The haunted St. James Hotel in New Mexico Artwork

Bantering Banshees

Step into the shadows with Steph and Jill, where paranormal history meets hilarious banter. Each episode, we discuss the history of how places came to be, the spirits said to linger there, and the creepy experiences from people.

But don’t worry… we keep it light with our offbeat humor and playful banter, making sure things never get too scary. It’s the perfect mix of eerie and entertaining.

All Episodes

Bantering Banshees

The haunted St. James Hotel in New Mexico

September 23, 2025 • Jill & Steph • Episode 25

Send us a message. We would love to hear from you and your spooky stories by emailing at banteringbanshees@gmail.com

This week, we talk about one of the most notorious haunted hotels in New Mexico, The St. James Hotel. From its bloody wild west history to the infamous sealed room where a man was gunned down, the St. James is packed with stories that refuse to stay buried.

We dive deep into the history, share a few personal encounters, and of course, we can't help but laugh along the way.

And don't miss the surprise ending... Steph gets quizzed on past Bantering Banshees episodes in a hilarious game you don't want to miss.

these are all of our socials:

https://www.facebook.com/share/19X3kx3miA/?mibextid=wwXIfr

https://www.instagram.com/thebanteringbanshees?igsh=MW5haHh0OTEybTk1ZQ%3D%3D&utm_source=qr

https://youtube.com/@banteringbanshees?si=LhbUP3TCoct4-nfM

https://www.tiktok.com/@banteringbanshees?_t=ZT-8yWVP5qtIbd&_r=1

Jill

Host

Stephanie

Co-host