Dirty Money Files

James Timothy Turner: Sovereign Delusion & The Monopoly Money Dumpster Fire 🔥

• Dominique McGregor

Share episode

Send us a text

The Great Thumbprint Hoax: How NOT to Dodge Your Taxes! 🙄💸

Ever wondered how a self-proclaimed 'President' of an imaginary nation tried to dodge a $300 million tax bill with fake bonds and a red thumbprint? 🤯 Dive into the absurdity with this episode of Dirty Money Files, where we uncover the wild world of the Sovereign Citizen Movement and their laughable schemes. From Walmart parking lot deals to exploiting desperate people during the financial crisis of 2008-2009, James Timothy Turner's audacious fraud is a tale of utter delusion and epic punishment. Let's mock, laugh, and learn from this finance fiasco - don't forget to hit subscribe and share the craziness! 💰😂🚓

00:00 Introduction to the Bold Scam
00:45 The Sovereign Citizen Movement
02:22 James Timothy Turner's Grand Scheme
05:09 The Fake Bonds and Their Appeal
10:30 The IRS Takes Notice
14:45 The Downfall of James Timothy Turner
21:48 Lessons from the Scam
24:36 Lingering Questions and Final Thoughts

Support the show

Speaker 1:

All right. Ever heard of the saying go big or go home? Well, today's scammer took that advice too seriously, except he forgot the part where going big also meant going to prison. Welcome to Dirty Money Files, where cons are bold, schemes are absurd and consequences deliciously satisfying. In a chef's kiss kind of way, today's story has it all Self-proclaimed presidents of imaginary nations, red thumbprints on fake financial documents and Walmart parking deals that make you wonder if we've all been just doing life wrong, or maybe right, because we're not sitting in prison for 18 years. Today we are going to take a lovely dip into the wild world of the sovereign citizen movement, which is basically a group of people who believe laws are optional and taxes are theft Pretty much legal conspiracy theorists who think they can just opt out of reality.

Speaker 1:

James Timothy Turner didn't just try to dodge taxes. James Timothy Turner didn't just try to dodge taxes. He instead thought of himself the mastermind that could rewrite the whole US financial system with a color printer and a red thumbprint, and shockingly finds out that's not exactly how the world works. Turner charged $150 and a pre-1964 silver dollar and don't worry, I will explain that soon In order to teach people to create fake bonds, he claimed he would magically erase their debts, because nothing says, trust me, like demanding payment in an outdated currency. He even tried to pay his own $300 million tax bill with one of these fake bonds. That is a big bill. Yeah, he must have had a bit of a business empire galley on there, dodgy one, and you can probably guess how well that turned out. I assume the IRS has a lot of patience, but I would say they draw the line at Monopoly money. Either way, buckle up, because this is the tale of financial delusion, patriotic nonsense and a hubris so outrageous it feels like satire. But trust me, every absurd detail is real, and so let's dig in. First, we'll set the scene by exploring how Turner became the self-proclaimed president of an imaginary nation and why so many people fell for his ridiculous scam and spoiler.

Speaker 1:

Desperation and delusion make for a dangerous cocktail. Picture this a seminar held in some dingy hotel conference room where the lights buzz overhead and attendees clutch cheap styrofoam cups of coffee. Eyes are wide open with hope. At the front, james Timothy Turner. He stands behind a flimsy folding table preaching about financial freedom and his secret Fake bonds that look like something your 8-year-old might whip up in an art class attendees. The ultimate hack, a way to wipe out their debt and their taxes with nothing more than a printer, some legal gibberish and, for some reason, a red thumbprint. It sounds like the setup for a bad comedy, but for Turner and his followers it was real. So real, in fact, that Turner actually tried to pay his own $300 million tax bill with one of these fake bonds. Honestly, how does someone come up with this and, more importantly, how does anyone believe it? Well, to answer that, we need to start at the beginning, to the rise of James Timothy Turner and the fertile ground that made his scam possible. It's the late 2000s. The economy is in shambles, jobs are scarce, debt is skyrocketing and foreclosures are rampant. People are desperate for a way out, and I think we know why we're here. Desperation is the perfect breeding ground for schemes like Turner's. James Timothy Turner I like his name. It's a bit of a tongue twister. I like it.

Speaker 1:

An Alabama native with an ego, unfortunately the size of his skinks. He wasn't just your average Joe tax dodger. No, he was full delusional, crowning himself the president of a completely made-up Republic for the United States of America, built entirely on sovereign citizen BS. To his followers, turner wasn't just a guy with a plan. To his followers, ternam wasn't just a guy with a plan. He was a savior. He offered hope to people drowning in debt, promising them a way to beat the system that had, in their eyes, failed them. All they had to do was trust him and, of course, pay him.

Speaker 1:

But before we move forward on that, let's talk about sovereign citizens. Sovereign citizens are basically well, people who've decided that laws are more of a suggestion. Taxes, no thanks. Speed limits Not their vibe. Reality, yeah. They'll pass on that too. Their favourite hobby Flooding the courts with absolute gibberish they call truce language. It's a chaotic cocktail of conspiracy buzzwords and fake legal nonsense. The judges hate it, the IRS hates it and honestly, everyone hates it, but to these pelicans it's just the apparent key to freedom.

Speaker 1:

Turner used the sovereign citizen movement as the perfect front for his scam. He wrapped up his fake bond scheme in their legal bogus nonsense, giving it enough credibility to reel in the desperate and gullible. He wasn't just pushing financial freedom, he was selling it in a way to stick it to the man and unfortunately, people bought it. Turner held seminars across the country in 2008 and 2009, teaching attendees methods to defraud the Internal Revenue Service, irs. He promoted the use of fictitious financial instruments, referred to as bonds, in which he could claim discharged debts, including federal taxes, charging $150 per person plus a pre-1964 silver dollar.

Speaker 1:

You need to know. Is the silver dollar worth more or less than $150? Probably more. I mean, it's outdated currency. It'd be like a coin collector's dream. Like dad, I'm into this Because they use paper dollars now. Yeah, no, I know, I'm just curious what the value was at the time. Well, I don't know what the value was at the time, but I did read a little bit about how people do collect it for the, the metal, the precious metal, um, like quality, content or something, not just coin collection, because it did. Actually, it was like 90 silver and like 10 nickel or something I don't know. Um, anyway, so he charged these for reasons no one will ever really understand, or maybe he just liked shiny things. But yes, the pre-1964 dollar is exactly what it sounds like a silver dollar coin.

Speaker 1:

His demand for silver dollars as seminar fees wasn't some random choice. These coins are made from real silver and are practically catnip for the sovereign citizens he targeted. Basically, sovereign citizens are obsessed with the idea that government-issued money is a scam, and see precious metals like silver and gold as the only real currency. So by insisting on silver, turner wasn't just getting paid. He was feeding their delusional anti-government ideals.

Speaker 1:

Either way, his seminars provided information and strategies that were laughably simple. You'd print the bonds on your home printer, slap on a red thumbprint for authentication and then, ooh, you have what Turner claimed was a legitimate financial document. It honestly sounds like it was felony arts and crafts. But it gets even better. Regarding the distribution methods, imagine meeting your financial sa in a walmart parking lot or, I guess, like kmart for us, where he hands you a stack of fake bonds from the trunk of his car. Honestly, nothing screams legitimate financial operation like a deal conducted in a car park. But for some of his more premium clients, like Thomas Fry, the pharmacist we'll hear more about later Turner handed out these bonds personally, providing step-by-step instructions on how to use them and the goal of these Submit them to banks, creditors or the IRS as payment for debts.

Speaker 1:

Turner's followers were convinced, with some of them trying to use these bogus bonds to pay off mortgages and credit card debt. Imagine yeah, that easy, I know, definitely right now. It's pretty expensive, though. What it's pretty expensive, true, if you get it printed. You know, I guess, like those laser ones, they've got those heat ones. Now, yeah, maybe you would like argue less with your printer. That's a serious financial commitment. Hate the printer.

Speaker 1:

Um turner himself took things a little bit further, attempting to pay off his 300 million dollar tax bill with one of these fake bonds. How many seminars is he giving? $150 for a seminar? And then he ends up with a $300 million tax debt. I don't know, I couldn't really find too much information prior to this, but, like Jesus, that's a lot of a tax debt. Anyway, shockingly, the IRS didn't accept it, because it turns out the IRS prefers actual money over printer paper with a red thumbprint, pink element. You know, yeah, who knew. In addition, he aided and embedded in sending at least 15 similar fictitious bonds to the Treasury to pay taxes and other debt.

Speaker 1:

So James Turner wasn't just selling fake financial documents, he was selling a dream-ish, a dream that you could outsmart the system, erase your debts and live free from the burdens of taxes and laws. And for his followers, it was a deal too good to miss. But, as you'll see, it was a deal too good to miss. But, as you'll see, this dream was built on a foundation of lies, delusion and spectacular misunderstanding of how laws and colour printers actually work, like how it's, as you'll see, as though the listeners haven't already caught on the fact that people have fallen in lies. If you haven't figured that out yet, I don't know if you will see for the rest of the episode. You probably need to know by now. You definitely would need to go get financial literacy training. Anyway, when the dream finally collapsed, it left a trail of financial ruin, legal trouble and probably some very, very confused Walmart shoppers.

Speaker 1:

So at the heart of this scam were these dodgy financial documents that Turner swore could wipe out millions in debt. He called them bonds, but let's be real, they were just fancy bits of paper covered in official-sounding nonsense, random legal jargon and one standout feature what is money, really? But you know, random jargon on a piece of paper. True, now you get it. Now you get the sovereign citizens. Okay, well, I'll find out what I'm doing next. You're going to be on TikTok, like arguing. I'll be on a Google spiral. No, like, you've seen those like TikToks where, like people are like actually arguing with cops. Yeah, I mean, they're all over Australia as well. It's not just like an American thing? Hmm, um, where was I? Um? Turner claimed this thumbprint made bonds legally binding. Where he got that idea? Who really knows? Either way, it was absolute rubbish.

Speaker 1:

These documents were supposed to look official enough to full banks and government agencies, but to anyone with a shred of financial literacy or really a brain, they were obviously a gift. They were obviously fake, and yet Turner sold these bonds to his followers with complete confidence, calling them the secret to financial freedom. In reality, though, they were just the fast track to financial disaster, and so how did Turner keep his household cards from collapsing straight away? The answer lies in three things Confidence, complexity and desperation. First, turner's confidence was his superpower. He sold his scam with such conviction that even skeptics started to wonder if there was something to it. Second, his pseudo-legal jargon he spouted was intentionally complex. The average person had no way of knowing whether what he said was legitimate or nonsense. And finally, turner preyed on desperate people. When you're drowning in debt, you're more likely to cling to a life raft or like leaking on. It's like global financial crisis right in 2008. Yeah, yeah, so people are very desperate at this point. I guess that makes sense that people tried to use it for the mortgages, because that was, it was the housing issue. Yeah, anyway, his scam was built on a foundation of false promises and bad printing techniques, but for a while it worked. People believed in him, they believed in the fake bonds and they believed they could outsmart the IRS with a piece of paper and a thumbprint. But no scam lasts forever, and Turner's time was running out. His followers weren't the only ones paying attention to him. So was the IRS, obviously, and when the government finally decided to crack down, they brought the full weight of the law with him the real law, not fake law. And so next up, we will dive in on how this ridiculous game unraveled and explore the fallout for everyone involved, because when you go up against Uncle Sam, you better believe he doesn't play games.

Speaker 1:

Every great scam has a breaking point, and for James Timothy Turner's it came courtesy of a pharmacist, thomas Fry, a 59-year-old from Andalusia, alabama and I'm so sorry You're not going to get places right ever on this show. No, I can't practice. Okay, he thought he'd found the ultimate tax hack. Fry owed $250,000 in back taxes and decided to settle the bill using one of Turner's vague bonds. Naturally, the IRS took one look at the bond and said nice try, but what really raised eyebrows was the red thumbprint. Imagine being the IRS agent who had to file that report. Suspected taxpayer fraud includes art project with thumbprint. It was enough to trigger an investigation, just not actually into Fry, but into the man who had sold him the ridiculous idea in the first place.

Speaker 1:

As the IRS agent dug deeper, they uncovered the paper trail that led straight to Turner. Reports of his nationwide seminars and fake financial documents poured in. The IRS realized this wasn't just a one-off incident. It was a full-blown operation, and the final straw came Turner's own attempt to pay his $300 million tax bill with one of his fake bonds. Investigators began to close in, culminating in a sting operation that, of course, went down in a Walmart parking lot. Sorry, I just the irony. In September 2012, turner was indicted on 10 counts, including conspiracy to deep road, the United States attempting to obstruct the IRS and, of course, fabricated financial documents. Fabricated financial documents Included in the broader charges against him was the $17.6 billion maritime lien that James Timothy Turner filed.

Speaker 1:

This kind of filing is commonly part of the broader strategy employed by members of the sovereign citizen movement. The tactic involves filing fraudulent or retaliatory. Retali, retaliatory, retaliatory. The tactic involves filing fraudulent or retaliatory liens against government officials or private citizens, often as a means of harassment or to assert baseless legal claims. Turner's lien, filed in Montgomery County, alabama, wasn't a legitimate maritime claim. It had nothing to do with shipment or international commerce. Instead, it was based on a deliberate misinterpretation of maritime law, a hallmark of sovereign citizen ideology. Because, you know, I guess they can't. Isn't it like international waters? You can't. I don't know if there's many international waters in Alabama, but we'll find out. These liens are typically used to intimidate targets, creating legal and financial headaches by complicating their records and transactions through such-like filings that have no actual legal standing to them.

Speaker 1:

James Timothy Turner's failure to file a federal income tax return for 2009 was also another key charge in the broader case against him involving financial crimes and anti-government activities. That year, turner earned taxable income primarily through seminars, where he promoted his fraudulent tax evasion schemes, making him legally required to file under federal law. However, as a prominent figure in the sovereign citizen movement, turner likely adhered to the unfounded belief that federal tax laws didn't apply to him, a claim that courts have previously consistently dismissed. Under the Internal Revenue Code, bailing to file a tax return is a criminal offence punishable by prison time or significant fines. In Turner's case, this additional charge was to show part of a larger pattern of tax evasion and obstruction that then, of course, strengthened the government's case. His refusal to comply with tax laws not only broke federal statutes, but also clearly showed his broader defiance of the government authority, which we can see is clearly a reoccurring element of his activities. That ultimately led to his 18-year prison sentence.

Speaker 1:

The trial that followed was nothing short of a spectacle. Federal Prosecutor Justin Gelfand had the unenviable task of explaining to a jury why a red thumbprint on a piece of paper doesn't make it a legally binding financial document. Turner, true to form, doubled down on his delusions. He argued that his bonds were legitimate and that he had uncovered secrets that Washington didn't want the public to know. He painted himself a victim of the government's overreach, claiming he was being persecuted for exposing the truth. The jury, thankfully, saw things differently. On July 31, 2013, turner was convicted on all counts. The judge handed him an 18-year prison sentence, which was actually one of the harshest ever given for this kind of financial fraud, and $21 in restitution to the IRS, and imposed a five-year term of supervised release following his prison term. In the end, the man who dreamed of a sovereign nation wound up in federal prison with more debt.

Speaker 1:

Turner wasn't the only one who paid the price for this scam. His followers, many of them who were already financially struggling, found themselves in deeper trouble. Take, for example, thomas Fry, the pharmacist who tried to pay off $250,000 of tax debt. Why is it so high, these tax debts? Anyway, the pharmacist, they don't have good accountants giving them advice, I guess Creepy. Thomas Fry, the pharmacist who tried to pay off his $250,000 tax debt with one of Turner's fake bonds, saw not financial freedom, but instead a six-month prison sentence and probably a lifetime of regret.

Speaker 1:

For Turner's victims, the consequences weren't just legal, they were personal and financial. People who attended his seminars were left with more mountains of debt and no real way to pay them off, and, I guess, being humiliated from being duped Worse. Many of them genuinely believed Turner's promises, only to discover their get-out-of-debt-free cards were nothing more than elaborate scraps of paper, and so this wasn't just a scam. It was a betrayal of trust preying on people's anguish and desire for financial salvation. I think the lesson here is there's no such thing as a free ride, particularly out of tax debt, if someone tells you they've discovered a secret. The government doesn't want you to know. They're either lying, delusional or about to sell you something. And if they ask you to pay in silver dollars, just run. When people feel trapped by debt, when they're drowning in bills and struggling to keep their heads above water, even the most ridiculous promises can sound like salvation, and that's exactly what Turner offered, no matter how illogical it was. And this is the part where we and society need to ask ourselves the hard questions how did we get to a place where people were so desperate they thought fake bonds could actually solve their problems? Turner may have been the con man, but the system that he exploited one where people felt powerless, concerned and ignored obviously set this stage.

Speaker 1:

Now, turner's conviction in 2013 might have been a win for the IRS, but it didn't spell the end of the sovereign citizen movement. If anything, the ideology has adapted and evolved in the digital age. Today, you can find YouTube channels, tiktoks and entire forums dedicated to spreading these pseudo-legal theories and secrets about how to outsmart the government, and it's not just about tax scams anymore. The movement has inspired everything from fraudulent real estate scams to confrontations with law enforcement. Like I was saying with the car, they don't give over their license. I was saying with the car, they don't give over their like license. The FBI even classifies certain sovereign citizen extremists as domestic terrorism threats, which is a sign of how dangerous these ideals can be when taken to the extreme. Of course, though, for most followers, it's not about extremism, it's about desperation.

Speaker 1:

Turner's followers weren't looking to overthrow the government. They were just looking to get out of debt, and what makes these scams so treacherous is they prey on people who feel like they've run out of options. Scams like Turner's are very much still alive. The tactics might change, but the playbook stays the same Exploit financial fear, promise an easy fix and wrap it in enough legitimacy to make it believable. Today, instead of fake bonds, you've got crypto scams, online trading gurus and influencers pushing get-rich-quick schemes on social media, and, just like Turner's Bonds, these scams often target the most vulnerable People, who can't afford to lose but have no choice but to gamble. Without a doubt, the best protection from these schemes is financial education, understanding the basics, like how taxes work and what constitutes as legitimate financial advice or documents, and, of course, skepticism. The more we talk about cases like Turner's, the harder it becomes for scammers to operate in these shadows.

Speaker 1:

In the end, the story of James Timothy Turner's isn't just about one man's delusions or the bizarre quirks of the sovereign citizen movement. It's about how easily people can be led astray when they're desperate for a solution to their problems. It's about systems that leave people vulnerable to exploitation and the enduring truth that if something sounds too good to be true, it probably is Okay. So we've unraveled the scam, laughed at the absurdity and noted the consequences, but there are still a few lingering questions, some, of course, that may never be answered and some, honestly, that make this whole story weirder.

Speaker 1:

First up, why did Turner really use the pre-1964 silver dollars? Was it really just a marketing gimmick or a way to make his seminars feel more exclusive? And then there's the walmart connection. Why did so many transactions and handovers be conducted in walmart parking lots? What was the convenience? Did turner think it was the perfect cover for a criminal enterprise? It's not exactly subtle either.

Speaker 1:

And then let's not forget the infamous red thumbprint. Did Turner really believe that dipping your hand or your thumb in ink transformed a counterfeit document into a legal tender? Or was it just a stupid fancy feature to make the bond seem more authentic to his prey? It's the kind of thing you'd expect from a child, not a full-on tax or financial scam. And, of course, the biggest question did Turner actually believe in his own BS? Did he truly believe in the sovereign citizen ideology, convinced he was fighting the good fight against the IRS? Or was it just some devious con?

Speaker 1:

The line between scammer and believer can get pretty blurry. At the end of the day, maybe some things like what the hell is going on in his brain are better left a mystery. Honestly, why would anyone think a printer and a thumbprint could fool the US government? It's beyond me Even more why China thought he'd get away with writing off a $300 million tax bill written in essentially what was Microsoft Word. And so that's the story of James Timothy Turner.

Speaker 1:

And so that's the story of James Timothy Turner, a man who dreamed of building a sovereign nation but ended up with nothing more than fake bonds, red thumbprints and an 18 year stay in federal prison. Honestly, it's the kind of absurd, as it was audacious, he promised his followers financial freedom with a printer and some pseudo-legal jargon, and for a while they believed him. But as we've learned today, there's no such thing as a shortcut when it comes to taxes. And let's not forget the players in this story, the desperate followers who bought into the financial freedom dream, the IRS agents who had to decode Turner's nonsense, and the federal prosecutors who had to explain to a jury why monopoly money isn't legal tender. It's like a comedy of errors.

Speaker 1:

So what's the takeaway? First, if someone claims they've discovered a secret loophole to avoid taxes, they're lying. Second, if they ask you to pay in silver dollars, run. And third, never trust a man who conducts business out of a Walmart parking lot. It's just a good rule of thumb of life. Anyways, thanks for joining us on this wild ride through the dirty money files of James Timothy Turner. If you enjoyed today's episode, don't forget to hit that subscribe button, leave us a review and share it with your favorite financial misfit. Until then, keep your money where you can see it and your taxes paid, and keep your skepticism.