Deep Story

Newton's Clockmaker Defeated: A Creativity Revolution

• MPT

Share episode

Unlock the mystery of 18th-century maritime exploration and the race to solve the deadly problem of longitude. Sailors faced chaos, shipwrecks, and even pirate attacks—all without knowing where they truly were. Enter John Harrison, a self-taught clockmaker who challenged the great Isaac Newton and revolutionized navigation with his groundbreaking marine timepiece.

But his journey was anything but smooth. Rivalries, skepticism, and innovation collided in a battle that reshaped history. What was the strange connection between floating fireworks and celestial navigation? And how did a carpenter outwit the era's brightest minds?

Dive into this gripping tale of ingenuity and perseverance—you won't believe how it ends.

Support the show

Speaker 1:

All right, folks. Thank you all for coming to Support Deep Story. Please buckle up, because today we're diving into a story of innovation, disaster and sheer human determination. Let's go back to the 18th century, specifically to 1707, when one of the most dramatic naval disasters in British history took place, setting the stage. Yet, the British fleet in 1707 pictured this. Sir Cloudsley Chauvel, a celebrated British admiral, had just led his fleet to a spectacular victory over the French in the Mediterranean. He's riding high, returning home with five ships and a full crew.

Speaker 1:

It's December 22, 1707. His fleet is off the coast of Brittany, near the Silly Isles. Now, if you've never heard of the Silly Isles, let me tell you. Back then, sailors called it the gateway to hell. Why. The place is crawling with hidden reefs and jagged rocks. Sail into that area without a clear course and you're done. And wouldn't you know it, a thick fog rolls in.

Speaker 1:

By 10 pm, disaster strikes. In just a few minutes, four of Chauvel's five ships smash into the rocks and sink. Over 1,000 sailors perish. Sir Cloudsley Chauvel, oh, he survives, at least for a while. He washes ashore, only to be murdered by a local woman who spots his fancy emerald ring and decides she'd rather have that than let him live. How do we know this? Well, decades later, this woman confessed on her deathbed to her priest. That's how the truth came out.

Speaker 1:

But today we're not here to focus on Chauvel's tragic end. No, we're here to talk about what happened before the disaster, the fatal decision. Hours before the ships ran aground, a crew member on one of the ships approached Sir Chauvel and said Sir, I think we're off course. You'd think this would lead to a calm discussion, maybe some adjustments. Nope, chauvel immediately ordered the crewmen to be hanged on the spot.

Speaker 1:

Why? Because at the time the British Navy had a strict rule no one was allowed to question the captain's judgment, especially when it came to the ship's location. Doing so was considered mutiny, punishable by death. Why such a rule? Here's the thing in the early 1700s, navigation was terrible. Captains didn't have GPS or even accurate maps to guide them. They relied almost entirely on gut instinct. Now, imagine you're trying to steer a ship through uncharted waters relying on nothing but your intuition. If every sailor starts chiming in with their opinion, it's chaos. It's like being in a crowded shopping mall with your indecisive friends all yelling let's go there. No, over here You'd lose your mind. So the rule was simpler the captain's word was final. If you questioned it, you died, and that's how that poor crewman ended up swinging from the mast.

Speaker 1:

The real problem longitude. This brings us to the heart of the issue Navigation in the open ocean. At the time, sailors could figure out their latitude pretty easily. Latitude is the north-south position on a map and you can measure it by looking at the height of the sun at noon. Sure, it was hard on the eyes, so hard in fact that 19 out of 20 captains supposedly went blind in one eye from staring at the sun. That's why so many pirates and captains wore eye patches. It wasn't because of fights, it was the sun. But longitude. Forget about it. Longitude is the east-west position and there was no reliable way to measure it. Unlike latitude, which is based on natural markers like the equator and the poles, longitude is totally arbitrary. For example, today we use the prime meridian at Greenwich as the starting point, but back then the French thought it should run through Paris.

Speaker 1:

Islamic scholars argued for Mecca. Everyone had an opinion, the simple but impossible solution. In theory, figuring out longitude is easy. All you need is time. Here's how it works. The Earth is 360 degrees around. It takes 24 hours for the Earth to rotate fully, so every 15 degrees equals one hour. If you know the time at Greenwich and the local time where you are, you can calculate the difference and figure out your longitude Easy, right.

Speaker 1:

The problem was time. Once you're out at sea, you lose sight of land and have no reliable way to keep track of Greenwich time. Why? Because 18th century clocks were garbage. They couldn't stay accurate on a moving, swaying, damp ship. The consequences of no longitude.

Speaker 1:

Without a way to measure longitude, sailors were basically gambling with their lives. They relied on luck to reach their destinations, which meant longer voyages. Without precise navigation, trips took unpredictable amounts of time. Sailors often ran out of supplies and got sick with scurvy, a brutal disease caused by a lack of vitamin C. You'd get bleeding gums, internal hemorrhaging and a slow, painful death. It wasn't until the late 1700s that Captain Cook figured out you could prevent scurvy with foods like sauerkraut and citrus juice.

Speaker 1:

Pirates ships couldn't stray far from known latitudes, so they all followed the same busy trade routes. This made them easy targets for pirates. The more predictable the route, the easier it was to ambush a ship. Shipwrecks like Sir Chaveau's fleet. Countless sailors met their end on reefs and rocks because they couldn't pinpoint their location.

Speaker 1:

Desperate attempts to solve longitude. People tried everything to fix this problem. Some ideas were clever, most were ridiculous. But no matter what they tried, without an accurate clock nothing worked. And so Europe's greatest maritime powers Britain, spain, france, the Netherlands were stuck losing ships, sailors and treasure, all because they couldn't figure out where they were.

Speaker 1:

Let's dive back into this wild journey of how humanity tried and hilariously failed to solve the longitude problem. We talked about Sir Cloudsley Chaveau's doomed fleet and how the lack of a reliable way to measure longitude turned the ocean into a watery lottery. Now let's explore the crazy ideas people came up with to fix it. Spoiler alert some of these are absolutely bonkers when desperation meets creativity.

Speaker 1:

Let's start with one of my personal favourites the sympathetic powder theory. Here's the idea If you stab someone, or in this case a dog, you sprinkle this magical powder on the weapon, not the wound, and supposedly it heals the injury. Sounds legit, right? So here's what they thought let's stab a dog, put it on a ship and send it to sea Back on land. Every day, at exactly noon, we sprinkle the powder on the knife, the dog on the ship. It feels the pain and yelps, boom, the sailors know it's noon in Greenwich and they can calculate longitude. Yeah, someone actually thought this was a good idea.

Speaker 1:

Then there was the floating fireworks plan. Every hundred miles or so, they'd station a ship in the Atlantic and at the top of each hour these ships would fire a cannonball or launch a flare into the sky. Any nearby vessel could check the time by spotting the flare and comparing it to their own Sounds. Cool, right, but then reality hit. First, the logistics. How many ships, cannons and flares would you need? Second, you can't just anchor a ship in the middle of the Atlantic. The water's too deep and the technology to keep a vessel stationary didn't exist. Two competing solutions.

Speaker 1:

So with the crazy ideas out of the way, humanity focused on two serious approaches. First, the star method. The stars and planets are like a massive cosmic clock. If you could map out the exact position of celestial bodies for a given time in Greenwich, you could compare them to the stars you see at sea and calculate the difference. Second, the clock method. Or you could just build a really good clock, sync it to Greenwich time and take it with you. Compare your clock's time to local time at noon and voile, you've got longitude. But let me tell you, both paths were easier said than done. For centuries, scientists were pulling their hair out over these challenges. Their hair out over these challenges. Enter Galileo the stargazer.

Speaker 1:

Let's talk about Galileo. The guy was a legend. He basically invented the pendulum clock and thought maybe clocks could solve this problem. But then he realized clocks back then were about as reliable as a drunk friend giving directions. So he turned to the stars. Galileo noticed that Jupiter's moons had a predictable schedule. By observing when these moons appeared or disappeared, you could figure out the time. In Greenwich Genius, right. He even invented a device for this, a contraption called the selotone. It was like an early version of a VR headset. You'd strap it to your face and one eye would lock onto Jupiter while the other tracked its moons.

Speaker 1:

The problem Try using that on a ship. Ships move, waves, rock. Try using that on a ship. Ships move, waves, rock. The tiniest motion throws off your aim. And let's not even talk about trying to spot a speck of light the size of a breadcrumb through a shaky telescope. It was impossible. So Galileo's brilliant idea ended up being a bust. The clock method back to the drawing board.

Speaker 1:

Fast forward to 1714, just a few years after Chauvel's disaster, the British were in full panic mode. They're a maritime superpower and they just lost an entire fleet right outside their own front door. That's like a NASCAR driver crashing in their own driveway. So Britain decides to treat this like their version of the Manhattan Project. They offer a massive cash prize to anyone who can solve the longitude problem. Enter Isaac Newton, the OG scientist and a guy you'd think could solve anything.

Speaker 1:

Newton shows up at the committee meeting looking absolutely exhausted. He delivers a report and his message is clear Clocks are a waste of time. Why clocks seemed impossible? Here's why Newton dismissed the clock method the ocean's constant movement. A clock on land sure works fine, no-transcript Temperature changes. Imagine you're sailing from the warm tropics to the icy north. The materials in the clock expand and contract with the temperature, throwing off the timing. Even the lubrication in the gears, animal fat and oil would thicken or thin depending on the weather. Thicken or thin depending on the weather. To solve the longitude problem you needed a clock that was so accurate it would lose no more than three seconds a day. That might not sound like much, but back then it was a pipe dream. Newton Flatt outtold the committee not only will we fail, but our kids will fail, and probably their kids too. Just when the world's greatest scientists and engineers were throwing up their hands and declaring longitude unsolvable In walks, a guy who, frankly, nobody saw coming.

Speaker 1:

John Harrison who was he? A clockmaker? Nope. A mathematician? Definitely not. He was just a carpenter Yep, your average rural, tinkering around with wood kind of guy. And somehow this ordinary man ended up solving one of the greatest scientific challenges of his time. John Harrison, the unlikely genius. Harrison grew up in the English countryside building things for local churches. As a young man he built a clock for one church that didn't even use gears. It was a totally original mechanism. Why? Because he didn't know the rules, so he just made them up. And guess what? The clock worked pretty well.

Speaker 1:

Harrison was one of those people who saw problems and thought yeah, I can fix that. He wasn't intimidated by the fact that the world's brightest minds had been stumped by longitude for centuries. He figured why not me? And then he heard about the prize, the race for the longitude prize. In 1714, after that disastrous naval accident with Sir Cloudsley Shovel's fleet, the British government offered a reward 20,000 pounds to anyone who could solve the longitude problem. Adjusted for today that's about 30 million dollars. Let me tell you, that prize got people's attention. Harrison being the ambitious and maybe slightly greedy guy, he was decided to go for it. He thought I've built a few clocks before. How hard can it be? The long road begins.

Speaker 1:

In 1730, harrison went to pitch his idea to Edmund Halley, the guy behind Halley's comet and head of the longitude board. Now Halley was all about astronomy. So when Harrison started talking about clocks, halley was like, uh, I don't get it, but you should talk to someone who actually makes clocks. He sent Harrison to meet George Graham, the most respected clockmaker in London Now the most respected clockmaker in London. Now Graham wasn't thrilled to meet some no-name carpenter, but when he saw Harrison's designs he changed his tune. Not only did Graham give him encouragement, but he also gave him 200 pounds from his own pocket to build a prototype. And so, a few years later, harrison built his first clock, the H1, which stood for Harrison Model 1. It was big, it was clunky, but it worked A 29-year obsession.

Speaker 1:

What followed was an epic saga. From 1730 to 1759, a hoping 29 years Harrison built four versions of his marine clock crew H-1, h-2, h-3, and finally H-4. Along the way. He faced constant setbacks and spent nearly three decades perfecting his design. The third version H-3, was especially brutal. Harrison worked on it for 16 years. He ran out of money, spent his brother's inheritance and eventually had to bring his son on board as an assistant. To survive, he kept begging the longitude board for more funding, squeezing out a few hundred pounds at a time, like a kid asking for allowance. Over the years they gave him a total of two 500 pounds, just enough to scrape by. When he finally finished age four in 1759, he was already an old man. By the time he received the prize money in 1773, he was 80 years old. At that point it wasn't about the money. It wasn't about the money, it was about finishing what he'd started.

Speaker 1:

The man behind the clock let's talk about John Harrison, the man. He wasn't exactly polished. He had no formal education and when he got into disputes with the Longitude Board he'd write angry pamphlets. One of his pamphlets was 25 pages long, with no punctuation, not one period, just an angry stream of consciousness. But what he lacked in fineness he made up for in craftsmanship, harrison was the definition of obsessive. He didn't just want to build a good clock, he wanted to build a perfect clock. If he thought he could improve something, he'd scrap everything and start over, no matter how much time or money it cost him. And while he was undeniably in it for the money 20,000 pounds was life-changing, there was more to it than that. Harrison had pride in his work. He had what we'd call craftsman spirit, a man of principle. Now here's where it gets interesting.

Speaker 1:

The French government got wind of Harrison's work and tried to poach him. They offered him money to share his designs. He refused. Why? Because he was a patriot, but also because he knew he could use this as leverage with the British government. He basically went to the Longitude board and said hey, the French are offering me 500 pounds just to take a look at my clock. Maybe you should up my funding, or Elsa? This guy was a mix of greed, craftsmanship and patriotism a truly fascinating cocktail of traits the legacy of John Harrison.

Speaker 1:

By the time Harrison finished H4, it was an engineering marvel. It was small, portable and incredibly accurate. It could keep time on a ship through storms, temperature changes and constant movement. Thanks to Harrison's obsession, the world finally had a reliable way to measure longitude. He didn't just solve a technical problem. He revolutionized navigation, saved countless lives and laid the groundwork for the modern world.

Speaker 1:

And all of this? It started with one stubborn carpenter who refused to give up. We've already talked about how this scrappy carpenter who refused to give up. We've already talked about how this scrappy carpenter turned clockmaker spent nearly 30 years perfecting his marine chronometer. But here's the twist Harrison wasn't working in a vacuum. While he was tinkering away, a completely different group of people was fighting him tooth and nail the astronomers. And at the center of this fight was one man, neville Maskelyne. Let's rewind for a moment.

Speaker 1:

Back in the 17th century, most scientists, including the legendary Isaac Newton, believed the key to solving longitude lay not in clocks but in the stars. The idea was that by understanding the clockwork of the heavens, the positions of the stars and planets, you could figure out the time in Greenwich and calculate your longitude. To pursue this, the British government established the Royal Observatory at Greenwich yes, the same Greenwich where the prime meridian is today. Its sole purpose to crack the longitude problem. Generations of astronomers poured their hearts into creating detailed star charts, hoping they could outshine, punn intended, any clockmaker's invention. And one of these astronomers, neville Maskline, was particularly vocal about his disdain for Harrison, who was Neville Maskline. Maskline wasn't just any astronomer. He was the fifth astronomer, royal head of the Greenwich Observatory and a man so devoted to his work that he postponed marriage until he was 54 years old. His entire life was dedicated to the stars, literally To Maskelyne.

Speaker 1:

Harrison was just a lowly carpenter with delusions of grandeur. He firmly believed that no human invention could ever rival the precision of God's celestial design. He also had a massive superiority complex. After all, he was a man of science and Harrison was well well a guy who built clocks in his backyard. A mask line wasn't just sitting around criticizing Harrison. He actually made significant contributions to the longitude problem by publishing the first comprehensive nautical almanac, a yearly guide that mapped the positions of stars and planets. Sailors could use this almanac to calculate Greenwich time by observing the stars and comparing them to the tables. This method was practical, scientifically rigorous and had the backing of nearly every intellectual in Britain.

Speaker 1:

But Masked Lens wasn't just competing with Harrison, he actively worked to undermine him. Let's be clear most of the drama between these two was exaggerated later for the sake of storytelling. For example, dava Sobel's book Longitude paints Maskline as the villain. But the truth is a little more nuanced. Yes, maskline threw some obstacles in Harrison's way. For example, he demanded multiple tests of Harrison's clocks, even after they had proven accurate. He required Harrison to hand over his designs and build additional prototypes to prove his methods could be replicated. But was Maskline some evil mastermind out to sabotage Harrison? Not really. He was just a bureaucrat doing his job, albeit with a healthy dose of skepticism and maybe a little ego.

Speaker 1:

That said, there was one incident that really pushed Harrison over the edge. At one point, the Longitude Board demanded that Harrison hand over his chronometer for further testing. Harrison refused, arguing that they'd just ruin it. Arguing that they'd just ruin it. And well, he wasn't entirely wrong. When the clock was finally taken from his home, it was transported in a horse-drawn carriage with no shock absorbers. During the trip, the clock fell to the ground. Harrison was livid To him. This was proof that Mask Lane and the Longitude Board were deliberately trying to sabotage his work. But was it sabotage or just bad luck? Either way, this became one of Harrison's biggest grievances.

Speaker 1:

Here's the thing, despite the rivalry, that the British system actually fostered innovation. Maskkelyne and his star charts weren't trying to destroy Harrison. They were providing an alternative solution and while the competition was fierce, it was also constructive. Maskelyne never falsified Harrison's test results. He didn't destroy data or block Harrison's progress outright. Sure, he made things harder, but in the end the system ensured that only the best solution would win. This is the hallmark of a healthy innovation environment. The competition might be cutthroat, but it's still fair.

Speaker 1:

Well, mostly by the 1770s, harrison was nearly 80 years old. He'd spent decades battling the longitude board, constantly facing new demands and delays. Finally, harrison decided he'd had enough. He bypassed the longitude board entirely and went straight to King George A Tieta, who happened to be a big astronomy nerd. The king personally tested Harrison's clock at his private observatory and declared it accurate. Armed with the royal seal of approval, harrison marched back to the longitude board and demanded his prize. Even then, the board resisted, but the public pressure, along with the king's backing, was too much to ignore. In 1773, harrison finally received the bulk of the prize money. He was 80 years old.

Speaker 1:

Why did Harrison succeed? So what made this all possible? Let's break it down Constructive competition. But while Masclane was a thorn in Harrison's side, he was also a necessary one. The rivalry between the two approaches clocks versus stars kept both sides sharp and ensured that the best solution prevailed.

Speaker 1:

Institutional support on the longitude board, despite its flaws, provided funding and oversight. It also created a system where even a carpenter could compete with the greatest scientific minds of the time A culture of innovation. In 18th century Britain, even the craziest ideas were taken seriously. Harrison's work may have seemed unconventional, but the system allowed him to prove himself. Hum. At the end of the day, harrison wasn't just a clockmaker. He was a symbol of what happens when passion, persistence and opportunity collide. He proved that innovation doesn't just come from elite institutions or prestigious titles. Sometimes it comes from the least likely places A carpenter's workshop, a backyard shed or even just a stubborn dream. And maybe, just maybe, we can learn something from him about how to create environments where every wild idea gets its chance to shine. Because the way John Harrison finally got his money is just the cherry on top of this wild, frustrating and completely inspiring tale.

Speaker 1:

After nearly 30 years of relentless work, after battling the longitude board, after building not one, not two, but four versions of his revolutionary clock, after testing and proving and re-proving that his invention worked, you'd think Harrison would just stroll into the Longitude Board's office and collect his 20 Zalozen pound prize. Right Wrong, that's not how it went down. Harrison never actually got the full price. The Longitude board, led by our buddy Neville Masclan, just kept dragging their feet. They demanded more tests, they wanted the designs, they asked for more clocks to be built. They stalled and stalled, hoping maybe that Harrison would just give up or, you know, die of old age before they had to pay him. But John Harrison wasn't having it. At 80 years old, after decades of fighting the system, he bypassed the board entirely and went straight to King George CT.

Speaker 1:

Now King George, you should know, was a bit of an astronomy nerd. He loved gadgets and science and even had his own little observatory in the royal gardens. When Harrison showed up with his clock, the king personally tested it. And guess what it worked. The king was impressed. He said you know what? Forget the longitude board, they're impossible. I'll pay you myself. So King George dipped into his own treasury and handed Harrison eight 750 pounds. Yes, not the full 20,000, mind you, but close enough for government work, but close enough for government work. That's how Harrison finally got paid.

Speaker 1:

The Longitude Board never officially awarded him the prize. It was the king, sick of the bureaucracy, who stepped in and said let's just end this madness. Ah, but here's the kicker by the time Harrison got the money he was 80 years old. What was he going to do with it? Retire, buy a yak? The poor guy spent his entire life chasing this prize and when he finally got it he probably didn't even have the energy to celebrate.

Speaker 1:

But this story doesn't just end with Harrison's personal victory, because while Harrison's clock was a masterpiece, there was one big problem it was insanely expensive. His clocks were handmade, incredibly intricate and cost upwards of 500 pounds each. That's more than most ship captains earned in years. Nobody could afford these things. Meanwhile, maskline's star chart system remember him was dirt cheap. You could get a star chart and a sextant for about 20 pounds. Sure, it wasn't as accurate as Harrison's clock and it might blind you if you stared at the stars too long. But it was affordable and that mattered. The problem was clear If Harrison's clock was going to change the world, it had to be mass-produced. Enter the Industrial Revolution.

Speaker 1:

After Harrison's death, his designs were published and Britain's clockmakers went to work. They refined his methods, improved efficiency and started mass producing marine chronometers. The price dropped from 500 pounds to around 50 pounds, making these clocks accessible to nearly everyone. By the early 19th century, there were thousands of chronometers in use around the world. By the time Charles Darwin set sail on the HMS Beagle in 1831, his ship alone carried over 20 chronometers.

Speaker 1:

The problem of longitude was no longer a problem. And this is the real magic of innovation. It's not just about inventing something brilliant. It's about making that brilliance accessible. Innovation doesn't happen in a vacuum. It needs a market, a system and an industrial base to turn great ideas into everyday tools. This wasn't just true in 18th century Britain. Look at today's emerging economies. Why are they so good at building infrastructure, advancing mobile technology or scaling up green energy? It's not because they have more geniuses. It's because they have massive demand. When millions of people need roads, phones or renewable energy, innovation follows. Necessity is the mother of invention and demand is its loud nagging aunt.

Speaker 1:

So what does Harrison's story teach us? First, innovation is never about one person. Sure, harrison was a genius, but he needed the Longitude Board, the Royal Navy, the King's Treasury and Britain's industrial might to turn his clock into a world-changing invention. Second, innovation requires tolerance for the outsiders. Harrison wasn't an elite scientist. He was a carpenter with a dream, but Britain gave him a chance, even when his ideas seemed crazy. Third, scaling matters. Harrison's clock didn't revolutionize navigation until it became affordable. The best ideas mean nothing if nobody can use them. And finally, innovation isn't just about ideas, it's about systems. It's about governments, businesses, workers and dreamers all coming together to solve big problems. Harrison didn't just build a clock. He built a better world, and that's why his story still matters today, because whether you're solving longitude or tackling the challenges of the future, the lesson is the same innovation isn't just about science, it's about people. It's about people, it's about persistence and it's about having the courage to dream big even when the whole world tells you it's impossible. Thank you, and I'll see you next time you.