Back to the Big Screen with Spencer and Sophie

Sing Street: The Cult Film That Should've Been Bigger

Spencer Season 1 Episode 6

Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.

0:00 | 22:58

This week on Big Screen, Spencer and Sophie review Sing Street — the 2016 John Carney film that was quietly one of the best movies of its year, overshadowed by La La Land and destined to become a word-of-mouth classic. Set in 1980s Dublin, it's a coming-of-age story about music, escape, first love, and one boy forming a band to impress a girl. We cover the casting, the era, the soundtrack, John Carney's personal connection to the story, and why unknown actors almost always make for better films. Rated 9/10 by Sophie, 8.3 by Spencer.


SPEAKER_01

You'd have to use copyrighted music for these.

SPEAKER_00

This is back to the big screen. I'm Spencer. At the moment, I'm running a film and screening night in Blackpool, and I've created this app that allows people to create their own screening events and getting their favourite film back onto the big screen. I'm joined by Sophie.

SPEAKER_01

Hello, I'm Sophie. I'm Spencer's pal and film lover and very pleased to be here today. Okay.

SPEAKER_00

This week we're going to be looking at the film uh Singstreet, based on the film done in 2016, and it was set in 1985. So we're going to go over the film and then we're going to list five facts about the film.

SPEAKER_01

And hopefully touch on our favourite moments.

SPEAKER_00

Touch on our favourite moments.

SPEAKER_01

I had never heard of Sing Street, which is unusual for me. So this was a well-known.

SPEAKER_00

It's quite a cold classic though, isn't it?

SPEAKER_01

Yeah, of all the films that we've watched, this probably has the consistently highest rating across IMDB and Rotten Tomatoes.

SPEAKER_00

You're aware with other John's films though, I take it. So have you seen his other films?

SPEAKER_01

I've seen once. Okay. And I didn't look into much else of what he'd done. And I don't know if he directed it or I know he wrote them. I assume he directed them both as well. They kind of have a similar-ish feel to it, at least. Once in this, if you've seen it.

SPEAKER_00

He's done a film called Begin Again as well. I don't suppose you've seen that. Okay. But I think this is most of his films don't have a big cast in them or a big budget.

SPEAKER_01

That's why they're unknown actors because he can't afford to pay the big bucks.

SPEAKER_00

Quite quite possibly. He says that's getting back to the rawness, but we'll go over that in a minute. So what did you think about the film, Sophie?

SPEAKER_01

Okay, first impressions. I honestly absolutely loved it. There were also instances in the film where I genuinely didn't know which way it was gonna go.

SPEAKER_00

Did you know anything about the film before you watched it?

SPEAKER_01

No.

SPEAKER_00

No, neither did I.

SPEAKER_01

Um This is nice because usually I've when we've done this, I've watched them before.

SPEAKER_00

So this was totally nook. What really stuck out to you in the film? Okay, so and maybe in comparison to like previous films John's done. John Carney.

SPEAKER_01

John Carney. So I've only got once to compare it to, and I watched it a long, long, long time ago. And it's worth watching the moment that she accepts the award at the Oscars. I think they win for best original song or something. Anyways, it's quite painful because you know the Oscars always usher people on, they've got 60 seconds to do their speech. She gets totally cut off. Oh really? Embarrassing. Oh geez. It's stuck in my mind, yeah, many years ago. Anyways, the film's fantastic and the music in it is so beautiful. So, initial initial about this film. Interestingly, I don't think there was very much in the way of bad weather. I thought that throughout how lovely they made Dublin look. So the bit where he takes her on the boat and then have the picnic on the private island, that at that moment I thought, oh my god, it looks amazing. It looks so beautiful.

SPEAKER_00

Yeah, it certainly doesn't it. It's a beautiful location. And even actually, John says this when he was filming, he was he found it quite hard to do because all the Georgia buildings have been demolished and they've been replaced with like glass buildings and whatnot.

SPEAKER_01

Also, it doesn't look anything like the 80s.

SPEAKER_00

It's not as much as he wanted to. He tried really hard to get scenes of buildings that kind of reflected the 1980s, but from what he remembers, it a lot of it didn't exist anymore. So they had to be in a bit creative what's what angles they use with the with cameras and stuff like that. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01

Also, one of the things I noticed, and I think this is why the film's probably so appealing. I I what do have no experience of the 80s. I love how angsty it seems to feel. The music, you know, boys in makeup, I think it's great.

SPEAKER_00

I think it's quite an interesting time for Island Low, the 1980s, because they were still more in religion or in the Catholic movement in the 60s, so didn't get the expression that the UK did back in the 60s.

SPEAKER_01

So it was all a bit delayed.

SPEAKER_00

It was a bit delayed for them. So this was their coming, I don't know, coming of enjoyment and people a chance to express themselves in the 60s, probably it'd be unthinkable to even put makeup on. I know it didn't go very well in the film.

SPEAKER_01

Oh, it's actually a brutal scene.

SPEAKER_00

Yeah, very brutal. Um, yeah.

SPEAKER_01

He's he's up there with one of the film, like film history, awful villains. I know it's a small moment, but it's so horrible to watch.

SPEAKER_00

Yeah, very horrible. Yeah. But it still showed that people trying to express themselves, and I think even the music videos they did, the outfits looked absolutely hilarious, but it's showing how they were trying to express themselves with what they're wearing and the creativity that I suspect because the reviews were so popular, like they're so positive.

SPEAKER_01

I think they must have done, they must have reflected the 80s really, really well. Yeah. And I that's sorry, so that's what I was trying to say earlier. Why part of the reason the film's so attractive watching it now, it's super less chaotic, it feels doesn't feel busy anywhere throughout the whole film, doesn't feel particularly chaotic, obviously the bullying scenes, but there's no mobile phones, you know what? Like the whole era of it is really attractive.

SPEAKER_00

One of the reasons he's done it in the 1980s is because he knew the era, he grew up in it. He's saying if he was to redo that today or when the film came out ten years ago, he would really struggle to really do that justice because he knew that era really well. He was he was part of a ban himself, and it I think he did that justice really.

SPEAKER_01

Yeah. I think if you did it now, I don't know if this is me just getting older and much more cynical, it would just be a less charming film. You wouldn't be able to do it, would you, in the same way. People whipping out their bones all the time.

SPEAKER_00

What was your favourite character in the film? Was it Connor, the main artist?

SPEAKER_01

So I think he was fantastic. He's I think you said he's not done very much acting before this. Okay. Yeah, I thought he was great. We mentioned it on podcasts previously, and I think it always works to a film's advantage when you cast an unknown actor. Yeah. Because you can't typecast them. You've got you've got nothing to compare a previous role. Yeah. I thought he was fantastic. Also, I know on the era, they all the kids look normal, you know, like slight, slightly goofy toothed, they're not like done up to the nines and perfect den dentures or whatever. I love that. It looks all normal and slightly spotty and whatever. Favourite character, hmm. I really liked the brother.

SPEAKER_00

I thought you were gonna say that. A lot of people say that, the older brother, Brendan. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01

Yeah, he was quite like a fantastic character, you know. And when he used to get him to sit down, he said this is homework and he'd put a record on. And then in the next scene when he'd be practicing with his band, I said to you earlier, you can really hear it in the song, which I loved. And so he was a really wonderful, positive exp um He's like the role model in all.

SPEAKER_00

I don't say role model, but just like, yeah, as the guide, you know. I mean, I think that works. I think that's really I think the film would really struggle without that. How would you sell this film to someone that hasn't seen it?

SPEAKER_01

Oh, a coming-of-age story, super uplifting. So um, I think after watching it, I did only a very tiny little readaround this morning. Weinstein, they bought the rights to distribute it in America, and he kind of sold it as like the new is it Don McHugh's who did The Breakfast Club, that director. Similar vibe, because it's all coming of age, yeah, and lovely, you totally see the character development.

SPEAKER_00

Yeah.

SPEAKER_01

Um, so Connor, you see him initially, you know, and he gets kind of beaten up by the bully. Yeah, he shows himself to be a victim, and the young chap who turns out to be their band manager, he says, you know, you basically you look like a victim, that's why you're getting picked on, you're giving him a reason. And then throughout the film, all that development, he becomes his own person, he's really brave. It's great. Okay, should we go into the facts? I'm gonna reel one off.

SPEAKER_00

Okay.

SPEAKER_01

Okay. What was the budget for the film?

SPEAKER_00

Uh four million dollars.

SPEAKER_01

Dollars, correct. An incredibly modest sum by even independent film standards. I mean, I think when he did once, he honestly, I think it was like 200k. Oh, really? I think more. I've actually made more. Well, I think that's it sounds good, though, doesn't it?

SPEAKER_00

But the thing is gets the creativity, because you haven't got a budget, you haven't got the actors, you really got to Time is literally money. So he probably I wonder when they when wonder how I think he went to great depths to get the right people involved in it.

SPEAKER_01

I think the casts were amazing.

SPEAKER_00

Yeah, really good cast, and I think he was looking for particular people that would gel well. But despite it being on a tiny buzz, it did win the Sundance Film Festival in 2016.

SPEAKER_01

Um it went on to become a global word of mouth phenomenon, which I can't believe I've never heard of it, honestly.

SPEAKER_00

I think I've read reviews and I I believe it's because and I could be wrong here, but La La Lan came out the same year, so I think that kind of got the box office, it got a lot of the attention while this one was I wouldn't say hidden, but not in the It got overshadowed. Out shadowed for such a big film at that time, and I think there was some really good films in 2016 when it came out.

SPEAKER_01

So I think sixteen, I actually can't believe that was ten years ago. I remember La La Land coming out of the cinema, I remember it being everywhere, it was so well what's it called, publicised. It didn't appeal to me, I've never seen it. Yeah, but I don't remember seeing straight. I'm so glad I've watched it now. Honestly, this is a recommendation, this is well worth a watch.

SPEAKER_00

Yeah, I think there've been such particular songs picked throughout the film. I've got to be honest, I'm not a massive 80s film, no, so like interesting 80s music, but every single of these tracks, I was like, this is brilliant, you know what I mean? It really sets the vibe.

SPEAKER_01

It was banger after banger, yeah.

SPEAKER_00

And it's like Duran Duran, you had was the cure in there as well? No, and it had really nice 80s music, and yeah, and I to be honest, I didn't know that it was based on John Carney's like basically his history at school, and I thought it was based on a band and kind of blended in. So I'm gonna do a fact now. John Carney drew heavily from his own life in this, so he created a band himself, and it was mainly to get attention from girls, and the music was a safe haven for Connor.

SPEAKER_01

Um that was a really sweet scene. Yeah. Oh, actually, we've got it playing on in the background at the moment. Yeah, when he picks his sister up and they dance, and the parents are arguing horribly.

SPEAKER_00

Yeah, it's just a really good feel-good where something can be really bad, but the creativity around music really is it was an escape for Connor.

SPEAKER_01

Do you know another thing that I love about this? Is everything nowadays, all music, it's so accessible. So I've got a Spotify account, for example. You literally can get any song you want at the tip of your fingers. Here, you had to save up, get a record, and you'd play it on repeat. I mean, I vaguely remember doing it when I was little with CDs, but not to the same way that they probably had to do it in the 80s. It meant so much, and those moments with his brother were so lovely.

SPEAKER_00

I think it's so nice, especially with the vinyl and the mixtapes, putting them in a little brown envelope and taking it with you to London. It was like how much effort you put into it. Now we're entering a world where everything's AI.

SPEAKER_01

Yeah. Um, you just don't have the same appreciation for music. That's what's lovely. How that's how that's what comes across through the film is how much music must have meant to John Carney growing up.

SPEAKER_00

A hundred percent. And how it really shaped his youth. My fact now is the lead actor almost had no acting experience. So the actor who played Connor, he'd done nothing previously, was at the time, I think actually is probably 16 when it came out the film, which is quite surprising because you said the other actor, Lucy, was she old a lot older?

SPEAKER_01

Well, she's born in '92. So I think she was 21 or 22 when she did this film.

SPEAKER_00

Yeah, so there's a massive age gap there, isn't there?

SPEAKER_01

Is he how actually old is he?

SPEAKER_00

Yeah.

SPEAKER_01

Oh my god, yeah, he was born in 1999.

SPEAKER_00

Wow. Yeah, so that's quite a big age gap. So he was playing it when he was 16, and she must have been 21 at the time, give or take a year. But I think he I think that's quite amazed him for a 16-year-old to get that part, and he deserved it. He literally he was the focal point for every scene. But Carney, he auditioned hundreds of boys in Ireland to play that role, and literally, the moment he saw Ferdia, he was like, It's my boy.

SPEAKER_01

He knew he was the one. Yeah. Also, all of the boys in the band, and a special shout out to Mark McKenna as Eamon, the multi-instrumentalist, he was phenomenal. I don't know what he's doing now, I can only imagine he's maybe gone on to do wonderful things. And those moments in the film where he would knock on the door, Eamon would open, and uh he said, Oh, do you know do you want to write a song? Oh, yeah. I thought it was lovely. Okay, so seeing as I touched on the brother being probably my favourite character in the film, interestingly, he almost didn't have a very big role in the film. He was cast to bring like warmth, credibility to what was originally a supporting part, if that makes any sense. During the filming, which I can only imagine was short because the budget was so small at four million.

SPEAKER_00

Yeah.

SPEAKER_01

Because the chemistry between Rayner and Ferdia, or Brendan and Connor, the brothers, was so wonderful, he wanted to give it much more screen time. So Brendan, or is it Jack Rayner, the actor? Yeah, kind of won himself a much bigger part in the film.

SPEAKER_00

You could believe they're actually brothers in real life. So charming.

SPEAKER_01

I bet that dynamic of him when he's when he does the quite heartbreaking scene, he says, you know, I carved the way for you, basically. And he's did you not find that I just awkward to watch?

SPEAKER_00

Yeah, it's like, oh god. But it was typical when you're like having a meltdown or siblings. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01

I can't imagine that actually because ultimately, at that point, up until that point, he only wants to support his younger brother, and he still does right up until the very end.

SPEAKER_00

Well, that was really nice, though.

SPEAKER_01

That was a slip, wasn't it, of his character. And it was really sad to watch because he kind of saw in his younger brother the youth that he maybe misspent, and there was an element of like bitterness to it, which felt actually really strangely out of character.

SPEAKER_00

Yeah, but it was so nice to see at the end just him being so happy for someone, you know what I mean?

SPEAKER_01

Um yeah, it was lovely.

SPEAKER_00

Yeah, and like you like constantly people jealous of stuff. It's nice to have that warming where you're just like thankful, even though it looked like he was gonna drown in the sea.

SPEAKER_01

That would have been a bad ending.

SPEAKER_00

Yeah, I wonder if how many people have actually got a small dinghy and sailed it from Dublin.

SPEAKER_01

I did look this up. Oh really? Oh no, no, sorry, not the number of people that have done it.

SPEAKER_00

Well zero. It's near certain death.

SPEAKER_01

Tomorrow we're going. Um yeah, because I was like, hang on, this boat, because I've gone from Liverpool to wherever, and I'm like, I swear that took me hours, but from Wales, which is is that what it is, Hollyhead?

SPEAKER_00

Well, it's Hollyhead, yeah. It's nearly the length of It's like 29 miles. Yeah, it's longer than Channel Tunnel.

SPEAKER_01

It's not far.

SPEAKER_00

Yeah.

SPEAKER_01

In a dinghy, I still think it takes a couple of hours.

SPEAKER_00

Yeah, it was taking them a couple of hours. It's a major shipping lane. Well, it was maybe not in the 80s.

SPEAKER_01

Or maybe. Yeah, so I don't know. Whether they survived that or not, I really don't know. I mean it was a pretty tiny boat.

SPEAKER_00

It must be quite scary as well, because he wouldn't know if they made it until like four days later when they got to a telephone box.

SPEAKER_01

Also, yes, exactly.

SPEAKER_00

Or maybe not four days a day later.

SPEAKER_01

I fully expected them to set sail and have these wonderful big visions of making it to England or where I thought they'd like run out of fuel or something and then have to get saved by the Coast Guard.

SPEAKER_00

I really thought that was gonna happen. I thought that was a possibility, especially when that ferry came along. I thought they were gonna be a rescue for it.

SPEAKER_01

If you were gonna play any role in the film, I'd probably I would want one that had a costume.

SPEAKER_00

Yeah, oh god. The funniest bit though, the funniest bit where you see the first music video and I think one of them's wearing the YMCA sort of outfit.

SPEAKER_01

The cowboy.

SPEAKER_00

Yeah, and he goes, I think it's like you you're gay, you guys are gay, and stuff like that. I couldn't do the accent very well there. And he was like, YMC aren't gay. Just so innocent. It was so good.

SPEAKER_01

Yeah, yeah, I love that. And uh when the is it Darren, the band manager, when he tries to do the film recording and the the tape cassette pops out, you know, it's like she finally arrives and they've obviously not got a clue what they're doing, but it's so sweet.

SPEAKER_00

But I think that's so fun about the creativity they had, and she obviously knew they had no clue what they're doing, but that she's willing to go ahead like along with it. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01

Yeah, she was so up for it in game, she was cool. I think I want to hear your top two moments in the film then.

SPEAKER_00

Um the first music video really set it alive. I think that, yeah. I really like that bit when they're recording. I can't remember if it's the model as a riddle, riddle ridder.

SPEAKER_01

The riddle of the model.

SPEAKER_00

Yeah, I think that was so beautiful. Yeah, I like that a lot. Um, and my second one. The prom scene, I guess a lot of people are gonna say that, and I think even the director said the prom scene is very good.

SPEAKER_01

Was his favourite?

SPEAKER_00

Yeah. Oh, actually, no, the director said his favourite scene was the one where they're escaping the harsh realities of their parents' uh separation.

SPEAKER_01

The room.

SPEAKER_00

Yeah, yeah. That's what the director said to the pinnacle. But I like the prom scene because you you I I got involved with the imagination that they were like like living that fantasy. Yeah. You know what I mean? I was trying to do that. What about yours?

SPEAKER_01

I actually would go with John Carney, and I think the scene where the parents are arguing horribly and the three siblings are dancing around, I really liked that. The other one, and you're gonna think this is so lame. When they're filming the other music video and Rafina jumps in the water. Okay, and then she says Predictable though, wasn't it? No, did you know? It it probably was, but I was like, and she goes, Never do anything by half, and then he kisses her, and it's so lame. And she's like, Oh, you ruined it. But, anyways, I loved that scene, isn't it?

SPEAKER_00

Yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_01

Also, his mates, the camaraderie between the band mates was so good. Yeah, ultimately, what you're watching is I mean, I wanted to be in a band growing up, surely everyone does. You kind of watch someone acting out the fantasy you probably had when you were younger. That's great. I've had to Google this because I was intrigued to know how much it might have grossed worldwide. So say the budget approximately is three to four million. How much do you reckon they grossed worldwide?

SPEAKER_00

Well, that's good, a good question. If you got it worldwide only. Yeah. A hundred million.

SPEAKER_01

Thirteen point six. Oh wow. Which I suppose and they made loads considering how small their budget was. Surprising. Yeah, I know. Yeah. Domestically it was three point two million, that's what it earned, and ten point four internationally.

SPEAKER_00

Oh god, that's really quite small.

SPEAKER_01

Yeah, I know.

SPEAKER_00

Yeah.

SPEAKER_01

Was it the debut, did you say, or the whole That just says grossed approximately worldwide, against a production budget of three to four million.

SPEAKER_00

So okay, so it wasn't a smash hit really.

SPEAKER_01

No.

SPEAKER_00

Yeah, okay, that's quite surprising.

SPEAKER_01

Of all the films that we've done on this, so a hundred and is that right? 107,116 reviews, IMDB says 7.9 out of ten. Like that is stonking good rating. And then Rotten Tomatoes, 215, 95%. That is st that's bloody good. Bloody high. So yeah, what would you rate it out of ten? Go on then.

SPEAKER_00

I would go for uh nine out of ten. Very high. What would you go for?

SPEAKER_01

Yeah, I'd probably go for like an eight point three.

SPEAKER_00

Eight point three. Very Pacific. What would you change to get it to a ten? That's a hard one, isn't it?

SPEAKER_01

That is a hard one. Do you know? I did really like it. I probably won't watch it again though. So against films that I love and watch time and time again, for example, He is up there, is close to a 10 for me. So I think it's a bloody great film.

SPEAKER_00

Okay, I'm gonna go with my last fact. There was a lot of um controversy in this because John Carney um got criticized for his Kira Knightley comment. He said because it was like, you know, raw actors in there, a new cast, he said there's no Kira Knightley's in this film, and he got heavily criticised for that comment. And that was in relation to From his previous film, Kira Knightley was in Beginnagain, and he was just basically he was trying to say, look, we haven't got any big artists in this film, there's no of these Kira Knightley models in there, and yeah, he had to do a public apology on BBC because of his comment there to try and retract it.

SPEAKER_01

To be fair, I'm reading this now. If he did genuinely say it's pretty harsh. I mean, she was probably pretty overexposed at that point, but I love Kira Knightley.

SPEAKER_00

But I think uh I wouldn't say had his point, but I think he wanted to create one of these creative masterpieces, he wanted to strip it all back to the bare minimum or and pick the right people for the right job.

SPEAKER_01

And I think like you said earlier, certain actors have um you've already got an idea about the character they're gonna play.

SPEAKER_00

And I think one of the great things about this, you had no idea, I didn't know the backstory but before this film or the synopsis, so it was great to know you didn't know what was gonna happen. You couldn't predict what was gonna happen. I think that's quite nice.

SPEAKER_01

I think it's important.

SPEAKER_00

Yeah, quite wholesome.

SPEAKER_01

Which is why Sigorny Weevil worked so well in Alien, she was unknown at that point, really.

SPEAKER_00

Definitely, yeah.

SPEAKER_01

So always bringing it back to Alien, yeah.

SPEAKER_00

I think they should do there probably is there always a lot of independent films that do that, but it's a shame that a lot of them don't make it to the cinema.

SPEAKER_01

Yeah.

SPEAKER_00

At least like major box office cinema. I agree, there is independent films out there, but they don't seem to it's all seem to be about the sequels, the big actors.

SPEAKER_01

Uh well, it's because they think that actors bring the box office, which I think to some degree is true. If it's a Johnny Deta film, you're Probably going 'cause you kind of want to see Johnny Depp's new film. Yeah. But for these unknown ones, it's great. You should watch once. It's really good.

SPEAKER_00

Oh yes. I do want to see. Has he done anything since? Do you know?

SPEAKER_01

Not a clue.

SPEAKER_00

No.

SPEAKER_01

I did see a whispering on the internet last night. I watched this very late. Yeah. And it was, was he gonna do a sequel to this? But I think they've just read it going wild. I don't think they were.

SPEAKER_00

I don't think it needs a sequel.

SPEAKER_01

No, I don't think you can.

SPEAKER_00

I think someone else should do like a sing street for a different era. Maybe not in the future, maybe not in the the noughties, but maybe in the sixties or the forties.

SPEAKER_01

The noughties would be pretty good.

SPEAKER_00

Yeah. You would have to take a different direction though. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01

Well, I loved it.

SPEAKER_00

I loved it too. And remember if you want to see your favourite film on the big screen, download the Screenwave app, pick your film, and select the location or cinema you want it to be played. That's all right. Oh yeah, I think that's good. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01

Wow. That's a lot of cutting out for you.