Siblings in Crime
Siblings in Crime is a weekly true crime podcast hosted by brother and sister duo, Blake Murphy and Ally Rossell.
Join us as we dive into the darkest, most chilling crime stories from around the world. Whether it's unsolved mysteries, brutal murders, or bizarre disappearances, Siblings in Crime is your go-to podcast for captivating and thought-provoking true crime tales.
Every week, we explore a new case, discussing details that will keep you on the edge of your seat. We mix humor with the macabre, offering a fresh approach to true crime storytelling. From historical criminal events to modern-day investigations, they explore both classic and contemporary cases that spark curiosity and discussion.
Tune in to Siblings in Crime for compelling storytelling, intriguing criminal investigations, and a deep dive into some of the most spine-tingling true crime stories out there. Perfect for true crime fans who love gripping narratives and the bond between siblings.
Subscribe now and join the conversation each week!
Siblings in Crime
30 Years Hiding in Plain Sight - April Tinsley
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
In 1988, eight-year-old April Tinsley disappeared during a short walk through her Fort Wayne neighborhood. Days later, she was found murdered.
For decades, the killer taunted investigators in various ways. Despite DNA evidence, witness sketches, FBI profilers, and hundreds of leads, the man responsible remained hidden in plain sight.
Thirty years later, this horrific monster was finally brought to justice.
This is the story of April Tinsley.
SOURCES
- Wikipedia — Murder of April Tinsley
- FBI.gov — Tinsley Killer Profile (primary BAU profile, May 19, 2009)
- FBI.gov — April Tinsley Murder, Parts 1, 2 & 3 (archived, 2009)
- Time Magazine — probable cause affidavit reporting, July 2018
- CNN — case coverage, June 2009 & July 2018
- NBC News — sentencing coverage, December 2018
- WANE-TV (Fort Wayne) — detective interview, January 2019; sentencing coverage, December 2018; Miller death, September 2025
- WTHR (Indianapolis) — genealogy break reporting, July 2018
- ABC News — arrest coverage, July 2018
- CBS News — case coverage
- Inside Edition — abduction and arrest coverage
- The Burr Magazine (Kent State) — Everett Shull sourcing, citing Crime Junkie interview with Janet Tinsley
- Casefile True Crime Podcast — Everett Shull detail, Miller post-confession statements
- True Crime Edition — FBI profile excerpt, case timeline
- Parabon NanoLabs — DNA Snapshot composite releases, 2015 & 2016
- America's Most Wanted — Season 22, Episode 29 (2009 segment)
