Talkin' with the AD

8 - Athlete Mental Health: What Coaches & Parents Get Wrong (Expert Roundtable)

Coach Morgan Sullivan, CAA, RMSAA, CIC, NFHS Level 3 Coach, NFHS Level 3 MS Coach Season 2026 Episode 3

Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.

0:00 | 1:29:57

Send us Fan Mail

Athlete mental health can't be fixed with a slogan, a one-time awareness day, or "toughen up." In this Talkin' with the AD roundtable, five professionals — mental health counselors, an athletic trainer, coaches, and a mental performance specialist — break down what today's student-athletes are really facing (anxiety, depression, perfectionism, burnout, recruiting pressure, and the loss of identity when a career ends) and the well-intentioned coaching habits that quietly do damage. If you're an athletic director, coach, or sports parent, this is the practical playbook for putting the person before the athlete.

The panel gets into the coaching behaviors that hurt without meaning to — public criticism, indirect communication, unexplained lineup changes, and correcting an athlete who's still highly emotional — and what to do instead: build the relationship, communicate directly, give athletes room to process, and make sure young people know their worth isn't set by their stats or their spot in the lineup.

The core message: when adults build environments where athletes feel seen, heard, and valued beyond the scoreboard, they don't soften competition — they build healthier teams, stronger athletes, and better people.

MEET THE PANEL

Liza Simrell, LPCC-S — Licensed professional clinical counselor and certified mental game coach (Toledo, OH); former collegiate basketball player, varsity coach, recruiter, and official. (Liza Simrell Counseling)

Bill Hoopes — Navy veteran, former educator and coach, founder of Lead Your Journey; leads Florida Premier Girls Fastpitch and has helped hundreds of softball players pursue college opportunities.

Danielle Vallas, LMHC, M.Ed. — Licensed mental health counselor, former school wellness director, author, and founder of D&G Wellness Consulting; creator of The Inner Game: A Mental Health Journal for Peak Performance in Sports and founder of Buffalo Believes.

Meghan Johnson, MA, LAPC, LAT, ATC, NCC — Licensed associate professional counselor, certified athletic trainer, and mental performance coach with Next Level Mental Performance; former collegiate softball player.

Kim Griffin, MHC-P — Mental health counselor and former NCAA Division I softball coach; nearly two decades at Canisius University, including 11 seasons as head coach. (Core Mental Health Counseling)

MEMORABLE MOMENTS

"Put the person first — not the athlete." — Liza Simrell
 "You're not building a softball player. You're building a strong, powerful woman who can use the game as a vessel." — Bill Hoopes
 "It doesn't take a special certification or a fancy degree to be an active listener." — Meghan Johnson
 "Our brains are prediction machines." — Kim Griffin
 Athletes often don't need a coach to fix the situation — they need the coach to stay present.
 Be the thermostat that regulates the environment, not the thermometer that just reflects it.

ACTION STEPS FOR ATHLETIC DIRECTORS

Create a written mental health emergency action plan for home and away contests.
 Set clear procedures for when school counselors aren't available.
 Build mental health awareness and referral steps into preseason coach training.
 Connect coaches, counselors, athletic trainers, administrators, and nurses before a crisis.
 Keep a vetted list of local and telehealth mental health professionals.
 Explain mandatory reporting and confidentiality boundaries to every coach.
 Create recurring athlete check-in systems across every program.
 Model help-seeking, emotional regulation, and healthy boundaries from the top.

PRACTICAL STRATEGIES FOR COACHES

The Percentage Check-In — Athletes name the energy they brought that day ("I'm at 60%"); the team answers, "We've got the other 40%." Builds a habit and surfaces patterns.
 Weekly Athlete Journal — Short reflection (what went well, what challenged you, what support you need) — an easier route for athletes who struggle face-to-face.
 Shoulder-to-Shoulder Conversations — Many young people open up more while moving and looking ahead, not in direct eye contact.
 Post-Competition Feedback Rule — Right after a game, lead with effort and connection; save technical correction for when everyone's regulated.

⏱️ Chapter timestamps go here once you pull them — chapters boost both watch-time and search.

MORE PODCASTS FOR ADs, COACHES & SPORTS PARENTS

If you care about education-based athletics, these are worth a follow:
 Educational AD Podcast
 Hangin' with the ADs Podcast
 Pure Athlete Podcast
 Youth Inc with Greg Olson Podcast
 Healthy Sports Parents Podcast
 AD 360 Podcast
 Middle School AD Podcast
 AD Insider Podcast

Talkin' with the AD is a podcast for athletic directors, school leaders, coaches, parents, and athletes — built around education-based athletics and the people who make it work. Hosted by Morgan J. Sullivan — athletic director, coach, and author of Coach on Leadership.

LEAD · TEACH · GROW

🔗 Free resources and more at betteryouthcoaching.com
 ▶️ Subscribe on YouTube and follow wherever you listen so you never miss an episode
 📩 Got a question for the show? Send it in — it might get answered in an upcoming Mailbag
 ⭐ If this one helped, leave a rating and review — it helps more ADs, coaches, and families find the show
 📚 Read Coach on Leadership, MS Education Based Athletics, and Before the First Snap by author Morgan J. Sullivan

#TalkinWithTheAD · #Sports · #Athletics · #AthleticDirector · #CoachonLeadership · #AthleteWellBeing

Welcome to Talkin' with the AD! 

LET'S GO!!

Better Youth Coaching
Mission is to improve amateur sports through education of parents, coaches, and athletes

Better Youth Coaching
Mission is to improve amateur sports through education of parents, coaches, and athletes

Support the show

Visit betteryouthcoaching.com - information for parents, coaches, and athletes.

SOCIALS

Facebook - talkinwiththead

X - Talkin’ with the AD

Instagram - talkin_with_the_ad

YouTube - Talkin' with the AD

Tik Tok - Talkin' with the AD