45: Should We Have Another Baby? My Honest Journey to Baby Number Two (Season II finale)

Redefining Us

Redefining Us
45: Should We Have Another Baby? My Honest Journey to Baby Number Two (Season II finale)
Jun 11, 2026 Season 2 Episode 45
Stephanie Konter O'Hara

Should we have another baby?

It's a question many parents wrestle with, and the answer isn't always clear.

In this deeply personal solo episode, Stephanie shares her journey from being firmly "one and done" to ultimately deciding to grow her family. Along the way, she opens up about the fears that made the decision so difficult: concerns about mental health, finances, identity, marriage, career, and whether she could show up for two children the way she wanted to.

Whether you're longing for another child, feeling unsure, or grieving that the answer may be no, this conversation offers an honest look at the reality that expanding a family is rarely a simple decision. Even when the answer becomes yes, it often comes with uncertainty, sacrifice, and the willingness to step into a new season without knowing exactly what lies ahead.

If you've ever wondered whether your family is complete or felt pressure to have an answer before you're ready, this episode is for you.

This episode completes Season II of the Redefining Us podcast. We will be back at the start of 2027 and look forward to being with you all again then! For now, I’m going to go enjoy some newborn snuggles with our second. 



Please leave us a review or rating! These help get the show out to more women like you wanting to have these conversations.

Would you like to chat more about this episode's topic? I would love to continue our conversation over on Instagram! @wellmindedcounseling

I wrote a book! Becoming Mommy: Aligning with yourself and finding your voice during pregnancy and motherhood, available at all major retailers - https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0DZT9P3RB?ref=cm_sw_r_ffobk_cp_ud_dp_KFT90ZBDS48FDGG6DH5X&ref_=cm_sw_r_ffobk_cp_ud_dp_KFT90ZBDS48FDGG6DH5X&social_share=cm_sw_r_ffobk_cp_ud_dp_KFT90ZBDS48FDGG6DH5X&bestFormat=true

Where to find more from Redefining Us:
Website: wellmindedcounseling.com/redefining-us-pod
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/wellmindedcounseling
Instagram: @wellmindedcounseling

If you want to support the show so we can continue sharing this content with others like you, you may do so here at, Buy Me A Coffee. From the bottom of our hearts, thank you!

Episode Artwork 45: Should We Have Another Baby? My Honest Journey to Baby Number Two (Season II finale) 19:55 Episode Artwork 44: Life Transitions | You’re Not Lost — You’re Becoming 20:02 Episode Artwork 43: She Built a Business While Navigating Postpartum and Burnout with Sydney Clare 35:26 Episode Artwork 42: Feeling Seen Through a Late Autism Diagnosis and it's Reveal During Motherhood with Anahita Lake-Khosravi, PsyD 36:18 Episode Artwork 41: Why “Tight” Isn’t the Goal for Your Pelvic Health (And What Actually Is) with Dr. Paige Rainford 31:29 Episode Artwork 40: Why Letting Your Child Struggle Might Be the Most Loving Thing You Do 12:49 Episode Artwork 39: Raising Kids Without Losing Yourself with Coach Shea Guerra LeJeune 31:39 Episode Artwork 38: More Than Muscles: The Pelvic Floor, Trauma, and Coming Home to Your Body with Amelia May 31:29 Episode Artwork 37: Doing Business Like A Mother with Jen Morris 36:58 Episode Artwork 36: When Discomfort Is the Path to Connection with Annmarie Chereso 34:35 Episode Artwork 35: Redefining Yourself Through Community and Creativity with Shani Raviv 27:34 Episode Artwork 34: The Weight of Decisions and Relationships 19:03 Episode Artwork 33: How Craniosacral Therapy Supports Parents and Kids with Lisa Foster 38:10 Episode Artwork 32: Navigating Your Identity Through Values Work 20:53 Episode Artwork 31: Postpartum Healing Through Connection and Nourishment with Radha Crawley 53:33 Episode Artwork 30: Helping Your Baby Feel Good in Their Body with Dr. Brita DeStefano 32:25 Episode Artwork 29: From Unexpected Pregnancy to 7-Figure Entrepreneur: Christy Pennison’s Story 40:59 Episode Artwork 28: Reclaiming Yourself Beyond Burnout with Jenn Ohlinger 45:02 Episode Artwork 27: Riding the Waves of Anxiety and Guilt in Motherhood 14:40 Episode Artwork 26: Giving Yourself Permission to Pivot 17:19 Episode Artwork 25: Breaking the Myths and Stigma Around Postpartum Depression with Courtney Miller 35:21 Episode Artwork 24: The Urgent Case for Comprehensive Sex Ed in a Changing World with Scotney Young 42:55 Episode Artwork 23: Motherhood, Matrescence, and the Healing Power of Art with Leanne Morton 44:30 Episode Artwork 22: Fertility, Lab Work, and Being Told You're "Fine" with Lauren Mallers 47:34 Episode Artwork 21: Perfectionism and the Good Girl Script with Brooke Jean, MA, LPC 43:19