Cold Tea with Sweet T
Cold Tea with Sweet T is where small-town secrets brew slow… and the tea is always served ice cold.
Hosted by Sweet T — a bold voice with Southern grace and a taste for the truth — this true crime and mystery podcast dives into unsolved cases, strange disappearances, and the forgotten files tucked away in dusty corners of America.
Each episode unpacks a real-life mystery, offering storytelling that’s soulful, suspenseful, and steeped in the kind of detail only Sweet T can serve.
From courthouse whispers to backroad vanishes, one thing's for sure:
When the tea runs cold... the truth might just be hiding in plain sight.
Cold Tea with Sweet T
The Babysitter Who Vanished: The Evelyn Hartley Case
It was supposed to be a normal night in La Crosse, Wisconsin.
In 1953, 15-year-old Evelyn Hartley was babysitting for a local family—books in her bag, a routine check-in scheduled with her parents. But when she failed to call home, concern quickly turned to panic.
Her father found the house locked, the baby sleeping soundly… but Evelyn was gone. Blood on the walls, broken glasses, and a trail of strange clues sparked one of the largest manhunts in Wisconsin history. Witnesses saw shadows. Footprints led nowhere. And decades later, the silence still screams.
What happened to Evelyn Hartley?
Join Sweet T as she pours up this haunting case filled with red flags, cold trails, and a faith that refuses to forget. Because some stories don’t fade—they just wait for truth.
☕ Cold Tea with Sweet T—where the tea is cold… and the case is colder.