The Comparison Trap: When Other Families Look Like They're Having More Fun— Ep 111

Escaping the Comparison Trap on a Hawaii Family Vacation

Marcie of Hawaii Travel Made Easy shares how comparing her family’s Hawaii vacation to other families, “perfect” restaurant moments, or Instagram reels made her question choices like letting her kids use iPads or eating grocery store poke in a Waikiki hotel room. She offers reality checks: what looks ideal is often staged or only a brief highlight, and every family has hard moments. She stresses that a vacation can be successful even if it doesn’t look like the brochure, and encourages planning around your own kids’ ages, energy, and needs rather than copying others. Marcie describes helping a client reset expectations after comparing to a sister-in-law’s flawless-sounding trip, promotes her itinerary audit at hawaiitravelwithkids.com, and suggests asking “why do you want to do this?” when adding activities like Pearl Harbor or out-of-the-way stops.

00:00 Poolside Comparison Trap
00:58 Restaurant Reality Check
01:52 Instagram Poke Envy
03:04 Behind the Highlight Reel
04:30 You Are Doing It Right
04:47 Plan Your Own Trip
06:06 Itinerary Audit Offer
06:34 Why Is This On Here
07:52 Reset Expectations
08:07 Resources And Wrap Up

Who this episode is for: Anyone catching themselves comparing their Hawaii trip to other families' "perfect" vacations or Instagram highlight reels.

What you'll learn: Why comparing your trip to others' online highlights sets you up for disappointment, and how to plan and evaluate your vacation around what actually works for your own family.

Activities discussed:

• Eating out vs. grocery store food in a hotel room
• Screen time/iPad use on vacation
• Adding activities like Pearl Harbor or out-of-the-way stops

Marcie's recommendations:

• What looks "perfect" on social media is often staged or just a single highlight, not the whole trip
• Every family has hard moments on vacation, even the ones that look flawless online
• A vacation can be successful even if it doesn't match the brochure image
• Plan around your own kids' ages, energy levels, and needs instead of copying someone else's itinerary
• Before adding an activity like Pearl Harbor or an out-of-the-way stop, ask "why do you want to do this?" to make sure it's actually right for your family
• Get an itinerary audit if you need help resetting expectations and building a plan around your own family

Related Hawaii Travel Made Easy episodes: 

• What First-Time Hawaii Travelers Always Overestimate— Ep 121
• Your First Hawaii Trip Isn’t a Once-in-a-Lifetime Trip— Ep 119

Related articles: 

• Hawaii Itinerary Review

About Your Host: Marcie Cheung is a Certified Hawaii Destination Expert who has visited Hawaii 40+ times and spent 20+ years as a professional hula dancer. Through Hawaii Travel with Kids, she helps families plan authentic, affordable Hawaii vacations that respect local culture while creating unforgettable memories.

Learn more at hawaiitravelwithkids.com

Connect: @hawaiitravelwithkids on Instagram | Book a Consultation

🌺 Join 11,000+ families receiving free Hawaii travel tips, island guides, and insider advice - subscribe now!
https://hawaiitravelwithkids.com/free-5-day-email-course-how-to-travel-to-hawaii-like-a-pro/

Transcript

Copy Transcript Copied

0:00

So there I was, poolside in Hawaii, Kindle in hand, full vacation mode activated, and my kids were next to me in lounge chairs on their iPads in Hawaii. Right in front of us, this other family was absolutely living it up, kids laughing, splashing each other, playing those elaborate pool games. It was honestly kind of beautiful. And I had a split second where I thought, "Am I failing at this?" Then I looked down at my Kindle, looked over at my peacefully occupied children, felt the Hawaiian sun on my face, and I thought, "No, we're fine. We are absolutely fine." Welcome back to Hawaii Travel Made Easy. I'm Marcie, and today we're talking about something I think every mom has felt on vacation and almost nobody admits out loud: the comparison trap. You've spent real money to be there, you've been planning for months, and somehow you're still watching another family across the pool thinking they figured out something you didn't. That feeling has a name, and we're gonna talk about it today. Let me tell you about the restaurant moment because you already heard the pool story. My kids were on their iPad at dinner at a really good restaurant in Hawaii that I had been looking forward to all day. The table next to us had these kids who were just on, talking about their day, excited about tomorrow, trying things off the menu. They looked like the brochure, and mine were on their iPads, and one of them was whining at me in Hawaii at a restaurant I'd been thinking about all day. And I felt it, that little drop in your stomach where you wonder if you're doing it wrong, if other families just have some switch you haven't found yet. And then I caught myself because going out to eat has always been a production with my kids. This is not a Hawaii problem. That is a Tuesday night problem that followed us across the Pacific. The iPads meant relative quiet. I could actually eat my food while it was warm. Nobody cried in public. By any realistic measure, that dinner was a success. It just didn't look like one. And then there's the version of this that I'm a little embarrassed to admit, but I think you need to hear it. A few years ago, I was sitting in my hotel room in Waikiki, jammies on, my youngest on his iPad next to me. I had a container of grocery store poke that, I'm not gonna lie, tasted great. I was happy. We were tired. It was that kind of night. And then I picked up my phone and started scrolling, and there were a group of twenty-somethings in these adorable tropical outfits doing a whole reel about the best poke spots on Oahu. North Shore Poke, these gorgeous colorful bowls. Everything looked incredible. And I looked down at my grocery store container in my hotel room in my pajamas, and I felt bad about it while eating poke that tasted great, that cost me twelve dollars and required zero effort after a day where we had absolutely nothing left The North Shore is not a quick drive from Waikiki. I knew that. We didn't have it in us. Those twenty-somethings without kids and without the day we'd had could absolutely make that drive and film it beautifully, and I could not, and that was the right call, and I let a sixty-second reel make me feel like I'd made the wrong one. If you've ever been in Hawaii and felt worse about your vacation because of something you saw on your phone, you're not alone. Put the phone down. Your poke is fine. So let's talk about what you're actually seeing when you're looking at those other families, because I wanna offer a few reality checks. That family laughing and splashing in the pool, two hours later at dinner, one of their kids was full-on sobbing. The kind of sobbing that takes over a child's whole body when they've had too much sun and too much fun, and there's nothing left in the tank. I've seen it. I've lived it. It happens to everyone. And the Instagram mom at the pool, I witnessed this firsthand, spending twenty-plus minutes staging what she's gonna caption as a candid moment with her kids in the water, directing them, repositioning them. "Can you splash again, but make it look more natural this time?" And those kids started losing it because they just wanted to swim, and instead they were doing unpaid modeling work in a chlorinated pool on vacation. The candid shot took longer than most job interviews. Or the mom at the luau carefully lining up a video of her kids watching the show, thinking, "This is the memory right here," and all three of them are asleep before the fire dancers even come out. Because it's eight thirty at night, and they've been in the sun all day, and they are done. That video exists. It's not the one she posted. And those bright-eyed menu exploring kids at the restaurant next to me, maybe that's just who they are. Or maybe it was day two, and by day five, someone said, "I never wanted to go on this stupid trip anyway," loud enough for half the restaurant to hear. I only saw one meal. That's the thing about comparison on vacation. You're watching a highlight reel, and you don't even realize it because it's happening in real life right in front of you, not on a screen. You're only seeing a sliver. And I wanna say this plainly because I think some of you need to hear it. You are not doing it wrong. A kid on an iPad in Hawaii is not a referendum on your parenting. A hard afternoon is not proof that you should have stayed home. You're there. You showed up. That counts for more than the highlight reel version ever could. So I had a client who came to me with a very detailed picture in her head of the Hawaii trip she wanted. And that picture came almost entirely from her sister-in-law's trip the year before. She walked me through everything, the resorts, the activities, the restaurants, and it all sounded incredible. But here's what caught my attention. Nothing had gone wrong. In her entire retelling, the trip was flawless. No hard days, no overscheduled mornings where everyone was grumpy by ten, nothing, which told me more about what I was working with than anything else she'd said. Because her sister-in-law had elementary-aged kids, my client had a toddler and a preschooler. I'm talking nap schedules, stamina that runs out around two in the afternoon, an entirely different kind of trip. Not worse, just different, and it needed to be planned that way. So I stopped her and I said, "I'm gonna tell you something a friend told me when I became a new mom, and that thing is comparison is the thief of joy." It's essentially sneaky when you're comparing your trip to one you only heard about secondhand in the best possible light from someone whose kids are in a completely different stage of life than yours. We set the sister-in-law's trip aside entirely and started over. What does your family actually need? What does a good day look like for a toddler and a preschooler? What does it look like for you? We came up with a plan that was actually hers, and I'd bet anything it was better for her family than anyone else's itinerary would have been. If you're in that place right now, building a Hawaii trip based on what you've seen someone else do, or what looks good on Instagram, or what your friend with older kids swears by, this is exactly what my itinerary audit is for. You send me what you've got and I look at it through the lens of your specific family, your kids' ages, their energy levels, the kind of trip that's actually gonna feel good for you. You can find it at hawaiitravelwithkids.com under Hawaii Itinerary Review. It's the fastest way to stop planning someone else's trip and start planning yours. So when you're building your trip or looking at one you've already built and something feels off, the question I come back to with almost every client is, why do you want to do this? And if you can't answer it, that's usually your answer. People put Pearl Harbor on their itinerary all the time, and when I ask why, there's often a pause and then something like, "Because you're supposed to, right? Because it's there?" But if nobody in your group has a real connection to World War II history, if your kids don't actually know what they would be walking into, that's three or four hours of your vacation that isn't actually for you. It's some imaginary version of what a Hawaii trip is supposed to look like. Same with the shave ice place someone mentioned in a Facebook group three years ago that's forty-five minutes out of your way. Is it worth the drive? Maybe. But do you know that? Have you asked whether the grandparents or the toddler or whoever you're traveling with actually wants to spend that time in the car? Or did it go on the list because it felt wrong to leave it off? The trips that feel right when you come home thinking, "That was exactly what we needed," are almost always the ones where you can explain why each thing is there. Not because someone else did it, not because you saw it on a reel, because it actually fits your family and the kind of day you're trying to have When you notice the comparison creeping in at the pool, at dinner, scrolling your phone while you're already sitting in Hawaii, just ask yourself, is this actually a problem or is this just not what I pictured? My kids on their iPads at the pool wasn't a problem. It was a Sunday afternoon at home, just with better weather and a view of the ocean. I was on my Kindle. They were resting. The vitamin D was free. If you want to get ahead of all this before you even get on the plane, episode 37 is a good place to start. That's the truth about Hawaii travel, managing expectations for a better trip. And if you're still in the should we even do this phase, episode 103 looks at whether Hawaii with kids is actually worth it right now for your family. For everything else, resources, guides, all of it in one place, head to hawaiitravelwithkids.com under Hawaii resources. If this one hit close to home, share it with another mom who needs to hear it. And if you've had your own comparison trap moment in Hawaii, pool deck, restaurant, phone in hand while grocery store poke sat there perfectly fine, I want to know about it. Come find me on Instagram at hawaiitravelwithkids. Your trip doesn't have to look like anyone else's to be worth every penny. It just has to be yours. Thanks so much for listening and I'll see you next time. Aloha.