The Lethal Library
Step into the spine-chilling aisles of 'The Lethal Library', where the only thing deadlier than the cocktails is the wit of its hosts, Dani and Stephanie. This podcast isn't just true crime, it's crime served with a side of snark and a garnish of gallows humor. So, pour yourself a strong one and buckle up for a ride through the Pacific Northwest's most notorious death row stories. Just remember, the only sentence here that's truly life-threatening is the one ending in a punchline.
The Lethal Library
53. Hidden Horrors: The Secret Life and Crimes of Payne
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Dani and Stephanie dive into another death row case in Idaho: A Boise State student leaves work for class and vanishes, along with her unmistakable green Mustang. That same morning, a brand-new Micron employee doesn’t show up either… and his wife finds their home weirdly “off”. Two days later, with a deputy finally at the house to take a missing-person report, the phone rings; what’s said on that call blows the entire case wide open and sends police racing from Idaho to an Oregon Motel 6. As the investigation unfolds, a disturbing pattern emerges: past “peeping” behavior, hints of other attacks, and a gut-wrenching look at how an earlier assault involving two 14-year-old girls was handled. Trials, DNA, a death sentence, reversals, and more follow—because this story does not stop once the cuffs go on.
Contact The Lethal Library at TheLethalLibrary@gmail.com. Follow us on Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok!
