Addiction, Divorce, and Protecting Children: When Tough Choices Become Necessary - Ep 39

In Episode 39 of Cases & Cocktails, Bryan and Janice Eggleston return with guest Jillian French for a unique “storytime” episode, blending real-life scenarios from Reddit with legal and practical insight. Over a Maple Bourbon Smash—crafted with High West whiskey, mint, maple syrup, and Topo Chico—the team discusses how addiction, custody battles, and protective parenting intersect when family safety is at stake.

The Case: Addiction, Hospital Stays, and Divorce

The story begins with a mother of a one-year-old child whose husband struggles with alcohol and prescription drug abuse. After leaving his family for a two-week bender, showing up drunk at the hospital while their child was in the PICU, and later being arrested for DUI, the husband insists he never wanted a divorce and blames his wife for filing while he was “in an altered state.”

Her question: Was I wrong to file for divorce at that time?

The Legal and Emotional Realities

Bryan, Janice, and Jillian agreed that the wife’s decision wasn’t just reasonable—it was necessary. Filing for divorce and seeking suspension of custody in such circumstances wasn’t punitive, but protective. As Bryan noted, “This is what we call being a protective parent.” When a child’s safety is threatened by substance abuse, courts expect the sober parent to take decisive action.

The attorneys highlighted how failing to act in Texas could even trigger involvement from CPS, placing the non-using parent at risk of losing custody for not protecting the child.

Addiction Cases: Complex and Emotional

The episode also dives into the complexity of addiction in family law cases. While substance abuse is common in custody disputes, the Egglestons emphasized the importance of separating substance issues from underlying mental health struggles. Addiction alone does not disqualify someone from parenting—failing to address it does.

Clients, they explained, often struggle with guilt, shame, or denial. Many still hope their partner will return to the person they once knew, making it difficult to move forward. The attorneys stressed that protecting children must always come first, even when it means ending a marriage.

Practical Legal Strategy

For clients accused of substance abuse, Bryan recommends facing the issue directly: voluntary testing, documented treatment efforts, and a demonstrated commitment to sobriety. Courts don’t expect perfection—they expect progress. Showing honesty and accountability goes further than denial or avoidance.

At the same time, the team reminded listeners that judges don’t always fully understand addiction. When a parent is told to “choose between your child and your addiction,” it oversimplifies a mental health struggle. Still, courts require visible effort to ensure children are not endangered.

The Takeaway

Episode 39 underscores a powerful message: protecting children is never the wrong choice. Addiction complicates family law cases, but parents who take proactive steps to safeguard their kids—and who are willing to face substance abuse issues head-on—stand on stronger legal and moral ground.