The Ex Appeal Podcast

“It Was A Good Thing For My Marriage” – Dating In An Open Relationship

Miriam Katz Season 1 Episode 2

Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.

0:00 | 1:10:31

Host Miriam Katz and Christopher talk open relationships, stretching the bounds of comfort, and closure.  A tender one.


It would help me soooo much if you would donate to the show. Thank you!!


Also please rate and review. What a dream.


Also throwing the word "ex" in here cause PodSEO told me I should. 


Audio engineering by Jeremy Emery and Lamps Lampanella

Theme song melody and vocals by Miriam Katz; Instrumentals by Jon Steinmeier

Logo designed by Anna Nguyen and Kathryn Davis

Photo by Dana Patrick

Instagram 

Tik Tok

YouTube

Miriam

Hi, welcome back to the Ex Appeal podcast. So happy to have you here. This episode is really interesting. I don't want to give too much away because everything kind of unfolds in the conversation, but I will vaguely say it's about stretching the bounds of a relationship and then recalibrating. And for me, it's about really believing that someone did their best. And I also think it's interesting here that intention really matters. I could state the facts of what happened and spin it in a particular way, because this experience took place with a really, really, really nice person. The good feeling is really what lasts. And yeah, this was a very nuanced situation, which is why I really love the podcast format, because we got into everything and didn't just summarize or simplify what happened. Yeah, Christopher rules. And as I say to him in the podcast, there's a real purity between us. So I hope you feel that and I hope you like it. Okay, enjoy. You liked drugs, you like God. You like drugs, you like God. You like drugs and you like God. Such a delight to see you.

Christopher

It's a delight to see you too.

Miriam

It is so fun to see you. It's funny.

Christopher

It's

Miriam

very, very funny that this is the first time I'm seeing you.

Christopher

Yeah. I don't, how long? I don't even, I'm struggling to place that. I mean, it was right

Miriam

before COVID. So it was three years ago. It was February of 2020. Wow. Yeah. I really appreciate you coming. I almost feel like you coming is part of the story because and we'll say everything, but there was a lot of testing stuff out.

Christopher

And

Miriam

so it's cool for you to maybe go up against or maybe even surpass a little boundary that you've made up for yourself. I think of you as someone who would be great at this and would be great at examining things and talking about feelings and being an artistic person. This is how I think of you. So in a way, it's cool. That was sort of part of the reason why, I mean, for a bunch of reasons, I really wanted you on. But I think that was also part of it was sort of like, yeah, let's step into power, baby. I

Christopher

mean, a big part of that for me is that, and this is sort of maybe the whole experience, but part of the reason I'm willing to do this, I think, is because you create a comforting environment. Cool. Yeah. Cool, cool,

Miriam

cool. So we met at a job I had, I'm just going to say that. That would be really funny if I was like, this exact thing at this address. Yeah. It was my first job outside of the job I had for many, many years.

Christopher

I didn't know that.

Miriam

Yeah. I think I did a teeny bit of freelance. No, but maybe I think that was actually my first office that I went into after going into one office for so many years in New York. And I walked in and I was like, what is happening? Why is everybody so hot? I was just so overwhelmed. I was like, what is going on? And the first day we all went out to lunch and they paid for lunch and everyone was being funny and hot like and also I was like well they're all gay like definitely because they're also well dressed and hot

Christopher

not the first time that that was like a reaction actually

Miriam

yes the gay thing or the hot thing

Christopher

oh the gay thing yeah but have people

Miriam

been like everyone in this office is hot before

Christopher

not that I had heard cool

Miriam

did you have a sense of that that it was like a nice looking crew I

Christopher

knew that everyone had a nice sense of like you know or ability to present themselves and to some degree that felt like to kind of to go with the flow or maybe that was a part of how you were kind of brought into the company was like oh you have like an aesthetic

Miriam

ah yes that

Christopher

makes sense I don't know that I fit into that very well but you know for what I was doing there I don't know that that was quite the same need. But yeah, I think I did think everyone was like, oh, everyone dresses really nice. And I stepped up my game probably when I got that job.

Miriam

That's very funny. This was very exciting, you know? And also it was like, yeah, I don't think I'd worked in a Los Angeles office. And yeah, you all, what did you, what did you play at four o'clock?

Christopher

Oh God. Football. Yeah. You threw a football. Let's call it that. There's a very distinctive name. Okay, we don't have to do that. I know I'm

Miriam

saying I actually didn't even know. But there was all these different things. It was like everyone went to lunch, everyone got coffee together, everyone threw a football in the parking lot. It was so cute. People played music, people drank beers. It was a good time. I

Christopher

want to add real quick that if you perceived us all as hot and stylish, you working there is also probably a reflection of that to you. Thank you so much.

Miriam

So it was like exciting and there was just like a bunch of hotties and I was doing my work just like flirting around having a good time but it was a very temporary job and I didn't even really always need to go into the office and yeah it was there was no like commitment to the job because it was for a project. And so that I think probably even added to the flirty nature of it. Cause there wasn't this feeling of, I can't date anyone here because that just wasn't true. Like I wasn't working there. You know, these were not my coworkers.

Christopher

Yeah. And then that, that door probably would have been like very open. You know, I think that, and not that I knew of a lot of like dating but dating going on inside the office, but it definitely didn't seem like there were any barriers preventing things like that. Yeah,

Miriam

I think that might even be my own rule though. If there's like an ongoing situation, I try to not date within it. Yeah, that makes sense. Because then if something changes, then you're really stuck in there and that doesn't seem that fun to me. Like I don't date within like the improv world.

Christopher

I mean, it seems like a smart move either way.

Miriam

Yeah,

Christopher

yeah. Just no, I mean, a little shade. And there's like a little what? A little shade, I guess, on my part. but I never meant. Yeah.

Miriam

Oh, were you throwing shade on that?

Christopher

I was lightly. Yeah. I don't know why though. Maybe implicit distrust towards the improv community. I'm not sure

Miriam

why. Oh, I get it. I didn't actually catch the shade. So I'm glad you clarified the shade. And also I could have given another example of like a place that like a workplace or a, I don't know, hobby place.

Christopher

I already realized I'm like derailing you from. No,

Miriam

there's everything's cool. And I, when I was like 24, one or 22, I hooked up with a guy in my building. There's only three units in the apartment in East Village, and it was like the dumbest idea. So I'm sure I had that and a few other examples that I was just like, oh, no, no, no. I don't want to deal. But anyway, it was not that kind of situation. It was very freeing and fun. And then I did end up dating somebody from that office.

Christopher

You

Miriam

know that.

Christopher

You gotta know that. Wait, No, no, please.

Miriam

You definitely, we have definitely talked about this because at some point you were like, I'm going to text him.

Christopher

Did it start with a J? Yes, it did. Yeah, okay. Okay, I'm catching up now. It's all coming back. Yes.

Miriam

The coding. Cool. There's going to be one sleuth who's like, it's an office in Los Angeles. And people were good looking. I think I know. I think I know. Okay. So.

Christopher

The game of catch would have like instantly. Yes.

Miriam

They all got coffee. They went, they ate lunch there. Okay. So then I feel like that was in 2016. Maybe 17.

Christopher

Yeah. I'm never good at this, but that sounds right to me. That was around

Miriam

the time that I left. Okay. My other job. So I think it was 2016 or 2017. And then. And you and I were friendly. There was a funny thing where the very first time we hung out at work, you were going to drive to San Francisco after work. Oh, wow. And you were like, do you want to come?

Christopher

Yeah. Yeah, what was the context there? That seems so out of character for me to just blanket invite you. Or not blanket, like I invited everyone, but for me to directly be like, Miriam, do you want to come to this?

Miriam

Well, I think it was maybe a little bit lighter than that. I don't think it was like you you know but I think it was sort of like you were just being fun and you didn't actually think I was going to because I was already at work I wasn't really gonna go because I needed a toothbrush or whatever but I actually for a second considered it

Christopher

I think I would have not said that to many people no no no yeah I 100% would have but I don't I think that everything you're talking about like about that office culture you you like you embodied that like my recollection of that was instantly you just like fitting right in and it's all like you know shooting the shit and having fun

Miriam

yeah

Christopher

which is cool so that's probably why I uh from what I perceive out of character would have been like yeah come to San Francisco

Miriam

yeah which is fun so it was like I didn't have to go to San Francisco for us for that to already feel like a tiny bit of an adventure like that already was sort of like a fun like brain opening like whoa what if you know alternate universe like I totally went to San Francisco

Christopher

yeah it was like early stage of us being like oh cool like we get along you know like this is like we're able to like dialogue easily

Miriam

yes and I think there was probably some jokes

Christopher

oh yeah must have been

Miriam

I think that you don't invite somebody in a car if you haven't made a joke together

Christopher

yeah I mean my memory of that time was only jokes between anyone there like very little very little seriousness at all

Miriam

yeah

Christopher

like surface level humor which was fine you know like that at the time was perfect

Miriam

i didn't feel like it was bullshit though

Christopher

maybe you did i mean i've been there longer you know there's a lot of nuance for me but um i agree i don't i don't i think because i've definitely had

Miriam

conversations that were like that are nothing and it felt fun

Christopher

no there there was a lot of fun there there definitely was and i think that you brought out a lot of the goodness there. So it makes sense that, you know, the look back on that moment wouldn't be like an empty fun.

Miriam

Yeah. Yeah. And then you invited me to a party at your house, maybe like eight or nine months later. It was definitely like after I hadn't been there for a second. So it was nice that you invited me. It was sort of like you remembered who I was because we probably hadn't like talked in a while. And I went and had a super good time.

Christopher

Yeah. Yeah. I remember that being a good time too.

Miriam

Yeah. Hung out with like a bunch of people from your office. Someone from your office was his, this is not going to be interesting, but his grandmother was married to my high school boyfriend's mother. That is interesting. I said that more quickly than I thought. I thought it was going to take like 20 minutes to explain, but it was interesting and fun. And there was just, yeah. And it was like cool to see your house and I think you did a good job. And yeah, I mean, again, like, the people in that office are a good time so I had a good time even though I didn't really really know anyone at the party and I didn't bring anyone which was a good choice I think because it meant that I like entered in

Christopher

yeah you met a lot of people outside of work too yeah there were a lot of different different you know parts of my life kind of came together for that very rare party because I think that was the first and probably only time I ever had a gathering so but yeah and once again I think this is a reoccurring thing that you're you're very good at just connecting with people. Because I recall you just blending in with everyone very effectively. Cool.

Miriam

Effectively.

Christopher

Effectively. That's how I see the world.

Miriam

Excellent.

Christopher

Effective social engagement. Effective podcast.

Miriam

And, you know, maybe that was 2017 or 18. And then just to say that it was maybe a year and a for two years later that you got in touch with me. So I hadn't talked to you in years. You sent me a Facebook message. I don't think we had each other's numbers.

Christopher

Yeah, probably. I don't think so either. But I do remember that Facebook message.

Miriam

Oh, so tell me what you remember.

Christopher

Oh, I set myself up there. I remember sending that Facebook message. I more so remember the emotions around it. I remember just feeling very comfortable sending the message. And I don't think I sent anything too special. I think it was just like hey it's kind of coming back now but yeah mostly to my to my memory it was just like oh i think i can say hello and that's going to be fine

Miriam

yes so you said i don't know exactly what you said we could look it up but i i think you asked to hang out and i think my response was like yeah cool totally like maybe in a couple weeks or you know just like the way that like someone that you're not very good friends with not even blowing off i actually am really good it, making plans. And I love hanging out with people I don't know that well. And I always really liked you. So I was definitely like, cool, totally. But I wasn't like, let's make this happen ASAP. Like, I think you might have sent me that message on, say, a Thursday, making that up. But you were like, how about this weekend? And I was like, uh, I mean, I'm going to a I guess I could meet you after. And you're like, yeah, you're like, yes, that'd be great. And I'm like, okay. And you did say there's something I want to talk to you about. And I didn't know what that meant. And that was mysterious, but it didn't, you know, like you are, I don't know that you would see yourself this way, but like you are kind of calm. There's something about you that's a little bit like relaxed. So even though you said something like there's something I want to talk to you about, I think the vibe was like, Like, yeah, there's something we could talk about. You know, like it was so, even though it was in Facebook Messenger, it was definitely not like aggressive. You are very not aggressive. And

Christopher

so. So I appreciate, by the way, that, you know, you're not like interpreting any of what, you know, what I'm presenting is like.

Miriam

No way. I mean, that's just not who you are. And I think probably something about the wording was clear that like, there's nothing intense going on. But you wanted to hang out soon. And there was something specific you want to talk to me about. And I didn't know what that could be about. Because I felt like it was something personal. Because if it was a work thing, you would have said exactly what it was. Yeah, you would have been like, I mean, we won't give an example, because we're keeping you anonymous. But um, you know, that's like interesting. And like I said, like, I always really liked you. So I was like, cool. Yes, I can make that happen and like leave this sound bath. birthday party and come meet you at a bar in Echo Park. What?

Christopher

No, it's memory. I've never really thought of myself as a great person for recall. So I'm appreciating how we're going through this because it's nice for me, actually.

Miriam

Oh, cool. That's great. Love that. Thanks for that. So we meet at this bar. I'm not going to name which one, but do you remember which bar? Like just in the high school. And I do remember that a friend of mine was there. And so we were having this like good conversation and I don't actually remember at what point he stepped in, but he was being really like negative

Christopher

and depressed. And you

Miriam

and I were laughing because it was so funny because you and I were having like a super good time and being very jovial. And then this like really depressed guy literally would just sat between it. Like it was, and then we're like, laughing at how funny that was. It felt like a TV show. I was like, what? Because you and I were like, like so exuberant. And then it was like, oh, fucking, okay.

Christopher

Yeah, it was like sad clown energy. Totally.

Miriam

And it didn't bring us down, but it was very funny how different it was from how we felt because we were feeling buzzy. So we sat down, I think for like an hour and just talked about life and caught up and

Christopher

I

Miriam

don't know, just had fun and made jokes. And I think it was really nice.

Christopher

Yeah, it was really easy.

Miriam

Yes. Easy like it would have been if I had driven with you to San Francisco.

Christopher

Yeah.

Miriam

So about an hour in probably, I was like, hey, so what do you want to talk to me about? Do you want to say what you said? I mean, yeah.

Christopher

Sure. Yeah. And feel free to like correct. But I mean, I think that the core of it was hey I'm beginning to explore an open relationship and I'm not sure why I felt like you know you would be a safe person to reach out to and to talk with about that I guess and obviously there was a part of my brain that was like you know maybe you know Miriam could be a person I explore that with getting ahead of myself but that was in my head I

Miriam

think that was spoken I

Christopher

think that

Miriam

was spoken right away I think okay so one thing I should say is that the last time I had seen you, you were not married. And then when you sat down at the bar, you had a wedding ring. So it was like, okay. Because I think that maybe part of me was like, maybe he's asking me out. And then when you sat down, I was like, oh, he's not because he got married since the last time I saw him. And then an hour in, even at that point, you just said something like what you just said about like, you thought I'd be a good person to talk to about it. And I thought that was because you knew that for many years, I'd been in open relationships.

Christopher

I'm not sure if you had ever said that. I don't know if we ever got to that type of conversation before that moment. I want to say we didn't.

Miriam

Yeah, I didn't think that I had, but there's a world in which I totally casually mentioned it because that was what the conversation was. I don't think that's necessarily the thing, especially in a professional situation, but I don't think that's necessarily the kind of thing I wave around. But I thought maybe, when you said I'd be interested in talking to you about this. I definitely did not get the sense that you were saying, at least initially. And I'm interested in exploring that with you. I thought it was like, you know about this. I want to get your advice.

Christopher

I think that you, in my head, you were a fun person, seemingly responsible person, and a cool person, and just an easy person to talk to. And I probably just needed someone to talk to. And so you checked those boxes. And I Um, yeah, I think I just, you know, shot my shot.

Miriam

Yeah. I'm very happy to be that person for any audience, but also for you. Thank you so much. And, but you did pretty much right away. Cause I was sort of like, Oh, you want advice about this? And you were like, yes. And also I'm interested in exploring this with you. Wow. So bold of me. I think it was like, we were sitting there having a good time. I think there was almost no reason. to not say that. And I think maybe I also was like being a little bit flirty. I don't want to say that if that's inappropriate to like the scenario I thought we were in, but I guess, you know, maybe there was some sense that like, that would have been cool.

Christopher

Yeah. And I mean, I think a certain amount of like, you know, there's, there's a, there's a vague space around like, you know, a flirtation that is more so just people getting along and like having a good ability to speak to each other that is not necessarily the same as like, this is a very intense flirtation that, you know, is, is filled with a ton of subtext.

Miriam

Yeah. That was well put. Thank you. Yeah. Cool. Great. Good job. Um, I think once I understood that you meant me as a person to date outside of your relationship, my question was, are there any boundaries between Yeah.

Christopher

Because

Miriam

that was something that I'd asked somebody another time who was in an open relationship. And I remember he was like, yes, this can't go to a 10. It can go to a 2 or a 3. Oh,

Christopher

that's a smart thing to say. Maybe. I mean, it sounds like a boundary. It sounds like a clear boundary.

Miriam

Well, it was a clear boundary and also it made me not interested.

Christopher

Interesting.

Miriam

Okay. So I slept with him once because I had to. But I did not go on a date with him again or sleep with him again.

Christopher

Yeah.

Miriam

That was... His boundary was, made me have a boundary.

Christopher

Yeah. I understand.

Miriam

So you saying there is, you also had never done it before, but like in your heart, you were like, no, there's no boundary. And I was like, is there no physical boundary? And you were like, no. And I was like, is there an emotional boundary?

Christopher

You were like, no. Did I really say no to that? Yeah. Interesting.

Miriam

But I think you didn't know. I think you thought

Christopher

that. Yeah. I mean, I wasn't, I probably wasn't able to uh share it with myself but i i think i was probably flailing a little bit internally got it yeah um but apparently i kept it pretty composed

Miriam

i mean that's maybe like a tiny bit of your persona but i didn't get the sense that you were like i don't know what i'm doing i'm so confused what the hell's happening like it was more just like you definitely were like this is very exploratory i have not done this yet but like my wife and i are on the same page about this And she even knew that she had met me. She even knew that you were hanging out with me. Everything was very out in the open. And I think she even encouraged it, which is interesting.

Christopher

Yeah, a big part of the reason that any of this went forward was because from the get-go, I think her perception was like, oh yeah, I remember Miriam. Miriam is a very cool person. And for whatever reason, I think that there was a certain amount of confidence that we both felt in me reaching out to you.

Miriam

I love that. Yeah. It's also so different. Like, I think that is true and want to like honor what you said. And I also think there's something about exploring that with somebody that you like have had some kind of connection with instead of like going on Tinder as, you know, like it's so different.

Christopher

Yeah. I didn't, I mean, I really briefly experimented with that and just didn't, yeah, I didn't like it. It was hard for me. I kind of was in a relationship before all of that really has popped off. And so I missed the intro to that world. And in a lot of ways, it was a lot of work to, and I didn't want to go about it that way. Yeah.

Miriam

Yeah. Well, especially that kind of thing. I think it would be really different if you were just straight up dating, but to come with so much, I mean, it's very nuanced. Yeah.

Christopher

And I genuinely did want to talk about it. You know, I wanted, I did want someone I could like confide in and sort of, you know, I don't want to say assist in helping understand the Yeah. You know, but yeah.

Miriam

Yeah. I think that makes sense. I do remember you walked me home. There's a world in which we held hands.

Christopher

Interesting. Yeah, I could see it.

Miriam

I don't totally know if it was not till like the second time we hung out, but I vaguely think, I think we might have held hands on the way home.

Christopher

There was flirtation for sure. Oh, for sure. But holding

Miriam

hands is different. Like that is like defined a little bit. It's so different than flirting.

Christopher

No, it is.

Miriam

Because you can flirt with like a barista for two years and not hold hands with them. Like that's so, it's intimate.

Christopher

Totally.

Miriam

So I have a vague memory of that, but it could have been like a different walk home. Um, we hung out the next Sunday. Do you remember that? And at a different bar, do you remember the bar? Okay, cool. I just think it's like easy to have like the, to place it, you know?

Christopher

Yeah, no. And it, it's, it's a lot of it is rushing back.

Miriam

Cool. I love it. I'm surprised I remember so much.

Christopher

I think this is a skill of yours and maybe it's, you know, maybe it's what a lot of people share and sort of a deficit of mine. I'm not sure, but either way.

Miriam

I think I remember it for like emotionally important things.

Christopher

I also realize how this is not like, it's not like none of this was important or meaningful or significant to me. I'm like, I don't remember. No, no, no. I'm not even

Miriam

comparing. I'm truly saying I think there's many, I forget. I think there's probably years, like full years that I'm like, what?

Christopher

Oh man, same.

Miriam

But I think, yeah, this was like notable for me. And then I do, yeah, so we hung out. I was dating someone else. And I think I told you about it during that second date, maybe even the first time we hung out. And I don't know if I ever told you this, but in therapy, I called you angel and I called him devil.

Christopher

Whoa. Yeah. Yes.

Miriam

Because you were so nice. And he was kind of mean.

Christopher

That's disappointing. I'm sorry. You know, I mean, I'm sorry. That's

Miriam

very sweet of you. He just, there was just something like a little bad. about that situation but I was still like compelled by it but it was like a very interesting thing to be dating these two very different energies at the same time and that I think is the only thing I remember from that second date I also remember that I said that I didn't want to kiss you yet

Christopher

yeah I remember that

Miriam

and I feel like it was around that time that I shared a song with you and I I think you were listening to the song a lot.

Christopher

Yeah. Oh, man. I do remember that song. I don't remember what that song is. It was

Miriam

Take Me Down Easy.

Christopher

There we go. Yeah.

Miriam

I can't believe how much I

Christopher

remember this. I'm trying to block all the shame. Why? Because, you know. I don't think it's at all. I'm surprised. I'm impressed and appreciate.

Miriam

Yeah, cool.

Christopher

Yeah.

Miriam

No shame.

Christopher

Cool.

Miriam

Yeah. helpful yeah and then I think it was like another week and then we decided to go to the beach which is like very different like that's like different than meeting at a bar and it was a far away beach

Christopher

yeah it's like a destination activity yes

Miriam

And it was like a special secret beach I know about. It was a nude beach. And I remember I like shared something really personal with you and cried. We were naked. So we'd never done anything and we were naked, which is really funny. But we have, there is like a, not to say that it wasn't sexy, but like we have like a bit of a childlike thing between us in a sense.

Christopher

Yeah. There's a lightness. Yeah. So it

Miriam

didn't feel that weird.

Christopher

Yeah.

Miriam

And then I remember I had to pee and I was peeing in the ocean and you were holding my hand so that I didn't like fall because it was like cold. This is February. And you kissed me while I was peeing. Wow. And that was the first time we kissed.

Christopher

Wow.

Miriam

Yeah.

Christopher

What timing.

Miriam

It was awesome. That's so funny.

Christopher

Yeah, I... I have no idea what compelled me to have that be the moment. But yeah, I guess, I mean, it was to my recollection, a good moment. So

Miriam

yeah, it totally worked. It was very

Christopher

funny. I think there was some falling too. I don't, I don't, I really don't want that to be just like, this is the time that I went for. Like, I think there might've been like, you know, the wave comes, you know, like, I think there was a circumstance that kind of like pushed us together a little bit more. So I was just like, let me just like bend down a little bit and give you a kiss right now I hope but whatever I guess either way it was fine

Miriam

it's very funny

Christopher

yeah yeah immaculate timing

Miriam

I mean that's great I loved it I loved it cool and then we so that was the first time we kissed and then at some point we like pulled over on the side of the road there was like really beautiful stars because we like went out of the city a little bit and then we like kissed a little and then and then that was it we didn't like go back up to my apartment

Christopher

no but

Miriam

No,

Christopher

we didn't. were early signals for me. Like, oh, I'm now confronting, you know, actually experiencing intimacy with someone outside of my primary relationship. And I think I pushed some of those signals that were not... I don't want to say uncomfortable, but I think that I began to experience what it was like to be close to somebody else. And I think I was pushing down any fears or nervousness that came from that so that I could experience the moment more.

Miriam

Yeah, and I think that is probably okay because sometimes it's awesome to push past fear. And also, I don't know, it's like, maybe there's a world in which it could have been a little uncomfortable and then became normal. So I think that's good. I don't think you not like articulating those in the moment is at all a problem because you were figuring it out and like watching yourself. And yeah, so like I didn't know that, but that's, yeah, now that really makes sense that that would have happened.

Christopher

Probably would have been a more interesting conversation Assuming I'd found the right moments to share those, in retrospect, I think it would have been a good conversation and maybe would have been more honest. But I think sometimes you have to be honest with yourself so that you can be honest with others. And I don't think I was able to be fully honest with myself in that time because I was just... confused and excited and obviously very happy, but... Yeah.

Miriam

I think also sometimes you have to take a beat, you know, it's like when you're in the middle of something, I mean, I think when you're in the middle of something, it's cool to experience it. And then once you're out, like think it over and see how you're feeling. I think it was pretty awesome that we had that day and just had fun that day. Obviously you were like, also had an extra layer to it. Cause I was just like, but actually now that I think about it, I probably was also experiencing that because I freaking broke up with that devil that week. is doing open relationships and always dated a million people and always had like one primary but like not even someone I was necessarily in love with and then would like date a thousand other people you know and was always free and it was so fun and so it was a turning point in my life in general of like being more interested in like really engaging with someone and like having feelings and yeah committing and it's just so funny that I was like yeah, I'm going to commit to this married man. But yeah, that was like the, I think it was just like, it didn't make me make that much sense. Cause it, and again, it wasn't, there was part of it that this guy was like maybe a little bit of an asshole clearly, but I would not have broken up with him if I, if it was not for you, I would have kept it going and eventually broken up with him. But it was like, I was feeling things for you and I didn't want to not be able to like justify Yeah. So we kind of were both having that experience of like, this is a lot.

Christopher

spending time with a person or dating a person. And that seemed to be at this certain emotional and physical level. And I think... I wanted to experience that also. And so when you were, I guess when we were both beginning to like, you know, experience that, that, that positivity together, uh, and that, that bond, it felt right to me because it in some ways felt like it was paralleling. Like I, I think in some ways it felt almost like I was sharing an experience with her, uh, by sharing an experience with you.

Miriam

Wow. That's interesting. I had never thought of that aspect of it. That's very interesting.

Christopher

And that's not even

Miriam

what we were talking about. No, but that's super interesting. I mean, there was somebody that I was like really in a relationship the first time that I like started to open up and we were like monogamous for the first two years and then open the second two years and we're still super, super good friends. And, um, and I remember it was kind of romantic.

Christopher

Oh yeah. Oh, definitely. There was, there was a ton of romance. I mean that, that whole day date was like I

Miriam

don't mean between us. I also wonder whether you starting to really feel something for me made you uncomfortable thinking that your wife could be feeling that much for someone else.

Christopher

That maybe would have required a bit more honesty with myself that I didn't get to at the time. I think that I was charging forward and just allowing myself to see it as an experience because it felt... positive for both of us and it felt positive with her and that partner at the time. Yeah, I think it did just feel like a good thing and something that we could share. And I love that you described what you had said about the relationship where you got to feel some type of romance with your partner. I think there was that. Yeah, so I appreciate how you communicated that. And I think there were some similar experiences in ours.

Miriam

That's cool. I hadn't thought of that part of the story, so it's cool to hear that. You just used the phrase charged ahead. We definitely charged ahead. You and I made a plan to go to a hot springs in Northern California.

Christopher

Yeah, this whole thing was very fast forward. We

Miriam

made a reservation. I mean,

Christopher

that's sort of jumping ahead too, though.

Miriam

No, that was right then. Was it right then? Well, because there was not much left, honestly. That was after that beach date. I think. Cause that was the third Sunday we hung out. And then the next Sunday you tried to take me on a hike. Oh, kind of far away. And then it's funny cause we'd been at the beach the week before, but we tried to go on a hike and a road was closed because we didn't have like chains for. Yeah.

Christopher

The weather was bad. Yeah, totally.

Miriam

Um, and so then we went back here and I'm just going to talk freely and if there's any Anything you, again, don't want me to include, I won't include it. And then we came and we were like kind of all over each other that day, like in the car. I was like, oh,

Christopher

like I was. We crossed the threshold. I was excited.

Miriam

Yeah. And then, and then, yeah, we came back here and we had sex. So we had like only kissed and then we had sex. Like we just like, and that was the fourth Sunday we'd hung out.

Christopher

Yeah.

Miriam

And I think at that moment we, maybe it was after that. that we made the plan to go to the Naked Hot Spring?

Christopher

I think it was. I think either in that same moment or very closely after. I think it might have been immediately after,

Miriam

actually. It might have been immediately after. I kind of vaguely remember that. Because then we spent some time together. I think we kind of spent the day together.

Christopher

Whereas in that moment, obviously that was an extremely... beautiful moment. Uh, and it was a positive moment, you know, just, I was grateful to have had that moment. And at the same time, internally, I was, um, just full panic mode.

Miriam

So I didn't

Christopher

know that. Yeah. I concealed all of that, unfortunately, you know, to, to yeah. Unfortunate for both of us.

Miriam

It's fine. Um, yeah, the, the, uh, spoilers that it's fine. Um, we made that plan and I think maybe I, I mean, I I am intense.

Christopher

Um, you are present. I don't know if intense is, uh, that's lovely. I mean, maybe that's a cool thing to own,

Miriam

but that's a really cool distinction. I'm definitely also like unafraid to move forward with things. So things, and I, and again, we can remove this, but like, it was really fun having sex with you.

Christopher

It was like very fun. Yeah. It was very fun for me too.

Miriam

Like, wow. Like, very well fit, like very suited bodies.

Christopher

Yeah.

Miriam

And, and I absolutely can take this out. Um, um, you hadn't had sex with anybody else in a long time.

Christopher

Yeah. Yeah. No. Years. Yeah.

Miriam

Yeah. So like that is exciting for both of us.

Christopher

Yeah.

Miriam

Like that's exciting.

Christopher

Totally. There was a lot of electricity, a lot of, a lot of positive, anxious energy. Yes.

Miriam

And I think, I don't really think we could have done it differently. I mean, you can always do things differently and maybe you feel like you should have, but at least for me, it felt so, There was such momentum. It's like sometimes you just need to live life. So I'm sorry if you feel like you did something you shouldn't have done. For me, it was so natural and so fun and right feeling that I don't think we could have done it differently.

Christopher

Oh, I want to clarify. I don't want to say I don't think we should have done it. I think that we practiced a lot of restraint because I think that that tension was there pretty early on. Yeah. And I'm saying restraint and realizing this was over the span of four weeks. So maybe not that much restraint. But yeah, there was no regret. It wasn't like, oh, this was a mistake. It was other feelings. It was other complications internally. Not like, oh, I'm so unhappy that I decided to be intimate with this person. Cool.

Miriam

Which honestly, if that was true, that would be okay because it would be the truth. I'm so interested in the truth that I just like to hear it even if it's like oh huh and then that week you told me that you were having some trouble and that it was like getting confusing and getting hard and we met up I think maybe that Thursday and we got tacos and talked and you were like this is hard I did some things that were like a little bit outside the bounds of what I think is okay

Christopher

yeah and I'll clarify it wasn't outside the bounds of any agreement with my primary with my wife it was outside of the bounds of I think my own comfort and I didn't know that until I went past that boundary yes but once I went past that boundary I knew it I felt it and yeah that was a that was a That was an intimacy boundary that I didn't know I wasn't ready to cross until I crossed it. And once I did cross it, I was just filled with fear. And I hadn't been filled with any fear up to that point, but just overcome in a way that I haven't experienced since. And I don't know if I had ever experienced, but yeah, to me, that was the first real time that I thought, okay, now I feel I feel separate from my wife in a way that I hadn't ever felt. And that feeling of separateness terrified me.

Miriam

Wow.

Christopher

It filled me with terror. And I was like, okay, this isn't for me. I'm not capable of this on so many levels. And I didn't know that until that moment. But yeah, I knew it then. And then that was followed by just... not wanting to treat you in any unkind way or treat myself in any unkind way, treat my wife in any unkind way. I just felt like I had gotten into some amount of deep water that I wasn't able to tread. I

Miriam

think there was a lot of that I knew. I don't think I knew that fear was like the primary feeling.

Christopher

Oh man. Yeah. That's the primary driving force in my life. Are you kidding me? That's yeah.

Miriam

I thought it was overwhelmed. Yes. But that's a little different. And can you explain, like, was it fear of losing your wife?

Christopher

It was. Yeah. It was. And she had, you know, I wasn't the first person I didn't cross that boundary without... I wasn't the first one to cross that threshold. I don't want to say boundary. Boundary feels like the wrong word. There was just a lot of nuance in the openness of our relationship and we were both kind of exploring it and... Yeah, I don't know, for whatever reason, me crossing that line, crossing that line doesn't feel like the right word either. I'm having a hard time finding the right way to communicate this. But yeah, that was just, it... It was just too much. It was too much. I think I felt very close to you. And I think that because it wasn't just some arbitrary sexual experience, because there was a lot of closeness and I felt very connected to you and I felt that intimacy and I felt a certain amount of understanding and connectedness and closeness. I think maybe it was even too close. Uh, and, and I, I couldn't get that close to anybody else.

Miriam

I feel like you just explained that so well.

Christopher

Oh, I mean, I stumbled. So thanks for saying that. But, uh, yeah. Yeah.

Miriam

Yeah. It's actually like, feels good to hear you say that.

Christopher

I don't think I've, uh, I've definitely explored it a lot in my own head, but I don't think I've put it into words in that way. So directly. And obviously I haven't put those words directly to you either. So,

Miriam

yeah.

Christopher

Cause at the time after, I mean, we'll go to this, but I, I, I wasn't thinking clearly immediately after that. And I think I got pretty cowardly. Uh,

Miriam

well, I kind of redirected it. I, um, so that was, I don't totally remember the timeline, but that was like a Thursday that you were starting to tell me that you're uncomfortable. And then we had a phone conversation, I think a few days later, maybe Monday, but like, yeah, maybe Monday, something like that, but like within certainly a week. And you said that you couldn't continue being romantic with me and that you and your wife for closing the marriage, which is a horrible term. You're unopening. You're, you know, whatever.

Christopher

Yeah. Returning to monogamy.

Miriam

Returning to monogamy. And which was like very, very surprising. We also canceled Harbin, I think before that, because of COVID. Yeah. This is the insane thing. This happened truly. This is like late February. I mean, it might have even bled into March.

Christopher

Yeah. 2020. It was early. around I don't think that I at that point was not that I wasn't taking it seriously but timelines are tough obviously for me I don't

Miriam

think I was taking it seriously until I remember being like two week lockdown are you kidding me I live alone like I was like yeah totally I definitely couldn't believe it and didn't believe it and my you know reasonable people were being concerned and I was like that's not a big deal like I just yeah of course I mean a lot of people you couldn't have imagined

Christopher

but I mean, yeah, it was good that we canceled. I mean, that was a good call. That was a smart move. But I think

Miriam

maybe we canceled because of the situation rather than COVID. I cannot remember.

Christopher

I hope that it wasn't me using COVID. No, I don't think so. I think we did it mutually because I was being, like, I think I wasn't being myself at that point. But I

Miriam

also think, like, maybe your wife had had to cancel something also. So it's just like, she was maybe going to be out of town. Totally. Oh my God, you're right. And then, yeah, like, COVID was already doing the canceling of certain things and I remember like South by got canceled and all of us were like wait

Christopher

what I also want to note that a part of that also was and this is just like a struggle in my life but uh there was a conflicting schedule moment in that. And what we had avoided, my wife and I, up until that point was, you know, I think a big part of what had made it work up to that point was that we were each other's primary focus and that was a moment in which I think I began to make a previous plan that we had had almost seemed secondary. And that was also a boundary that like we started touching upon that and that instantly didn't feel good. And it brought attention in our relationship that we hadn't experienced in our experience being open. And so that was bad. It tainted the moment for me.

Miriam

That makes perfect sense. I think there was also like a financial boundary because it was like you were spending money on a reservation. Yeah,

Christopher

totally.

Miriam

So there was definitely like a lot of things conflating at once.

Christopher

So much of that. Actually, that's a great call out because we have a lot of, we align a lot on our spending habits and our, I think our, I don't want to say frugal, but we've been very selective about how we choose to spend money together in large ways. You know, I think we'd always enjoyed and prided ourselves in affordable dates, I guess, just because we'd had some goals that we had been seeking out for a while and had stuck to that and been really good at that. And I think we'd had a lot of pride and there was a strength in our relationship was our ability to do that together. And so this reservation was like substantially more than we generally would spend on anything. And that introduced, you know, like very understandably, like unhappy feelings.

Miriam

Yeah. I do remember when you told me that you needed to end things, you kind of just wanted to get off the phone, which I understood, you know, it's like, it's very hard to do. Like we've all like told somebody something they didn't want to hear and been like, can I just do this by text? Like, it's like really, really hard to do because yeah, like we all want to make everybody happy. all the time.

Christopher

Which is, you know, definitely something I struggle with.

Miriam

Yeah, I mean, I think, yeah, that's totally normal. And I wanted to take a second to have a funeral for our relationship. Because as much as I was thrown for a loop, although there was like a little, you know, you had sort of warned me. It sounded like as the feelings were arising, you were sort of letting me know.

Christopher

I'm I guess, I don't know. I'm

Miriam

glad to hear that. just the fact that things were, had been really good and that we had had this like really beautiful connection and just to take a second to say goodbye to a beautiful connection that could not be so that there wasn't this like, like more longing than there needed to be and more of a sort of like never ending feeling. Like I felt like there was like a, I wouldn't even say cut the cord. It was more delicate than that. There was something that we were doing together that I wanted to do and I have to say you were down to do. I think initially it totally makes sense that you were like, okay, bye. But when I did suggest it, you were down and I think we kind of back and forth said nice things to each other.

Christopher

Yes, but I don't. You're being really kind to me, but But I remember distinctly there being a moment where I think I was trying my best to put up a wall out of fear. And in a very caring way, you called me out.

Miriam

Interesting. Do you remember what I said?

Christopher

Hmm. I don't, I don't remember the exact words, but I, I think, I think you just, uh, you like understandably like had a lot of, uh, like respect for the time we spent together and, um, I'm grateful. And this is, you know, I kind of reflective of why I was able to reach out to the beginning. I think you, you communicated respect towards me and you communicated a lot of respect towards yourself. And, uh, when I was just in panic mode, you, you sort of stopped me and said like, you know, quit that, uh, you know, we need to engage in this moment because it was meaningful and you can't just shut this down. You can't shut yourself down because that's not essentially, that's not kind to me. And you were totally right. And, um, Yeah, it was hard for me, but I do remember us having an extended moment where we got to reflect and sort of look at what we were experiencing and think about what it meant and how it felt. Yeah. you know, what it meant to move forward.

Miriam

I mean, it's cool that you were able to switch gears.

Christopher

I mean, it wasn't, it wasn't, yeah.

Miriam

I think it's hard when you're in sort of like one track to hear what, The person who's trying to get you to switch tracks is saying, and I feel like you did.

Christopher

I'm glad to hear that. Yeah. Yeah.

Miriam

I mean, I, I felt like I got exactly what I wanted.

Christopher

Really? Yeah. Oh man. That's so nice to hear.

Miriam

Oh my God. I mean, I think that is really what I wanted. I wanted to say nice things to each other.

Christopher

Yeah.

Miriam

Like I wanted, it wasn't even just that I wanted to like hear you say nice things. I wanted to say nice things to you because it had been this like great situation.

Christopher

Yeah. It was, it was awesome.

Miriam

Yeah. Yeah.

Christopher

It was like a very special time. Totally. Yeah, that was sort of kind of like confirming, I think... my desire to reach out to you in the beginning, you did sort of confirm that choice even towards the end by, I would say like taking on a little bit more of a mature angle and sort of calling out the need to do that because I was resistant internally, but I'm really glad that we did. And I think that was a much healthier way of working through the process. than I would have done if I had had full control, which, you know, would have been just, you know, like shut down, you know, essentially like just shut down emotionally. Yeah. And you very caringly prevented that from happening or at least gave us the opportunity to have that not happen.

Miriam

Yeah. And I think that made me be able to move on.

Christopher

Yeah.

Miriam

Yeah.

Christopher

Yeah. Yeah, that was such a challenging moment. I remember that final time that we got together and sat down and just as you said, essentially said nice things to each other and reflected and grieved.

Miriam

Yeah. Oh, that's a good word. Yeah, totally.

Christopher

But it was positive and it helped me too because I knew that it was the right thing for me to move back into monogamy but I also you know I would have felt terrible if we hadn't had some amount of closure and you know like a healthy way to communicate through it like a finalizing moment

Miriam

yeah I mean and earlier when you were talking about passing a boundary or a threshold or a line or whatever my thought was because recently I've been doing that in my life. And even when I come up against something that's like too much, I think my feeling is like, I am grateful that I am in a life where I am going up against things and then maybe reassessing rather than just being afraid of even going anywhere near the line. And especially in like a marriage, definitely it seems like in this area, you don't need to go anywhere near the line. the line, but just in general in life too, like we did like cross a boundary and then like move back and reassess and decide to do something different. Yeah. And we were like, okay with it.

Christopher

Totally. And, and, um, yeah, in, in some ways it was a, uh, in, it was a good thing for my marriage.

Miriam

Uh, wow.

Christopher

Yeah.

Miriam

Uh, oh my God.

Christopher

Yeah. So, I mean, I, just to, I guess to continue from what you're saying about the benefit of crossing that boundary and to sort of get past something and then experience that. And even if you have to recalibrate, I mean, COVID was a big part of it. And so timing really aligned in a very interesting way. But after you and I experienced the crossing of that threshold, boundary, whatever we want to call it, and then as my wife and I redirected our shared experience back into like a monogamous choice together. You know, we just, we went right into COVID together. And I mean, you knew our place at the time was like a extremely small little shoe box. And so we basically just stayed in that shoe box for two years. I mean, pretty stringently actually, but it completely transformed everything. And yeah, we got, I mean, I think we were always very close and always very open to like experiencing things and understanding each other better. and understanding ourselves better, but that, that strengthened things. Wow. Yeah. And I mean, it's, and in retrospect, like, I don't know that we'll, I don't want to say never, I don't, I don't think we'll ever go back into exploring any type of like openness because that time followed immediately by COVID and this like forced, you know, like one-on-one journey. Yeah. It, it strengthened, it strengthened things. Because

Miriam

you guys had been honest about what you

Christopher

want from each other? I'd want to try this at our strongest, not at our weakest moment, because I didn't want it to be something that is like a one step out the door and a way to ease out of a relationship. I want it to be, you know, we are at a very high communication level and we're very close and happy. And so if we're going to try this, let's try it when we're feeling strong. And that happened. And I think coming out of it and still trusting each other and still like communicating at a pretty high level confirmed a lot of it confirmed a lot of the positive aspects of the relationship and then you know being forced to be next to someone for two years only further confirmed you know that what we were doing was the right thing

Miriam

I mean that's really cool

Christopher

yeah it's I mean it's it's wild to think that it's been three years I mean you know I guess in the grand scheme of things that's not that much time but it also feels like a you know it feels like a lifetime it's been a significant three years so it does feel like a lot a lot's happened yeah you know

Miriam

but yeah hearing that makes me so happy for

Christopher

you thank you yeah you know who knows I mean I can I can be grateful that it worked out that's you know not not to assume there won't be more challenges in the future like you know there always are but I am grateful that we got to experience that we got to know each other better through that experience and I am so grateful that I got to become closer to you. You were probably the best person I could have ever reached out to in terms of just being a caring person and being an open person and someone that I could learn with and from, obviously. But yeah, it was a very positive experience. I'm very happy that we did it. I

Miriam

love how it makes you really happy. I remember, I think it was like fall of 2020, I texted you because I had this thought that like, maybe you and I kind of sensed that COVID was coming, even though we totally didn't believe it. And that maybe that's why everything was like so heightened and so sped up and so intense. I mean, I think that was going to happen, but yeah, that was an interesting thought that it was sort of, it did, it is significant that it was like just before COVID. It totally is. There was this yeah, it's cool to think that we were sort of tapped in to the future without, you know, being there yet.

Christopher

And, and we did, uh, I think like have a, a full extended, you know, experience that, that really could have been stretched out over a longer period of time. But I think that we were able to experience a lot in, in a pretty short amount of time. And I didn't, didn't even think about that amount of time being as short as it was. Like it felt like a longer experience for me.

Miriam

Yeah. But that's, That's also really useful. It's like, we learned the lesson, and then we got out of there. And that's useful for your marriage, and that's useful for me. Like, that's cool. It's like, all of the expansion happened, but it didn't have to take 11 months or whatever.

Christopher

Totally. Expansion's a great way of putting it.

Miriam

Yeah. I mean, it was really fun, too.

Christopher

It was.

Miriam

Also, we have the same birthday.

Christopher

Yes, we do. Yes, we do. Birthday twins.

Miriam

I'm curious whether you, and like, sometimes these questions could feel like a I guess I like think of you as an artist and like wonder whether you've had some like fun in that realm.

Christopher

Oh man. Uh, unfortunately, no. Um, I've gotten deeper into my career, which has, uh, pushed me into like a whole different mindset. And I still struggle with the, uh, you know, I keep telling my, and it is still a challenge to try to, to try to honor both sides of, you know, like how I see myself, which is, you know, like a person that likes the technical sides of things and someone that I guess even has mostly a creative background. But it is hard for me to honor both at once. Seems like I have to dive into something and I can't, I can't do, I can't do two things at once, unfortunately.

Miriam

Yeah.

Christopher

Yeah. But it's a great reminder. And I hope I keep getting these reminders because like, I think that I don't think it's, I don't think it's gone. I don't think it's out there yet.

Miriam

There's no way. That's totally how I think of you.

Christopher

Yeah. I love that. How about you?

Miriam

Oh, yeah. Tons. Yeah.

Christopher

Cool.

Miriam

Yeah. It's been a really fun, interesting time. And even this project has been so exciting. This

Christopher

is extremely cool.

Miriam

It's been really fun. Very moving. And like, yeah. I mean, I also just thank you so much for being down.

Christopher

Yeah. I mean... with all things related to you, you seem to be, uh, helping me, you know, um, push myself in positive ways. This is another example of that.

Miriam

That's really cool.

Christopher

Yeah. Yeah. I mean, yeah, I'm, I'm still very anxious, but I'm loving it. It's very fun. Yeah. It's been a fun first podcast experience.

Miriam

Oh, you first. Oh

Christopher

yeah. Are you kidding me? I

Miriam

don't know. Yes. I don't know. There are a lot of them.

Christopher

This is, yeah. Uh, probably my last, uh, I mean, who knows what the future holds, but like, yeah, you're probably the only one I would say yes to.

Miriam

Cool. I love that. I really, really appreciate that. Totally. And it's interesting because I feel like even not being in touch, like the way we are, it's like, I feel like on some level we have been in touch. Yeah.

Christopher

Totally. It wasn't a challenge to talk to you to come in and do this. And yeah, it's... Yeah. And I have a lot of respect for you. Is there

Miriam

anything you can think of that you want to make sure is said?

Christopher

no no not at all actually cool i mean like yeah we touched a lot of we really got

Miriam

into everything i feel like

Christopher

yeah it's it it feels like i mean i want there to be like a nice like closing to this but i i'm just drawing a full blank

Miriam

no but i i mean i think there there was like a great arc i feel really good about it like my like my third eye feels open you know like things feel really good i feel like there's such a purity

Christopher

yeah

Miriam

between us

Christopher

i feel it too all Although honestly, I felt that way when I listened. I feel like I'm, I mean, you already said that you shared another episode with me, but like listen to the whole thing. Like enjoyed it so much. Really like whoever that was. Yeah. Seems like a great person. Yeah. You can say it

Miriam

was Chad's episode. Yeah.

Christopher

Chad's episode. Yeah. Chad seems cool and intelligent and kind and yeah. Good person.

Miriam

Yeah. Oh, I'm so happy. Yeah. I saw him twice yesterday. He's like one of my closest friends.

Christopher

Nice. Yeah. I would like to hear more of these.

Miriam

Um, well you will. Okay. Yeah. And there's some wild stories coming.

Christopher

I, yeah, it's yeah. Um,

Miriam

but yeah, God, I mean, I just like, thank you. Cause I know it wasn't like the simplest thing in the world to agree to do this. And this like felt really good.

Christopher

Cool. It felt good for me too.

Miriam

Thank you. Thank you. I'm like really happy.

Christopher

Yeah. Cool.

Miriam

That like really happened.

Christopher

Yes. All right.

Miriam

Yes. I want you also. That felt so good to be able to talk to him like that and that we actually experienced closure together. The intro was so funny because I didn't want to say to you why it was interesting, but I just wanted to say, trust me. But yes, there's so much to say about open relationships. I'll definitely talk about that more in future episodes and what it was like to be in them but I really liked talking about what it was like to be the outside person in one and I'm really glad that Christopher was so down to reveal so much of himself and what happened and as I said to him in the episode I'm just so happy that what happened between him and me was good for his marriage I mean that is incredible and I think I can feel that happy for him because he gave me a lot of love something that I've noticed about myself is that if I don't get the amount of love that I want or need I get anxious and then if I do get that love I can be very cool and forgiving so even though that relationship ended I was never mad I was really happy to have had that experience I mean I think that's pretty obvious from that episode and yeah I have such a good feeling about Christopher and I loved having you all here to hear it. So thank you. Until the next ex.