How To Be A Handmade Boss

#81 - Why Your Etsy Listings Aren’t Selling (and What’s Really Going On)

Steph Cole-Lewis Season 1 Episode 81

Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.

0:00 | 20:29

You’ve poured time into your products, uploaded them to Etsy, and maybe you’re even getting some traffic and a few favourites… but sales? Crickets. 😬

In today’s episode, we’re unpacking the real reason why your Etsy listings aren’t converting  and no, it’s not just the algorithm.

I’m breaking down the 3 essential layers of a high-converting listing:
        1.        Getting found in search (hello, buyer keywords!)
        2.        Getting clicked (your thumbnail matters more than you think)
        3.        Getting purchased (because a nice listing isn’t enough)

This is a must-listen if you’ve ever said:
        •        “My views are up but no one’s buying”
        •        “I don’t know what else to try”
        •        “I think I’ve hit a plateau…”

💡 You’ll leave with clear examples, real-life success stories, and quick wins you can action today - even if you’re a total beginner.

🎯 Plus: I’ll share a juicy comparison between two sellers - one stuck in the Etsy spiral, and one who made 3 small changes and tripled her conversion rate.

📌 Homework included (yep, we’re doing this properly):
Choose one listing and optimise it using what you learn today.

Whether you’re new or just feeling stuck, this episode will help you spot what’s actually going wrong and fix it.

Insta CTA

If social media feels way harder than it should… this is for you.

Fix Your Socials Week starts 16th April … it’s a free challenge for handmade business owners who are fed up overthinking content and still not seeing sales.

Give me 10 minutes a day for five days and I’ll help you get clear on what to post, what to stop doing, and how to show up online without it taking over your life.

No fluff.

No pressure.

No trying to keep up with everyone else.

Just practical support that actually makes sense.

Sign up now at www.handmadebosses.com/fixyoursocials

The link’s also in the show notes.