Missing from New Milford PA: The Sara Reynolds Case

26‑year‑old Sara Reynolds of New Milford Township, Susquehanna County, PA, has been missing for 32 agonizing days. 
In this episode, host and advocate Tiff Kline breaks down the timeline, the last known moments, the surveillance footage, the witnesses who remain silent, and the unbearable reality her family wakes up to every single day.

Sara was last seen on July 2nd, 2026, near Route 492 and Interstate 81 after being dropped off by her ex‑boyfriend’s mother. She had no transportation. She never made it home. She never called. She never showed up again. And for 26 days, the only proof of her existence has been a few seconds of surveillance video.

Her family has lived through 32 days of torture, 32 days of not knowing, 32 days of pure hell.
Her five‑year‑old son cries for his mother.
Her father and loved ones beg for answers.
Witnesses stay in the shadows.
And the silence is killing them.

This episode dives into:

• Who Sara is — a mother, daughter, friend, and human being who deserves to come home.
• Her last known movements and the critical surveillance footage.
• The abuse history that shaped her life and may hold answers.
• The witnesses who have not come forward despite knowing what happened.
• The heartbreaking timeline of missed birthdays, missed milestones, and missed chances for answers.
• The desperate plea for anyone with information to speak up — anonymously if needed.

This is not just a case.
This is a family’s nightmare.
This is a child without his mother.
This is a community that must not go silent.

If you know anything about Sara’s whereabouts, please contact: 
Pennsylvania State Police – Gibson Barracks
Trooper Godino: 570‑465‑3154 
PSP Tips: 1‑800‑472‑8477

Someone knows something.  
And it’s time to do the right thing.

Transcript

SPEAKER_00 0:00

Hey guys, we're back with another episode of True Crime with Tiff Klein, giving criminals the disrespect they deserve. Tonight I'm not going to be giving disrespect to anybody unless we find out who did it or what happened. Tonight I'm featuring a missing woman, a local missing woman, um, not far from where I'm from. And she's been missing since July 2nd of 2026. Her name is Sarah Reynolds. You may be seeing a lot of flyers going on around social media about her. It's starting to take, you know, hold and it's it's becoming viral. Um I remember I, you know, I've been following this because it's in Susquehanna County. New Milford Township is where she was last seen and went missing. And um, I'm not far from there. So I've been seeing it on the news stations. I know a radio station had shared it. Um flyers are going around. Again, it's for Sarah Reynolds, but tonight, tonight's episode's not for entertainment. It's not a mystery to solve for curiosity's sake. It's a mystery to be solved, but not for entertainment. Um, it's a cry for help. It's a plea from her family living through something no one should ever have to endure. Now, I am friends with her mother on Facebook, and I also am friends with a woman whose son used to date Sarah. Um, not recently, and he has nothing to do with this, but um, so I've gotten some inside information. Not a lot, but um, I I just wanted to make a podcast because it, you know, obviously every set of ears and every set of eyes it hits is just one more person that could help find Sarah. So again, Sarah Reynolds is a 26-year-old woman from New Milford Township in Susquehanna County, Pennsylvania, and she's been missing for 32 days, July 2nd, 2026. That's from what our mom said is 32 days since her family last heard her voice, 32 days since her father and mother saw her face, 32 days of torture for them, 32 days of not knowing, 32 days of pure hell, and 32 days for a little boy waiting for his mom to come home. And somebody out there knows something. Somebody knows something. People don't just vanish, they don't just evaporate into thin air. But before we talk about timeline, surveillance footage, and some other things, Sarah, what's important right now is Sarah is 26 years old. She's a mother, she's a daughter, she's a friend. She has auburn hair with reddish tones and brown eyes. She's slim, has a nose piercing, and a gentle smile. She is a mother to a five-year-old son who cries for her. A little boy who doesn't understand why his mom isn't home. A little boy who had a birthday party 17 days ago, and his mother wasn't there. Not because she didn't want to be, not because she didn't care, because she couldn't be. Sarah is a daughter, a friend, a human being who deserves safety, love, and a chance to come home. Sarah was last seen on July 2nd, 2026. Her last known location was Route 492 near the intersection of Interstate 81 in New Milford Township, PA. Surveillance cameras did capture her. That was 26 days ago from today. Today is July 28th, 2026. So 26 days ago, she appeared on video. 26 days ago, she was dropped off by one of her ex-boyfriend's Devin mother. 26 days since witnesses saw her and chose silence. Sarah had no means for transportation. She may have been traveling on foot or gotten into a car with an unknown person or somebody that she didn't know. She was wearing gray leggings, black hey dude shoes, and a black sleeveless shirt. Again, auburn hair, about 130 pounds, slim builds, nose piercing, last scene in gray leggings, black hay dudes, and a black sleeveless shirt. So she's on camera and then she's gone. Nothing. No confirmed sightings, no calls, no lead strong enough to bring her home. And her disappearance didn't just happen in a vacuum. Friends have reported her having a history of abuse with her on and off again relationship with Devin, who I just mentioned. Um, someone who she was dating back in high school. So this goes back to high school. They, you know, on and off, on and off, but his mother is the one that dropped her off at the HO Mart. And she's gone. Her father and mother last heard her voice 32 days ago. 32 days ago is the last they saw her alive. 32 days since they felt the comfort of knowing that she was safe. And every day since has been a waking nightmare. We have to make sure that these posts don't slow down. If you see a flyer of any missing person, share it. It takes two seconds. I had somebody the other day say, Well, why share in this state if that's not where they're missing from? And I said, Because people can end up anywhere. People could be taken hostage or kidnapped and taken across state lines, and there might be a flyer hanging up in somebody's gas station or whatever it is, and recognize the missing person. I know this happened recently with a moving company. Um, noticed a little girl whose flyer was going around social media and he realized that she was missing. And he actually took the moving truck and barricaded the kidnapper and and then um they rescued her. So it's very important that you share these flyers and it takes one second. And I guarantee you, if it was somebody you loved and cared about, you'd be begging everybody to share it. What is it gonna do? What it what harm does it do? Nothing. It it helps it helps bring one person home because all it takes is one set of eyes instead of ears, guys, to recognize somebody that's missing. And every day, all day, people are missing. Anytime you see a missing person's flyer, just add it to your story. If you don't want to put it on your page, just add it to your story. Hers is going around right now. It's it's starting to really catch a buzz, but I'm gonna try my best to push it out further with the people that I know and all my podcast friends and try to raise a lot of awareness on this. But 32 days she's been gone with no trace. So she used to date this guy Devin, going back to high school, on and off, on and off, on and off. And there is a history of abuse, but his mother is the one that dropped her off at the HO Mart in Susquehanna County, which again, it's off 492 in I-81. I don't think people can go missing just randomly, evaporate in thin air. I mean, we don't live in Hogwarts. I mean, we're this is real life people. And Sarah's been missing for 32 days. And it's up to us to keep the flyers going. It's up to us to keep talking about it. It's up to us to push it out into the media. Um, we can't let this urgency fade. She has a little boy waiting for her to come home. Just like many other missing people. And if it was your family member, you'd be begging everybody to share a post. It takes one second to help save a life. So somebody saw something, somebody knows something. What that is, who that is, we have no idea. Um her parents think they have an idea, and the last person seen with her was her ex-boyfriend's mom dropping her off at the HO Mart. They don't know if maybe she continued on foot, ended up in the woods, but they said that's very, very, very unlikely. Um, or if she just continued on the road, maybe hitchhiked, or maybe met up with a friend that picked her up. Nobody knows anything. So all the possibilities are endless. So a cold case is not a closed case. And until Sarah is brought home, this is an open case. I'm not sure all the details because this is a new um missing person's case, but I do know that it's it's circulating around Pennsylvania. I think it's starting to make its way up to Binghamton, New York, which is southern New York. I wouldn't be surprised if it's starting to hit it to Jersey to hit the tri-state because she could be any, I mean, she could be anywhere across the country, but it's starting to pick up local traction, which is good. Um, but yeah, today's been 32 days since her family loss saw her, 26 days since she appeared on surveillance footage, 21 days since she was officially reported missing, 17 days since she missed her son's birthday. Every one of those days has been filled with fear, grief, and desperation. And every morning her family wakes up hoping for news. And every night they pray for a miracle, but every day they continue to get nothing. I want to speak to directly whoever is listening to my podcast. Whether you are a neighbor, a friend, a stranger, or someone who knows exactly what happened, please keep sharing. Please keep talking. And please call with any tips or leads, no matter how small they seem. It could mean the difference between life and death. And Sarah is still missing. Her son needs her home, her parents need her home, and the community needs answers. If you know something, anything, you can remain anonymous. You can message me directly, I will call it in for you. You can reach out to her parents on Facebook. You can call the police anonymously and give a tip. But please, if you know something, do the right thing. This is killing Sarah's family and it's destroying her little boy. It's tearing apart everybody who loves her. And if you know where she is, if you know what happened, if you saw something, if you heard something, call. If you have any information about Sarah's whereabouts, contact the Pennsylvania State Police, the Gibson Barracks. Trooper Godino 570 465 3154. Again, that's the Pennsylvania State Police Gibson Barracks. Trooper Godino. That's G-O-D-I-N-O-570-465-3154. And for any Pennsylvania State Police tips, call 1-800-472-8477. Again, that's the Pennsylvania State Police Tip Line. 1-800-472-8477. Again, you can remain anonymous. You can protect your identity, but if you saw something, say something. It could save Sarah's life. It could bring Sarah home. How would you feel if your sister, daughter, or friend in 32 days had absolutely no trace, no leads, nothing? And all you could do was depend on the person who knows something and depend on the people on social media to get the flyer out there so everybody sees it. That's a lot of work, my friends. It's a lot of work for one person, especially somebody that has no idea where their daughter is. So I'm begging you, when you see her flyer or anybody else's missing person's flyer in your feed, share it to your story, share it to your feed. It takes one second to hopefully save a life. I mean, what, why? I and I like that's a question I always have. Like, why do people not share them? Do because you don't want to mess up your algorithm? Well, you know what? Somebody wants their kid home. So how about you stop being selfish, share the freaking post, and maybe try to help save a life for once? But you know, it's it's a share. You can put it in your story, you can put it on Snapchat, Instagram, Facebook, TikTok, whatever platform you use, put it in your stories. Send it to a friend. Do something. Try to save a life. Don't just keep scrolling and only reacting to stupid shit that doesn't serve a purpose and stuff that does nothing for the world or humanity or society. You know, instead of posting 10 stupid memes every day, why don't you take one of those posts and make it a missing person's flyer? Because you never know who's going to see it, or see it and know something, or even see it and say, I think I saw that girl. Somebody has the answers. But we need the power of the people. So I'm asking you if you see the flyer for Sarah Reynolds or any other missing person, please, for the love of you, for the life of you, for the life of somebody who is missing, share the post. Share the flyer, share the TikTok, share the reel. Just share it. Because if it was your loved one, you would be begging people to share it, to bring your loved one home. Again, Sarah is 26 years old. She went missing July 2nd, 2026, on a normal summer day in Susquehanna County. The kind of day where people run errands, grab gas, stop for snacks, head to work, visit family in a day that should end like any other, but instead, Sarah Reynolds went missing. She was dropped off at the nearest intersection of Route 492 and Interstate 81 in New Milford Township. Dropped off by Devin's mother, which was her ex-boyfriend that she had an on-and-off relationship with. His mother was the last person confirmed to have seen her. So the location matters because it's rural. And I grew up in a rural area. So I understand rural and I know what it means to be out in the middle of nowhere, where you can see every star in the sky, you can hear every animal in the woods, and it's rare when you see a car drive by. It's isolated where she went missing. Okay. It's a place where people pass through quickly, where cameras catch glimpses, but not answers, and where someone could disappear without anyone noticing. Okay. And this is exactly what happened to Sarah. She literally vanished, but she didn't. People don't just evaporate. So she either went on foot to continue on her journeys and got lost or something happened to her, or she got in the car with somebody, either somebody she knew, or somebody she didn't, but she did not just evaporate. Something happened to her when she got to that HO mark off Route 492 and I-81 after her ex-boyfriend's mother dropped her off. And the surveillance cameras caught it, and it was the last she was ever seen. You don't just disappear, people. So she'd walked away from the drop-off point and then just vanished. So the cameras caught her, but didn't catch enough, or the direction possibly she was going. I'm not positive. I don't have that information. But I'm gonna try to talk to her mom more. But so she's seen on surveillance, being dropped off at the HO mark. But after that, there's no sign of her getting in someone's car, someone taking her. I mean, it's just gone. And it's reduced to a few seconds of grainy video. Like it's not even like a minute or two. And it's a moment frozen in time, and the world is moving, and we need to find her. And we don't know what happened to her after she was dropped off at the HO Mart by her ex's mom. We don't know who she encountered. We don't know if she was scared. We don't know if she was alone. We don't know if she was hurt, but we do know that someone saw something, someone heard something, and someone knows something. There has to be a witness. Somewhere, somehow, somewhere reason, there had to have been a witness on something. People who saw her, people who know she didn't just walk away into thin air, because ladies and gentlemen, again, we don't live at Hogwarts. This is this is real life. But these people that know something are hiding and remaining in the shadows, and they remain quiet and they remain cowards. While her five-year-old son cries for his mother, while her father and mother wake up every day hoping for a miracle, they hang on by threads, desperate for a clue. And the silence, I guarantee you, is torture. It's cruel, it's inhumane, and it's not fair. I didn't know Sarah personally, but again, I have a friend who did. And what I could tell from the flyers, she looked like a very soft spoken, generous, gentle, genuine person, and just warm. Her life, like I said, her friends did say that she was in a relationship that had a history of abuse on and off with this guy, Devin. Um, she struggled. She fought through things most people never see. Um, I can't confirm if there was drug use. I can't confirm if there was anything. All I know is that the friends did confirm there was a history of abuse. Um, and then that relationship she had with Devin was on and off for years. So clearly it was a toxic cycle. And I'm a survivor, so I can speak on that because I know what that's like to be trauma bonded to somebody. Um this the cycle of abuse started with her and Devin while she was in high school and it never truly ended. Now, I don't know if that's physical abuse. I don't know if that's mental or emotional, sexual, financial. Abuse is abuse, and you can call it whatever you want, but it's all abuse. So when I say there was a history of abuse, I don't know the fact if it was physical, mental, or emotional. Either way, it was abusive. But Sarah was trying to pick up the pieces. Sarah was trying to move forward with her life. She was building a better life for her and her son, and she was trying to be a good mother and break free from things that hurt her. She loved her son more than anything in this world. He was her world, her reason, her anchor. She would never, she would never willingly leave her son. She would never disappear on her own, and she would never miss her son's birthday. Not in a million years would she miss her son's birthday. And that's how her family knows something terrible has happened. 32 days her parents have woken up with a pit in their stomach. It's like checking your phone every five minutes for news that never comes. It's like praying until your voice cracks. It's like begging strangers for help. It feels like screaming into a void that never answers. And I'm sure it feels like hell. Her parents and her son are going through a daily cycle of hope and heartbreak and a nightly battle of exhaustion and fear. And every hour is a reminder that she is still not home. Her father is breaking, her family is breaking, her son is breaking, her mother is breaking, and the community is hoping and waiting and begging and pleading and trying to help their family find answers on what happened to Sarah on July 2nd, 2026, at the HO Mart off Route 492 and I-81 in New Milford Township in Susquehanna County. So again, if this was somebody you loved, somebody you cared about, you'd be begging people to share this missing flyer. Sarah didn't just vanish. Someone saw something, someone heard something, someone knows something, and they're choosing to stay silent. Sarah would not willingly leave her son behind. She would not just disappear on her own and not tell somebody. You know, since this started, I I have been seeing Sarah's flyers go around Facebook, which is wonderful. And today I saw one of the local radio stations posted on Facebook and a lot of the news, and that's what it's about. And this should happen for every single person who goes missing. There's no rhyme or reason why certain cases get picked over others to get highlighted, right? Um, and it's a lot of it is the the media and the power behind the people. And um, you know, I I know Joe Petito, father of Gabby Petito, who's life was taken in 2021 while traveling across country with her fiance in a van. Her father even said, you know, he's trying to make sure every missing person gets the same amount of coverage his daughter did. And he said, that's on the media. That's their fault because they pick something and they run with it. It's not their fault that their daughter's case went, you know, viral. It's the it's the people behind the media and it's the people behind social media meaning us. We have the power to make things go viral. But if you're not sharing posts or reels or liking them or commenting to boost engagement, you're not doing anything helpful. You scrolling by is doing absolutely nothing when it could take one second to throw a comment, to share a post, to share a flyer, to share a reel, to like something just to boost its algorithm so more people see it, guys. It's two seconds of your day. And we can't let these shares slow down. We cannot let these posts get fewer reactions because Sarah is still missing and her son is still crying for her, and her family is waking up every single day in agony. Why does the world go silent when a family is screaming? Why do people stop sharing when sharing could save a life? Why do people look away when a mother is missing? I don't have those answers, but I wish I did, because these are questions I ask myself all the time. So here's my plea. Again, louder, clearer, and more desperate. Please keep sharing. Please keep talking. Please keep asking questions. Please keep Sarah's name alive. If you know something, anything, please call. You can remain anonymous, you can protect your identity, you can message me directly, or her family, or somebody who can call it in for you. Your name never has to be mentioned. You can call into the police anonymously, but your information could save a life. If you have any information again about Sarah's whereabouts, no matter how small it may seem, even if you're wrong, it's you're trying. I I would rather people call in things, even if they're not sure, because it's possible. It's a possible lead. It's better than nothing. So if you know anything, call the Pennsylvania State Police, the Gibson Barracks. Trooper Godino 570-465-3154. Again, that's the Pennsylvania State Police, the Gibson Barracks. Trooper Godino, G-O-D-I-N-O-570-465-3154. And you can call in the Pennsylvania State Police Tip Line, 1-800-472-8477. Again, that's the Pennsylvania State Police Tip line. 1-800-472-8477. Please try to help save Sarah. Please try to bring Sarah home. And please, please let her parents get some answers. You are holding information that could save a child from growing up without his mother. You are holding information that could give a family peace. You are holding information that could end this torture. If this was your loved one, if this was your child, if this was your sister, and this was your mother, you would want someone to come forward. Do the right thing. Do the human thing. Do the decent thing and tell someone where she is. Please. I'm begging you. Her parents are begging you. Her son is begging you. Sarah Reynolds is still missing. It is a cold case, not a closed case. Her story is not over. Her family's not giving up. Her son's not giving up. And you know what? This community is not giving up. But we need your help to bring Sarah home. This has been True Crime with Tiff Klein, giving criminals the disrespect they deserve. Tonight we're not giving that disrespect. I'm I'm asking you to help raise awareness to bring home Sarah Reynolds. Stay tuned. I will make episode updates as it comes. And in the meantime, you can follow True Crime with Tiff Klein on TikTok, Snapchat, Instagram, Facebook, and my newest podcast, Turning the Corner, starts with a K on TikTok, Snapchat, Facebook, and Instagram. Um and I'm streaming on Apple, Amazon, YouTube, iHeart, and Spotify. And if you want more information on Sarah Reynolds, her mom goes by Naomi Reynolds on Facebook. But all you have to do is type in Sarah Reynolds, S-A-R-A Reynolds, R-E-Y-N-O-L-D-S, and put in Pennsylvania, and you're probably gonna see her come up. Again, she has auburn hair, brown eyes, nose piercing, a warm smile, but 130 pounds. Last seen wearing a black sleeveless shirt, gray leggings, and black hay dudes. Last seen July 2nd, 2026, at the H.O. Mart off 492 and I-81 in New Milford Township, Pennsylvania. Thank you for tuning in. Please share her flyer. Even if you just have to go to my Facebook page, it's posted True Crime with TIFF Klein. Um, you'll see it. I made a TikTok as well that I made into a reel. Please share it. Let's let's try to get some answers and bring Sarah home.