How To Be A Handmade Boss

#84 - Why More Etsy Listings Won’t Fix Your Sales Problem

Steph Cole-Lewis Season 1 Episode 84

Think slow sales mean you need to add more products? Think again.

In this episode, I’m busting one of the biggest myths in the handmade world: that more listings = more sales. Spoiler alert - it’s not about quantity. It’s about quality, clarity, and conversion.

We’ll talk about:
✅ Why uploading random new products could actually be hurting your shop
✅ The real reason Etsy rewards certain listings (hint: it’s not how many you have)
✅ What to do instead: smarter product variations, giftable bundles, and clarity around your niche
✅ Real-life examples of handmade sellers who scaled down to grow up

Whether you’re stuck in a sales slump or constantly churning out new designs hoping something will “take off”, this episode will help you shift your focus to what actually moves the needle.

🎯 ACTION STEP:
Instead of creating something brand new this week, take your top-selling product and make one thoughtful variation - a new colour, size, or giftable version. That’s how you build momentum without the burnout.

FREEBIE: The “More Listings” Myth Fix Worksheet  

Insta CTA

🎙 Welcome to the Handmade Bosses Podcast with Steph 👋

If you’re dreaming of starting your handmade business or knee-deep in Etsy listings and feeling stuck - you’re in the right place.

I’m Steph - handmade business coach, Etsy seller since 2016, and founder of Handmade Bosses. I help makers go from overwhelmed to consistent sales (yes, even if you’re just starting).


🛍 Learn how to:

• Start and grow on Etsy

• Turn browsers into buyers

• Master SEO, branding, pricing

• Find your niche and ideal customer

• Scale beyond Etsy to your own website


💸 I’ve helped thousands of makers build profitable 4 and 5-figure shops — and in this podcast, I’ll show you how too.


✨ Free starter resources: handmadebosses.com/freeresources


🎓 Deeper help? Explore the HBSA, the SMS & more: handmadebosses.com/paidresources


📅 Join our Facebook group for free workshops: facebook.com/groups/handmadebosses/events


📸 Follow us on Instagram for tips and inspo: instagram.com/handmadebosses


Hit follow, grab a brew, and let’s grow your handmade biz.


Love, ...