Is This the End of Star Trek? Starfleet Academy Ep 1+2

Star Trek fans were ready to be mad.
Instead… we found a lot to love.

In this SPOILERS-FILLED discussion of Star Trek: Starfleet Academy Episodes 1 & 2, our Observers sit down as longtime Trek fans to talk through the moments, ideas, and creative choices that surprised us—in a good way. This isn’t a scene-by-scene recap; it’s a big-picture conversation about why these opening episodes feel rooted in Trek’s core, even as they push the franchise somewhere new.

We dig into the themes, character dynamics, representation, and tone that have already sparked heated debate online—and why a lot of the early backlash might be overlooking the heart of what Starfleet Academy is trying to do.

If you’re skeptical, cautiously optimistic, or already defending the show in the group chat, this episode is us making the case for why Starfleet Academy deserves a fair shot.

Join our crew! Like! Share! Leave a review!

@STFrom60KLY @JClark787 @TrekkieB47