Walk Alone in his memory. yeah. Also performing at Proms in the Park was Chico.
EmmaWas it Chico time?
Samwas, Chico told this anecdote, It was Chico's taken out a second mortgage to fund his new album time.
EmmaOh God,
SamI know.
EmmaOh, Chico.
SamAnd we all know how massive Chico's second album
EmmaYeah. I remember that. We were queuing up in the streets to buy it. Yeah. Oh, I don't really remember anything from Chico's
Samother than it being Chico time.
EmmaAnd even then, wasn't really aware of that much of Chico time because, well, I didn't really follow. Chico's career. Even then.
SamI don't want to delve into Chico's career today
Emmabecause you're saving me that for the next series.
SamI did just have a little light bulb go off over my head. Yeah. you wanna hear what the people of the internet have to think? Yes. About this beautiful
EmmaI do. Yeah. Go on.
SamAt Jason Montgomery Cavern at 7 2 2. Pavarotti has the worst haircut I have ever seen on a man. And it's true. He does not have great hair.
Emmabad isn't, There's the unkempt beard that just needs tidying. I'm trying to figure out what it's doing. It's,
SamWell, he is much like Meat. He's a very sweaty man when he performs. And that doesn't help.
EmmaMaybe he needs to grow it long and tie it back like Meat
Samwe've not even talked about opera at, you're not an opera person?
EmmaI've not an opera person.
SamHave you
EmmaAre are you an opera person?
SamI enjoy a bit of opera now
EmmaI have never been to an opera, so perhaps if I went I could get into it. But it's just not something I ever particularly choose to listen to.
SamI'm the sort of person that goes to opera a bit, but not enough to know about opera. Right. I just sit there and listen to the lovely singing
EmmaI haven't even done that.
SamIs it time to rate this song, Emma? I think it is, yes. okay. So, this is a song by Meat Loaf with no Jim Steinman involvement. So we're gonna use our Meat Loaf song rating scale, running from Michael Lee Aday at the top, down to Michael Lee Okay in the middle, all the way down to Michael Lee No Way for the bad songs, what he'd done. What's this?
EmmaIt's a hard one to judge. It's, not something that I would ever actively choose to. I think Meat Loaf did all right in it. I don't think his voice was terrible
Samlike that. Yeah. But it wasn't at its best either. No. Due to the weird restrictions upon him. Yeah. But obviously Pavarotti's banging in it'cause he's Pavarotti.
EmmaYeah.
SamIn it.
Emmathat's what he does.
SamThat's what he does. So what we're effectively saying, Emma, is how we rating this Pavarotti song on our Meat Loaf song rating scale?
EmmaHave you not managed to get the rights to the Pavarotti scale?
SamOh, what? The one that runs from Luciano Pavarotti to Luciano pava. Hang on, Hang
Emmasorry. sorry.
SamLuciano Pavaiforgotti, all the way down to Luciano Pavanotti
EmmaLuciano Pavanotti or Luciano Pavagrotti.
SamWhere are you in the writer's room? As a song. We have this sort of mystery about it.'cause it's in a language neither of us speak, so it sounds lovely, but the English translation I read out is, it's nice, but it's not it's not Jim Steinman putting in boner jokes. So, if that had been an English folk song would've gone, oh, lovely English folk song. Fine. Performance wise Meat Loaf is good, but not at his best on it. It's an okay. Yeah.
EmmaYeah. Yeah. I'm happy with that.
SamMichael Lee. Okay.
EmmaOh. Oh.
SamSo Emma, what song have you brought?
EmmaI have brought Like a Rose from Hang Cool Teddy Bear. This was requested by Stephanie. There's no video for this one, so go away and find it wherever you find your music, you hip young things.
SoundtrackShe can you on. She kick you when you
EmmaThat was Meat Loaf singing Like a Rose. And that was the Meat Loaf reinvention of the Beastie Boys that we never knew we wanted. Did I take the words right out of your mouth?
SamNo, Emma, please don't.
EmmaIt's a stylistic choice, isn't it?
SamCertainly is. Did
Emmawe enjoy that then Sam?
SamEnjoy is an interesting word.
Emmaisn't it?
SamAm I glad to have headphones on so that song didn't reach anywhere else in the
EmmaYeah, I was thinking that every time I listened to it. I don't want people knowing I've heard this. So it's from Hang Cool Teddy Bear, which is an album I appear to have been stuck on a bit. This series, I'm looking forward to doing something else. It was written by Kevin Kadish and Jake Shearer. Kevin Kadish also co-wrote, produced, and mixed All About That Bass by Meghan Trainor.
SamAll about that bass. That bass. Treble. Which I believe is about bums. I know how Very rude. We would never find bums amusing, Emma.
EmmaJake Shearer a member of the band called New Medicine and they also did a version of this song on their 2014 album, breaking The Model. The commenters on YouTube seem to be having a battle about who sung it first and who's got ownership of it. But Meat Loaf's version came out in 2010. Theirs came out in 2014. So,
SamSo it's Meat Loaf's fault.
EmmaJake wrote it, but Meat Loaf sang it first, I assume he wrote it for them
Samand Jake listened to that recording and said, yes, this does work.
EmmaHave a listen. We can just do a tiny bit.
SoundtrackShe's kind like a she'll cut you on your tongue, she'll kick you
Emmato me, that sounds a little bit like um,
SamI was, I was looking around for a backwards baseball
EmmaYeah.
SamI felt bareheaded wasn't the way to listen to that song.
EmmaIt felt very
SamFred Durst.
EmmaYeah. Sort of new metal vibes. Not enjoyable for me personally. The people of the internet disagree with me. There's a lot of praise for that version. And of course, whenever there's more than one version of a song by anybody,
Samthere's
Emmaarguments
SamCan we talk about the lyrics?
EmmaAbsolutely, Sam.,
SamI would just like to take issue with the central premise of the whole song, really. Uh, Yeah. So the chorus goes, she's kind of like a rose uhhuh and first, have the courage of your convictions. Is she or isn't she like a rose? Don't throw in this, She's
EmmaLike a rose,
SamLike a rose, but
Emmakind of like a woman.
SamSo she's kind of like a rose. She'll cut you on your thumb. Uhhuh. That is roses do that. They've got sharp thorns. Yeah. The other things that she will do that apparently make her like a rose, include kicking you when you are low. Fucking
Emmadone
Samshe's done. And every time you think you've got control, she got it.
EmmaYeah.
SamLike roses do. This
Emmathis is absolute dog shit. It doesn't get any better. The worst lyric in it is"yeah, it doesn't really matter that she isn't 21.'cause she's always backstage when the band gets done."
SamSorry, I'm just doing a quick bit of maths.
EmmaOh, for the age difference between a 21-year-old and
SamAnd Meat Loaf.
EmmaYeah. At this point. It's not gonna be a happy
SamMeat Loaf was 63 when he sang. It doesn't matter that she's not 21.
EmmaAnd of course he's in character. he's in character and he's playing one of the various versions of the Dying Soldier because it's Hang Cool Teddy soldier just won't stop. So in this case, the woman that he's singing about,'cause he's always singing about a different partner in, all of this, is some kind of crazed wild child girl that is so often fetishized in this kind of song, when really it's probably about a woman who needs a lot of help.
SamLike roses do
Emmaroses need a lot of help.
SamYeah, Do make sure to give her an appropriate feed around springtime.
EmmaThis song features the word fuck. Which does not come up in Meat Loaf songs.
SamHe's not actually a big swearer.
EmmaParticularly when he is singing Jim's stuff. Jim will have sex and drums and rock and roll. And uh, cheaper than spit so, you Jim actively avoided.
SamDid we ever hear why that was? Because I've heard Jim eff and jeff in interviews and stuff.
EmmaI dunno if we've actually found
Samthat he's not prudish about swearing per se, but he doesn't put it in his, oh wait, no, he put it a lot in his earlier
EmmaYeah. But he hasn't put it in the things that he wants to be
SamOn the radio.
EmmaOn the radio. yeah.
SamThose 12 minute songs that he's made for the radio,
EmmaBut I guess he's still got his mind on some sort of commercial success. Or maybe he feels that it's not necessary in these contexts. For these stories.
SamYeah.
EmmaBecause his early stuff, he's looking at some quite edgy pieces, commentary on like Vietnam War situations
SamUhhuh,
Emmaand of course the but this whole album has some quite edgy concept in it. I say edgy in that edgy boy.
Samyeah. EE edgy, like the people of the internet.
EmmaYeah.
SamNot you listeners. You are lovely, but you know the ones we
EmmaYou know who we're talking about. It's an unpleasant song. with unpleasant themes. And again, this fetishization of
SamThe damaged girl. yeah.
EmmaThat's a horrible trope that you see a lot of. It's not good to perpetuate this myth that all these damaged girls are incredibly sexy when really these damaged girls just help and support. but that's not very rock and roll, is it? I think back to being a teenager. I am very not edgy. I never really have been. but I fetishized And then you see the reality later on and it's not sexy, it's just heartbreaking. And I resent the fetishization of that in a lot rock and associated culture. As As, a, woman who requires support.
SamMm-hmm.
EmmaThis sort of thing doesn't help, but it's there. It's not going anywhere. She's kind of like a rose. She attracts a lot of bees.
SamShe makes a lovely tea.
EmmaShe's kind of like a rose. She flavours Turkish delight.
SamShe's kind of like a rose. Your gran likes her.
EmmaShe's kind of like a rose. Your wife will be delighted if you take her home.
SamShe's kind of like a rose. You get a big tub of them at Christmas.
EmmaShe's kind of like a rose. No one really likes the coffee ones.
SamAnother one, just another one of those. Yeah.
EmmaMeat Loaf doesn't torture this to death by himself. Jack Black is also involved.
SamOh, Oh I'm not surprised.
EmmaHe's doing the duety bits with Meat Loaf. We've talked about Jack Black's affection for Meat Loaf before. Meat Loaf played his father in the Tenacious D movie. But why choose to get involved in this horrible song?
SamWell. Have you heard the Tenacious D's output that isn't that one good song
EmmaNo, No, I haven't. And I suspect that might be for my best.
SamI would say I'm sure I mentioned this when we talked about, it Kickapoo? Yeah. That he did in, in, yeah. Tenacious D are a band that have learned that fuck rhymes with suck. Made a career out of it. Oh, but also now he's the voice of a cartoon panda, so
Emmait's all
Samare you gonna do?
EmmaYeah. I don't like this song.
SamYeah, me neither.
EmmaI know how we're gonna rate it already.
SamWe've heard some proper misog on this podcast from across his career. Yeah. And some of them are at least a bit singable or have a catchy hook or have some good word play in their treatment of women as things. This has none of that.
EmmaNo, and yet there are people out there including, review sites that really rate it.
SamWhy is it a fucking Beastie Boys tribute act for the
Emmayeah.
Sam30 seconds?
EmmaIt really isn't it? who thought that was a good idea? And it's like your uncool Uncle has decided to have a go at doing a Beastie Boys. Sit down Granddad. You're making us all look stupid.
SamBut frame that as well. We talked about last week, his first pass at this album was with lovely folk singer Sean McDonnell. And then he put all of that aside and went, do you know what I'm gonna sing about how women are
EmmaYeah,, ah subjective sounds.com said"Like a Rose is one of the best songs on Hang Cool Teddy Bear, it is not, and it's one of my all time favourite Meat Loaf tracks."In part, it's due to Jack Black's involvement, but the tip of the hat to the Beastie Boys takes Like a Rose to another level. If there was one aspect I'd change, it would be the mix. The guitar is simply too concealed." No, wrong in your be bad dog, just bullshit. Do you wanna hear what the people of the internet have got to say?
SamA bit, but also
Emmaalso no
SamI'm sort of scared and sad. Emma.
EmmaYeah. So. Superthrowndownone said, so happy my kick-ass girlfriend showed me this song."
SamOh, well they've got us now Emma. Girls
EmmaAnd to make it worse, Amber Jet said,"I love this song. I'm sure he's singing about me, LOL. No, I know. He's singing about me."
SamEmma, can you handle these?'cause if I say anything, it'll damage my credibility as a, as an ally,
Emmawhereas I have no credibility left. Oh, don't try to be these people the dark 1 5 0 8 said,"well, it sounded awesome on paper. This song is fucking horrible."Yay. Yay. Should we rate it
SamMichael ly no way.
EmmaMichael Lee.
SamNot even introducing the scale.
EmmaIt's awful.
SamWhat was Stephanie's
EmmaStephanie said that she'd been a bit of a Meat Loaf apologist at times, but this is the worst one and the misogyny is horrible.
SamThere we go. Yes.
EmmaSo, yep. Thanks Stephanie.
SamThanks Stephanie.
EmmaNice to have that one out of the way.
SamSo that was our songs this episode.
EmmaYay.
SamWhat a way to end the series. And I know we had a pre-show chat about whether to end on an introspective note about Meat Loaf being really shy, or a song that hates women.
EmmaWas no way to win this
SamThere was no last minute comeback where we pull out an incredible version by Dido.
EmmaRory Dodd.
SamOh. I said Dido you said Rory Dodd? Yeah. Meet in the middle. But what did you think of those songs? You can let us know with an email to chat out of hell@gmail.com, which some people have been emailing. Emma. Yes, people have been emailing that email. Email address. With an
Emmaemail.
SamWith emails. And we've been forgetting to do them for the past couple of episodes. So let's do our email emails now.
EmmaLet's Let's have a good old rustle through that mailbag
SamLet's open up our email, email bag and pull out the first email, which is from Shane
EmmaHysteria's really set in badly tonight, isn't it?
SamThere is a noticeable difference between the ones we record just after lunch and the ones we record just before bed. It is from Shane Hogan. Hey Emma and Sam, maybe it's a sign that I've been listening to too many of your episodes, but my mind immediately thought of your rating scale when this name popped up on the Lincoln Lawyer credits, which was this is a film executive produced by Ross Fineman, And I agree, having seen it, the Lincoln Lawyer is a Ross Fineman. alright. It's fine. Whatever.
Emmalovely stuff.
SamI love the podcast, particularly the episodes covering tracks from Bat One, Dead Ringer, and Bad for Good. The Rory Dodd interview was amazing, particularly to hear him ripping off his Irish mammy's accent. I've been a fan of Meat Loaf and Steinman here in Dublin Ireland since my school days in the early eighties when it was seen as desperately uncool during the emergence of the new romantics and synth music. And Meat Loaf has remained desperately uncool for all of the time since then. Yay. Each of those early tracks takes me to a special place. You might enjoy this documentary on Meat's 1990 tour of small venues in rural Ireland. The title comes from British Colonist, Oliver Cromwell's, standard refrain to the Irish"To Hell or to Connaught" during his ethnic cleansing of Ireland during the 1650's describing him as British colonist. is honestly letting him off.
EmmaYeah, it's, it really is. Wholesale bastard.
SamAbsolute rotter. Connaught refers to the West of Ireland, west of the Shannon River, generally seen as poor quality land for farming. But hey, who's gonna hold a grudge for 400 years bracket, most of us Fair play. And there is a link to that documentary, which I've not yet watched, but it is on my to-do list for our break. It's nice to see the early nineties Meat Loaf when hope was high and misogyny w as so far away except for all the misogyny he'd more recently done in the eighties. Thanks Shane. Thank you, Shane. And then Chris Matts. Uhhuh
EmmaUhhuh
Samregular listener. Chris Matts sent the same email twice. Yes. Once from his work account and then once from his personal account a couple of days later. And we are laughing Chris, but we find that amazing. Yes,
EmmaThat's the sort of thing that I would do,
SamI'm so touched that Chris clearly thought to himself, oh, I really must email Chat out of Hell. And then a couple of days later, thought, did I send that? Email It's not in my outbox. So I but Chris said so sorry for not being in contact for the last few months, but I've had a busy time of it getting married and all that entails. Congratulations. First of all, also it's lovely, Chris you don't have to apologise for not emailing two idiots talking about Meat Loaf in their living room. Thank you though. It's lovely. Thanks. Chris said"we had Dead Ringer as our second song, and I thought that would raise an interesting question. If you had to have a Meat Loaf first dance, what would it be?"
EmmaOh, there's a question. Sam, did you have a first dance at your wedding?
SamNot at our actual wedding. We had our reception a couple of years later and called it a visa renewal party in order to cut the bill by about 50%. Got away with it. We didn't intend a first dance, but we were bullied into starting the dancing by other people. So our first dance ended up being to the Luckiest Guy on the Lower East Side by the Magnetic Fields. This is quite a nice one actually. I, we'd landed quite nicely on that. Did you have one?
EmmaNo, we did not. Ed and I, neither of us are what you'd call natural dancers
Samwhereas Kat and I are
Emmaand I are ballerinas. Yes, I can imagine. So when we first got together, or not long after we first got together we went to a friend's wedding and we got drunk enough to have a go at dancing. It was bad. Ed's dancing is somehow even worse than mine, which is really saying something. And so a joke formed that Ed wouldn't dance at any more things because I had him on a dance ban. A three year dance span that has since been extended to well, we celebrate 18 years together in a couple of days, so we decided to opt out of the first dance because the world's not ready for our version of rhythm.
SamI'm really sad'cause the things that you and I and our friends do together, never include any opportunity for dancing. Now that's all I want to see. I'm trying to work out where and how we can get some dancing on just so I can witness this.
EmmaWell, I'll let you figure that one out. So, yeah we didn't have a first dance, however that That's
Samquestion is: Meat Loaf first dance. What you having?
EmmaI don't know I suppose you want something quite sweet and romantic.
SamHeaven can Wait
EmmaYeah. something Like that. A hilarious suggestion. Yeah. You're thinking of California Isn't Big Enough, aren't you?
Samenough aren't
Emmathinking of California isn't Big Enough, but our lovely friend Becky, didn't she mention something about the idea of Two Outta Three Ain't Bad?
SamI think she had I think she had that.
EmmaYes. Which is an awful choice.
Sam50 50 on it, I think because, it is quite a good song. How do
EmmaI need you There ain't no way I'm ever gonna love you.
Samknow, I'm aware of the lyrics,
EmmaBut
Sambut it's also quite a good song to slow dance to. You don't have a lot of those in the Meat Loaf canon.
EmmaAh, I suppose we could go really outlandish. Life is a Lemon And I Want My Money Back.
SamOh, hello. It's a really, he's a lucky boy. I doubt you gonna beat those two, to be honest. Dead ring Ringer's a good call.
EmmaDead Ringer's a lot of fun.
SamDead Ringer's is a nice dancey one. it's quite quick. Everybody's gonna come and join in on
EmmaDance in my Pants
SamOh geez.
EmmaSurf's Up. That's a nice
SamSurf's Up is a slowey. Yeah, sure.
EmmaI'm gonna go with Surf's Up.
SamSo Emma's going with Surf's Up. I'm gonna take the question seriously, gonna say Heaven no, I'm not. I'm gonna say Love, Death and an American Guitar. Listeners, if you had or might have or just have a suggestion for a Meat Loaf slash Steinman first dance, let us know. Chat out hell@gmail.com. and last one is, the email from Claire, Muncaster that I mentioned earlier. So, we've confirmed Claire, this isn't the final series. You can get back off the edge of But Claire's also suggested we review, She Waits by the Window on the Stoney and Meat Loaf album. Mm-hmm. that's not psychedelic soul, that's folk. Jim Steinman would've had a field day Claire adds some insightful commentary on the song, which no sense to me because I've not heard it yet. But Claire we'll take those on board and we'll put those on our suggestions list. Thank you for those. And if you've got any other suggestions of songs for us to listen to, you can email those as well. You can email too, chat
Emmachat out of hell@gmail.com.
SamAnd finally, Emma, there's one more email, which I have just found in our sent items.
EmmaSent items?
SamYeah. Very strange what it's called. the chicken ones are really nice.
EmmaOh God, what does it say?
SamIt says: Dear Heck's Sausages, open. Do you mind if we call you Heck's? We've been saying Heck's all this time, but actually your packets just say Heck, like how the supermarket is called Tesco but people call it Tesco's, as though it was owned by Kenny Tesco. Anyway, hello? No, first up, love the sausages, hashtag the chicken ones are really nice. My name is Sam Wilkinson and with my colleague Emma Crossland I host Chat out of Hell, Britain's most downloaded fortnightly podcast about the works of songwriter Jim Steinman and his musical collaborator and best bud Meat Loaf.
EmmaHang on just a second. Most downloaded because it's the only one
SamShush.
EmmaUhhuh do go on.
SamIt's all about the razzle dazzle. I guess you could say. Jim Steinman was the soft white roll to Meat Loaf's delicious Heck's Sausage. Why not give it a listen? Every episode we each pick a song by Meat or to research and present our findings to the other. There's a bit of discussion about the creative process, the musicians involved and their surprising links to other bits of pop culture, and then I always hide a surprise reference to Cotton Eye Joe by Rednex somewhere in the show to annoy Emma with, I bet I've really got her with this one. She thought she was safe by now. Did you know Rednex has 16 members and 12 former members. That's three packets of Heck's chipolatas you'd need just to give'em one sausage each with one each left over for Jim Steinman and Meat Loaf. What I'm saying is the show's good fun even if you're not a Meat Loaf fan, as long as you're up for occasional side chat about meat products and or the sauces you can pour on them, which you definitely would be, of course, give it a go. I know you are saying to yourself,"what is the point of this email, Sam? Don't waste my time sitting at this computer when I should be making a range of affordable but high quality sausages." The thing is, a while ago we learned that A1 sauce once ran an ad campaign with Meat Loaf. Do you know A1 sauce? It's like a thin version of brown sauce that Americans eat with steak. If you've never tried it, I've got an almost full bottle. You can have no really take it.
EmmaOkay. Yep.
SamI wrote to the A1 people to ask if they had any more info on what am I doing?
EmmaYou've started now.
SamA while ago I had a thought that if I could go back in time and tell my 20-year-old self I'd be interviewing the man who sang on Total Eclipse of the Heart, Uhhuh, he would be amazed. PS three months later, this is what I did. I wrote to the A1 people to ask if they had any more info on the ad campaign, but all I got was a very generic corporate email back and since then we've been on the lookout for other, better, meat associated companies to talk about instead. This series, we've been on a bit of a Heck's obsession So with that in mind, I have three questions I hope you could answer. One. What's your favourite Meat Loaf song? Two. Have you seen the full book performance of the Bat Out of Hell Musical that ran in Manchester in early 2017? And three. Any chance of some free sausages? Go on. Emma really loves the ones you do. Thanks, Sam and Emma. Chat out of Hell. It's weird. I don't know how that got in our outbox, Emma. It's the second time this has happened.
EmmaHow little work have you got on at the moment? Hence displacement activity. Astonishing email, Sam. Bravo Well done.
Samit was just there. It was just there.
EmmaI need to start checking our sent items as well as I received items
SamGot you, didn't I? You thought you were safe?
EmmaWhen did you send it?
SamJust today. Yeah. I wanted to put some tension in for the break that we're about to go on.
EmmaOh my God. We might get a reply. Yeah. we might. From some poor, baffled person at customer support.
SamWell, their email address is sausages at heck's dot co dot uk so, oh, well
Emmainviting this kind of bullshit then, isn't it?
Samyeah. Play stupid games, win stupid prizes.
EmmaWho's playing the stupid games? Us all sausages out. Heck.
Samwell, ideally it's, it is us, so that we wouldn't
EmmaI
Samyeah. All the listeners. Are you gonna be glad to not be doing this for a while?
Emmabecause I've been a bit stuck on Hang Cool Teddy Bear, I've not been having much fun. I'm looking forward to having fun songs again.
SamOkay. Soon. Well, we can have fun songs after the break. Yes, we are about to go on one of our regular breaks. We are taking a slightly longer break than we normally do because I am very selfishly going on a bit of a holiday in May. But we will be back on the 25th of May with our next edition of Chat out of Hell Film Club and because we are a podcast with our finger on the pulse of popular culture. Wuthering Heights was very recently all the rage, and by the time May comes along, there'll be zero rage about it whatsoever. We are gonna take a look at Jim's version of Wuthering Heights that he made for MTV in the early two thousands. You know how Cruel Intentions was a, modernised version of. Whatever it was a modernised version of
EmmaYes.
SamOh, les liasons dangerouses, Yeah. Ah, I know things. And also
Emma10 things I Hate About You was the modernised version it the Taming of the Shrew?
SamIt was Jim Steinman's modernised version of Wuthering Heights set in California, I believe, goes under the name of Wuthering Heights.
EmmaIt's gonna be fun.
SamAnd if film adaptations of classic novels ruined by Jim Steinman aren't your thing, then we'll be back with the regular podcast two weeks after that on June the eighth where we'll be listening to.
EmmaStark Raving Love from Bad for Good,
Samand I'm gonna be bringing Razor's Edge from Midnight at the Lost and Found. And they're not rubbish, Emma. Yes. So if you've got opinions on those, let us know. Chat out of hell@gmail.com. don't forget to give us five stars on your podcast listening apps. That does a thing with an algorithm where when people do it, it recommends us to somebody else. So it is quite nice if people want to do that.
Emmaus with
Samrecommends to your friends and family across a big Easter egg. We're gonna be gone over Easter. And just keep your Meat Loaf thoughts and anecdotes flying in. Did you see Meat Loaf on Robot Wars operating Razor, the most successful robot in the world with 40 victories and only seven defeats thanks to its hydraulic crusher and hardened steel armour, let us know. Chat out of hell@gmail.com. Use the hashtag, the chicken ones are really nice, keep eating those Heck sausages. Emma, any other thoughts? all. No thoughts whatsoever. Thanks for listening to Chat out of Hell. We've enjoyed it. Hopefully you have too. We'll see you in a couple of months.
EmmaBye
SamBye bow now, now, now. Ding.