Coaches, Avoid This Mistake in 2026

Is your health coaching business ready for 2026?

As AI and ChatGPT make "information" free, the old model of selling education is dead. To compete, you must pivot to selling experiences.

In this episode, Valerie Feghali delivers a "State of the Industry" address for online wellness coaches. If you are still selling general meal plans or educational PDFs, you are competing with robots that work for free. Valerie breaks down the exact strategic pivot you need to make this year: moving from a "Generalist" (The Swiss Army Knife) to a "Hyper-Specific Specialist" (The Electric Screwdriver).

You’ll learn how to redefine your client avatar for the post-pandemic world, why "community" is the only product AI can't replicate, and how to structure high-ticket offers that sell themselves—even in a saturated market.

In this episode, you will learn:

• The "Experience" Pivot: Why clients are ghosting coaches for AI, and how to productize "connection" instead of content.
• Niche Strategy: The "Electric Screwdriver" analogy that proves why generalist coaches are losing money.
• Offer Architecture: How to build high-ticket packages around a single, urgent pain point (e.g., "3 AM hot flashes" vs. "hormone balance").
• The 2026 Client: Why your "Client Avatar" worksheet from 2020 is obsolete and the new questions you must ask.

🔗 Resources Mentioned

👇 START YOUR FREE TRIAL OF THE WELLNESS VAULT 👇

Stop wasting hours on content creation. Get access to our all-in-one library of white-label meal plans, recipes, and social posts designed for health coaches.

Start your 7-Day Free Trial: https://wellnessvault.com/

Connect with Valerie:

• Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/v.feghali/
• Website: https://wellnessvault.com/

⏳ Timestamped Chapters

00:00 Is Information Dead?
Valerie introduces the hard truth: in the age of AI, "education" is no longer a unique value proposition for coaches.

00:40 The AI Impact on Coaching
Why clients are turning to ChatGPT for answers and how this forces coaches to change their business model immediately.

05:04 The "Electric Screwdriver" Strategy
Valerie explains the difference between a "Swiss Army Knife" (Generalist) and an "Electric Screwdriver" (Specialist) and why you must choose a side.

09:27 Scale with The Wellness Vault
A brief look at how the Wellness Vault helps coaches automate their content creation to focus on client experience.

09:56 The "Before & After" Technique
How to articulate your value by painting a vivid picture of the client's transformation (using a wedding weight-loss example).

12:25 Structuring High-Ticket Offers
Step-by-step advice on building a coaching framework that justifies premium pricing through specific deliverables.

15:12 Experience vs. Content
Why "community" and "experience" are the only defensible moats against AI competition in 2026.

16:26 The "One Step" Rule
How to simplify your Calls to Action (CTA) so potential clients actually take the next step.

⭐ Review the Podcast

Enjoyed this episode?

If you found value in today’s conversation, please leave a 5-Star Review on Apple Podcasts! It helps us reach more coaches like you and "Fuel The Flow" of the entire industry.

Disclaimer:

The Fuel The Flow Podcast is for educational purposes only and does not constitute medical or professional business advice. Always consult with a qualified professional before making changes to your health or business strategies.

Health coach business plan, nutrition coaching tips, online business 2026, competing with AI, ChatGPT for coaches, Valerie Feghali, Wellness Vault, high ticket coaching offers, niche marketing strategy, scaling a wellness business, female entre

Transcript

SPEAKER_00 0:00

Information and education is no longer as valuable as it once was. So what we need to do is we need to think about our programs as experiences. And we need to be the obvious choice for the type of person that we want to work with. What are you bringing to the table that's different from what other people are bringing to the table? Welcome to the Fuel Your Flow podcast. I am your host, Valerie Fagali, physical therapist, turned software CEO and business coach for health and wellness coaches. We are going to be talking about all things health and business. They might be more closely related than you think. So let's go ahead and get into it. As we move into 2026, many of us are going to have to adjust the way that we are doing business. As health and wellness professionals and coaches, we are going to have to change the types of programs that we have and the way that we deliver those programs to match what's happening in our current world. AI is in full force and information is so easy to get and also to deduct in a way that we can use in a simple format such as a framework or a roadmap. And so information in education is no longer as valuable as it once was. It's much, much easier for our consumer to find and to get without our help. So what we need to do is we need to think about our programs as experiences and in a way that is more engaging and fun than looking it up on Chat GPT. Another thing that this is going to require is that we get hyper specific on both the result that we are planning to get with the program and also the type of person that that program is for. So when this person comes across your program, whether they're scrolling through social or somehow land on your sales page, that they know immediately that the program is for them. An example of this would be that I'm training for a competition and it requires running. And I get cramps in my abdomen when I run. But if I were to find a program that was specifically designed for women who are getting cramps in their abdomen when they run, I would buy into that because it solves a very hyper-specific problem that I'm dealing with currently. Now, that of course wouldn't necessarily be the end program, but that would be an easy lead-in to a higher level program that you are offering people. But in order to get people to buy in with you, to know, love, and trust you, to start to learn about your products and your offering, you need to be very hyper-specific on the front end of who it is that you are serving and the types of results that you are getting with the coaching that you provide. Experience is going to trump education or teaching every time in 2026. Using that example of a running program, I was at the gym and someone told me that they had uploaded a Chat GPT running protocol and that they're using that to train for this specific event. And yes, as we can do that, that does not mean that I'm going to stop going to the gym because the reason that I go to the gym is for the community, the accountability, the social aspect, and the experience that I am getting while I am there. So though I can get the framework or the protocol outside of the gym, I go for the experience in the community. So we need to be thinking about this when we're building out our own products and offers and slightly changing what we have offered in the past so that it creates more of that experience and potentially even that community within our programs. When we are getting clear on our who, we also need to be very, very specific. So this is who we are working with, who our products are for, who we are messaging to with all of our content. And when we get clear on that, not only does it get much easier for the potential buyer to see us as the right fit, but it also gets easier for us to create content, including social media content, sales page content, offers and programs, all the content that we create in our business for that specific person. Now think of it this way: if you needed to replace the cabinets in your kitchen, would you choose a Swiss Army knife, which does a little bit of everything, does have a mini screwdriver on it, and could potentially get the job done in a very slow and painful way? Or would you choose the electric screwdriver, right? Every time you're going to go for the electric screwdriver. Can the electric screwdriver cut a piece of string for you? No, it can't. The Swiss Army knife can, kind of, but the electric screwdriver is very good at what it does. And we need to be the obvious choice for the type of person that we want to work with. That is how we stand out in a crowded market. That is how we make ourselves known for something specific. And that is how we get buyers to see us and immediately know that we could help them. And they start to learn a little bit more about us and eventually buy into our programs or products so that we can change their life in some way. When you are able to clearly articulate who it is you work with and how it is you get them the results that they truly want, that they are really looking for, actively searching for, that is when you become the right fit and the obvious choice for people to work with you. So when you're going through your products or programs, you always want to come back to would this relate to my ideal customer? Is this something that they really truly want? Or is this something that I think that they need? We always have to create based on what it is they want. Now, yes, can we tie in and start to filter in some certain things that we maybe they don't know that they need that we, from a professional standpoint, understand would be best for them, but we're not leading with that. We're leading with their true desires, the true things that they want, the things that they think are going to help them. And that is how we start to build up their trust in order for them to come and work with us. Even if you have been in business for several years and you've done the client avatar activity and you know exactly who it is you work with, I would highly recommend doing this on a yearly basis. Now, I just met with my secondhand and we spent two hours going over our client avatar. Now, do we know who our client avatar is? Yes, of course. But that person is going to change and evolve with time. And as our products and services change and evolve, we might be working with a slightly different person. Now, even if we're working with the same exact type of person, that person is going to be in a different position now. So an example of this would be if you work with busy mothers who are career-driven that have new toddlers, that person looks very different now than they did five years ago. Five years ago, before the pandemic, before most people started working from home, things were different. And so that person was likely going to a nine to five job, was dropping their toddler off at daycare, had to be back there by a certain time. Whereas now that same exact person could be working from home, might even have their toddler home with them potentially during the day. So their challenges, their struggles are going to be very different than that same type of person five years ago. So it's so important that you go back to your client avatar and figure out in this day and age, what does this person need? What are they struggling most with? And what are their true deep down desires from the deepest level? Some questions you can ask about your client avatar to narrow in on your messaging are what keeps them up at night? What's top of mind? What do they go to bed worrying about? What are they actively searching for in Google, right? So what are they actually typing in in their words? Not in your words. You're not typing in, oh, they're worried about their hormone balance. No, they're worrying that they're waking up at 3 a.m. with hot flashes and can't go back to sleep. So in Google, they're searching how do you reduce hot flashes in the early morning, right? So what are they actually typing into the search bar and seeking advice or seeking a fix for? So those are the types of things that you really want to focus on in your messaging. You're always going to be messaging from their voice, from their words, not from your professional standpoint. Because if you start using any sort of technical terms that they may not know, then they're going to get lost. You know, you're not going to use the term estrogen dominance on your pitch or on your sales page. You're going to be talking about the symptoms that they might experience with that. So maybe they've had waking that they just can't seem to break. Maybe they can't sleep at night. Maybe they're having issues with their skin and either dry skin or acne and breakouts as an adult. Those are issues that they are facing that they can talk to you about. The symptoms are what they're experiencing in their body. And those are the things that you want to speak about when you are talking with them, either on a sales call, on your sales page, inside of a workshop trying to help them, any sort of free content that you're providing for them should be in their terminology so that they can relate and then take that and put it into action. Hey, sorry to interrupt, but if you are a health or wellness professional and you haven't yet checked out the wellness vault, you're missing out. The wellness vault is a content hub for coaches who create their own plans and programs for their clients, run workshops, create digital guides, and so much more. You can now do all of this in a fraction of the time so you can focus on your clients and grow your business faster than ever with more U time. The link to the Wellness Vall is in the show notes. So go sign up for your free trial today. One way to help people understand what it is you do is to describe their before and after. If you were to picture somebody that you work with in their before state, what do they look like, feel like, experience before they come to you? And then what do they look like, feel like, experience after they have worked with you? So contrasting those two before and after pictures in somebody's head can really help to describe what it is you do and the transformation that you provide for people. When you are explaining your products or offers, you want to make sure that the person you're explaining it to can picture themselves in that scenario. So here's two examples: one being not quite as good and the other hitting the nail on the head. So the first would be: I help women who are getting married lose weight and improve their energy so they can feel their best on their wedding day, right? We're pretty specific. We're saying that you're helping women who are engaged to get married. That's specific on who you work with. But then we get vague after that. We're improving their energy so they can feel their best. What does that really mean? So a better answer or a better statement would be: I help women who are engaged to be married lose the stubborn five to 20 pounds they have struggled to take off for confidence walking down the aisle and glowing memories years later when looking back at their wedding album. That they can picture in their head. They can picture themselves walking down the aisle and all the eyes on them. They can picture themselves flipping through their wedding album with their husband or their friend years later and having all those memories that come flooding back. And so when they can picture themselves in this situation and you're very specific. So in this case, you help women who are engaged to be married. That's very specific. And the outcome is to lose the five to ten stubborn pounds. Again, very specific on what it is you do so that somebody who's considering working with you knows immediately whether or not they want to dive in with you. Somebody who is engaged to get married and just has that like five to 20 pounds to lose immediately is going to say yes to this. Yes, I if you can promise me that or if you can work with me towards losing this five to 20 pounds, that would be incredible. And so that is how specific you need to be in your messaging in order to stand out and in order to communicate to potential buyers what it is you do. Then when it comes to the framework of your actual offer, you want to be very clear. So people do need to know who you work with, but they also need to know how you do it. So what is your method? Because people want to know, is this something that is feasible for me? Because if it's going to require, you know, 45 minutes of my day every day, then I'm out, right? Where other people might say, oh, okay, yes, 45 minutes of my day, that's feasible for what it is that we're doing here. I can commit to that. But they need to know, they need to understand, is this achievable in the timeframe that I have with the amount of effort that I'm willing to put into it? So, what is it going to take for me to get the result? So you need to overcome that objection, that question in their head before they even ask it. So you need to be very clear on what it is that you are offering. So, an example could be a three-part metabolism jumpstart kit, which would include a metabolic assessment, and you can give a time frame, you can say like a 30-minute metabolic assessment, followed by a 14-day customized meal plan with weekly or by, you know, twice a week accountability check-ins. That would be very clear on what exactly that is and the type of effort and time commitment that it's going to take to get the result. So putting time stamps on things, talking about how long or how detailed things will be, how the frequency of how often that you'll meet or how often you'll check in, that's also going to set realistic expectations. And expectations are so incredibly important when it comes to coaching. This is where a lot of coaches fall short, is that they set these big results or they promise this grand transformation, but then they don't really tell you what to expect each and every week or each and every day. And so the client might think, hey, she's going to be checking my food log and checking in with me every day. Where you're thinking, like, no, this is a once-a-week check-in via Zoom where we will go over everything. And if two people, if you and your client have those two different ideas of how the process is going to go, there is going to be disappointment. Whereas when you say, We are doing once a week check-ins, I'm going to review your food log with you during that check-in so that you can ask questions, the person automatically is prepped for that. That's what they're expecting, and that's what they're excited about. Even though it's the exact same offer as before, if they know what to expect, then they actually can get excited about it and they will know when to reach out to you. It does well for both you and your client. Another thing you want to think about when you are presenting your offers is what makes your offer different than everything else out there. And this can tie back to what we talked about in the beginning with experience. What are you bringing to the table that's different from what other people are bringing to the table? Maybe it's some sort you incorporate some sort of challenge that could be fun. Again, that's experiential learning or experiential action where people are coming in, they're doing a challenge with you, they're engaging with each other, they're engaging with the community. Those do very well right now with the way of the world. People want to be part of something bigger. They want to feel like they belong, especially because a lot of people are now working from home and they're getting a lot of their information from AI. So they don't feel like they have that human connection in a large part of their day. So if you can bring that in in some way, even in a group setting, even in an online community forum where you're not actually live as often, that can go a long way. So think about how can I bring experience into my programs? How can I make my program different than what they can find online or what they can find from another coach? What makes it unique? And then lastly, you need to know that what exactly people should do to get started and be very clear about that. On all of your content, your email newsletters, your opt-in pages, your sales pages, there should be one call to action. So one step that people can get. A lot of times coaches make the mistake of putting multiple things on there. So it might say, you know, download this free guide and or book a call, right? Those are two competing calls of action, or you would just want one on the page. The only option is to book a call. They can't download something for free, or they can't watch, you know, watch this video and then respond with a question. No, each piece of content should only have one call to action, not multiple different links, not multiple different ways that they can go, but a clear thing that you want them to do, the very clear next step. And that is how you get people to sign up with you and work with you in 2026 and also have a phenomenal 2026. I hope you enjoyed our conversation from today. Any links we discussed will be in the show notes below. Also, we would be incredibly grateful if you would leave us a five star review. This helps us keep the podcast going so that we can continue to provide value for all of you. I hope we see you on the next one.