EP18 無專業書評 | 由漢娜鄂蘭《政治的承諾》剖析西方哲學傳統

久未與各位聽眾相借問，實在歹勢。

說起漢娜鄂蘭這位哲學家，多數人對其印象就是用語異常地艱深，時常反覆閱讀好幾次文本，還是領略不到其箇中之意。我想，她的這一特質源自於思想的縝密，也正是出自這般原因，我才對她的哲學與政治理論感到興致盎然。

蘇格拉底曾遭受陪審團的控訴，在一場不公的審判中試圖申辯。他樂觀地認為，唯有將自己看到的世界形諸言語、充分地勾勒出來，城邦才會變得良善，而那個東西才是真理。現實的洗禮卻殘酷且疾速地端到蘇格拉底的眼前，掌權者與政治家們無不以說服與修辭之道擄獲人心，這對原本堅信老師蘇格拉底的觀念的柏拉圖產生偌大的思想衝擊，就此憤慨地說道：真理即說服的對立項；把事情談通徹即說服與修辭的對立項。

西方長達千年的哲學傳統就這麼轟烈地展開。

Transcript

SPEAKER_00 0:00

Take her one yung shooting to cool kill takedi Kongtiong Sionwedo. I got to see Yung Baby Yaba Kong the Tin Zoe Twansi Kan Tang Kiao Chia Bing Yu Kyao Tong Uaho Sheng Tin to it. Can I get better conju then at the changizama? No catch up the tatte. Uh you give two is a teth, uh young jungle so caboy and woman yung three teth or hensu so it's the henna orange, Hannah. Yeah, chipunti, or is he konkong tin chupan? I see e siya ye to Jeremy Kern E. So Chung di Yipun said uh E meant the Ching dog Wakamakong Siana Bekashipun said, Chipun said, I'll go to the shit or some come. Dim a boty changti, Wangong, e chile hen sion, as gong chire kaiam, has gong and tang sui ho tag, diao kai hong swe a hotke ki shwa su colo shikwa ki ching di kare sudo, one chetu dan ki diaokai dan hen sai the shiaho zong hong to a bang zongato as a me chingti on chingti the siwa sira imga im gaga than zikaba di ho and a gwan di the sea nan so may canomboto tingti kinagi chibonse chingti yak shim e kaiam. Chippon se ye gon chia henna or is e theong tagan as it three teraka gang qas gong the in a long sang henna in which the choke to the teraka does either put nongbe su teraka e couldn't ching the di run ka asong ching the suung ka a siana tesiana e betu siangesi to the terakana what guys e teraka su siung si chok chingse uh do see ye sukha ye su la long to ho siana to ho the siung e suka me gang to ching te so di a kon the gong e so sha soda me so sia soda sambo san your kongia tau ka ye te at the boon bo ne bungi biker yang taugi sung ye sabosa u gong e petuanta kaiam sisna Tanji twana hen and su e so yung ksi choc up atanzi so cato chao. A jeman de yang dog ye eye tall daswanakong Jamikern e kit yung di e go ye more me, or e so kata socia ja could picky or kata weaker or e cupantula, or chang di or dear aca chupantula. So, in a one asong e suang di the dear na chiban's hair to ching diung dog ishana big a her to chikon miya chang Wakamangong ching diang dog that take uh e g di de na chi de miya chung the e the egg easy i kai su e tio chungtia diangi qing dia diungiti hanna aren chibbons heading e kai sug qing di e si yu kwan chikwenang kyong tongan mea won e the watong so jungti chile e dangong hanna aren u chale choktyong yao it a kong ho so yung di si di chide kyong tong se kai di boto ngong kun te as yung or kunte wa tong. A henna e gong kana u can di jongbin e tangju yu hwa pand don a e dang ka tui hong swe hog no e ka di so kwa zide se kai or hwa pate e ken. A shiao ka dang song the jingti kun te. So is jing di tingi that ching di kun teengi. Kana ching di ching dog de g ye e siana chyungti di okay to the xing dog yung xieng dog si ching di so pipi huh it yung su yao to the gon so it ying su yao to the siung a chuasan di yungi tasona kong di kong jong a yung tongma nan kun jong a yung tong so it di it yung ki tung di uhiawa si pa ya ting ding and mi kya so is it no di ka jeng hu kang qwa do zikabo ya or e birds I won't k dox shit di bells I won't jing a tangi tups yung e so chu zu mikya. So it ng guan diang or to si the chingti kun te kazukong di ba we suan tingatang ki ansula pik yang tora. So in zingong qing dier dexu do si putwan digao guan deong qing ng kaitoa tang diong this koa it is a gi hu. This bur lock shit, the egg guandyong, guan dong dia couple called that xing dog, other ane it is say di say this say so it ching dixu the z di Xang dog kia guan dung tang diong chinga this say koha kana cheng diang dog juman sa it house. So it can see kissy tang the inner sink king the dear like can the inner sinking ahong the sura di simpong e poi our chile tellha e gis na e chile boxinbun tang henna earns chokia e te to the hik symbun tells kong dunko na kong nanu hox sau chyang do dum ball kit twad di jingti goodong to mo j the yung ton k yung yung do dan kun jong uh good yung so it dunas e hox so yung a go tang or full suin ka two j the byangsu yangsu a tanki go my gong to the full suin yeangi tohes yano. So henna sill the pogon kicsi bundas gong nanja khasi hoxo yung Adamaki twa di uh di kuntei has kong, jing pang, chem pangang zona shi la e j the champang in with champang do z in hisona zer chingwa ku yuk soi tongan in a suga bundes gong na meana kit twa di shen pang a tong the in a konga changsi a guy them the kong to see bean kit twa di kokka or in j ma jingwa ku yuk ign konk konkwa ikan hun kwa zos e the coca jet a tanui. So yang gir te girti no dame tik todi jong jungti kunte as gong koka as gon teana ki todi chyangti nai siung na kazu gong chikin at tai sakakin orsi u tanga to e cow nane e the hwan yang soengti kao xiang or e bur jun sai to y kwan dian. Oh in curang kan kenai or king nan siangwa on shengua chingti on chyangti. Nakazugong num dan to yung siang good, not to the tong bood, num bok and k diungti. Nanan sims it's young what does it chingti bumatu on to the sugarati to the haxyang you ji pun on ji ping bunj or the sugarati a sampin. I the kilo sugarati po sim ton or peasin ton it's it uh so e di simpon either kyo rang pea kyang pandun as you don't make so kong young tanzi sugarati e codin i bokama konta penun e bokama konta kyang pen easy no kong easy the ka is all kwa the seota yanggi i is all secai pyota zagangi dian tin zipo kataiji kong ho chia woon kata ji kong ho soda na di telak jong e utilegi su atangkai sota ji kong ho chia woon chile chiao so e di like a sty. Yung diamana white y na the xion big on this pyota bo kata ji konghia woon kon ho chiao tia to make ya tussy h di like a sun d- i a l g e s t h a i kasu gong yung su dangi sa konga so dan tangong su gara t simpon diong i e strategyong dursy e so qua de sa ye se ka iso qua e yung gengi a yang si ki ya piao ta i shai kong ho yao d is your maka taiji kong ho be. Kong kakantana chika taiji kong ho beung that simbo keka wanasika sugarati po si hiung so eit a to kam tan e the so chasi me wanaki e t kaki no king tai itin di can a two di pang two di young chin di can a two di pang cutting ta zona kong ta ji kong ho b eang one xigong pasu tan tong s dozona kong e g is young di like a sty. Oh one kong tong Basu dongsi is shoggy zosu sholz si chingti shong gengi yang ship so nan sabong po e suongs kama gong telha gengi yang ship but su in the long so kyo changti e gengi yang shi hok shulz si two diamatang t a kedun poratu kamagong telha kiao cheng di two di the yu chai e the sugar sympo e tete two y cheng di kama sibong no sa meda de suga ye in our su as suang like there in our su iangok quan chang ten e shong kin no can dip yujiang yu jung a tianggi terakyunggian tanj Ya disu daugong Yu Jung e si jong Tinghu Ikon Piang Ting Ikona Pyang Ting Ikonzi Ken dipti kyung the eggis ho is young. Some cow so can dipti king the egg's hold is young Bizu Kong di can I g no this is the San Jang San Yong nang I danzi this young key ka tia ta mo so di the tea taut yum di t ja parko on the koi chan te ja parkoi doubt jing ki ah the tea toi who to the e sang the dong hobu who to eat boon the dong hobu ki one chokdi na din ng kingse ki so ping tinhua quanma i t the eva eye di mounted the tansi chikwan e ping tinhua kwan hai din ngang till tanzi si taoko e kingse or di dihoi chianji yu jung di bursu yao kingse di kao ba or di kau su jong uita or ha din ng at theo kin dip yu jingon. So sugarati kamagong wal kiao chi bi ken dip yu jing. Alan and ho chong swe lang eken kon ho bing kong ta ka hotok ken dip chide qing di yak yong tong se kh u tao go e j the hong shoto hong shiawe pendeo kaka send your kaiu chit kayoto imagin gong dika di so con di a se gai no chikong ah yung gengiye yang si kialta e canzi jin di munji theang so qua di a se gonganzi ton bia mi kenji tao ked but you so ken jang deo di zila dang so kyangam t anaj mi kya sugarati e chwana e the ginokong t me can si chin di tanzi sugarati a haxyang boratu i swa ho jin chasinha wanga mangong chile sugarati so jin we a chin di gimpunzi chindi eit jinong dung curry yung ki or chamzi a siung dog swe hok, swa boa dog kyo yungguan a chin di soyho, chin minga zidan tazwang kong so e nantazan kongama tuan chugarati ki jaws you the simpiao tigak the ngyazi thousing at two de young siana yanas nyo dozi in with sugarati noigong dialka di so qua di me can me di poratu e qua the simpo they are e can jing the simpon they are you saw in equal the uh me can see we su uh pillogong ton tiao jimpin bong e uh jimbin bhongong uh one the ching quan yung one nong by shallbe does it telaka e the ziang konjin me tang a shell bed in we kon a guten burgering the ching quanzi tanga to tau couple edi tsunzayama so teraka the got chic on a susion belt uh as it in so qua migama uh i wanna j no long to the megansi young one jin di ma so e shome ho chi vin the chivin ki or coca chic on a chamsi is yung dog suih tansi e suakama kong the teraka e chickon sug other gong qing quan chong chikan a hui bed chic on a suung chi vin injun gong chivin in kamagong chipossian e e can a ki dongil any ania cabo e can either yung sang to theong ka chindi kam di kam di e ka chindi boto k swayho kun jong. So caboya suga na tiong simpong Chang Bigua bigyok Yung Cheng di caboya ikan sie empensa Sui hoga siangong Suiho Yung Dika in so to e g hog jim Shinzi meho jim uhyong kigan Shing dog Shing Lokong quite or disame quite he burjung sami answan. Then e punch yung she burger and get usin' in a person burger yung one Uha Sugarati eong bird cannon as a gong e can se card dog one and uh yeah punch yung is a con de chip in a heakin succincata or on burger. Is you no gong dance of one sort of one chicken. Tender kit we have the tongue. So you don't tie a shot. Jinui Chiana bottle todd each gong Jin duang si both eh doesn't go a pio nun don't see tan talk soon sire or children does it on chang here or children early anzi take a rumbo Dan Lang and Su Sion Si uh couple out of some easy. Is a metonda regard Numidan burger once one Kyoko So shong I care may I hikan mo yo sit Tweetan. Nancun shall make the answer to dana do a simaltun the So each number tin the guanta kiss Kiaokati Tao tin theokai anagati tautin and la Cassika Kyorang Cassia Kia rang Bono Kyon Kaupoi Kyon Sil Sway. So it's gonna jin do bottle to the ching diagonte Kiss is your hand earn as your hand earns. Either Zigam Namsi Hong Soad di Gunteya Sugarati Chiangu in his unjang the con gang other than hong bottle unchun e got the con ton tweekong either sang. So in sans kiptan in polatu ginogs or ang eagen she hun doan in both you the cow in a treasuble comes or bana quite a rang don't hop yo egg. Anne the border teal kia beaution. That's the more easy and country so either yung young do a piano terak sang the in sectong so is it a terak twang either we put the suggestion take it So, Hong Shield Yung Yong Pools right a terak ton tong seng the terakantong. Kisi I gong Bora to a Su Xiong Biu Pai. Yung di Tongsi Seng Ta Swen Sho the Boratu Yang Zosion Dazi. Kwa Tangaboya Usam Kau Giudi Yuma. Nan Tazuna Kong the Bola to San Xing a de Seng a terak ton tong. Ki si le gong chong bolatu an e xong yong telakikai su jungti and si oh nan nan nan a kata terak the long shong e mo zit yung and terak as in cut you su shong kikai su jungti. So it did a thousand telak ashong kikai su jungti pun si na hingui do she the sang and telakantong. So in a yung zitagonin seng and terak su e the or song kari j call i border thousude in it toi one itiki one to e kata chang and di doon. So it di koa t to i kyukong semikon a terak semakondui cata yung di ka markers no e two hando e chugi or markersugi kai siang juna seng atong kazu an shity markers ye hexim su yung later e gardan punji tiangi to zidl tongiao siung sanga seng and tadak su tongi ida yang edition but qi mo chung tadak that kai swe chyangti on tontong tihwana number two yo ki kaiswe jungtiya yung we both two yao dan e kata the ziddong gyao chyang san. Dansii a hana earns e the prev yong kong chikon a t gana e ho chingti sh di ana kwan e canabesu kong mm dan chyangti baker ki fo mo z yung diun. Baker ki or toshia mo chungdiun, din chia yu chen si zhang. Dans jinui kao dixu kekko tang diong zenem pe qing ku di go yung markeksu margasu exu pizen no di eang wun tang e kiki po jindui. So dexu u the kuido tie, so jinui isi tiao dexu e kuido tang diong nan chibu kasi xing san e kiki, the tongue kiki. Kana u stawe xing san chikon hong sh ka e tanki piao hen nanekad. Given zhung chipen sa kong the dexu asu and gong wasima abe kwa ka chauya abbeo chiko nemasi ana kwa kwa given zhong tang e the gong sa than si kua be so chim givewa pyo ta kuakination. Anyway, takibensia was in the gong henna ean y suong xiong huakama mom me ting tong zhong si tui sugarati or yin i jin tong sukarati e suong uh sugarati suang the zigong i kamga lang kiao lang di tui we chi kan ho zion di kai kai dang ki yang siang zihong e chyang di se kai. Na chitiam naiko hana e song yin tong. Kazada sugarati i gwana mshenjing cut di hu ya. Tiam kyna earn ma kan kona or henna earn ima ima jmere u di hu yadam. Im telaka, e ching ho kati or two ching dia, chyangti tadak, nana t chungti tedahak dunka nongong e chi bo e dun chianinse tetha e huanui no teta wondui ji dyeong chile hun kin or to the chok se hunduinye. Tan si the henna aren e suong at te e jungong, eka chungti k ter hak diong si ya gin tosi twidip hang. Ika ng jinwit zosi, twit the hang. Telaka inu ji jong shong bet twa de chungti di shong. Tanji jong di song y shong shonko di shong shongo burgerong si henna. A dan telaka one zit the jin du ya. Nan chottu wardon ki twa di jungti kuntaya or kanadi kyo cati the tautin little uh her eye chot to burger sire. Yon uh why um it's soti kia henna earns si cho shio shawa on a jinong chibunsei punti song the henna earns dega sugarati or yen sangongti kui chung ni e dai chong sang zi henna earn theokay t sugarati. So is sangongsi hai di cong or een giao chi one. In a k yong tong tia monotosia na bigong in boj mega tenha asong more to jung chi dia tonsi decang outdo kanku. I majdyon ka ter hap sagiga ching dia pia in gam timbatia chyang di lambo twenty e dish yo ka hot kikan it konch jong tang her u piang ting at two yway konkung konkan kani at lisiahua ganahoms jungti ka tok tsu no or two tun the terap su consa. Nakasakong number gong chong boato u piang ting to yung sing on a konk yung kon kane curry yung dana tongue di chia kai samikon a terak, samikon a terak to tongyiang. Some con a susyo to new tongue chillisha hui na chia onga chillumikansi by chilisha hui chim ho. So chipun say yeah, wow not so chantong dinamikan. So, changing dinamikian the chong uh then tetang quana canabi su oh jumporongato chiao n til sega long tangki a kai soyao t shong iwana si baudi ching di kunte tang tung genamikya no boto one chwan ki kai soy chimti dynamikya hoxaw ka hot or jin we punchin to kardio gai chingti punchi. So nongama hen di on thresh yu ging andresting one or blue ja chang ping you. Nanny gang side sangway chan chanakong uh chingti one ching dia inga sou boon hapna ting tang we di don bingi buck the chang dia buring guai e siok yang tai. Walkers jinukong, chang as the sangma. Sungui sa su hen or monk in guys yingwi ching di chip ton ching chha ching di chip ton e j the oxyang e kyung chang no jo in gai kui or chia ching chan zi ton uh she the chinzen chai chong to t su te run e shak yang tai ch the biong su hong uing huaki ma tisu the changti or chanzu pona she moon said the long cham boo a ho song kong su e can a chakongan kaboya swa hong di one hwaki uh yunhua pensiangui song kiptone ch the quan kill caboya ma tisu the nan chal shall and poin kama gong duangti hand song jan si bong caboya do can see began ki chaps you the hen side zong hong or chan song ah do dang jung di atang diung ping pyang so not twizang gong or yeah two chang di pushong sibong or di taug the tents of orong si tame more chang di rang. Don a dungi tal chipons ki chim chim ki deo ka cheng di a punjit, taugo jungti su lanjaku ye jung de su ki theoga the gong cheng diapunchit chengti i ta siang. Nat chibanse kib chong the chipun segdi su Sweden du yong dong se diagong telak su in annak su chengti ku tia su te chong wanasika chingti dong so siukak. Songong chippense nga hana earn k gamasyongeka sugarati gonna tedak and shogdo eki no tangi. Sweden poratu e sugarati hakshenga, danji swa huantu e su zhong a hot su di se pang bechia chingwa tangak ton tong. Sweden machek su ka tua ma kyksu ka chugon a tedak ton tong shak, daj sugarati e to gonna de swayasi chim chim tai t intagon bo heni uh henna earn either kia tai jong a kakto, kiao suit, kidun suit, kikai s di sugarati guansa gonna suong a kito chi song, ako kyao e pun zin a sujong kao tago chipunse kiken di chitu shin su zong ana kimjong kin I geto yong and long zong si wakati ye chenkin wong honey at twang yap no mum the tuck tetare awa target tetar se my wokon honey a danzi teoung of tagera uh kazu pong walkong and as you to your ki cut oom t so niung tagera chiung poet yung uh some the card out we wang taganyo tingao kai uhwana whisongja coboi tin a jump ping with shooting a tau chi a king pangan. Who shong e now uh I cannot get a tag me the cause I'm come shako waiting a jump ping or shooting a gil chi and a teacher the cause that we tia ta man