Episode 21: Accidental Project Manager Trap: Challenges, Fairness, and Success Strategies with Erik Donert Artwork

Powering ProjeX: From Vision to Victory

Thanks for following Powering ProjeX.

Vision: A world where project people are celebrated as the quiet architects of progress: turning the boldest visions into victories through wisdom, courage, and relentless learning.

Mission: To equip project professionals to master their craft through raw, authentic conversations with the respected CEOs, experts, and practitioners.

Listen to the Powering ProjeX on:

You Tube: https://www.youtube.com/@poweringprojex

Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/4ouQGB93q1OThUbNODUedu?si=23eb21e242dc4b2b

Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/au/podcast/powering-projex-from-vision-to-victory/id1823405814

In 2026, Powering ProjeX will be publishing some of our long-form content on Patreon. Short form (20 minute episodes) will continue to be published YouTube Podcasts, Spotify and Apple Podcasts. Head over to our Patreon site for more content and member only offers. Patreon: https://patreon.com/PoweringProjeX

Donation: You can support Powering ProjeX with a one-off or recurring donation at https://buymeacoffee.com/poweringprojex

Engage with Powering ProjeX on:

X: https://x.com/PoweringProjeX

Linked In: https://www.linkedin.com/company/powering-projex

Content Frequency: Powering ProjeX releases full length podcasts fortnightly on a Monday at 9:00am AEST.

Until next time, keep leading with distinction, driving impactful outcomes, and turning your projects into lasting and prosperous victories!

Inspiration:

"In all the eternity of time, in this infinitely expanding universe, you have for a fact, this one moment. Why then would you want to blow it? Why would you not want to believe in yourself? Why would you want to go through your job, your life, being too soft and fearing failure, afraid to assert yourself, running from conflict, taking abuse from others, playing the victim, not pursuing your dreams, not believing in yourself, not demonstrating the courage to make things happen? Why would you want to operate under the shadow of others instead of creating your own shadow? This is your moment. Life is an adventure. It’s yours to seize. Your career clock is ticking. Now go make a bigger difference." Neal Whitten from the Neal Whitten Group, as spoken in PMI Webinar 'The Wonderful World of Power Skills: Achieving Exceptional Performance.'

Disclaimer: The content provided in the Powering ProjeX podcast is for informational and educational purposes only and does not constitute professional, legal, or financial advice. The opinions expressed by the host and guests are their own and do not necessarily reflect the views of any affiliated organizations or sponsors. While strive to provide accurate and up-to-date information on project management methodologies and related topics, but no guarantee is made regarding the completeness, accuracy, or applicability of the content to your specific circumstances. Listeners are encouraged to consult with qualified professionals before making decisions based on the information shared in this podcast. The host, guests, and producers are not liable for any losses, damages, or outcomes resulting from the use of this podcast’s content. By listening to this podcast, you agree to assume all risks associated with the application of the information provided.

All Episodes

Powering ProjeX: From Vision to Victory

Episode 21: Accidental Project Manager Trap: Challenges, Fairness, and Success Strategies with Erik Donert

October 14, 2025 • DK • Season 1 • Episode 21

0:00 | 1:23:34

Send us Fan Mail

Ever stepped into a massive project with zero PM training, feeling like you're assembling a plane mid-flight? You're not alone! That's the wild world of the Accidental Project Manager.

In this episode of Powering ProjeX, host DK sits down with Erik Donert, a PMO powerhouse who traded a career in finance for leading $MM+ transformations.

Certified in PRINCE2 and SAFe, Erik shares raw stories from Australia's Royal Commission era, where SMEs like him were thrust into leadership roles overnight.

We unpack the thrills and pitfalls: imposter syndrome, stakeholder showdowns, AI ethics in projects, and why "busy" doesn't equal "effective." Erik reveals how to harness your domain expertise, build unbreakable teams, and turn "accidental" into intentional success. Plus, we explore tips for hiring managers on spotting (and supporting) these hidden gems.

If you're an operational pro eyeing a PM role, or a burnt-out accidental leader, or building a PMO that actually works, this one's your roadmap from overwhelm to outcomes.

Connect with Erik Donert on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/erik-donert-b4687910a/.

Key Takeaways:

- The Accidental PM Journey is Widespread and Risky. Many professionals are thrust into project leadership roles without training, especially in regulated or high-stakes industries like financial services.

- Fairness and Strategy Matter - Assigning operational experts to PM roles without training is not just unfair, it’s strategically unsound.

It confuses subject matter expertise with leadership capability, creating systemic risks for organizations.

- Common Pitfalls Have Real Costs - Operational: “illusion of progress” where teams look busy but deliver poorly. Financial: hidden costs of rework and poor quality. Cultural: team burnout, turnover, and loss of trust when leaders can’t protect or prioritize effectively.

- Background Skills Can Be an Asset to build on- Erik’s financial services expertise gave him transferable strengths: planning, forecasting, and asking the right questions at transition points.

This helped him build governance structures and shift teams from being task-driven to outcome-focused.

- AI Projects Amplify the Challenge - Accidental PMs face extra strain in AI initiatives, where regulation lags innovation.

Balancing innovation with compliance requires cross-functional collaboration (legal, risk, compliance) and structured validation checkpoints.

- Strategies for Accidental PMs- Protect your team and focus on servant leadership (echoes Lencioni’s teamwork principles).

Keep learning frameworks (Scrum, Kanban, RAID, Benefits Realisation) without becoming dogmatic.

Ruthlessly align to outcomes and shield the team from toxic discourse.

- Advice for Hiring Managers - “Go slow to go fast”: give new PMs time to plan, learn, and structure execution.

Don’t assume top performers in one domain will automatically succeed as project leaders without support, mentoring, and training.

- Human Impact Beyond Metrics - The most meaningful outcomes are when projects restore trust and shift teams from target-driven to purpose-driven — such as financial remediation projects after the Royal Commission. Leadership lessons often come not from success, but from setbacks where presence, empathy, and resilience mattered most.

About Our Guest: Erik Donert Erik is a transformation leader with roots in financial services. He's led multimillion-dollar programs, blending PRINCE2 precision with SAFe agility. Passionate about human-centered PM, Erik turns SMEs into change agents and chaotic "motley crews" into high-impact teams. Connect with him on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/erik-donert-b4687910a/.

Support the show