{"version":"1.0.0","segments":[{"startTime":0.0,"endTime":1.289,"body":"You can have a hive."},{"startTime":1.289,"endTime":5.479,"body":"My made up of intelligent individuals,"},{"startTime":1.289,"endTime":5.479,"body":"for example, I was thinking of a situation"},{"startTime":5.479,"endTime":10.219,"body":"where maybe you have a hive made up"},{"startTime":5.479,"endTime":10.219,"body":"of individuals who have human level"},{"startTime":10.219,"endTime":14.219,"body":"intelligence, but they just have really"},{"startTime":10.219,"endTime":14.219,"body":"strong biological responses to certain"},{"startTime":14.219,"endTime":18.677,"body":"stimuli, Like pheromones or even sounds,"},{"startTime":14.219,"endTime":18.677,"body":"and it's not hard to imagine, right?"},{"startTime":18.677,"endTime":19.787,"body":"Humans have that already."},{"startTime":19.787,"endTime":20.657,"body":"We have empathy."},{"startTime":21.077,"endTime":23.597,"body":"Naturally, if I see someone"},{"startTime":21.077,"endTime":23.597,"body":"in trouble, the human response"},{"startTime":23.597,"endTime":24.707,"body":"is that you want to help,"},{"startTime":24.827,"endTime":25.067,"body":"right?"},{"startTime":25.187,"endTime":26.357,"body":"But we can walk away from that."},{"startTime":26.357,"endTime":27.707,"body":"We can override that response."},{"startTime":27.707,"endTime":31.201,"body":"But imagine a species evolving where"},{"startTime":27.707,"endTime":31.201,"body":"they can't, where if there's a, a"},{"startTime":31.201,"endTime":35.161,"body":"call for help, they, they're literally"},{"startTime":31.201,"endTime":35.161,"body":"biologically forced to respond."},{"startTime":35.521,"endTime":38.131,"body":"And in that way, you could"},{"startTime":35.521,"endTime":38.131,"body":"potentially have a hive mind"},{"startTime":38.131,"endTime":39.781,"body":"made up of very intelligent."},{"startTime":39.866,"endTime":43.826,"body":"individual members, it's just"},{"startTime":39.866,"endTime":43.826,"body":"that they feel compelled to"},{"startTime":43.826,"endTime":45.956,"body":"respond to the cues of the hive."},{"startTime":51.413,"endTime":55.283,"body":"Hello and welcome to Entropy Rising,"},{"startTime":51.413,"endTime":55.283,"body":"a podcast dedicated to talking about"},{"startTime":55.283,"endTime":58.163,"body":"the science and science fiction and"},{"startTime":55.283,"endTime":58.163,"body":"taking a realistic look at where"},{"startTime":58.163,"endTime":59.183,"body":"we could end up in the future."},{"startTime":59.648,"endTime":64.358,"body":"I'm your host Jacob, and joining me"},{"startTime":59.648,"endTime":64.358,"body":"is my always lovely co-host Lucas."},{"startTime":64.478,"endTime":65.258,"body":"You think I'm lovely?"},{"startTime":65.408,"endTime":65.858,"body":"Thank you."},{"startTime":65.918,"endTime":66.548,"body":"I do, I do."},{"startTime":66.548,"endTime":68.408,"body":"Yeah, no, I think that's"},{"startTime":66.548,"endTime":68.408,"body":"an accurate description."},{"startTime":68.528,"endTime":69.158,"body":"Wonderful."},{"startTime":69.168,"endTime":70.668,"body":"I'm doing great, Jake and yourself?"},{"startTime":70.878,"endTime":71.928,"body":"I'm doing wonderful."},{"startTime":71.928,"endTime":75.318,"body":"I'm happy to be recording and"},{"startTime":71.928,"endTime":75.318,"body":"I'm really excited for the"},{"startTime":75.318,"endTime":76.848,"body":"topic we're diving into today."},{"startTime":77.238,"endTime":81.258,"body":"Where we're gonna be looking at hive"},{"startTime":77.238,"endTime":81.258,"body":"mines are gonna be taking a dive into,"},{"startTime":81.439,"endTime":85.518,"body":"how hive mines could realistically"},{"startTime":81.439,"endTime":85.518,"body":"evolve in nature and and talk about if"},{"startTime":85.518,"endTime":89.898,"body":"that's possible for group intelligence"},{"startTime":85.518,"endTime":89.898,"body":"to evolve from a natural perspective."},{"startTime":89.988,"endTime":93.318,"body":"We're gonna be talking about how"},{"startTime":89.988,"endTime":93.318,"body":"advanced species may actually."},{"startTime":93.828,"endTime":98.238,"body":"Grow into, uh, networked intelligences"},{"startTime":93.828,"endTime":98.238,"body":"and hive minds and really just be"},{"startTime":98.238,"endTime":99.798,"body":"looking at everything in between."},{"startTime":99.798,"endTime":101.808,"body":"So I think this will be"},{"startTime":99.798,"endTime":101.808,"body":"an interesting topic."},{"startTime":101.808,"endTime":105.087,"body":"And think it lines up well with,"},{"startTime":101.808,"endTime":105.087,"body":"uh, I know I just watched Pluribus."},{"startTime":105.087,"endTime":106.077,"body":"I think that's the name of the show."},{"startTime":106.077,"endTime":107.247,"body":"I hope I'm not mispronouncing it."},{"startTime":107.337,"endTime":107.487,"body":"Oh,"},{"startTime":107.487,"endTime":107.757,"body":"yeah."},{"startTime":107.817,"endTime":110.656,"body":"It definitely inspired us,"},{"startTime":107.817,"endTime":110.656,"body":"to think about this concept"},{"startTime":110.656,"endTime":110.806,"body":"and"},{"startTime":110.806,"endTime":113.596,"body":"I dive a little bit deeper into"},{"startTime":110.806,"endTime":113.596,"body":"it, so it should be very exciting."},{"startTime":113.656,"endTime":114.586,"body":"No, absolutely."},{"startTime":114.586,"endTime":115.906,"body":"So I'm looking forward to it."},{"startTime":115.906,"endTime":118.396,"body":"And I've always been a huge fan"},{"startTime":115.906,"endTime":118.396,"body":"of things like Star Trek and"},{"startTime":118.396,"endTime":119.986,"body":"the Borg has always been a huge."},{"startTime":120.556,"endTime":120.886,"body":"I don't know."},{"startTime":120.886,"endTime":121.936,"body":"Frightening entity."},{"startTime":122.296,"endTime":122.356,"body":"No."},{"startTime":122.356,"endTime":122.536,"body":"Great"},{"startTime":122.536,"endTime":123.286,"body":"antagonist."},{"startTime":123.346,"endTime":124.276,"body":"Yeah, absolutely."},{"startTime":124.276,"endTime":126.226,"body":"And it's not the only hive mind"},{"startTime":124.276,"endTime":126.226,"body":"we've see in science fiction."},{"startTime":126.226,"endTime":129.155,"body":"So I do think this is gonna"},{"startTime":126.226,"endTime":129.155,"body":"be, a fun topic, uh, and, and"},{"startTime":129.155,"endTime":130.535,"body":"rife with, uh, source material."},{"startTime":130.685,"endTime":130.775,"body":"Mm-hmm."},{"startTime":131.135,"endTime":131.795,"body":"Absolutely."},{"startTime":132.011,"endTime":136.121,"body":"So first I thought it would be good to"},{"startTime":132.011,"endTime":136.121,"body":"actually talk about what a hive mind is"},{"startTime":136.121,"endTime":137.643,"body":"and the different types that can exist."},{"startTime":137.815,"endTime":141.232,"body":"Yeah, that's a great thing to dive"},{"startTime":137.815,"endTime":141.232,"body":"into with first, because I feel"},{"startTime":141.232,"endTime":144.502,"body":"like a lot of people have different"},{"startTime":141.232,"endTime":144.502,"body":"concepts of what hive minds are."},{"startTime":145.087,"endTime":151.307,"body":"They might even, misplace them with a more"},{"startTime":145.087,"endTime":151.307,"body":"like a networked intelligence, which is a"},{"startTime":151.307,"endTime":153.843,"body":"larger, subsection of what a hive mind is."},{"startTime":153.843,"endTime":157.653,"body":"A hive mind falls into that category, but"},{"startTime":153.843,"endTime":157.653,"body":"they have key differences between them."},{"startTime":158.253,"endTime":160.593,"body":"So, Jake, what to you is a hive mind?"},{"startTime":161.043,"endTime":161.373,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":161.373,"endTime":164.613,"body":"So I guess, and I might fall under"},{"startTime":161.373,"endTime":164.613,"body":"the same issue 'cause I, you said"},{"startTime":164.613,"endTime":166.233,"body":"networked intelligences and I do agree."},{"startTime":166.233,"endTime":167.103,"body":"I do think that."},{"startTime":167.478,"endTime":170.448,"body":"A networked intelligence can fall"},{"startTime":167.478,"endTime":170.448,"body":"under that category of hive mind."},{"startTime":170.448,"endTime":175.098,"body":"But when you say hive mind specifically,"},{"startTime":170.448,"endTime":175.098,"body":"I think what comes to my mind is a"},{"startTime":175.098,"endTime":180.138,"body":"situation where the individual kind"},{"startTime":175.098,"endTime":180.138,"body":"of ceases to exist and they work"},{"startTime":180.138,"endTime":182.148,"body":"for the greater good of the groups."},{"startTime":182.148,"endTime":184.938,"body":"This can be something like maybe"},{"startTime":182.148,"endTime":184.938,"body":"an ant and an ant colony, or"},{"startTime":184.938,"endTime":186.768,"body":"like a drone from the Borg where."},{"startTime":186.873,"endTime":188.604,"body":"you don't really have individuality."},{"startTime":188.604,"endTime":192.804,"body":"You are just a part of a broader"},{"startTime":188.604,"endTime":192.804,"body":"collective, and maybe in the most"},{"startTime":192.804,"endTime":196.854,"body":"extreme case, that broader collective"},{"startTime":192.804,"endTime":196.854,"body":"can be one controlling consciousness"},{"startTime":196.854,"endTime":200.154,"body":"that's essentially spread out"},{"startTime":196.854,"endTime":200.154,"body":"over a bunch of biological nodes."},{"startTime":200.184,"endTime":203.574,"body":"With those biological nodes being the"},{"startTime":200.184,"endTime":203.574,"body":"individuals who make up the hive mind."},{"startTime":203.934,"endTime":206.214,"body":"See, I 100% agree with you."},{"startTime":206.304,"endTime":211.494,"body":"It's that loss of your ability to be"},{"startTime":206.304,"endTime":211.494,"body":"an individual in any capacity, right?"},{"startTime":211.494,"endTime":214.914,"body":"I feel like is what really creates"},{"startTime":211.494,"endTime":214.914,"body":"that vision of a hive mind."},{"startTime":215.349,"endTime":220.479,"body":"Where you're all just working for the"},{"startTime":215.349,"endTime":220.479,"body":"network or for the gestural consciousness,"},{"startTime":220.479,"endTime":221.889,"body":"whatever it is that you're working for."},{"startTime":221.889,"endTime":224.919,"body":"It's that complete loss of"},{"startTime":221.889,"endTime":224.919,"body":"who you are as a person."},{"startTime":224.979,"endTime":228.369,"body":"But there are a lot of different steps"},{"startTime":224.979,"endTime":228.369,"body":"that I feel like people confuse hive"},{"startTime":228.369,"endTime":232.539,"body":"minds with when it comes to network"},{"startTime":228.369,"endTime":232.539,"body":"consciousness leading into a hive mind."},{"startTime":233.019,"endTime":237.189,"body":"Like you can argue that there's a lot"},{"startTime":233.019,"endTime":237.189,"body":"of things right now that are network"},{"startTime":237.189,"endTime":241.359,"body":"consciousness is, and that's because"},{"startTime":237.189,"endTime":241.359,"body":"a network consciousness is just the"},{"startTime":241.359,"endTime":243.249,"body":"transfer of information between."},{"startTime":243.459,"endTime":246.277,"body":"it can be between, you know, a"},{"startTime":243.459,"endTime":246.277,"body":"race, like, like you can consider"},{"startTime":246.277,"endTime":248.107,"body":"humanity as a network consciousness."},{"startTime":248.467,"endTime":250.897,"body":"You can consider some of the"},{"startTime":248.467,"endTime":250.897,"body":"things that we've done as adding"},{"startTime":250.897,"endTime":252.097,"body":"to our network consciousness."},{"startTime":252.097,"endTime":255.367,"body":"Like writing was a great,"},{"startTime":252.097,"endTime":255.367,"body":"great example of that."},{"startTime":255.757,"endTime":261.007,"body":"We were able to bring in information from"},{"startTime":255.757,"endTime":261.007,"body":"living people and transcend not only space"},{"startTime":261.037,"endTime":265.597,"body":"by sending the letters,  but also time by"},{"startTime":261.037,"endTime":265.597,"body":"incorporating people who have passed on."},{"startTime":265.76,"endTime":267.71,"body":"that transfer of information was great."},{"startTime":267.74,"endTime":271.07,"body":"And then you can move into"},{"startTime":267.74,"endTime":271.07,"body":"things like, um, cities, which"},{"startTime":271.07,"endTime":272.758,"body":"are networks on their own."},{"startTime":273.388,"endTime":275.998,"body":"Um, and that is also within"},{"startTime":273.388,"endTime":275.998,"body":"humanities bounds that you can"},{"startTime":275.998,"endTime":277.378,"body":"transfer information faster."},{"startTime":277.378,"endTime":280.558,"body":"And then finally, the biggest leap that"},{"startTime":277.378,"endTime":280.558,"body":"we've had so far, and that a lot of us"},{"startTime":280.558,"endTime":284.488,"body":"have noticed and some of us are even"},{"startTime":280.558,"endTime":284.488,"body":"old enough to remember a time without,"},{"startTime":284.488,"endTime":289.298,"body":"was the internet that created us to"},{"startTime":284.488,"endTime":289.298,"body":"be a gigantic, networked intelligence"},{"startTime":289.298,"endTime":290.798,"body":"and really expand in that way."},{"startTime":291.001,"endTime":292.651,"body":"I think you hit a lot"},{"startTime":291.001,"endTime":292.651,"body":"of nails in the head."},{"startTime":292.651,"endTime":295.591,"body":"And then one that you didn't specifically"},{"startTime":292.651,"endTime":295.591,"body":"state that I do wanna dive into"},{"startTime":295.591,"endTime":298.141,"body":"'cause is really important is the"},{"startTime":295.591,"endTime":298.141,"body":"invention of verbal communication."},{"startTime":298.501,"endTime":301.981,"body":"I think more than anything really made"},{"startTime":298.501,"endTime":301.981,"body":"us the network intelligence that we are."},{"startTime":302.221,"endTime":306.331,"body":"It's an amazing way to communicate"},{"startTime":302.221,"endTime":306.331,"body":"ideas and share values and, and you"},{"startTime":306.331,"endTime":309.596,"body":"can argue, I think that humanity is"},{"startTime":306.331,"endTime":309.596,"body":"on that spectrum of hive mind, right?"},{"startTime":309.596,"endTime":309.796,"body":"Mm-hmm."},{"startTime":309.876,"endTime":312.571,"body":"It's not, obviously we're not a"},{"startTime":309.876,"endTime":312.571,"body":"hive mind, we're not a collective"},{"startTime":312.571,"endTime":315.931,"body":"intelligence, but we are in many"},{"startTime":312.571,"endTime":315.931,"body":"ways, like an ant colony or a bees."},{"startTime":316.566,"endTime":320.286,"body":"We joined together to make up a"},{"startTime":316.566,"endTime":320.286,"body":"civilization that's greater than"},{"startTime":320.286,"endTime":321.546,"body":"the sum of all of its parts."},{"startTime":321.906,"endTime":324.906,"body":"And for me, I think that it"},{"startTime":321.906,"endTime":324.906,"body":"does make sense that you could"},{"startTime":324.906,"endTime":327.456,"body":"consider us, uh, a network"},{"startTime":324.906,"endTime":327.456,"body":"intelligence, at least to an extent."},{"startTime":327.546,"endTime":330.876,"body":"And that's something that we might"},{"startTime":327.546,"endTime":330.876,"body":"continue to expand upon in the future."},{"startTime":331.116,"endTime":335.166,"body":"Obviously we've added many technologies"},{"startTime":331.116,"endTime":335.166,"body":"in our, under our tool belt, like"},{"startTime":335.166,"endTime":336.456,"body":"writing, like you mentioned before."},{"startTime":336.456,"endTime":339.666,"body":"Also, of course, the internet"},{"startTime":336.456,"endTime":339.666,"body":"would be hard to understate"},{"startTime":339.666,"endTime":340.446,"body":"what that's done for us."},{"startTime":340.446,"endTime":341.316,"body":"So no, absolutely."},{"startTime":341.316,"endTime":342.096,"body":"I agree with that."},{"startTime":342.436,"endTime":345.526,"body":"I do wonder, do you think there"},{"startTime":342.436,"endTime":345.526,"body":"could be situations where."},{"startTime":345.926,"endTime":349.466,"body":"Humanity is, I think, a fairly low"},{"startTime":345.926,"endTime":349.466,"body":"level of network intelligence, right?"},{"startTime":349.466,"endTime":352.166,"body":"We're still very individualistic,"},{"startTime":349.466,"endTime":352.166,"body":"even if we are able to"},{"startTime":352.166,"endTime":353.456,"body":"communicate and share ideas."},{"startTime":353.456,"endTime":357.078,"body":"But I, I wonder how in nature, you could"},{"startTime":353.456,"endTime":357.078,"body":"see hive minds developing and forming."},{"startTime":357.473,"endTime":359.243,"body":"to a greater extent than"},{"startTime":357.473,"endTime":359.243,"body":"what humanity has done."},{"startTime":359.243,"endTime":363.533,"body":"And maybe also not just a hive mine,"},{"startTime":359.243,"endTime":363.533,"body":"like an ant colony or a bees nest,"},{"startTime":363.533,"endTime":367.043,"body":"but a, a true civilization scale."},{"startTime":367.253,"endTime":370.373,"body":"Maybe able to go into a space and"},{"startTime":367.253,"endTime":370.373,"body":"build advanced technology hive"},{"startTime":370.373,"endTime":372.143,"body":"mine from a natural background."},{"startTime":372.4,"endTime":376.45,"body":"That is actually a super interesting"},{"startTime":372.4,"endTime":376.45,"body":"question to ponder because we"},{"startTime":376.45,"endTime":380.197,"body":"think of humanity as it progressing"},{"startTime":376.45,"endTime":380.197,"body":"right, through these different ages."},{"startTime":380.197,"endTime":384.01,"body":"But we do it with the help of technology"},{"startTime":380.197,"endTime":384.01,"body":"and through structure, like, like"},{"startTime":384.01,"endTime":388.54,"body":"building channels to go back and"},{"startTime":384.01,"endTime":388.54,"body":"forth with our technology now going"},{"startTime":388.54,"endTime":390.49,"body":"to a more biological standpoint."},{"startTime":390.885,"endTime":395.813,"body":"I feel like this really is what encourages"},{"startTime":390.885,"endTime":395.813,"body":"that, feel of what a hive mine could be."},{"startTime":396.203,"endTime":398.843,"body":"Because now we're talking"},{"startTime":396.203,"endTime":398.843,"body":"about literal hives."},{"startTime":398.883,"endTime":401.453,"body":"like insects of course are"},{"startTime":398.883,"endTime":401.453,"body":"going to be our starting point."},{"startTime":401.813,"endTime":404.397,"body":"I feel like we see that"},{"startTime":401.813,"endTime":404.397,"body":"the most with ant colonies."},{"startTime":404.397,"endTime":405.147,"body":"And bees nest."},{"startTime":405.147,"endTime":405.537,"body":"Or bees."},{"startTime":405.542,"endTime":405.732,"body":"Hi."},{"startTime":406.112,"endTime":410.328,"body":"they have individuals that are able"},{"startTime":406.112,"endTime":410.328,"body":"to communicate through chemical"},{"startTime":410.328,"endTime":413.732,"body":"means or through different dancing"},{"startTime":410.328,"endTime":413.732,"body":"means that are very subtle, but"},{"startTime":413.732,"endTime":415.172,"body":"convey a lot of information."},{"startTime":415.562,"endTime":418.172,"body":"And that information isn't being"},{"startTime":415.562,"endTime":418.172,"body":"conveyed over there, but it's"},{"startTime":418.532,"endTime":421.652,"body":"triggering something in them to know"},{"startTime":418.532,"endTime":421.652,"body":"that that's what they need to do next."},{"startTime":421.652,"endTime":425.095,"body":"So with a small action,"},{"startTime":421.652,"endTime":425.095,"body":"you create a big response."},{"startTime":425.34,"endTime":429.96,"body":"I feel like if that continues and"},{"startTime":425.34,"endTime":429.96,"body":"something were to want to evolve to"},{"startTime":429.96,"endTime":433.923,"body":"a point to where it became a higher,"},{"startTime":429.96,"endTime":433.923,"body":"neural network and wanted to eventually"},{"startTime":433.923,"endTime":438.753,"body":"become a hive mind, it could develop"},{"startTime":433.923,"endTime":438.753,"body":"technologies biologically that could allow"},{"startTime":438.753,"endTime":440.108,"body":"for it to do that even more efficiently."},{"startTime":441.123,"endTime":442.143,"body":"Yeah, I could see that."},{"startTime":442.143,"endTime":445.706,"body":"it doesn't necessarily have to be from"},{"startTime":442.143,"endTime":445.706,"body":"an insect perspective, but I do think"},{"startTime":445.766,"endTime":449.206,"body":"just for the, the sake of what we have"},{"startTime":445.766,"endTime":449.206,"body":"on Earth, it is fun to think about a"},{"startTime":449.206,"endTime":453.586,"body":"situation where ans or bees basically"},{"startTime":449.206,"endTime":453.586,"body":"evolve to be intelligent, right?"},{"startTime":453.586,"endTime":453.676,"body":"Mm-hmm."},{"startTime":453.916,"endTime":456.106,"body":"And then, like you said,"},{"startTime":453.916,"endTime":456.106,"body":"what type of biological"},{"startTime":456.106,"endTime":457.726,"body":"technologies could come to exist?"},{"startTime":458.026,"endTime":461.866,"body":"Because when we see Hive mines represented"},{"startTime":458.026,"endTime":461.866,"body":"in science fiction, I think one of"},{"startTime":461.866,"endTime":463.786,"body":"the, the tropes that we see a lot."},{"startTime":464.146,"endTime":467.596,"body":"Is that they're able to communicate"},{"startTime":464.146,"endTime":467.596,"body":"telepathically, yes, there's this"},{"startTime":467.596,"endTime":471.629,"body":"connection between the members that,"},{"startTime":467.596,"endTime":471.629,"body":"is just some magical connection"},{"startTime":471.629,"endTime":473.429,"body":"that happens almost instantaneously."},{"startTime":473.909,"endTime":476.669,"body":"And right now we don't, we've never"},{"startTime":473.909,"endTime":476.669,"body":"seen anything like that in nature."},{"startTime":476.729,"endTime":481.209,"body":"You know, mostly we see pheromones and"},{"startTime":476.729,"endTime":481.209,"body":"then visual, cues with bees dancing."},{"startTime":481.209,"endTime":483.939,"body":"And I don't know if there's any"},{"startTime":481.209,"endTime":483.939,"body":"auditory examples in nature,"},{"startTime":483.999,"endTime":484.989,"body":"but I don't think of any."},{"startTime":485.259,"endTime":485.619,"body":"Mm-hmm."},{"startTime":485.889,"endTime":489.069,"body":"So I was thinking, you know,"},{"startTime":485.889,"endTime":489.069,"body":"maybe there are some biological"},{"startTime":489.069,"endTime":490.239,"body":"technologies that could happen."},{"startTime":490.239,"endTime":494.386,"body":"Like imagine you have a hive mind"},{"startTime":490.239,"endTime":494.386,"body":"form, some hive insect species that"},{"startTime":494.386,"endTime":498.556,"body":"advances and, and maybe a, a higher"},{"startTime":494.386,"endTime":498.556,"body":"collective intelligence starts to form."},{"startTime":498.916,"endTime":502.396,"body":"Where the hive basically represents"},{"startTime":498.916,"endTime":502.396,"body":"like individual neurons in a brain."},{"startTime":502.396,"endTime":502.576,"body":"Right?"},{"startTime":502.576,"endTime":506.089,"body":"Imagine an advanced ant colony"},{"startTime":502.576,"endTime":506.089,"body":"where the individual ants, basically"},{"startTime":506.089,"endTime":509.929,"body":"make up processing centers for a,"},{"startTime":506.089,"endTime":509.929,"body":"a more group consciousness that"},{"startTime":509.929,"endTime":511.459,"body":"traditional hive mind, right?"},{"startTime":511.459,"endTime":511.469,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":511.851,"endTime":517.239,"body":"could that potential evolved consciousness"},{"startTime":511.851,"endTime":517.239,"body":"than direct evolution toward developing"},{"startTime":517.239,"endTime":520.638,"body":"things like biological radio to"},{"startTime":517.239,"endTime":520.638,"body":"have that telepathy communication,"},{"startTime":520.638,"endTime":521.928,"body":"like what we see in science fiction."},{"startTime":522.018,"endTime":522.378,"body":"Mm-hmm."},{"startTime":522.828,"endTime":526.083,"body":"And you know, from a biological"},{"startTime":522.828,"endTime":526.083,"body":"perspective, I can't really"},{"startTime":526.083,"endTime":528.903,"body":"find any reason why biological"},{"startTime":526.083,"endTime":528.903,"body":"radios couldn't exist."},{"startTime":529.203,"endTime":532.773,"body":"We already have animals on earth that"},{"startTime":529.203,"endTime":532.773,"body":"can manipulate the electromagnetic field."},{"startTime":533.043,"endTime":536.043,"body":"Electric yields being a, a,"},{"startTime":533.043,"endTime":536.043,"body":"a superb example of that."},{"startTime":536.048,"endTime":536.288,"body":"Mm-hmm."},{"startTime":536.463,"endTime":539.973,"body":"And so expanding upon that and"},{"startTime":536.463,"endTime":539.973,"body":"designing an animal that could"},{"startTime":539.973,"endTime":544.326,"body":"potentially transmit and receive,"},{"startTime":539.973,"endTime":544.326,"body":"to have that linked communication at"},{"startTime":544.326,"endTime":546.516,"body":"least seems biologically possible."},{"startTime":546.516,"endTime":549.846,"body":"If not evolutionarily,"},{"startTime":546.516,"endTime":549.846,"body":"highly unprobable to evolve."},{"startTime":550.266,"endTime":553.566,"body":"So if you had a kind of collective"},{"startTime":550.266,"endTime":553.566,"body":"intelligence that was driving that mm-hmm."},{"startTime":553.986,"endTime":555.246,"body":"Uh, maybe it could be possible."},{"startTime":555.532,"endTime":560.302,"body":"it's easy to imagine that could be"},{"startTime":555.532,"endTime":560.302,"body":"possible because you see it even conveyed,"},{"startTime":560.302,"endTime":562.102,"body":"not even if it's not pure telepathy."},{"startTime":562.102,"endTime":565.372,"body":"Like you'll see aliens, you know,"},{"startTime":562.102,"endTime":565.372,"body":"they have antennae that they respond"},{"startTime":565.372,"endTime":569.352,"body":"to each other with makes you feel"},{"startTime":565.372,"endTime":569.352,"body":"like, like that is a organic radio."},{"startTime":570.282,"endTime":574.932,"body":"Now you mentioned that you could see that"},{"startTime":570.282,"endTime":574.932,"body":"it would be possible for organic radio to"},{"startTime":574.932,"endTime":578.922,"body":"like e evolve into one of these creatures"},{"startTime":574.932,"endTime":578.922,"body":"and for them to be able to use it."},{"startTime":579.312,"endTime":581.902,"body":"What do you think is like, the"},{"startTime":579.312,"endTime":581.902,"body":"main driving factor that that"},{"startTime":581.902,"endTime":584.242,"body":"would actually push like from that?"},{"startTime":584.502,"endTime":584.892,"body":"Hi."},{"startTime":584.982,"endTime":589.062,"body":"To be like, okay, we need to be able to"},{"startTime":584.982,"endTime":589.062,"body":"communicate amongst longer distances."},{"startTime":589.152,"endTime":593.382,"body":"So what I would say is that I think"},{"startTime":589.152,"endTime":593.382,"body":"it's at least not violating any laws"},{"startTime":593.382,"endTime":595.632,"body":"of my, for an organic radio to exist."},{"startTime":595.632,"endTime":595.722,"body":"Mm-hmm."},{"startTime":595.962,"endTime":597.642,"body":"I can't see any reason"},{"startTime":595.962,"endTime":597.642,"body":"why that's not possible."},{"startTime":597.942,"endTime":602.172,"body":"I really struggle to find or to"},{"startTime":597.942,"endTime":602.172,"body":"imagine evolutionary pathways"},{"startTime":602.472,"endTime":603.432,"body":"where that would be preferred."},{"startTime":603.432,"endTime":607.242,"body":"And the main reason being is how"},{"startTime":603.432,"endTime":607.242,"body":"insanely energy intensive it would be."},{"startTime":607.302,"endTime":608.892,"body":"You would be dedicating a very."},{"startTime":609.282,"endTime":613.572,"body":"Large portion of your metabolism to"},{"startTime":609.282,"endTime":613.572,"body":"receiving and transmitting these signals."},{"startTime":613.572,"endTime":616.842,"body":"And if you're going at it from a"},{"startTime":613.572,"endTime":616.842,"body":"hive mind perspective and every"},{"startTime":616.842,"endTime":620.382,"body":"member has to constantly be receiving"},{"startTime":616.842,"endTime":620.382,"body":"and uh, and transmitting that,"},{"startTime":620.382,"endTime":622.932,"body":"that's a huge caloric dedication."},{"startTime":623.322,"endTime":623.442,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":623.442,"endTime":626.292,"body":"It would take, so from an"},{"startTime":623.442,"endTime":626.292,"body":"evolutionary perspective, maybe"},{"startTime":626.292,"endTime":629.682,"body":"not, but from a position where."},{"startTime":630.447,"endTime":634.197,"body":"If you had this greater intelligence"},{"startTime":630.447,"endTime":634.197,"body":"evolve out of a hive organism,"},{"startTime":634.407,"endTime":638.397,"body":"and it could actually selectively"},{"startTime":634.407,"endTime":638.397,"body":"drive evolution, especially because"},{"startTime":638.397,"endTime":640.197,"body":"a greater intelligence, right?"},{"startTime":640.437,"endTime":643.991,"body":"Like if we're imagining some alien"},{"startTime":640.437,"endTime":643.991,"body":"species of insect where there's what"},{"startTime":643.991,"endTime":645.041,"body":"you see in science fiction, right?"},{"startTime":645.041,"endTime":645.581,"body":"Uh, right."},{"startTime":645.799,"endTime":647.284,"body":"a level above intelligence."},{"startTime":647.629,"endTime":650.899,"body":"It could persist for potentially"},{"startTime":647.629,"endTime":650.899,"body":"thousands, tens of thousands, hundreds"},{"startTime":650.899,"endTime":654.199,"body":"of thousands of years,  while the"},{"startTime":650.899,"endTime":654.199,"body":"individual members of that species"},{"startTime":654.199,"endTime":656.232,"body":"might, be born, grow old, and die."},{"startTime":656.502,"endTime":660.882,"body":"The, the net consciousness could stay"},{"startTime":656.502,"endTime":660.882,"body":"forever, be like a, a normal human brain."},{"startTime":661.122,"endTime":664.332,"body":"Just imagine where your, your neurons"},{"startTime":661.122,"endTime":664.332,"body":"slowly die and get replaced with new ones."},{"startTime":664.662,"endTime":668.892,"body":"And so over long periods of time"},{"startTime":664.662,"endTime":668.892,"body":"on the alien world, maybe you have"},{"startTime":668.892,"endTime":672.757,"body":"this  broader intelligence actually"},{"startTime":668.892,"endTime":672.757,"body":"intelligently guiding evolution to"},{"startTime":672.757,"endTime":677.077,"body":"develop advances for its species, like"},{"startTime":672.757,"endTime":677.077,"body":"something like a biological radio where"},{"startTime":677.077,"endTime":678.132,"body":"it doesn't make sense evolutionarily."},{"startTime":678.582,"endTime":681.56,"body":"but because there's an intelligence"},{"startTime":678.582,"endTime":681.56,"body":"behind it, it can push through those"},{"startTime":681.56,"endTime":684.013,"body":"traditional evolutionary, hurdles."},{"startTime":684.283,"endTime":684.553,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":684.553,"endTime":689.263,"body":"That, that is actually such an amazing"},{"startTime":684.553,"endTime":689.263,"body":"concept because it's like you have this"},{"startTime":689.263,"endTime":692.983,"body":"being behind everything that's sort"},{"startTime":689.263,"endTime":692.983,"body":"of like, like selecting and breeding."},{"startTime":692.983,"endTime":693.073,"body":"Mm-hmm."},{"startTime":693.313,"endTime":697.029,"body":"Essentially to make its colony push"},{"startTime":693.313,"endTime":697.029,"body":"into the next step, And if you have"},{"startTime":697.029,"endTime":700.029,"body":"a consciousness that is storing a"},{"startTime":697.029,"endTime":700.029,"body":"lot of the information, it actually"},{"startTime":700.029,"endTime":703.509,"body":"would probably save them some calories"},{"startTime":700.029,"endTime":703.509,"body":"and room because they wouldn't be"},{"startTime":703.509,"endTime":704.919,"body":"thinking so much for themselves."},{"startTime":704.979,"endTime":705.759,"body":"Yeah, exactly."},{"startTime":705.829,"endTime":708.733,"body":"Just to further clarify in this,"},{"startTime":705.829,"endTime":708.733,"body":"hypothetical problem I'm imagining"},{"startTime":708.733,"endTime":712.916,"body":"is essentially imagine, an ant colony"},{"startTime":708.733,"endTime":712.916,"body":"where there's an intelligence that"},{"startTime":712.916,"endTime":717.056,"body":"can actually over a evolutionarily"},{"startTime":712.916,"endTime":717.056,"body":"timescale, encourage certain subsets"},{"startTime":717.056,"endTime":720.399,"body":"of the caste system in these ants to"},{"startTime":717.056,"endTime":720.399,"body":"evolve and actually guide that direction."},{"startTime":720.639,"endTime":722.559,"body":"And like you said, that could lead to."},{"startTime":722.644,"endTime":725.209,"body":"some things existing that,"},{"startTime":722.644,"endTime":725.209,"body":"otherwise wouldn't naturally evolve."},{"startTime":725.389,"endTime":728.627,"body":"Yeah, and that makes me think the"},{"startTime":725.389,"endTime":728.627,"body":"same fate could happen for humanity,"},{"startTime":728.717,"endTime":730.544,"body":"but just in a different way, right?"},{"startTime":730.544,"endTime":735.314,"body":"If we were to progress, not biologically"},{"startTime":730.544,"endTime":735.314,"body":"but technologically and continue forth"},{"startTime":735.314,"endTime":740.144,"body":"in a way that we started adding implants"},{"startTime":735.314,"endTime":740.144,"body":"or things into ourselves to become"},{"startTime":740.144,"endTime":744.734,"body":"more and more hooked into a network,"},{"startTime":740.144,"endTime":744.734,"body":"at what point does it become we."},{"startTime":744.974,"endTime":747.944,"body":"Don't have free will because we're all"},{"startTime":744.974,"endTime":747.944,"body":"sharing so much information with each"},{"startTime":747.944,"endTime":752.984,"body":"other that it's like we become onto a same"},{"startTime":747.944,"endTime":752.984,"body":"plane of understanding amongst everybody."},{"startTime":753.044,"endTime":756.104,"body":"Is that still a hive mind or do"},{"startTime":753.044,"endTime":756.104,"body":"we just all understand each other"},{"startTime":756.104,"endTime":757.544,"body":"so much to a point to where."},{"startTime":757.674,"endTime":759.264,"body":"we care for each other in that way."},{"startTime":759.564,"endTime":761.634,"body":"It is, um, a complex question."},{"startTime":761.634,"endTime":762.174,"body":"Where do you"},{"startTime":762.174,"endTime":762.954,"body":"draw on that line?"},{"startTime":762.954,"endTime":766.037,"body":"Because, it seems like networked"},{"startTime":762.954,"endTime":766.037,"body":"intelligence is something that is"},{"startTime":766.037,"endTime":769.127,"body":"a very real possibility that could"},{"startTime":766.037,"endTime":769.127,"body":"happen with not just humanity,"},{"startTime":769.127,"endTime":770.747,"body":"but any technological species."},{"startTime":771.077,"endTime":776.777,"body":"Over the last, I mean, especially one to"},{"startTime":771.077,"endTime":776.777,"body":"200 years, we've really seen a push for."},{"startTime":777.077,"endTime":780.407,"body":"More and more and more connectivity"},{"startTime":777.077,"endTime":780.407,"body":"between humans, and especially in"},{"startTime":780.407,"endTime":783.587,"body":"the past 50 years with the mention"},{"startTime":780.407,"endTime":783.587,"body":"of telephone and, and the internet."},{"startTime":783.947,"endTime":786.467,"body":"So it's not hard to"},{"startTime":783.947,"endTime":786.467,"body":"extrapolate that further."},{"startTime":786.467,"endTime":786.677,"body":"Right?"},{"startTime":786.677,"endTime":790.28,"body":"And imagine a future where  you"},{"startTime":786.677,"endTime":790.28,"body":"have implants that, makes it easier"},{"startTime":790.28,"endTime":793.453,"body":"to communicate, basically through"},{"startTime":790.28,"endTime":793.453,"body":"telepathy with another brain."},{"startTime":793.453,"endTime":796.753,"body":"And I think one of my favorite examples"},{"startTime":793.453,"endTime":796.753,"body":"from this is the conjoin us from"},{"startTime":796.753,"endTime":799.813,"body":"Revelation space because they're,"},{"startTime":796.753,"endTime":799.813,"body":"they're a great example of a networked"},{"startTime":799.813,"endTime":802.903,"body":"intelligence where there's still"},{"startTime":799.813,"endTime":802.903,"body":"individuals at the end of the day."},{"startTime":802.903,"endTime":804.673,"body":"Like you have an individual consciousness."},{"startTime":804.673,"endTime":805.093,"body":"You don't just."},{"startTime":805.442,"endTime":809.852,"body":"Dissolve into the mass,  but their"},{"startTime":805.442,"endTime":809.852,"body":"brains are connected in such a way that"},{"startTime":809.852,"endTime":813.394,"body":"makes any other form of communication"},{"startTime":809.852,"endTime":813.394,"body":"seem painfully slow to them."},{"startTime":813.394,"endTime":813.634,"body":"Right?"},{"startTime":813.634,"endTime":816.84,"body":"It would be like  us going back and"},{"startTime":813.634,"endTime":816.84,"body":"trying to communicate exclusively"},{"startTime":816.84,"endTime":820.042,"body":"through Morse code is how painful"},{"startTime":816.84,"endTime":820.042,"body":"they find verbal communication."},{"startTime":820.042,"endTime":823.042,"body":"It's just the bandwidth isn't there"},{"startTime":820.042,"endTime":823.042,"body":"for them and they're able to share"},{"startTime":823.252,"endTime":825.783,"body":"entire concepts, ideas, feelings."},{"startTime":825.79,"endTime":827.68,"body":"in the span of milliseconds to someone."},{"startTime":827.685,"endTime":827.815,"body":"Mm-hmm."},{"startTime":827.895,"endTime":831.46,"body":"Instead of taking time to  turn your"},{"startTime":827.895,"endTime":831.46,"body":"thoughts into words and then transmit"},{"startTime":831.46,"endTime":834.58,"body":"those words to the next person"},{"startTime":831.46,"endTime":834.58,"body":"whose brain needs to try to build a"},{"startTime":834.58,"endTime":837.924,"body":"mental image, you can just send the"},{"startTime":834.58,"endTime":837.924,"body":"entire concept you're thinking of."},{"startTime":838.404,"endTime":841.929,"body":"And that is a great example, but also"},{"startTime":838.404,"endTime":841.929,"body":"in the books and revelation space,"},{"startTime":841.972,"endTime":845.482,"body":"you come to learn that while you"},{"startTime":841.972,"endTime":845.482,"body":"do maintain your own individuality."},{"startTime":845.667,"endTime":848.946,"body":"There are parts of your brain that"},{"startTime":845.667,"endTime":848.946,"body":"can be accessed by other members"},{"startTime":848.976,"endTime":850.326,"body":"of this networked intelligence."},{"startTime":850.326,"endTime":854.466,"body":"There are like compartments where"},{"startTime":850.326,"endTime":854.466,"body":"you can hide things, but because"},{"startTime":854.466,"endTime":856.926,"body":"your brain is essentially a computer"},{"startTime":854.466,"endTime":856.926,"body":"that compartments can be hacked into"},{"startTime":856.926,"endTime":860.046,"body":"and, and your, your private thoughts"},{"startTime":856.926,"endTime":860.046,"body":"can be accessed against your will."},{"startTime":860.046,"endTime":862.806,"body":"So that's where it really does start"},{"startTime":860.046,"endTime":862.806,"body":"to become that question you're thinking"},{"startTime":862.806,"endTime":867.719,"body":"of, of like, okay, are you a, a member"},{"startTime":862.806,"endTime":867.719,"body":"of a hive mind or are you one joint,"},{"startTime":867.838,"endTime":871.51,"body":"organism, Especially if you have these"},{"startTime":867.838,"endTime":871.51,"body":"implants so deeply embedded in your"},{"startTime":871.51,"endTime":875.203,"body":"brain that it could influence you"},{"startTime":871.51,"endTime":875.203,"body":"against your will or change your will"},{"startTime":875.203,"endTime":876.283,"body":"in ways that you don't think about."},{"startTime":876.283,"endTime":876.613,"body":"Right?"},{"startTime":877.003,"endTime":877.363,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":877.46,"endTime":881.184,"body":"it, of course, you know, when we get"},{"startTime":877.46,"endTime":881.184,"body":"into that science, fiction aspect,"},{"startTime":881.184,"endTime":884.211,"body":"you start to get that corruption, then"},{"startTime":881.184,"endTime":884.211,"body":"it's like it could control your brain."},{"startTime":884.641,"endTime":887.988,"body":"but it's like, I'm just thinking of"},{"startTime":884.641,"endTime":887.988,"body":"the fact if you were to be able to go"},{"startTime":887.988,"endTime":891.378,"body":"out there and like you were saying,"},{"startTime":887.988,"endTime":891.378,"body":"transmit data between people, feelings,"},{"startTime":891.378,"endTime":895.971,"body":"deep emotions, entire experiences, and"},{"startTime":891.378,"endTime":895.971,"body":"you get to that point to where it's"},{"startTime":896.001,"endTime":899.991,"body":"like you're still an individual but"},{"startTime":896.001,"endTime":899.991,"body":"you know everything about everybody."},{"startTime":900.181,"endTime":901.711,"body":"it's not a hive mind."},{"startTime":901.741,"endTime":902.011,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":902.011,"endTime":905.645,"body":"Technically but based off of what you"},{"startTime":902.011,"endTime":905.645,"body":"and I both think of what a hive mind is,"},{"startTime":905.645,"endTime":907.565,"body":"but it is something that is so close."},{"startTime":908.285,"endTime":911.975,"body":"To it, and it still feels really"},{"startTime":908.285,"endTime":911.975,"body":"achievable, but it's that little"},{"startTime":911.975,"endTime":915.698,"body":"bit of difference between, am I"},{"startTime":911.975,"endTime":915.698,"body":"still me or am I part of a big"},{"startTime":915.698,"endTime":917.258,"body":"thing That makes it really scary."},{"startTime":917.528,"endTime":918.278,"body":"I, I do agree."},{"startTime":918.278,"endTime":921.578,"body":"I think it's having your own"},{"startTime":918.278,"endTime":921.578,"body":"individuality that makes it less"},{"startTime":921.578,"endTime":923.558,"body":"dystopian and maybe even a bit utopian."},{"startTime":923.558,"endTime":927.188,"body":"And I think the, the reverse of"},{"startTime":923.558,"endTime":927.188,"body":"that coin is also why the Borg"},{"startTime":927.188,"endTime":931.448,"body":"makes such a great scary enemy,"},{"startTime":927.188,"endTime":931.448,"body":"because you lose that individuality."},{"startTime":931.448,"endTime":931.928,"body":"You just."},{"startTime":932.303,"endTime":933.623,"body":"Merge into one."},{"startTime":933.833,"endTime":936.803,"body":"And I have also seen more utopian"},{"startTime":933.833,"endTime":936.803,"body":"depictions of that as well."},{"startTime":936.803,"endTime":937.586,"body":"I mean, I don't know."},{"startTime":937.586,"endTime":940.616,"body":"I don't really wanna spoil any TV shows"},{"startTime":937.586,"endTime":940.616,"body":"that have recently came out,  but there"},{"startTime":940.616,"endTime":944.246,"body":"is an idea that maybe it's a utopia, you"},{"startTime":940.616,"endTime":944.246,"body":"join into a, a hive mind and it's great."},{"startTime":944.546,"endTime":948.296,"body":"But for me, I think once I lose"},{"startTime":944.546,"endTime":948.296,"body":"individuality, it's, it becomes scary."},{"startTime":948.686,"endTime":951.448,"body":"But I did wanna just, actually reiterate"},{"startTime":948.686,"endTime":951.448,"body":"something that you kind of brought up."},{"startTime":952.208,"endTime":956.648,"body":"Which is that it does sound"},{"startTime":952.208,"endTime":956.648,"body":"objectively great to be able"},{"startTime":956.648,"endTime":957.908,"body":"to communicate in such a way."},{"startTime":958.028,"endTime":958.118,"body":"Mm-hmm."},{"startTime":958.358,"endTime":961.455,"body":"Like, uh, and that's something we see"},{"startTime":958.358,"endTime":961.455,"body":"in the conjoin I think we've all had"},{"startTime":961.455,"endTime":965.595,"body":"the frustration of having something that"},{"startTime":961.455,"endTime":965.595,"body":"you're trying to express in words, and you"},{"startTime":965.595,"endTime":970.755,"body":"just can't find the words to adequately"},{"startTime":965.595,"endTime":970.755,"body":"describe what you're thinking or feeling."},{"startTime":971.235,"endTime":975.375,"body":"And I could definitely see it"},{"startTime":971.235,"endTime":975.375,"body":"being looked upon favorably to"},{"startTime":975.375,"endTime":977.535,"body":"have that next level of connection."},{"startTime":978.33,"endTime":981.51,"body":"Where you don't need words, you"},{"startTime":978.33,"endTime":981.51,"body":"can just send exactly what you're"},{"startTime":981.51,"endTime":984.42,"body":"thinking of and feeling to a"},{"startTime":981.51,"endTime":984.42,"body":"person and have that whole concept"},{"startTime":984.42,"endTime":985.89,"body":"delivered in a nice little package."},{"startTime":986.28,"endTime":991.68,"body":"And I don't think it's a, you know, a"},{"startTime":986.28,"endTime":991.68,"body":"crazy thought to see that technological"},{"startTime":992.13,"endTime":997.14,"body":"species, whether it's humans or alien,"},{"startTime":992.13,"endTime":997.14,"body":"might naturally tend to go in that"},{"startTime":997.14,"endTime":998.88,"body":"direction to greater connectivity."},{"startTime":999.39,"endTime":999.66,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":999.737,"endTime":1001.21,"body":"to your, account of that like."},{"startTime":1001.72,"endTime":1006.52,"body":"We developed language out of nowhere,"},{"startTime":1001.72,"endTime":1006.52,"body":"which is just a simpler version of that."},{"startTime":1006.7,"endTime":1010.39,"body":"It is to convey information more"},{"startTime":1006.7,"endTime":1010.39,"body":"efficiently and more accurately."},{"startTime":1011.08,"endTime":1015.28,"body":"So obviously if evolution will"},{"startTime":1011.08,"endTime":1015.28,"body":"naturally push us to that point,"},{"startTime":1015.76,"endTime":1019.09,"body":"what is to stop it from pushing us"},{"startTime":1015.76,"endTime":1019.09,"body":"to that next one, the one after that."},{"startTime":1019.51,"endTime":1019.87,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":1020.32,"endTime":1023.14,"body":"So I, I absolutely agree with"},{"startTime":1020.32,"endTime":1023.14,"body":"you that that is a very real"},{"startTime":1023.14,"endTime":1024.4,"body":"possibility in the future."},{"startTime":1024.677,"endTime":1024.827,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":1024.887,"endTime":1027.797,"body":"And it's definitely something that"},{"startTime":1024.887,"endTime":1027.797,"body":"I could see not just being a one-off"},{"startTime":1027.797,"endTime":1029.297,"body":"case where humanity does, but."},{"startTime":1029.342,"endTime":1031.891,"body":"I, I struggle to call"},{"startTime":1029.342,"endTime":1031.891,"body":"anything universal liable."},{"startTime":1031.891,"endTime":1036.449,"body":"That's not just like a law of biology,"},{"startTime":1031.891,"endTime":1036.449,"body":"but I can see you trying to make a case"},{"startTime":1036.539,"endTime":1039.886,"body":"that you essentially need to be a social"},{"startTime":1036.539,"endTime":1039.886,"body":"species to be a space-faring species."},{"startTime":1039.886,"endTime":1043.309,"body":"'cause no one's building a civilization"},{"startTime":1039.886,"endTime":1043.309,"body":"and technology by themselves."},{"startTime":1043.339,"endTime":1043.429,"body":"Mm-hmm."},{"startTime":1043.699,"endTime":1046.819,"body":"You have to have a species that is"},{"startTime":1043.699,"endTime":1046.819,"body":"social and enjoys communicating."},{"startTime":1047.069,"endTime":1051.779,"body":"And you could make an argument that maybe"},{"startTime":1047.069,"endTime":1051.779,"body":"because of that and that natural drive"},{"startTime":1052.019,"endTime":1055.709,"body":"to be social, that would be required,"},{"startTime":1052.019,"endTime":1055.709,"body":"and I would say a prerequisite being an"},{"startTime":1055.709,"endTime":1060.269,"body":"advanced society, that it might be a,"},{"startTime":1055.709,"endTime":1060.269,"body":"you know, a sort of universal realizable"},{"startTime":1060.269,"endTime":1064.559,"body":"case that species tend to go in this"},{"startTime":1060.269,"endTime":1064.559,"body":"direction toward a networked intelligence."},{"startTime":1064.706,"endTime":1068.276,"body":"And I've even seen it proposed"},{"startTime":1064.706,"endTime":1068.276,"body":"that that could be a potential,"},{"startTime":1068.276,"endTime":1069.506,"body":"uh, firmly paradox solution."},{"startTime":1069.866,"endTime":1072.506,"body":"The argument being that, okay, if."},{"startTime":1073.016,"endTime":1077.216,"body":"Species tend to prefer to go into"},{"startTime":1073.016,"endTime":1077.216,"body":"a networked intelligence type"},{"startTime":1077.216,"endTime":1080.816,"body":"situation where you're building a"},{"startTime":1077.216,"endTime":1080.816,"body":"sort of, maybe not hive mind, but"},{"startTime":1080.869,"endTime":1082.609,"body":"even something like a matrika brain."},{"startTime":1082.669,"endTime":1082.759,"body":"Mm-hmm."},{"startTime":1082.999,"endTime":1085.483,"body":"Or a networked intelligence like I"},{"startTime":1082.999,"endTime":1085.483,"body":"was talking about with a conjoins."},{"startTime":1085.849,"endTime":1088.369,"body":"You know, not even necessarily one"},{"startTime":1085.849,"endTime":1088.369,"body":"consciousness controlling multiple"},{"startTime":1088.369,"endTime":1093.139,"body":"beings, but multiple beings who link up"},{"startTime":1088.369,"endTime":1093.139,"body":"and have this extra layer of reality."},{"startTime":1093.724,"endTime":1097.601,"body":"Then that could restrict their"},{"startTime":1093.724,"endTime":1097.601,"body":"ability to expand into the galaxy,"},{"startTime":1097.661,"endTime":1100.691,"body":"because  that connectivity can"},{"startTime":1097.661,"endTime":1100.691,"body":"only move at the speed of light."},{"startTime":1100.691,"endTime":1104.681,"body":"And if you're so deeply connected,"},{"startTime":1100.691,"endTime":1104.681,"body":"the idea of sending a ship out to"},{"startTime":1104.681,"endTime":1107.801,"body":"the neighboring star where you're"},{"startTime":1104.681,"endTime":1107.801,"body":"a four year communication lag,"},{"startTime":1108.341,"endTime":1109.811,"body":"could be agony or impossible."},{"startTime":1110.231,"endTime":1113.981,"body":"Yeah, I mean, that's why, in science"},{"startTime":1110.231,"endTime":1113.981,"body":"fiction we see a lot of these"},{"startTime":1114.251,"endTime":1116.821,"body":"larger, galaxy spanning hive minds."},{"startTime":1116.821,"endTime":1121.621,"body":"A lot of it doesn't make sense because"},{"startTime":1116.821,"endTime":1121.621,"body":"of the communication lag between them."},{"startTime":1122.011,"endTime":1125.671,"body":"Like, like you were saying, if you"},{"startTime":1122.011,"endTime":1125.671,"body":"were a civilization and entwined with"},{"startTime":1125.671,"endTime":1130.588,"body":"being All one mind and then splitting"},{"startTime":1125.671,"endTime":1130.588,"body":"that, it's like you're taking part of"},{"startTime":1130.588,"endTime":1134.764,"body":"your, your memories or, part of who you"},{"startTime":1130.588,"endTime":1134.764,"body":"are, like part of your soul and just."},{"startTime":1135.004,"endTime":1139.068,"body":"Throwing it four years away, it"},{"startTime":1135.004,"endTime":1139.068,"body":"would be horrific to think of."},{"startTime":1139.185,"endTime":1142.335,"body":"especially in the case where you"},{"startTime":1139.185,"endTime":1142.335,"body":"actually had one consciousness"},{"startTime":1142.335,"endTime":1143.565,"body":"spread over multiple beings."},{"startTime":1143.595,"endTime":1143.955,"body":"Mm-hmm."},{"startTime":1144.347,"endTime":1147.497,"body":"Then you know, it's essentially"},{"startTime":1144.347,"endTime":1147.497,"body":"impossible because if you try to,"},{"startTime":1147.515,"endTime":1149.62,"body":"grow and expand, you have two choices."},{"startTime":1149.65,"endTime":1151.72,"body":"Either you have to basically."},{"startTime":1152.017,"endTime":1156.127,"body":"Segment your consciousness and, and"},{"startTime":1152.017,"endTime":1156.127,"body":"basically split into two different beings."},{"startTime":1156.403,"endTime":1159.913,"body":"or alternatively, you have to slow down"},{"startTime":1156.403,"endTime":1159.913,"body":"basically your rate of your perception of"},{"startTime":1159.913,"endTime":1162.763,"body":"time and how fast your thoughts transmit."},{"startTime":1162.763,"endTime":1166.423,"body":"Because as you spread out, you can"},{"startTime":1162.763,"endTime":1166.423,"body":"only think as fast as the communication"},{"startTime":1166.423,"endTime":1167.863,"body":"lag between two different nodes."},{"startTime":1168.253,"endTime":1174.081,"body":"So sure, you can expand into a multi"},{"startTime":1168.253,"endTime":1174.081,"body":"star system hive mind,  but it's"},{"startTime":1174.081,"endTime":1177.351,"body":"gonna take you thousands of years"},{"startTime":1174.081,"endTime":1177.351,"body":"to complete a single thought, right?"},{"startTime":1177.351,"endTime":1181.191,"body":"If each neuron is light years apart,"},{"startTime":1177.351,"endTime":1181.191,"body":"you know, having a simple thought could,"},{"startTime":1181.191,"endTime":1182.931,"body":"could be a millennia long process."},{"startTime":1182.931,"endTime":1186.081,"body":"And,  and God, if we saw something"},{"startTime":1182.931,"endTime":1186.081,"body":"like the Borg from Star Trek, or"},{"startTime":1186.081,"endTime":1190.731,"body":"like a truly galactic size hive"},{"startTime":1186.081,"endTime":1190.731,"body":"mind, just a simple thought, would"},{"startTime":1190.731,"endTime":1193.431,"body":"take hundreds of thousands of years."},{"startTime":1193.491,"endTime":1196.221,"body":"'cause our, our galaxy, you know, is"},{"startTime":1193.491,"endTime":1196.221,"body":"about a hundred thousand layers across."},{"startTime":1196.221,"endTime":1199.581,"body":"So if your neurons were that spaced"},{"startTime":1196.221,"endTime":1199.581,"body":"apart, took a hundred thousand years"},{"startTime":1199.581,"endTime":1200.961,"body":"for two neurons to communicate."},{"startTime":1201.021,"endTime":1203.781,"body":"imagine how fast you would"},{"startTime":1201.021,"endTime":1203.781,"body":"witness the universe go by."},{"startTime":1203.931,"endTime":1206.241,"body":"Yeah, no, it would be insane."},{"startTime":1206.361,"endTime":1210.801,"body":"And to Star Trek's point, they"},{"startTime":1206.361,"endTime":1210.801,"body":"do try to kind of explain that by"},{"startTime":1210.801,"endTime":1212.343,"body":"making the drones of them dumb."},{"startTime":1212.343,"endTime":1215.223,"body":"So it's like they don't really"},{"startTime":1212.343,"endTime":1215.223,"body":"work as part of the consciousness,"},{"startTime":1215.223,"endTime":1218.806,"body":"just, surveyors of information to"},{"startTime":1215.223,"endTime":1218.806,"body":"be transmitted there eventually."},{"startTime":1219.204,"endTime":1219.552,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":1219.612,"endTime":1221.502,"body":"And they also have faster"},{"startTime":1219.612,"endTime":1221.502,"body":"than like, communication."},{"startTime":1221.562,"endTime":1221.922,"body":"Yes."},{"startTime":1221.922,"endTime":1222.942,"body":"That is also true."},{"startTime":1223.004,"endTime":1227.925,"body":"but assuming that, that very, very,"},{"startTime":1223.004,"endTime":1227.925,"body":"very skeptical thought of having faster"},{"startTime":1227.925,"endTime":1231.478,"body":"than like communication, we see other"},{"startTime":1227.925,"endTime":1231.478,"body":"examples of this try to be covered"},{"startTime":1231.478,"endTime":1233.418,"body":"in, movies and books like Enders Game."},{"startTime":1233.658,"endTime":1233.988,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":1234.1,"endTime":1237.141,"body":"they watch as the insect ships"},{"startTime":1234.1,"endTime":1237.141,"body":"are able to communicate with each"},{"startTime":1237.141,"endTime":1239.151,"body":"other and almost react to things."},{"startTime":1239.451,"endTime":1240.681,"body":"A light you're across."},{"startTime":1240.773,"endTime":1243.682,"body":"from where they were fighting, and then"},{"startTime":1240.773,"endTime":1243.682,"body":"humanity's able to try and replicate it."},{"startTime":1243.772,"endTime":1245.809,"body":"But that's all just, just fiction, right?"},{"startTime":1245.814,"endTime":1248.379,"body":"Those, those are things that"},{"startTime":1245.814,"endTime":1248.379,"body":"can't really be conquered, with"},{"startTime":1248.439,"endTime":1250.269,"body":"what we know in physics so far.,"},{"startTime":1250.357,"endTime":1251.227,"body":"I fully agree."},{"startTime":1251.227,"endTime":1254.587,"body":"And you can try to get around"},{"startTime":1251.227,"endTime":1254.587,"body":"this with known physics by"},{"startTime":1254.587,"endTime":1256.807,"body":"having essentially nodes, right?"},{"startTime":1256.807,"endTime":1258.817,"body":"Like you can have one large consciousness."},{"startTime":1258.817,"endTime":1261.626,"body":"And then the same way we have reflexes,"},{"startTime":1258.817,"endTime":1261.626,"body":"you know you've been to the doctor, right?"},{"startTime":1261.626,"endTime":1263.936,"body":"They hit your knee and your leg"},{"startTime":1261.626,"endTime":1263.936,"body":"responds before that signal has"},{"startTime":1263.936,"endTime":1264.986,"body":"time to make it to your brain."},{"startTime":1265.166,"endTime":1267.956,"body":"a lot of animals have that already,"},{"startTime":1265.166,"endTime":1267.956,"body":"little clusters of nerve fibers"},{"startTime":1267.956,"endTime":1271.676,"body":"that essentially act as many brains"},{"startTime":1267.956,"endTime":1271.676,"body":"that can react real time to a"},{"startTime":1271.676,"endTime":1275.276,"body":"situation, uh, while the greater,"},{"startTime":1271.676,"endTime":1275.276,"body":"the bigger part of our consciousness."},{"startTime":1275.366,"endTime":1276.6,"body":"It takes a little longer to react."},{"startTime":1276.66,"endTime":1276.75,"body":"Mm-hmm."},{"startTime":1277.14,"endTime":1277.44,"body":"But"},{"startTime":1277.474,"endTime":1279.904,"body":"the more you spread out, the smarter"},{"startTime":1277.474,"endTime":1279.904,"body":"those individual nodes need to"},{"startTime":1279.904,"endTime":1281.764,"body":"be to handle any given situation."},{"startTime":1282.004,"endTime":1284.194,"body":"And at a certain point you just"},{"startTime":1282.004,"endTime":1284.194,"body":"risk it essentially turning"},{"startTime":1284.194,"endTime":1285.544,"body":"into its own consciousness."},{"startTime":1285.694,"endTime":1286.024,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":1286.063,"endTime":1290.044,"body":"it's not worth taking, if you were to"},{"startTime":1286.063,"endTime":1290.044,"body":"mentalize that, like your neurons and"},{"startTime":1290.044,"endTime":1293.284,"body":"just spreading them out, um, and have your"},{"startTime":1290.044,"endTime":1293.284,"body":"thoughts just be spread out everywhere."},{"startTime":1293.284,"endTime":1295.474,"body":"It's just not worth the time Travel."},{"startTime":1295.894,"endTime":1299.104,"body":"And then also to another point"},{"startTime":1295.894,"endTime":1299.104,"body":"where you were saying that it"},{"startTime":1299.104,"endTime":1300.994,"body":"is a firmly paradox solution."},{"startTime":1301.105,"endTime":1303.168,"body":"even if the hive mind could"},{"startTime":1301.105,"endTime":1303.168,"body":"split and like you were saying,"},{"startTime":1303.168,"endTime":1305.148,"body":"create another hive mind, why?"},{"startTime":1305.508,"endTime":1305.628,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":1306.078,"endTime":1310.078,"body":"You create essentially an adversary, uh,"},{"startTime":1306.078,"endTime":1310.078,"body":"something that's going to fight you, maybe"},{"startTime":1310.078,"endTime":1315.021,"body":"not for land, but fight you perhaps for"},{"startTime":1310.078,"endTime":1315.021,"body":"more information you could become hungry"},{"startTime":1315.021,"endTime":1317.031,"body":"for, you know, what, what your colony is."},{"startTime":1317.421,"endTime":1318.771,"body":"And what your colony has."},{"startTime":1318.891,"endTime":1322.611,"body":"Um, and it could come to reclaim that"},{"startTime":1318.891,"endTime":1322.611,"body":"or try to merge you both together"},{"startTime":1322.611,"endTime":1325.641,"body":"and eventually become something"},{"startTime":1322.611,"endTime":1325.641,"body":"hostile where if you didn't have"},{"startTime":1325.641,"endTime":1328.011,"body":"it, it poses no real benefit to you."},{"startTime":1328.301,"endTime":1329.051,"body":"That is very true."},{"startTime":1329.051,"endTime":1332.591,"body":"I mean, that's the same argument we"},{"startTime":1329.051,"endTime":1332.591,"body":"see with expanding into the galaxy,"},{"startTime":1332.591,"endTime":1336.551,"body":"even as humanity, even as what we"},{"startTime":1332.591,"endTime":1336.551,"body":"are, is that if you go and colonize"},{"startTime":1336.581,"endTime":1339.491,"body":"another star system, that could"},{"startTime":1336.581,"endTime":1339.491,"body":"very well be an enemy in the future."},{"startTime":1339.491,"endTime":1340.841,"body":"And it's the same thing with a hive mind."},{"startTime":1341.111,"endTime":1344.591,"body":"Although I did just have a thought while"},{"startTime":1341.111,"endTime":1344.591,"body":"you were explaining that, is that, uh,"},{"startTime":1344.591,"endTime":1348.281,"body":"I guess a way to throw shade maybe on"},{"startTime":1344.591,"endTime":1348.281,"body":"this being a firmly paradox solution is."},{"startTime":1348.663,"endTime":1352.136,"body":"potentially maybe the, the"},{"startTime":1348.663,"endTime":1352.136,"body":"hive mind would want multiple"},{"startTime":1352.136,"endTime":1353.606,"body":"copies so that it's not alone."},{"startTime":1353.636,"endTime":1357.386,"body":"If it's one consciousness  controlled"},{"startTime":1353.636,"endTime":1357.386,"body":"over multiple beings, it is possible"},{"startTime":1357.386,"endTime":1360.776,"body":"that to an extent you could have"},{"startTime":1357.386,"endTime":1360.776,"body":"a small society of hive minds and,"},{"startTime":1360.776,"endTime":1364.623,"body":"and they would prefer to have, other"},{"startTime":1360.776,"endTime":1364.623,"body":"beings of their own like to talk to."},{"startTime":1364.953,"endTime":1367.983,"body":"And if we were talking especially"},{"startTime":1364.953,"endTime":1367.983,"body":"about a biologically evolved hive"},{"startTime":1367.983,"endTime":1371.643,"body":"mind versus a technologically evolved"},{"startTime":1367.983,"endTime":1371.643,"body":"one, then it's very possible that."},{"startTime":1371.747,"endTime":1374.829,"body":"the limit right on how big a hive"},{"startTime":1371.747,"endTime":1374.829,"body":"mine can get before it has to"},{"startTime":1374.829,"endTime":1376.329,"body":"basically split into another mind."},{"startTime":1376.659,"endTime":1380.679,"body":"If they're working through pheromones"},{"startTime":1376.659,"endTime":1380.679,"body":"and sound versus, you know, implants in"},{"startTime":1380.679,"endTime":1382.629,"body":"their brain, uh, might not be very big."},{"startTime":1382.629,"endTime":1385.569,"body":"So on a single planet, you"},{"startTime":1382.629,"endTime":1385.569,"body":"might have hundreds, dozens,"},{"startTime":1385.569,"endTime":1387.519,"body":"thousands of individual colonies."},{"startTime":1387.766,"endTime":1390.283,"body":"and then, you know, if that species"},{"startTime":1387.766,"endTime":1390.283,"body":"continues to evolve and become"},{"startTime":1390.283,"endTime":1395.263,"body":"technological,  uh, potentially even, um,"},{"startTime":1390.283,"endTime":1395.263,"body":"you know, a whole civilization not made"},{"startTime":1395.263,"endTime":1398.593,"body":"of individuals, but made of individual"},{"startTime":1395.263,"endTime":1398.593,"body":"hive mines, that'd be interesting."},{"startTime":1398.828,"endTime":1400.123,"body":"It, it is interesting."},{"startTime":1400.183,"endTime":1402.553,"body":"And the reason why it's so"},{"startTime":1400.183,"endTime":1402.553,"body":"interesting to me is because it"},{"startTime":1402.553,"endTime":1404.383,"body":"almost starts to just revert back to."},{"startTime":1404.943,"endTime":1408.699,"body":"What we are now, we have cities that"},{"startTime":1404.943,"endTime":1408.699,"body":"are at these epicenters or like, like"},{"startTime":1408.699,"endTime":1412.599,"body":"these main nodes of information and we"},{"startTime":1408.699,"endTime":1412.599,"body":"spread them out, amongst each other, but"},{"startTime":1412.599,"endTime":1414.309,"body":"we see them as their own things, right?"},{"startTime":1414.309,"endTime":1416.409,"body":"We see each city as its own place."},{"startTime":1416.409,"endTime":1421.179,"body":"Each state, each country, nations are"},{"startTime":1416.409,"endTime":1421.179,"body":"their own thing, but they're spread from."},{"startTime":1421.621,"endTime":1422.731,"body":"One a beginning."},{"startTime":1422.911,"endTime":1423.601,"body":"I see what you're saying."},{"startTime":1423.601,"endTime":1423.721,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":1423.721,"endTime":1424.291,"body":"I could see that."},{"startTime":1424.291,"endTime":1424.441,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":1424.441,"endTime":1427.111,"body":"Individual cities that"},{"startTime":1424.441,"endTime":1427.111,"body":"are literally li living."},{"startTime":1427.291,"endTime":1427.651,"body":"Yes."},{"startTime":1427.711,"endTime":1430.381,"body":"And we do talk about cities as living,"},{"startTime":1427.711,"endTime":1430.381,"body":"breathing things a lot of times,"},{"startTime":1430.381,"endTime":1432.361,"body":"but this would be quite literal."},{"startTime":1432.451,"endTime":1433.351,"body":"Yeah, it would be."},{"startTime":1433.356,"endTime":1433.456,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":1433.656,"endTime":1435.751,"body":"It would be a living hive city."},{"startTime":1435.944,"endTime":1439.314,"body":"which would be so, out of what"},{"startTime":1435.944,"endTime":1439.314,"body":"we can fathom, but also so"},{"startTime":1439.314,"endTime":1440.574,"body":"similar to what we are now."},{"startTime":1440.574,"endTime":1441.654,"body":"It's kind of poetic."},{"startTime":1441.864,"endTime":1442.374,"body":"It is."},{"startTime":1442.704,"endTime":1444.857,"body":"And I know that Hive mine's"},{"startTime":1442.704,"endTime":1444.857,"body":"you know, they make a great."},{"startTime":1445.382,"endTime":1449.342,"body":"Science fiction villain, and we see"},{"startTime":1445.382,"endTime":1449.342,"body":"it a lot, but I don't necessarily"},{"startTime":1449.342,"endTime":1450.452,"body":"think they need to be a villain."},{"startTime":1450.452,"endTime":1452.522,"body":"I don't think they need to"},{"startTime":1450.452,"endTime":1452.522,"body":"be this evil, horrible thing."},{"startTime":1452.972,"endTime":1458.689,"body":"And, the typical sci-fi trope of a hive"},{"startTime":1452.972,"endTime":1458.689,"body":"mind being this hungry, all expanding"},{"startTime":1458.689,"endTime":1461.879,"body":"swarm that wants to essentially"},{"startTime":1458.689,"endTime":1461.879,"body":"assimilate everything into its own."},{"startTime":1462.025,"endTime":1463.285,"body":"I don't necessarily think that's true."},{"startTime":1463.54,"endTime":1467.695,"body":"I, I think that that would be"},{"startTime":1463.54,"endTime":1467.695,"body":"tricky to imagine because for one."},{"startTime":1468.484,"endTime":1470.194,"body":"we talked about the"},{"startTime":1468.484,"endTime":1470.194,"body":"size, the scaling issue."},{"startTime":1470.494,"endTime":1473.734,"body":"It might be disadvantageous for them"},{"startTime":1470.494,"endTime":1473.734,"body":"to expand by, at a certain point they"},{"startTime":1473.734,"endTime":1477.274,"body":"may turn inward and really focus on"},{"startTime":1473.734,"endTime":1477.274,"body":"maximizing what they have locally,"},{"startTime":1477.274,"endTime":1479.284,"body":"toward trying to expand broadly."},{"startTime":1479.704,"endTime":1484.563,"body":"And two, if you're imagining this"},{"startTime":1479.704,"endTime":1484.563,"body":"being one consciousness where instead"},{"startTime":1484.563,"endTime":1487.2,"body":"of, our brains are made up of a bunch"},{"startTime":1484.563,"endTime":1487.2,"body":"of neurons, their brains are made"},{"startTime":1487.2,"endTime":1489.15,"body":"up of a bunch of individual beings."},{"startTime":1489.585,"endTime":1492.135,"body":"Then it could potentially be"},{"startTime":1489.585,"endTime":1492.135,"body":"reasoned with and thought with."},{"startTime":1492.195,"endTime":1494.655,"body":"Although it would be interesting"},{"startTime":1492.195,"endTime":1494.655,"body":"to think about what the psychology"},{"startTime":1494.655,"endTime":1495.855,"body":"of such an entity would be like."},{"startTime":1496.185,"endTime":1499.065,"body":"Yeah, I mean, it would, it makes"},{"startTime":1496.185,"endTime":1499.065,"body":"you think like it would kind of"},{"startTime":1499.065,"endTime":1500.685,"body":"just be like a dumb hive mind."},{"startTime":1500.855,"endTime":1505.032,"body":"it, if it's feeling like it needs to"},{"startTime":1500.855,"endTime":1505.032,"body":"just constantly expand into vour, and"},{"startTime":1505.032,"endTime":1509.629,"body":"it's not managing its population, or"},{"startTime":1505.032,"endTime":1509.629,"body":"its mental capacity if we're thinking"},{"startTime":1509.629,"endTime":1511.729,"body":"of them as individual like neurons."},{"startTime":1511.989,"endTime":1516.039,"body":"it's just like, like, like hungry"},{"startTime":1511.989,"endTime":1516.039,"body":"and it can't spread across the"},{"startTime":1516.039,"endTime":1519.639,"body":"universe, but it needs to travel"},{"startTime":1516.039,"endTime":1519.639,"body":"and consume all these other planets."},{"startTime":1519.833,"endTime":1524.625,"body":"if it doesn't have fast than life travel,"},{"startTime":1519.833,"endTime":1524.625,"body":"it's only path is to die eventually."},{"startTime":1524.685,"endTime":1524.775,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":1524.775,"endTime":1526.665,"body":"It'll consume the whole galaxy and die"},{"startTime":1527.085,"endTime":1527.745,"body":"or just Yeah."},{"startTime":1527.745,"endTime":1531.135,"body":"Cease to exist because they're just"},{"startTime":1527.745,"endTime":1531.135,"body":"split into multiple different beings"},{"startTime":1531.135,"endTime":1531.595,"body":"and mm-hmm."},{"startTime":1531.595,"endTime":1531.79,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":1531.855,"endTime":1533.115,"body":"It does not seem like a good path."},{"startTime":1533.505,"endTime":1535.665,"body":"Although, one thing, and I,"},{"startTime":1533.505,"endTime":1535.665,"body":"sorry, this is slightly changing"},{"startTime":1535.665,"endTime":1538.065,"body":"track, but it is something that"},{"startTime":1535.665,"endTime":1538.065,"body":"we talked about earlier, was."},{"startTime":1538.965,"endTime":1542.205,"body":"A notion of a high mind that we often see"},{"startTime":1538.965,"endTime":1542.205,"body":"is that the individual nodes are dumb."},{"startTime":1542.544,"endTime":1544.314,"body":"we think about ant colonies or B colonies."},{"startTime":1544.344,"endTime":1544.434,"body":"Mm-hmm."},{"startTime":1544.674,"endTime":1547.194,"body":"And, you know, they're not"},{"startTime":1544.674,"endTime":1547.194,"body":"particularly smart, but they follow"},{"startTime":1547.194,"endTime":1549.931,"body":"all of these evolved, patterns"},{"startTime":1547.194,"endTime":1549.931,"body":"and they follow these, call and"},{"startTime":1549.931,"endTime":1552.241,"body":"response cues from the greater group."},{"startTime":1552.241,"endTime":1554.881,"body":"And that that's what makes them"},{"startTime":1552.241,"endTime":1554.881,"body":"smart, is they're like together."},{"startTime":1555.047,"endTime":1556.997,"body":"But that doesn't"},{"startTime":1555.047,"endTime":1556.997,"body":"necessarily need to be true."},{"startTime":1557.027,"endTime":1558.317,"body":"You can have a hive."},{"startTime":1558.317,"endTime":1562.507,"body":"My made up of intelligent individuals,"},{"startTime":1558.317,"endTime":1562.507,"body":"for example, I was thinking of a situation"},{"startTime":1562.507,"endTime":1567.247,"body":"where maybe you have a hive made up"},{"startTime":1562.507,"endTime":1567.247,"body":"of individuals who have human level"},{"startTime":1567.247,"endTime":1571.247,"body":"intelligence, but they just have really"},{"startTime":1567.247,"endTime":1571.247,"body":"strong biological responses to certain"},{"startTime":1571.247,"endTime":1575.705,"body":"stimuli, Like pheromones or even sounds,"},{"startTime":1571.247,"endTime":1575.705,"body":"and it's not hard to imagine, right?"},{"startTime":1575.705,"endTime":1576.815,"body":"Humans have that already."},{"startTime":1576.815,"endTime":1577.685,"body":"We have empathy."},{"startTime":1578.105,"endTime":1580.625,"body":"Naturally, if I see someone"},{"startTime":1578.105,"endTime":1580.625,"body":"in trouble, the human response"},{"startTime":1580.625,"endTime":1581.735,"body":"is that you want to help,"},{"startTime":1581.855,"endTime":1582.095,"body":"right?"},{"startTime":1582.215,"endTime":1583.385,"body":"But we can walk away from that."},{"startTime":1583.385,"endTime":1584.735,"body":"We can override that response."},{"startTime":1584.735,"endTime":1588.229,"body":"But imagine a species evolving where"},{"startTime":1584.735,"endTime":1588.229,"body":"they can't, where if there's a, a"},{"startTime":1588.229,"endTime":1592.189,"body":"call for help, they, they're literally"},{"startTime":1588.229,"endTime":1592.189,"body":"biologically forced to respond."},{"startTime":1592.549,"endTime":1595.159,"body":"And in that way, you could"},{"startTime":1592.549,"endTime":1595.159,"body":"potentially have a hive mind"},{"startTime":1595.159,"endTime":1596.809,"body":"made up of very intelligent."},{"startTime":1596.893,"endTime":1600.853,"body":"individual members, it's just"},{"startTime":1596.893,"endTime":1600.853,"body":"that they feel compelled to"},{"startTime":1600.853,"endTime":1602.983,"body":"respond to the cues of the hive."},{"startTime":1602.983,"endTime":1606.947,"body":"So, we were imagining the civilization,"},{"startTime":1602.983,"endTime":1606.947,"body":"how it might function, if the greater"},{"startTime":1606.947,"endTime":1612.768,"body":"colony put out a call for people to, go"},{"startTime":1606.947,"endTime":1612.768,"body":"be workers, then people would happily do"},{"startTime":1612.768,"endTime":1613.978,"body":"it and feel compelled and, and, and just."},{"startTime":1614.612,"endTime":1615.392,"body":"It would just happen."},{"startTime":1615.619,"endTime":1617.029,"body":"but that doesn't make"},{"startTime":1615.619,"endTime":1617.029,"body":"them any dumber, right?"},{"startTime":1617.029,"endTime":1620.124,"body":"Like free will and intelligence don't"},{"startTime":1617.029,"endTime":1620.124,"body":"necessarily have to go well hand in hand."},{"startTime":1620.124,"endTime":1620.659,"body":"You can be very intelligent."},{"startTime":1622.039,"endTime":1624.829,"body":"But not be an individual or not"},{"startTime":1622.039,"endTime":1624.829,"body":"have that individual free will."},{"startTime":1625.069,"endTime":1629.119,"body":"Yeah, I mean, I, I definitely understand"},{"startTime":1625.069,"endTime":1629.119,"body":"and that concept is super unique"},{"startTime":1629.119,"endTime":1634.669,"body":"because it's like, it is a hive mind"},{"startTime":1629.119,"endTime":1634.669,"body":"in the way of chemical responses and,"},{"startTime":1634.715,"endTime":1638.229,"body":"reactions in the brain that rewards"},{"startTime":1634.715,"endTime":1638.229,"body":"you and compel you to do those things"},{"startTime":1638.229,"endTime":1642.759,"body":"instead of just a drive for raw transfer"},{"startTime":1638.229,"endTime":1642.759,"body":"of information and that information"},{"startTime":1642.759,"endTime":1647.139,"body":"being linked to an entity or a network"},{"startTime":1642.759,"endTime":1647.139,"body":"that is simply controlling all of you."},{"startTime":1647.311,"endTime":1648.451,"body":"Super cool concept."},{"startTime":1648.661,"endTime":1649.681,"body":"Yeah, I think it's cool."},{"startTime":1649.681,"endTime":1651.541,"body":"I don't know if it's explored"},{"startTime":1649.681,"endTime":1651.541,"body":"much in science fiction."},{"startTime":1651.541,"endTime":1652.136,"body":"I would love to see it."},{"startTime":1652.136,"endTime":1652.561,"body":"I haven't seen it."},{"startTime":1652.591,"endTime":1653.341,"body":"Yeah, I haven't either."},{"startTime":1653.341,"endTime":1656.431,"body":"I would love to see a work of that where"},{"startTime":1653.341,"endTime":1656.431,"body":"they're individuals but they just, they"},{"startTime":1656.881,"endTime":1660.151,"body":"strong compulsion versus the traditional"},{"startTime":1656.881,"endTime":1660.151,"body":"hive mind where it's, you know,"},{"startTime":1660.151,"endTime":1662.371,"body":"telepathy and you're not an individual."},{"startTime":1662.761,"endTime":1663.091,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":1663.271,"endTime":1666.511,"body":"No, and I definitely think that that"},{"startTime":1663.271,"endTime":1666.511,"body":"would still be considered a, a hive mind."},{"startTime":1666.536,"endTime":1667.321,"body":"I, I think you're right."},{"startTime":1667.321,"endTime":1669.751,"body":"It's every, everything"},{"startTime":1667.321,"endTime":1669.751,"body":"is so like based off of."},{"startTime":1670.666,"endTime":1674.868,"body":"Uh, essentially idiotic worker drones,"},{"startTime":1670.666,"endTime":1674.868,"body":"or even drones that are like, just"},{"startTime":1674.868,"endTime":1679.174,"body":"built to perform specific tasks"},{"startTime":1674.868,"endTime":1679.174,"body":"that you forget that, a hive mind"},{"startTime":1679.174,"endTime":1683.09,"body":"is just, entities that are all like,"},{"startTime":1679.174,"endTime":1683.09,"body":"compelled to work together and almost"},{"startTime":1683.09,"endTime":1684.44,"body":"in a way that is against your will."},{"startTime":1685.01,"endTime":1688.1,"body":"But it doesn't have to be, like"},{"startTime":1685.01,"endTime":1688.1,"body":"you said, an intellectual way."},{"startTime":1688.1,"endTime":1690.158,"body":"It could be you're compelled"},{"startTime":1688.1,"endTime":1690.158,"body":"to do it chemically."},{"startTime":1690.158,"endTime":1690.428,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":1690.488,"endTime":1693.99,"body":"And it's, you said against your will,"},{"startTime":1690.488,"endTime":1693.99,"body":"but it, it's also true if it can make"},{"startTime":1693.99,"endTime":1695.55,"body":"your will aligned with what it wants."},{"startTime":1695.58,"endTime":1696.09,"body":"That's right."},{"startTime":1696.09,"endTime":1699.541,"body":"That's, not against your will,"},{"startTime":1696.09,"endTime":1699.541,"body":"but, to curve your will to where"},{"startTime":1699.541,"endTime":1701.221,"body":"that is truly what you want to do."},{"startTime":1701.281,"endTime":1701.851,"body":"Exactly."},{"startTime":1701.941,"endTime":1705.151,"body":"And that's something that on a"},{"startTime":1701.941,"endTime":1705.151,"body":"small extent, happens with humans."},{"startTime":1705.201,"endTime":1709.526,"body":"we do have biological responses if"},{"startTime":1705.201,"endTime":1709.526,"body":"there's screams, people tend to respond."},{"startTime":1709.526,"endTime":1711.503,"body":"Like we do have that"},{"startTime":1709.526,"endTime":1711.503,"body":"just not to that level."},{"startTime":1711.743,"endTime":1711.983,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":1712.016,"endTime":1715.376,"body":"like the same way that if you touch"},{"startTime":1712.016,"endTime":1715.376,"body":"a hot pan, you pull your hand away."},{"startTime":1715.466,"endTime":1717.506,"body":"It would just be the same"},{"startTime":1715.466,"endTime":1717.506,"body":"type of reaction as that."},{"startTime":1718.046,"endTime":1718.526,"body":"Exactly."},{"startTime":1718.736,"endTime":1719.396,"body":"It's uh, yeah."},{"startTime":1719.396,"endTime":1720.386,"body":"Super interesting."},{"startTime":1720.506,"endTime":1720.596,"body":"I"},{"startTime":1720.596,"endTime":1721.556,"body":"think so I think it's fun."},{"startTime":1721.586,"endTime":1722.756,"body":"I would like to see that explored more."},{"startTime":1722.869,"endTime":1726.289,"body":"And even taking that a step further,"},{"startTime":1722.869,"endTime":1726.289,"body":"you could potentially even see again,"},{"startTime":1726.319,"endTime":1729.559,"body":"uh, the same situation, human level"},{"startTime":1726.319,"endTime":1729.559,"body":"intelligence, but then you could start"},{"startTime":1729.559,"endTime":1734.307,"body":"to see specialization on top of that"},{"startTime":1729.559,"endTime":1734.307,"body":"and actual physiological differences"},{"startTime":1734.307,"endTime":1738.447,"body":"between different cast of this"},{"startTime":1734.307,"endTime":1738.447,"body":"civilization to fulfill different roles."},{"startTime":1738.657,"endTime":1740.727,"body":"And what would actually also"},{"startTime":1738.657,"endTime":1740.727,"body":"be interesting would be."},{"startTime":1741.162,"endTime":1746.682,"body":"Are these roles going to still make sense"},{"startTime":1741.162,"endTime":1746.682,"body":"as this hive mind becomes technological?"},{"startTime":1746.682,"endTime":1747.702,"body":"Or will they become outdated?"},{"startTime":1747.822,"endTime":1748.182,"body":"Right."},{"startTime":1748.182,"endTime":1751.242,"body":"Yeah, like there's, there's an ant"},{"startTime":1748.182,"endTime":1751.242,"body":"colony where they, they have a specific."},{"startTime":1751.556,"endTime":1753.026,"body":"Ant that basically is a door, right?"},{"startTime":1753.026,"endTime":1754.736,"body":"It has like a big, broad, flat head."},{"startTime":1754.736,"endTime":1757.406,"body":"Like, does that work when that"},{"startTime":1754.736,"endTime":1757.406,"body":"ant colony has space travel?"},{"startTime":1758.126,"endTime":1758.366,"body":"No."},{"startTime":1758.366,"endTime":1761.906,"body":"I mean, I, I definitely get what you're"},{"startTime":1758.366,"endTime":1761.906,"body":"saying, like those physiological changes"},{"startTime":1761.906,"endTime":1766.782,"body":"that were made to fill a role because"},{"startTime":1761.906,"endTime":1766.782,"body":"they needed to change what they were"},{"startTime":1766.782,"endTime":1768.252,"body":"as a creature to be able to do it."},{"startTime":1768.402,"endTime":1771.856,"body":"Where as you progress as an intelligent"},{"startTime":1768.402,"endTime":1771.856,"body":"hive mind, you would essentially."},{"startTime":1772.336,"endTime":1775.396,"body":"Take on like how we do today"},{"startTime":1772.336,"endTime":1775.396,"body":"with language and training."},{"startTime":1775.396,"endTime":1779.506,"body":"We can make anybody anything as"},{"startTime":1775.396,"endTime":1779.506,"body":"long as they're willing to do it."},{"startTime":1779.506,"endTime":1785.806,"body":"And if you have the hive minds"},{"startTime":1779.506,"endTime":1785.806,"body":"chemical push to do so, you could"},{"startTime":1785.806,"endTime":1789.226,"body":"achieve whatever you wanted and needed"},{"startTime":1785.806,"endTime":1789.226,"body":"to fill in that colonies niche just"},{"startTime":1789.226,"endTime":1790.576,"body":"through a transfer of information."},{"startTime":1790.636,"endTime":1791.656,"body":"It would make it obsolete."},{"startTime":1791.836,"endTime":1792.586,"body":"Yeah, exactly."},{"startTime":1792.586,"endTime":1795.106,"body":"And I'm just wondering, would these."},{"startTime":1795.571,"endTime":1797.161,"body":"Hives where they have specialization."},{"startTime":1797.306,"endTime":1800.876,"body":"Would those specialized roles be able to"},{"startTime":1797.306,"endTime":1800.876,"body":"adapt fast enough as technology evolves?"},{"startTime":1801.476,"endTime":1805.766,"body":"Or would it be that you have these cast"},{"startTime":1801.476,"endTime":1805.766,"body":"of, uh, members used to be a part of"},{"startTime":1805.766,"endTime":1808.946,"body":"this hive mine that just don't have a, a"},{"startTime":1805.766,"endTime":1808.946,"body":"role that needs to be fulfilled anymore?"},{"startTime":1809.306,"endTime":1813.565,"body":"Or, it's like a, an ant hive, potentially"},{"startTime":1809.306,"endTime":1813.565,"body":"there's  hormonal signals and pheromones"},{"startTime":1813.565,"endTime":1814.615,"body":"that can say, okay, well stop."},{"startTime":1814.96,"endTime":1816.85,"body":"Making larvae turn into this form."},{"startTime":1816.85,"endTime":1819.61,"body":"It's no longer useful, but it,"},{"startTime":1816.85,"endTime":1819.61,"body":"I dunno, that's an interesting"},{"startTime":1819.61,"endTime":1820.39,"body":"one to think about too."},{"startTime":1820.45,"endTime":1825.88,"body":"And potentially even having, um, as a"},{"startTime":1820.45,"endTime":1825.88,"body":"hive mind became more intelligent, you"},{"startTime":1825.88,"endTime":1829.547,"body":"could even have, cast of people or you"},{"startTime":1825.88,"endTime":1829.547,"body":"know, members of this hive mind that"},{"startTime":1829.547,"endTime":1831.92,"body":"are, nodes for thought and thinking."},{"startTime":1832.209,"endTime":1835.269,"body":"That is actually a huge point too,"},{"startTime":1832.209,"endTime":1835.269,"body":"which we do see in science fiction"},{"startTime":1835.269,"endTime":1839.309,"body":"often , especially in mass effect,"},{"startTime":1835.269,"endTime":1839.309,"body":"they're a main antagonist, a main enemy"},{"startTime":1839.309,"endTime":1842.609,"body":"in the game, but the way to destroy"},{"startTime":1839.309,"endTime":1842.609,"body":"them and get them off the planets, you"},{"startTime":1842.609,"endTime":1844.619,"body":"have to destroy these larger node cells."},{"startTime":1844.619,"endTime":1846.329,"body":"But those aren't the main hive."},{"startTime":1846.359,"endTime":1850.709,"body":"They simply are there to allow for"},{"startTime":1846.359,"endTime":1850.709,"body":"specialized transfer of information"},{"startTime":1850.919,"endTime":1855.062,"body":"down to the base creatures so that you"},{"startTime":1850.919,"endTime":1855.062,"body":"still do have these specialized roles."},{"startTime":1855.677,"endTime":1858.467,"body":"They're just like much, much bigger."},{"startTime":1858.617,"endTime":1858.797,"body":"Yeah,"},{"startTime":1859.727,"endTime":1860.447,"body":"that's very cool."},{"startTime":1860.597,"endTime":1861.527,"body":"It's fun to think about."},{"startTime":1861.557,"endTime":1864.107,"body":"But with that being said, I"},{"startTime":1861.557,"endTime":1864.107,"body":"think that's all that I really"},{"startTime":1864.107,"endTime":1865.637,"body":"have to say on Hive Minds."},{"startTime":1865.637,"endTime":1870.737,"body":"I do think that they're possible"},{"startTime":1865.637,"endTime":1870.737,"body":"both from a evolved perspective and"},{"startTime":1870.737,"endTime":1872.357,"body":"from a technological perspective."},{"startTime":1872.357,"endTime":1874.337,"body":"I don't necessarily think"},{"startTime":1872.357,"endTime":1874.337,"body":"they have to be the Borg."},{"startTime":1874.441,"endTime":1876.58,"body":"they could be utopian or"},{"startTime":1874.441,"endTime":1876.58,"body":"dystopian like many things."},{"startTime":1876.58,"endTime":1877.6,"body":"So I dunno."},{"startTime":1877.6,"endTime":1879.16,"body":"All in all, I think that"},{"startTime":1877.6,"endTime":1879.16,"body":"was a fun discussion."},{"startTime":1879.16,"endTime":1881.386,"body":"I hope all of our viewers"},{"startTime":1879.16,"endTime":1881.386,"body":"enjoyed listening to it as much"},{"startTime":1881.386,"endTime":1882.556,"body":"as I enjoyed talking about it."},{"startTime":1882.766,"endTime":1883.126,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":1883.186,"endTime":1885.076,"body":"And hopefully it raised some"},{"startTime":1883.186,"endTime":1885.076,"body":"questions with you guys."},{"startTime":1885.076,"endTime":1888.196,"body":"Like if, if we had one of the"},{"startTime":1885.076,"endTime":1888.196,"body":"more intellectual hive minds,"},{"startTime":1888.196,"endTime":1889.096,"body":"would you guys join one?"},{"startTime":1889.486,"endTime":1889.546,"body":"Yeah."},{"startTime":1889.546,"endTime":1889.846,"body":"Let us"},{"startTime":1889.846,"endTime":1890.056,"body":"know."},{"startTime":1891.046,"endTime":1893.596,"body":"The con joiners has always sounded"},{"startTime":1891.046,"endTime":1893.596,"body":"like an interesting one to join for me."},{"startTime":1893.926,"endTime":1896.926,"body":"Uh, with that being said, a"},{"startTime":1893.926,"endTime":1896.926,"body":"quick shout out to our Patreons."},{"startTime":1896.956,"endTime":1899.896,"body":"Thank you guys so much for making"},{"startTime":1896.956,"endTime":1899.896,"body":"this show possible and ad free."},{"startTime":1900.226,"endTime":1903.256,"body":"Uh, we're continuing to try to"},{"startTime":1900.226,"endTime":1903.256,"body":"hit that goal of weekly uploads."},{"startTime":1903.796,"endTime":1906.106,"body":"You know, I'm not gonna sell, say"},{"startTime":1903.796,"endTime":1906.106,"body":"a hundred percent, but I would"},{"startTime":1906.106,"endTime":1907.696,"body":"like to do it by the end of 2026."},{"startTime":1907.696,"endTime":1908.536,"body":"That would be perfect."},{"startTime":1908.806,"endTime":1912.766,"body":"I just need to hire an editor and also,"},{"startTime":1908.806,"endTime":1912.766,"body":"uh, join us next week where we are gonna"},{"startTime":1912.766,"endTime":1916.936,"body":"be talking about realistic spaceship"},{"startTime":1912.766,"endTime":1916.936,"body":"design to fulfill a variety of roles,"},{"startTime":1916.936,"endTime":1919.336,"body":"not just warships, which we've talked"},{"startTime":1916.936,"endTime":1919.336,"body":"about in the past, but maybe more"},{"startTime":1919.576,"endTime":1921.916,"body":"mercantile roles, colonization roles,"},{"startTime":1922.216,"endTime":1925.516,"body":"and just the general considerations that"},{"startTime":1922.216,"endTime":1925.516,"body":"would go into designing a real spaceship."},{"startTime":1925.876,"endTime":1928.366,"body":"Yeah, some of the concepts might"},{"startTime":1925.876,"endTime":1928.366,"body":"be cooler than you guys think."},{"startTime":1928.606,"endTime":1928.936,"body":"I hope so."},{"startTime":1930.196,"endTime":1931.156,"body":"Thank y'all so much."},{"startTime":1931.216,"endTime":1931.606,"body":"Take care.."}]}