The Monster Mashup

MM Mini Ep 2. - The Hex Hollow Murder

The Monster Mashup Season 1 Episode 17

Send us a text

In 1928, three men from rural Pennsylvania murdered a local powwow healer named Nelson Rehmeyer. Why? They believed he'd put a curse on them. Known as the Hex Hollow Murder, this bizarre true crime case blends backwoods superstition and folk magic with the desperation to ditch bad luck. What drove these men to kill? And why does the legend still haunt York County nearly a century later? 

For full-length episodes, check out the Monster Mashup wherever you listen to podcasts.

Follow us on all platforms for behind-the-scenes content, bloopers, short episodes and more!

Instagram - @themonstermashuppodcast

TikTok - @themonstermashup

YouTube - @themonstermashuppodcast

Send us an email at themonstermashuppodcast@gmail.com.

We appreciate your support. Stay spooky!