Text us your comments or topic ideas for future shows.

Connect with Us on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/coreyharlock/ 

Take the KeyHire Capacity Calculator: www.keyhire.solutions/capacity

In this episode of The KeyHire Small Business Podcast, Corey Harlock breaks down one of the biggest risks small business owners face in a chaotic economy: making the wrong hire because the market looks full of available talent.

With layoffs continuing across multiple industries, AI reshaping white-collar work, and some sectors booming while others struggle, it can be easy for business owners to assume that great candidates are suddenly easier to find. But as Corey explains, available talent is not the same thing as qualified talent. Just because someone impressive is on the market does not mean they have the right skills, experience, industry knowledge, or capacity to succeed inside your business.

Corey walks through three common hiring mistakes small business owners make when the economy gets noisy. The first is getting swept up by a referral or an impressive resume and rushing someone through an informal hiring process. Maybe a friend, neighbor, or colleague recommends a recently laid-off leader or salesperson, and the business owner sees a rare opportunity to bring in “big company” talent. The problem is that without a consistent hiring process, red flags get missed, expectations stay unclear, and six months later, the business owner may realize they are paying top dollar for someone who does not understand the business.

The second mistake is bargain hunting. Corey explains why hiring someone at a discount simply because they are out of work can create what he calls a “rental player.” They may take the role because they need a paycheck, but once another opportunity appears at their previous compensation level, they are likely to leave. That turnover creates lost time, lost momentum, and a much higher cost than the salary savings ever justified.

The third mistake is hiring for transferable skills without building the training structure needed to make that hire successful. Corey makes an important distinction between hiring for experience and hiring for potential. Experience costs more, but it can create faster return on investment. Potential may be less expensive upfront, but it requires clear 30-, 60-, and 90-day goals, structured training, follow-up, coaching, and patience.

Throughout the episode, Corey gives small business owners practical ways to avoid these traps. He emphasizes the need for a consistent hiring process, fair and thoughtful compensation, clear KPIs, structured onboarding, and regular check-ins. He also reminds owners that their best employees are already getting calls from other companies, so retention depends on consistently giving them reasons to stay.

This episode is especially valuable for small business owners who are hiring in today’s uncertain economy, considering candidates from outside their industry, or trying to decide whether to hire for experience or potential. Corey also points listeners to a recorded webinar that expands on these ideas, including how to build a hiring avatar, create a scorecard, and design a stronger interview process.

If you want to make better hiring decisions, protect your investment, and avoid expensive hiring mistakes, this episode is a must-listen.  

Connect with the Experts

Connect with Corey Harlock on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/coreyharlock/ 

Learn more about KeyHire Solutions: https://www.keyhire.solutions