Flop Doctors

American Idol

Clare Reynders & Henry Rosenbloom Season 1 Episode 6

This week, Clare & Henry welcome writer and musician Spencer Nachman for an examination of the former cultural behemoth that introduced us to icons such as pop star Kelly Clarkson, Smash actress Katherine McPhee and Christmas-cover playlist heavyweight David Archuleta… that’s right. the Timeslot Death Star itself, American Idol.

You may be asking - how can it be in its flop era if it’s not on anymore? Well, the answer is that it is. Previous patient Katy Perry left the judges’ lineup *last year*. Do you know what a “platinum ticket” is? Just how Christian it’s gotten, and how well-suited contestants who only sing Gospel are to the endeavor? Can you even tell me who won any of the last ten seasons? 

Let’s face it, the show has become a corpse, but the Doctors and their counsel are trying something new: necromancy. They’ve engineered a top-to-bottom reimagining of the show in which nothing is sacred.  Against all odds, they have a plan to bring it back to its former glory… even if it means sacrificing Ryan Seacrest.