Cool Talk with Hartzell's | Your HVAC Questions, Answered!

Heat Pumps versus Gas Furnaces

Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.

0:00 | 23:07

Give Use A Shout

Heat pump or gas furnace in 2026. I get this question every single week. The honest answer is not what most contractors will tell you, because it depends on your utility, your gas situation, how long you plan to live in the house, and how you like your heat to feel. I break down where heat pumps win, where a furnace still makes more sense, real install pricing for a Kingfisher home, and a three option side by side for a typical OG and E customer replacing both ends. More episodes: https://hartzellsheatair.com/podcast/

Thanks for tuning in to Hartzell’s Heat & Air — your trusted HVAC experts in Oklahoma and beyond. From Kingfisher to coast-to-coast consulting, we design, install, and maintain smart, efficient systems that deliver year-round comfort.

We’re employee-owned, family-run, and powered by 48+ years of experience. Whether it’s AI-powered thermostats, geothermal systems, or classic tune-ups, we deliver upfront pricing, expert care, and warranties that back it all up.

🛠️ Book Online:
https://book.housecallpro.com/book/Hartzells-Heat--Air/4a569038b3dc460daf2d5f6497b18351?v2=true
🌐 www.hartzellsheatair.com
📞 (405) 375-4822

🚛 Trane Comfort Specialist • Mitsubishi Diamond Dealer • ClimateMaster Elite
 🛡️ VIP Comfort Club • Remote Monitoring • Extended Warranties

📲 Follow us for tips, updates, and real-world installs:
 YouTube: @hartzellsheatair6003
X: https://x.com/HartzellsHVAC
Facebook: facebook.com/hartzellsheatair
LinkedIn: Dave Hartzell

Built on trust. Backed by warranty. Designed for comfort.

The Invisible $15,000 Upgrade

SPEAKER_00

Imagine dropping like $15,000 on a massive home upgrade.

SPEAKER_01

Yeah, that is a huge chunk of change.

SPEAKER_00

Right. But the catch is nobody will ever see it. You can't, you know, show it off at a dinner party. It won't pop on a real estate listing photo. It lives entirely out of sight.

SPEAKER_01

Aaron Powell Out of sight, out of mind until it breaks.

SPEAKER_00

Exactly. Because if this invisible upgrade goes wrong, you will feel it in your bones every single day and you will pay for it every single month. Today is April 24, 2026. And well, if you own a home, or if you're just fascinated by these massive technological shifts that happen right under our noses, there is a quiet war raging right now, down in your basement and out on the concrete pad in your backyard.

SPEAKER_01

It really is an invisible revolution. I mean, we are watching a fundamental rewiring of the American home's infrastructure. We're moving away from a century of combustion toward this totally electrified future. And uh the stakes for your daily physical comfort, not to mention your bank account, are just massive.

SPEAKER_00

Which is why we've pulled a very specific stack of sources for you today to really understand what is happening in the HVAC industry.

Heat Pumps Versus Gas In 2026

SPEAKER_00

We're looking at two totally contrasting realities. On one side, we have an industry article from HVAC Informed. It outlines how these massive global manufacturers, specifically Medea, are actively tooling up and equipping contractors to push this massive industry-wide transition toward heat pumps.

SPEAKER_01

Yeah, and that gives us the top-down corporate perspective, right? The manufacturers are really forcing this shift. But we paired that with something much more grounded. It's a candid, no-nonsense breakdown from Dave Hartzell.

SPEAKER_00

The guy from Oklahoma?

SPEAKER_01

Right. He is a 45-year veteran HVAC contractor based in Oklahoma. This is a guy with a master license and NATE certification, which is essentially like the gold standard PhD of the HVAC trade. He actually has to look you in the eye and make these complex systems work in your living room.

SPEAKER_00

So our mission today is to arm you with the facts. We want to cut through the heavy manufacturer hype and just bypass the typical contractor sales pitches to answer one critical question for your specific home. Do you need a heat pump or do you stick with a gas furnace? We are going to unpack the technological, financial, and environmental realities of this 2026 transition so you can make a choice based on reality, not marketing.

SPEAKER_01

Aaron Powell, which is so needed right now.

SPEAKER_00

Okay, let's untack this because looking at the sheer volume of marketing from companies like Medea, I mean, the entire industry is shoving heat pumps down our throats right now. Why the aggressive push?

When Heat Pumps Clearly Win

SPEAKER_01

Well, to understand the push, we really have to look at the underlying mechanics of the technology itself. According to our veteran contractor, heat pumps definitively win the argument in four very specific scenarios.

SPEAKER_00

Okay, what's the first one?

SPEAKER_01

The absolute most clear-cut case is for homes that are electric only. Like if you live in a neighborhood or rural area where you do not have natural gas pipe directly to your meter, a heat pump is fundamentally your best and frankly only logical option.

SPEAKER_00

Because if you don't have gas and you don't have a heat pump, you're stuck with electric resistance heat, which, looking at the physics of it, is essentially like trying to warm your entire house with a giant toaster.

SPEAKER_01

That is the perfect analogy.

SPEAKER_00

You are literally forcing raw electricity through a metal coil until it glows hot.

SPEAKER_01

Yeah. Electric resistance is a one-to-one energy transfer. For every unit of electricity you pay for, you get exactly one unit of heat. It is incredibly taxing on the grid, and it's the absolute most expensive way to heat a physical space. Just burning money. Totally. But a heat pump completely bypasses that brute force method. It doesn't generate heat out of nowhere. It uses a refrigerant cycle to simply absorb existing ambient heat from the outside air, compress it, and move it into your house.

SPEAKER_00

So it's just moving the heat instead of creating it from scratch. Which explains why the sources note a heat pump uses 50 to 75% less electricity than that giant toaster method. But wait, I'm stuck on this thermodynamics thing.

SPEAKER_01

What part?

SPEAKER_00

Well, the veteran contractor explicitly states that heat pumps are incredible for his clients in Oklahoma. He says they handle single-digit cold snaps. But if a heat pump is just moving existing ambient heat from the outside to the inside, how on earth is it pulling heat out of a five-degree Oklahoma blizzard? That sounds like pure marketing magic to me.

SPEAKER_01

What's fascinating here is that it feels like magic until you look at the boiling point of the chemicals involved. The old argument that heat pumps don't work in the cold. That's based on technology from 20 years ago.

SPEAKER_00

Oh, really?

SPEAKER_01

Yeah. Modern cold climate heat pumps use specialized refrigerants that literally boil at negative 50 degrees Fahrenheit.

SPEAKER_00

Wait, negative 50?

SPEAKER_01

Exactly. So even if it is five degrees outside, that freezing air is still vastly warmer than the liquid refrigerant in the outdoor coil. The refrigerant absorbs that thermal energy, boils into a gas, the compressor squeezes that gas to intensify the heat, and then pumps it inside to warm your house.

SPEAKER_00

Wow. So because the chemical's baseline is so incredibly cold, a five-degree winter day actually feels hot to the machine and it can extract that energy. That is a massive technological leap.

SPEAKER_01

It's totally changed the game.

SPEAKER_00

So they win in electric-only homes, they win in mild to moderate climates like Oklahoma. But the third scenario seems to be entirely about the math. We're looking at massive utility rebates.

SPEAKER_01

Absolutely. The technology is great, but the adoption is really being driven by the wallet right now. The sources highlight utilities like OGE offering a $1,500 rebate per qualifying unit, which can stack up to $3,000 per home depending on the configuration. That's huge. Right. When you have utility companies throwing that kind of cash at the transition, it radically alters the upfront return on investment. Trevor Burrus, Jr.

SPEAKER_00

And the fourth scenario ties right into that ROI, long-term ownership. If you know you're going to be living in this specific house for the next decade, that 50 to 75 percent drop in your monthly heating bill compared to electric resistance starts compounding.

SPEAKER_01

Yeah, month after month.

SPEAKER_00

You are pocketing hundreds of dollars a winter, which adds up to thousands over the lifespan of the unit.

SPEAKER_01

It creates a snowball effect of savings that easily offsets the initial premium of the equipment, provided you stay in the home long enough to realize those gains.

SPEAKER_00

So if the thermodynamics are this brilliant, if the utility companies are paying us to install them, and if the long-term

When Gas Still Makes Sense

SPEAKER_00

savings are guaranteed, I mean, I'm sold, I'm ripping out my gas furnace tomorrow. Why shouldn't every single homeowner listening do the exact same thing today?

SPEAKER_01

Well, because that brings us to the danger of treating a house like a spreadsheet instead of a home.

SPEAKER_00

Okay, fair.

SPEAKER_01

Our veteran source is very clear that despite the hype, the classic gas furnace still holds the crown in three very distinct scenarios. And the first is purely practical. If you already have a gas line and you have a furnace that is only five to eight years old and it's working perfectly, carrying out a functional midlife furnace just to chase the heat pump trend is a terrible financial decision.

SPEAKER_00

You'd just be throwing money away.

SPEAKER_01

Exactly. You will never recoup the cost of the new system through efficiency gains alone.

SPEAKER_00

That makes sense. Don't throw away a perfectly good engine just because a new model came out. What about new builds?

SPEAKER_01

That's the second scenario. If you are building new construction in an area with cheap natural gas access, the mass flips. Installing a highly efficient 95% gas furnace alongside a standard mid-tier air conditioner generally has a lower upfront cost than putting in a premium full home heat pump system.

SPEAKER_00

Oh, I see.

SPEAKER_01

And because natural gas is still abundant and cheap in many parts of the country, your day-to-day operating costs stay incredibly low.

SPEAKER_00

Okay. So the budget and the existing infrastructure dictate a lot of this. But the third scenario for keeping a gas furnace is the one that really caught my eye. It completely stuck away from the financial math and dives into something highly subjective. It's about the feel of the heat.

SPEAKER_01

This is where the physics of the machine meet the biology of the homeowner.

SPEAKER_00

The source points out a startling difference in output. A gas furnace physically combusts fuel, meaning it blasts air out of your floor registers at 130 to 140 degrees Fahrenheit. A heat pump, relying on that slower refrigerant compression cycle, puts out air that is around 95 to 105 degrees.

SPEAKER_01

Right, it's significantly lower.

SPEAKER_00

Now the human body sits at 98.6 degrees. If I'm standing over a vent, air blowing on me at 95 degrees might actually feel drafty or slightly cool to my skin, even though it is technically warm enough to slowly raise the ambient temperature of the room to my desired 70 degrees.

SPEAKER_01

It is the difference between slow radiant warming and immediate thermal impact.

SPEAKER_00

I picture it like coming inside after shoveling snow. A gas furnace is like pointing a hot hairdryer directly at your freezing hands. A heat pump is more like standing in a slightly warm, gentle breeze. It'll get you warm eventually, but it doesn't give you that intense, satisfying blast of heat. Comfort isn't just a number on a digital thermostat, it is the physical sensation of the air hitting your skin.

SPEAKER_01

And Dave Hartzel, our 45-year veteran, calls this out specifically. He says the absolute cardinal sin in the HVAC trade is selling a system that looks great on paper, but fundamentally ignores how the homeowner actually lives.

SPEAKER_00

Yeah.

SPEAKER_01

If you have a client who has lived with a 140-degree furnace blast their entire life, and you talk them into a heat pump to save a few bucks, they're going to call you every week complaining that their house is cold.

SPEAKER_00

Even if the thermostat says 70.

SPEAKER_01

Exactly. The thermostat will say 70, but their perception of comfort is shattered. A good technician doesn't override human preference with a sales

Comfort Matters More Than Efficiency

SPEAKER_01

pitch.

SPEAKER_00

Here's where it gets really interesting, though, because while personal comfort is crucial, we also have to zoom out to the global perspective. We are constantly hearing from policymakers and climate scientists that we need to decarbonize immediately. The push is to eliminate gas appliances, to stop burning fossil fuels in our homes. But the sources reveal a massive paradox when it comes to the green reality of this transition.

SPEAKER_01

The environmental math is incredibly counterintuitive.

SPEAKER_00

How so?

SPEAKER_01

Well, the knee-jerk reaction is that going electric immediately is always the most environmentally responsible choice.

SPEAKER_00

Right. That's what we're told.

SPEAKER_01

But the veteran contractor points out the hidden costs of embedded carbon. If you have a working gas furnace, the carbon footprint of manufacturing a brand new heat pump, I mean, mining the copper for the coils, forging the steel cabinet, fabricating the microchips, and shipping a 300-pound unit across the ocean from a manufacturer like Medea, that footprint is astronomically high. It's huge. That manufacturing footprint is actually worse for the environment than just letting your current gas furnace burn fuel until it reaches the end of its natural life.

SPEAKER_00

Wow. So the greenest HVAC system on the planet is the one that doesn't need to be manufactured today.

SPEAKER_01

Precisely. The carbon debt of creating new heavy machinery is massive. So from a purely environmental standpoint, the advice is surprisingly conservative. Run your existing equipment into the ground, maintain it, repair it, and only when it is truly dead, make the transition to an electric heat pump.

SPEAKER_00

But let's say my system is dead. I'm ready to make the green transition. I call a local company. The HVAC-informed article mentions Madea is scrambling to equip contractors for this exact moment. But our Oklahoma veteran bluntly throws a wrench in the whole operation. He says the industry is currently facing a severe competency crisis.

SPEAKER_01

Yeah, that's a big issue.

SPEAKER_00

If I call a guy with a truck today, is he actually ready to instill this complex technology properly?

SPEAKER_01

The candid reality from the ground level is a resounding no. A vast portion of the workforce is simply not trained for this yet. And you have to understand why. For decades, replacing a furnace or a standard AC was largely a like-for-like swap. You unbolt the old metal box, slide the new one in, braise the lines, and turn it on. A modern heat pump installation is an entirely different beast. It requires an advanced understanding of fluid dynamics and airflow.

SPEAKER_00

The source mentions they have to assess the duct system for static pressure. What does that actually mean for the homeowner?

SPEAKER_01

Think about your home's ductwork. Much of it was designed in the 1980s or 90s, specifically for a massive gas furnace blower pushing high-velocity air. A heat pump requires a much steadier, highly calibrated airflow. If a contractor doesn't measure the static pressure, they might hook a high-efficiency heat pump up to ducts that are way too restrictive.

SPEAKER_00

Like trying to breathe while running a marathon through a tiny cocktail straw instead of a paper towel tube?

SPEAKER_01

Exactly.

SPEAKER_00

The machine is going to suffocate and burn out its motor trying to push air through a space that is too small.

SPEAKER_01

Precisely. And the mechanical

The Embedded Carbon Paradox

SPEAKER_01

complexity doesn't stop at the ductwork. We are currently in the middle of a massive global refrigerant transition. The industry is moving to new A2L refrigerants, specifically one called R454B.

SPEAKER_00

Okay, but why does the specific chemical matter to the guy installing it?

SPEAKER_01

Because A2L refrigerants operate at higher pressures and they are mildly flammable. This isn't the old freon from the 1990s, where a technician could just hook up a gauge and eyeball the charge based on experience. Yeah. R454B requires an exacting, mathematically precise charge. If a contractor overcharges the system, the compressor works too hard and dies early. If they undercharge it, the system freezes up. It demands a level of precision that a lot of old school rule of thumb installers simply haven't adapted to yet.

SPEAKER_00

And then even if they get the ducts right and the chemicals right, there's the brain of the operation, right? Yeah. The thermostat. The source warns about botched staging logic and auxiliary heat lockouts.

SPEAKER_01

This is perhaps the most common and expensive point of failure. A heat pump system usually has a backup heat source, like those electric resistance heating strips for when the weather gets truly extreme.

SPEAKER_00

So it's very much like driving a hybrid car.

SPEAKER_01

Yes.

SPEAKER_00

The onboard computer has to know exactly when it is most efficient to use the electric battery and exactly when it needs to kick on the gas engine. If the computer is confused and runs the gas engine all the time, your fuel economy is ruined. In a house, the thermostat has to know exactly what the outdoor temperature is so it knows when to rely on the efficient heat pump and when to trigger the expensive backup strips.

SPEAKER_01

That's a great way to visualize it. And what the veteran contractor sees constantly is unequipped technicians wiring a complex heat pump thermostat exactly like a basic old school AC unit.

SPEAKER_00

Oh no.

SPEAKER_01

Because the staging logic is configured wrong, the system gets confused. The moment the temperature drops slightly, the thermostat panics and turns on the giant toaster backup strips. The system technically works. Like your house feels warm, but you are using the most expensive heating method possible. The homeowner has no idea until they get a power bill for $700.

SPEAKER_00

$700 just because the thermostat was wired wrong.

SPEAKER_01

Just because of the staging logic.

SPEAKER_00

Which means the homeowner has to play defense. You can't just trust the logo on the side of the van. You must ask any prospective contractor point blank how many heat pumps did your crew install last month. If they hesitate, or say two or three, they're practicing on your house. You need a contractor who understands hybrid car level staging logic and A2L chemical pressures.

SPEAKER_01

You need someone who installs them weekly,

Contractor Skill Crisis And Failure Points

SPEAKER_01

not just occasionally.

SPEAKER_00

Okay, we've navigated the thermodynamics, the psychology of 140-degree air, the carbon footprint of manufacturing, and the very real danger of uneducated contractors. Let's talk about the wallet. What does this transition actually cost in the reality of 2026?

SPEAKER_01

Before we get into the baseline quotes, we need to issue a massive warning based on our sources. There's been a ton of buzz over the last few years about the federal government paying for your heat pump.

SPEAKER_00

Right, the tax credits.

SPEAKER_01

But both the Section 25C tax credit for air source systems and the Section 25D credit for geothermal officially expired on December 31st, 2025.

SPEAKER_00

That is a critical detail. The federal tax credits are gone. Meaning, if a contractor is sitting at your kitchen table in 2026, pointing to a brochure and pitching federal tax credits to make their $12,000 bid look cheaper, they are either wildly ignorant of a current tax code or they are actively lying to you.

SPEAKER_01

Either way, it is a massive red flag. The only financial offsets left on the table right now are local utility rebates, which vary wildly by zip code.

SPEAKER_00

So stripping away the expired federal promises, what are the raw baseline costs?

SPEAKER_01

For a standard home requiring a typical three-ton installation, an air source heat pump will run between $8,000 and $12,000 fully installed. If you compare that to the traditional route, a 95% efficient gas furnace paired with a new mid-tier AC unit that runs between $8,000 and $11,000. So the baseline upfront costs of the equipment are actually incredibly similar right now.

SPEAKER_00

That's surprisingly close. But what about geothermal? I know it's often touted as the holy grail of efficiency because it pulls heat from deep underground where the temperature is constant. How does that factor into the 2026 pricing?

SPEAKER_01

Geothermal is in a completely different financial universe. Because of the heavy excavation required to bury the ground loops, you are looking at $18,000 to $30,000 upfront.

SPEAKER_00

Wait, $30,000 to heat and cool a house? Who is paying that? You'd never recoup that cost in energy savings, even over 20 years.

SPEAKER_01

Well, that's where those hyper-local utility rebates come into play. The source mentions a utility called Seek Energy, which is currently offering a staggering $2,000 per ton up to $24,000 in rebates for geothermal.

SPEAKER_00

Oh wow.

SPEAKER_01

Yeah. If you happen to live in a utility area aggressively incentivizing ground source heat, that $30,000 system suddenly drops to $15,000 out of pocket. But you really have to do the legwork with your local provider.

SPEAKER_00

Okay, let's bring this down to a very common

2026 Pricing And Expired Tax Credits

SPEAKER_00

everyday crisis. It's November. You have a house with a 15-year-old air conditioner that rattles and an 18-year-old gas furnace that just cracked its heat exchanger. The whole system is completely dead and has to be replaced. According to Dave Hartzall, an honest, competent contractor won't just push a single heat pump solution. They should provide three distinct quotes. Walk us through those three options.

SPEAKER_01

The three options really provide a spectrum of choice based on your goals. Option one is the conventional route. You replace the broken gas furnace with a new 95% efficient gas model, and you put in a standard AC for the summer. Assuming a minor basic utility rebate, your net out of pocket is going to hover right around $8,000.

SPEAKER_00

Straightforward, like for like known technology.

SPEAKER_01

Yes. Option two is the full heat pump. You have the gas company cap the existing gas line, you remove the furnace entirely, and you install a high-efficiency air source heat pump with electric backup strips. Because you're often allowed to stack multiple utility rebates when you do a full system electrification, the net costs drops slightly, coming in between $7,500 and $9,000.

SPEAKER_00

So options one and two are virtually neck and neck on price, purely depending on how many local rebates you can stack for going electric. What is the third path?

SPEAKER_01

Option three is the hybrid system. This is the best of both worlds. You keep a gas furnace to act as your heavy-duty backup for deep, deep cold, but you replace your AC unit with a heat pump that does 80% of the heavy lifting during mild and moderate winter weather.

SPEAKER_00

I like the sound of that.

SPEAKER_01

It's great. But because of the complex staging integration required to make the two different fuel systems talk to each other seamlessly, this is the most expensive upfront option. It generally comes in around $11,500.

SPEAKER_00

So if you are the homeowner staring at these three quotes on your kitchen table, how do you decide? Looking at the data, it seems to map directly to three distinct buyer personas. If you're a short-term owner, meaning you plan to sell the house in the next three to five years, you generally go with option one, the conventional gas and AC for eight grand. You simply won't be living in the house long enough to reap the compounded

Three Replacement Quotes And Buyer Types

SPEAKER_00

monthly energy savings of a heat pump. So you minimize your upfront cost and keep the standard setup for the next buyer.

SPEAKER_01

Exactly. You are prioritizing immediate capital over long-term efficiency.

SPEAKER_00

But if you are a long-term owner on a strict budget, option two is the play, the full heat pump. You stack those electrification rebates to get the installation cost as low as possible, and then you sit back and enjoy significantly lower monthly power bills for the next 10 to 15 years.

SPEAKER_01

And then there is the hybrid.

SPEAKER_00

Right. The hybrid seems designed for the long-term owner whose absolute priority is comfort and who has the budget flexibility to pay for it. You pay that 11.5 grand premium up front, but you get the cheap operating costs of the heat pump in November and March, plus the peace of mind knowing you still have that 140-degree blast of gas furnace heat ready to go when a January blizzard hits.

SPEAKER_01

If we connect this to the bigger picture, the ultimate lesson from our veteran source is that there is absolutely no universal right answer. A contractor who walks into your home and pushes a one-size-fits-all heat pump solution isn't acting as an advisor. They're just acting as a salesman for the manufacturer.

SPEAKER_00

So, what does this all mean? When you're sitting in your living room listening to your ancient furnace make noises it shouldn't make, the main takeaway from all of this is that you have to match the machinery to your specific house and your specific lifestyle. You must demand three distinct options. You have to protect your wallet by knowing that the federal tax credits are expired as of 2026. You need to optimize your daily comfort by being brutally honest with yourself about whether you will miss that intense blast of hot furnace air.

The Big Risk Of Rushing Adoption

SPEAKER_00

And most importantly, you have to navigate this major industry transition intelligently by rigorously questioning your contractor to ensure they actually understand static pressure, A2L refrigerants, and complex staging logic.

SPEAKER_01

It demands vigilance. You cannot be a passive consumer in this transition. You have to be an active, informed participant.

SPEAKER_00

Absolutely. And as we wrap up this deep dive, there is one final, somewhat provocative thought that really lingers when analyzing these sources, especially regarding that competency crisis we discussed.

SPEAKER_01

It raises a critical systemic question for the Entire industry. If massive manufacturers like Medea, coupled with aggressive utility companies, successfully push the general public toward heat pumps faster than the local ground level contractors can actually learn to properly install them, are we walking blind into a massive wave of improperly installed systems?

SPEAKER_00

That's a terrifying thought.

SPEAKER_01

Right. Because if thousands of homes end up with botched staging logic running expensive backup heat and incorrect R45E4B refrigerant charges burning out compressors, it will cause skyrocketing power bills and cold houses. That will ultimately sour the general public on what is actually a perfectly brilliant technology. Ironically, by pushing the transition too fast without ensuring the workforce is ready, we might be delaying the green transition even further.

SPEAKER_00

The execution really is everything. It all comes back to that invisible war happening right behind your drywall. The thermodynamics are incredible, the environmental intent is valid, but none of it matters if the person wiring the thermostat doesn't know what they are doing. Keep questioning the systems running behind the scenes in your world, and we'll catch you on the next one.