HCA Tech Talk - News, Reviews and Opinions

Most Replayed Moment: What Makes A Home Cinema

HCA Media Episode 21

Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.

0:00 | 20:02

Send us Fan Mail

What turns a room with a big screen into a place where stories breathe and families gather? We take a clear-eyed look at what “home cinema” really means today, separating design-led experiences from out-of-the-box shortcuts and explaining how to get immersive results without wasting budget.

We start with the blueprint: seat-to-screen distance, viewing angles, and speaker locations. Those decisions shape everything—from soundstage precision to the punch of bass and the clarity of dialogue. Then we dig into immersive audio, decoding the muddle around “Atmos” on headphones, soundbars, and true multi-speaker rooms. Using RP22 performance levels as a guide, we map practical paths from a thoughtful TV-plus-speakers setup to a dedicated, reference-grade space. Along the way, we show why calibration and dynamic range matter more than raw volume, and how a well-tuned 5.2.2 can outperform a bigger but poorly planned array.

Picture quality pairs with sound for an impact that feels cinematic. We talk Filmmaker and Cinema modes, day/night presets, and when a professional calibrator is worth it—especially with projectors. You’ll hear real examples of small speakers placed well, outshining larger, pricier gear dropped in at random. Most importantly, we focus on purpose: turning unloved rooms into flexible media spaces where movie nights, big-match moments, and gaming sessions become weekly rituals that pull people off their phones and into the same story.

Ready to test-drive the difference between good, better, and breathtaking? Hear how demo rooms reveal where each dollar goes and how to choose the right RP22 level for your needs. If you’re planning a build—or just want to make your TV sound ten times better—this conversation gives you a clear, jargon-free roadmap. If you enjoyed the show, follow, share it with a friend who’s planning a room, and leave a quick review to help others find us.

Learn more about the Home Cinema Alliance - https://linkly.link/2SXqX


Get the latest News, Reviews and Opinions:

HCA Tech Talk - https://linkly.link/2a0s3

Inside CI - https://linkly.link/2cM2p


Support the Podcast by using our Affiliated links:

Support the podcast by shopping on Amazon - https://geni.us/npUEx 

An award-winning VPN deal from Surfshark - https://linkly.link/2cM3B

Start your own podcast and received $20 - https://linkly.link/2acMf

Support the show

Public Perception And Misuse Of Terms

SPEAKER_00

So bringing this on to our topic of the month, um, I thought we'd sort of like strip it right back to you know, fundamentally, what is a home cinema? What do you as a client perceive a home cinema to be, a viewer? Uh please let us know below what you are aware of uh as a home cinema. I've always wanted to do like a I think it's family fortunes, you know, stand out on an industrial estate somewhere, not looking weird, uh, and basically do a And the survey says? The survey says, you know, are we allowed to say that? It's not copyrighted, is it? Uh are we allowed to do a uh sorry, uh uh what's your idea of a home cinema? You know, because I I do believe that the word home cinema has been banded around a lot. Uh it's now used on uh very many different things. Uh but I don't, in a way, I don't think that's a bad thing. But you know, because in the way of like you clients are made aware of Dolby Atmos, which is in this room, but they're made aware of it because of soundbar, it's written on a soundbar, or it's on a set of headphones because maybe a set of gaming headphones uh can run immersive audio, Dolby Atmos audio type of thing. So I think because we are the home cinema alliance and we do build rooms like this, um where do you see the home cinema? Where do you think sometimes people's misunderstanding of the term home cinema is?

Have-It-Your-Way Rooms For Families

SPEAKER_01

I I I think it's educating the client and as you said, where they've seen it. So whether it's an advert, whether it's the local retail park, um, and what what they're into. So whether it's gaming, movies, or watching sport. Um home cinema, we did an article not too long ago, is like have it your way. Yeah. Because you can nowadays have a room your way. It doesn't have to be a dark, blacked-out room like a coffin. You can have a nice, bright, airy room with a TV or cinema or media um projector-based system. Um, so with a with a home cinema, for us, it's again, it's that destination for the whole family to come to. Doesn't matter how old you are, how young you are, and what you want to do in that room. Whether the kids want to come in and put YouTube on or whatever, do a bit of gaming, watching movies, or watch Britain's got talent, for instance. It's just it's it's just bringing the whole family together and sitting down, they're not on their phones, they're not like going off, wandering off to do other things and you know where they are. Obviously, depending on their age and what they want to do, but they can give their friends come around as well. We've we've got a demo facility, and I know you have too, where the kids can go and that can be their base, and yeah, it it works for everybody. So I think the perception of home cinema in a box.

SPEAKER_00

Yeah, I was gonna say, do you so a lot of people would consider as a home cinema coming in a box that you would buy from one of the big department stores?

SPEAKER_01

I think so. I I think people's perception of oh, I need a big room, I need a I need an extra extension built, for instance. But it's any unloved room. Yeah. That we we've done kitchens before, so we've done a kitchen because they did build an extension, so we did a really decent cinema uh in in a that what used to be a kitchen. Um any unloved room, like a uh a playroom, yeah. Kids are growing up, what's in there now? Not a lot.

Any Unloved Room Can Work

Design-Led Vs Box Solutions

Seat, Screen, Speakers, Calibration

Atmos Tiers And Clear Expectations

SPEAKER_00

Well, I think if you go if you go to cinema in there. For me, the term home cinema, so if it comes in a box, I would say that's a surround sound system. Because fundamentally, what you're the next step up from Prologic, maybe. Yeah. Oh god, that there's back to the days where you had the wires running around from your Toshiva Cafe Tube TV. It worked. Yeah. Uh Debonham's in Hastings, I think, was my Saturday job when that when Top Gun first came out. Um, but you know, I sort of perceive a home cinema as being something that has been led by a design. Um, I think it's something where by your reach out to a HGA member, a CDM member, or or just someone who is uh, you know, at home cinema, a respected home cinema company globally, not just in the UK. And they the questions they'll ask you is more about about the room you're going to use. You know, they'll work out, like if you speak with Paul here at Arcoustics, you know, it fundamentally a lot of it base is based around the seated position, which is based around the screen size, which is based around speaker locations, which I know in our video we touched on the speakers that are in here, and ultimately they're a relatively smaller speaker. But for me, I don't say there's anything wrong in a box solution. So I don't say there's anything wrong with solutions like Sonus, um, you know, where they may use a five-speaker system. Um, but I think the term at home cinema, I think he's I think it's been misused personally, and I think it's for me, it's been quite a few years to educate my clients on the difference of you know, buying a box solution or putting a sound bar. I mean, there's a friend of ours who told me a story once of a room that he had, which was many, many speakers, and it was in his garden, and he ran a garden festival. I won't mention his name, uh, he ran a garden thing every year, and and all these kids were in it and using it, and one of the clients came up to him and said, What's this? And he just said, Oh, it's a home cinema. Um, and next year, this person uh who asked the question, it was their opportunity to run this event, uh charity event. Um and after it all happened, and this is the guy's name then, after it all happened, this lady took this unnamed man into the room and said, What do you think of my home cinema? And it was a 98-inch Samsung TV with a Dolby Apple soundbar below it. Um now, I'm not saying there's anything wrong with that, but that's not a cinema. You know, if you went to an Odeon or can't think of any others, uh if you went to an Odeon or a Kino or something like that, and you had a soundbar below the screen, yeah, you'd be a bit miffed that you just.

Matching Picture Quality With Sound

SPEAKER_01

You'd be a bit annoyed that you spent 15 quid on a ticket and uh bought some popcorn and some and a and a drink, but it I think you're right, is that misuse of that word? So especially with home cinema and and Dolby Atmos, that Dolby Atmos is an immersive experience in a room. Yeah, they're now classing headphones as Dolby Atmos. There should be different levels of what you get from Atmos, in my in my personal opinion. So Atmos level yeah, like, or for instance, it's like yeah, extreme or something like that, just so the client is more educated and understands what's going on. So, yeah, uh and the the way we approach things is understanding the client's needs and requirements. So, how are you gonna use this room? What are you gonna do in this room? If you're just gonna sit here and watch normal TV, yeah, sound barb might be perfectly fine for you. But okay, do you stream TV? Yep, Netflix, Amazon, yeah, Apple TV, streaming all those? That's an immersive experience now. So it's so cinematic TV. Uh you can get the Dolby Atmos, you can get um uh Dolby Vision and picture quality, really pops out the screen, really does. So if you've got a really vibrant picture and you've got a little soundbar, you're getting a big screen with loud noise. Yeah, you want that cinematic experience.

Dynamic Range And Real Impact

Affordable 5.2.2 Done Right

SPEAKER_00

Well, you're losing that dynamic range. 100%. Uh Paul, one of Paul's favourite clips uh back in the old showroom was uh Cloverfield Road. Uh and it's a bit of the beginning where it's quiet, quiet, quiet, quiet, quiet, and then something happens and it literally scares the living bejeebas out of you. I mean, I remember Paul saying to me as he walked out, he went, Stuart, you haven't got a heart condition, have you? Uh, because it there was that dynamic range. Yeah. And I remember going home and doing that on my uh, what was then 5.1 system in the lounge, and it it worked, but then a few days later Did your sub pop? No, luckily it's a it was a good sub. At that point, I had two kef subs, so it was fine. Um, but a few days later I tried it at the the showroom where I had an old solace play bar on the wall, um, and you just completely lost it. So, you know, Sony used the the phrase lens to living room, you know, and you know, calibrating TVs to how the director intended it to be seen, so the case being colour accurate. I think that I think you're missing a big part of a film. If you're if you're really passionate about a film, and I'm not saying you have to spend tens and tens of thousands of pounds, um, but if you're really passionate about a film, about just thinking a little bit more about you know where you're positioning your speakers, you know, work with a HCA member, uh, how even go on to like Dolby and just look uh at their speaker placement recommendations uh and get the system professionally calibrated, um, uh if it's a a smallish sort of like in you know, like a I don't know, let's say for argument, a relatively small system like the one we did at uh in the Bedfordshire one, which was a uh an anthem amplifier, and that was a 5.2.2, so five speakers around you, two supporters, two ceiling speakers for Atmos, and that was a great little system, professionally calibrated, uh, which didn't cost a lot of money, but it just gave them much more immersive.

SPEAKER_01

It's just designing the room to the to a decent standard. As you said earlier, sometimes you could emit rear speakers because you you they don't work in the room, you don't need them. So a good 5.2.2 system works pretty well, you know. It's um you get really good sound from from that.

RP22 Performance Levels Explained

SPEAKER_00

And actually, sometimes stepping it back. I mean, uh you've probably done it, and I know, I know I've done it, and many other HCA members have done it. I know our friend Owen at Cinema Works recently did a project that we took some photography for for him uh down in Somerset. Funny enough, all of Owen's clients are called Steve, which gets really confusing. But that was a room which it it didn't require, because it was actually smaller than this room, but it didn't require loads of speakers and it was just a bit of a waste. Um obviously we have RP22 now, uh which was launched last year. It was last year.

Demo Rooms And Value Decisions

SPEAKER_01

It was January last year. It's been a long time in the making, but uh we're we're big, big advocates of that, and it just it just helps the client understand what what we're trying to achieve for them. So level one, level two, level three, level four, if you can get to that. Yeah, wholly level four. Holy level four. But what it also helps is um the client can make intelligent decisions, yeah. So they understand, especially coming to facilities like like this or any other facility that's available to uh to um the the end user um via HCA members is um what what can what can be uh achieved. And they know the difference between level one and level two and level three. Oh level three is quite a lot of money, but level two, actually okay, I'll I'll have I'll have that system because I can see the worth in that. Well and I think Paul would. You wouldn't buy a car without test driving. Exactly. That's about test driving. Come into these facilities that we've all got used to. If you've got your own demo room, then fantastic. So contact the HA member and uh they'll they'll they can either bring you to a facility like this or go to their own uh their own showroom.

SPEAKER_00

And I think when you're a client and you see uh, I don't know, I'm gonna pull a figure out of the air. So if you see a 20,000 room, 20,000 pound room, and then you're shown a 40,000 pound room, and then you're shown a 60,000 pound room, and let's just say the decor and every room's the same. I think, yeah, like like with cars, you want to know where your that money is being spent and why. Why is the do you see the worth in that?

Calibrate TVs And Projectors Properly

SPEAKER_01

If you don't see the worth in it, just go for level one and level two. If you if you see the worth in a level three, stroke, level four cinema room to have that grand cinema experience, then uh then go for it. But uh I think the RP22, um, and then now they're doing one for the uh the video as well, um which uh I think will help um in a lot of a lot of projector stroke TV designs within that room because obviously that that plays an important part in the room as well.

SPEAKER_00

Well, as we said now, especially with uh you know screens, TV screens getting bigger, and although you know, like my LG's got out of the box filmmaker mode, uh uh ISF mode, and I know when I was with Greg, formerly of THX, where Steve was formerly of JVC, uh, we calibrated uh or took out a box of Panasonic G20 or something like that out of a box, and we checked the calibration on it with you know with the the the the computer and the cameras, and actually it was pretty close. So actually, if you're doing a TV-based system and it has a filmmaker mode or uh ISF, I don't think many have THX now, um, but set it to that. Yes, it will look darker, it may look a bit browner. Uh, but it it I have that at home and it does work.

SPEAKER_01

Yeah, we always set our TVs to uh to cinema mode, and uh that gives you that uh that correct setting. But uh we would always recommend calibr getting a professional calibrator in so uh most HA members either know somebody or they can do it themselves, but um get getting a projector uh especially is uh is beneficial and obviously TVs do have that built in, but uh getting that set up for day and night mode um is uh is very very uh worthwhile.

Great TV Plus Speakers Can Shine

SPEAKER_00

So I think for me, you know, ultimately home cinema and I think where where I think about with our clients, you know, I I I mean we did an exhibition recently um which was like my five-year-old panasonic OLED connected to a kaleidoscape, connected to a I can never get this right, WIM amplifier, W-I-I-M, all I think is we, uh, as we were saying earlier. And actually, I was just using the remote control that came with the Panasonic, and it was really nice. That's all you need. And actually, the the two paradigm in-walls with a paradigm uh little rockweiler subwoofer, that thing kicked, and actually, there's nothing wrong with having a TV with two good like bookshelf speakers with or without a subwoofer.

Flexible Paths Beyond Soundbars

SPEAKER_01

A lot of people were more than happy with that. More than it's not, it's not, you've just got a TV with nothing else, it sounds ten times better than that. If you want something even better, and you've got the space and the room, and obviously the money, then uh you can have any system in in in theory.

SPEAKER_00

Yeah, I mean, Paul's just shown us uh a CPH soundbar out there, which again, if you watch the Arcoustic Showroom tour on the HGA YouTube channel, um that sounded phenomenal. I mean, obviously, you can't tell on the video, and we didn't play anything on the video because we get struck for copyright. Um, but actually, no sub on it.

SPEAKER_01

No sub, really cool stereo speaker that can integrate with the TV. Um so yeah, just watching normal TV and playing music, say on a whim, or streaming your uh your uh your your streaming services on there, that's a great sounding experience. Yeah, I think I think again it's how it's how you want it. That's that's the way that I now perceive a media stroke cinema room. It's how you want it. Have it your way. Yeah, you you can have that stereo centre speaker, as long as it sounds better than the TV and a sub, fantastic. If you wanted surround sound, you can have surround sound in that, but you you're not stuck to one particular system now. If you want something better than out of the box or just that sound bar, then that's fine. Nothing wrong with that. If you want something better, then there's there's plenty out there.

SPEAKER_00

I believe that if you strip out all the fancy stuff out of the room, like the finishes, things like that. Okay, it's not gonna be a 500 pound surround sound system from a high street store, but uh and they're not as dear as you think they are gonna be. And actually, you could take a very small speaker and uh and if it's in the right place, pointed in the right direction, and it's calibrated properly, you'll get a fantastic little room. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01

It's like when you speak to friends, it's like, oh, when I win the lottery. Yeah, yeah. It's like, what do you mean when you win the lottery? Have you got a kitchen? Yeah. How much does that cost? We'll give you the price. Well, cinema room is less than that. Yeah. Quite a lot less than that. If you've got a bigger room, then it might cost a little bit more. But you don't need to win the lottery to uh nowadays, anyway, to have a media uh cinema room.

Family Rituals And Screen Time Together

SPEAKER_00

It's uh No, you do get them. I mean, your comment about the kitchen. I I did uh uh one for a client I won't mention. It was a 15-seater cinema. You can see it on our YouTube channel if you want to see it. Um, and I still don't know what cost more the cinema or the kitchen, uh, because I know the brand of kitchen that was put in and I know how much the client spend with me. Um yeah, I still don't know. So for me, you know, and I think for you as well, the feedback you get from clients on these rooms, and and actually if you want it to be somewhere special that you spend time with your family. I mean, one of the first cinema rooms I ever did in uh Wandsworth, I think it was, you know, the clients turn around to me and said, every Friday, uh sorry, every Saturday night, they go down there as a family. No phones, no tablets, no computers, no games consoles, no switch to. Um it wasn't even the switch then, uh, no switch to, but they just go down as a family. You know, one person chooses to take away, not eating downstairs, sitting upstairs first. Uh, one person chooses to take away, one people choose person chooses to film every week. So, as my friend would say, some weeks you do get frozen for the third time and KFC, but then sometimes you'll get a really good movie and you'll get you know um a uh you know uh a Chinese or something like that. But for them it's just it's spending quality time with each other, and that's what it's about, yeah.

SPEAKER_01

And it's we'll leave busy lives and it's drawn.

SPEAKER_00

It's walking out of the room and going upstairs, and actually, I think I think there were four of them, two kids, two adults, might have been five, can't remember now. Um, but uh they said we were having conversations afterwards about the film we just watched. Yeah, and I think that's what's brilliant about cinema.

More Than Movies: Sports And Events

SPEAKER_01

Yeah, there's there's so many different films out there and educational educational films and things that uh historical films that people can can watch and uh and they look back on as like, oh actually, yeah, that's uh that's fundamentally really important.

Memories Over Gear

SPEAKER_00

It's great in family memories, and it's you know, we'll touch on it in a future topic as well. But you know, big screen sports, you know, during COVID we had the demo room, and and if you go way back on my Instagram, uh you'll see like a picture of microwaved popcorn and snacks that we would put in and drive the 15 minutes to my demo room, and we'd sit and watch a film. I mean, hell, during COVID, there was times where I was sitting in the office doing quotes for clients uh and the girls were watching the strictly final, or you know, now it would be um uh Brit's got talent or the voice or something like that. But a cinema room is not just about movies, in my opinion. Uh, it's about watching content with your family to make memories.

SPEAKER_01

Yep, 100%, and that's what it's all about. Awesome.

SPEAKER_02

Thinking of building your dream home cinema? Don't know where to start? Start with the HCA. At the Home Cinema Alliance, we connect homeowners with the very best in the business. Our members are trusted designers, installers, and technology experts who know how to turn any room into a breathtaking cinematic experience. Whether you're building from scratch or converting a spare room, our members are here to help you every step of the way. Visit our website to find your local member.uk, and we're not going to be able