Your Money. Your Move. with Holly Wallis | Money Confidence for High-Achieving Women

Spending More Than You Earn, Even With a Good Income

• Holly Wallis | Personal Finance & Profitability Coach • Season 1 • Episode 3

Share episode

Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.

0:00 | 17:08

Why solid-earners still feel financial pressure and how overspending patterns develop. 

Spending more than you earn rarely comes from one big pricey decision. It usually builds through small choices shaped by psychology, pressure, and expectations you did not consciously choose.

In this episode of Your Money, Your Move, Holly breaks down four powerful forces that quietly push spending beyond income, including present bias, identity and status, success rewards, and invisible social expectations. Through real stories and behavioral insights, she shows why willpower is not the issue and why more discipline is not the solution.

This conversation helps you recognize the moment when spending shifts from intentional to reactive. Holly shares a simple pause that turns impulse into information, and gives you back choice without cutting yourself off from enjoyment.

This episode is for high-achieving women who want spending decisions to feel grounded, intentional, and aligned with what actually matters.

Next steps:
Download the free guide 3 Easy Steps To Look At Your Money (even when you’d rather not) to build awareness and confidence using the same foundation Holly teaches her private coaching clients.

FREE GUIDE: 3 Easy Steps To Look At Your Money (even when you'd rather not)

When you want deeper support and a money system designed for your real life, learn more about working with me one-on-one at HollyWallisCoaching.com

Join my list, sign up here!


Additional Resource Links:

Welcome & Year-End Money Pressure

Holly

Welcome to Your Money, Your Move, the podcast for women who want more from their money. Here, money is made simple, practical, and actually doable for your life. You'll get a straightforward way to work with your money so you can see your finances clearly, enjoy life now, and feel secure about tomorrow. I'm your host and personal finance and profitability coach, Holly Wallis. Here we are in the final sprint to the end of the year again.

What Overspending Really Looks Like

Holly

I feel like I was just here in 2024 yesterday. You know, maybe there is something to this thing about time speeding up as you get older. I always notice that at this time of the year, every year, expenses seem to creep up a little higher. I feel like we just come out of summer holidays and immediately start planning for more of them at the end of the year. And I don't know about you, but at this time of year, I really crave outdoor time before it gets too cold here in California. So I am constantly looking for a patio to enjoy, a great dinner, or a long Sunday brunch. It all adds up fast, especially when we're having fun. And if I don't pay attention, before I even realize it, I've spent way more than I brought in for the month.

Beyond Willpower: Why We Spend

Holly

That's exactly what spending beyond your income feels like. It rarely happens all at once. It creeps in little by little. A dinner here, a vacation booked on credit, an extra swipe of the card because payday is just around the corner. It feels totally manageable when we just think about it one transaction at a time. It even feels temporary. You tell yourself you'll pay it off as soon as you get paid. Then one day you notice the balance isn't shrinking. It just keeps growing.

Holly

This episode is about noticing when you've slipped into spending more than you earn and how to shift before you feel like you're constantly running to catch up. But I'm not just going to tell you all the ways that money is slipping through your fingers. We've already talked about money blind spots in my previous episode, 'The hidden cost of money blind spots', and I'll put that link in the show notes here so you can have a listen.

Story 1: Status and Identity

Holly

If it were so easy, I would just say, stop spending more than you make. You would say, okay, and off we go. But it's not that easy. And unless we understand why we think, feel, and act the way we do around spending, changing our patterns is really hard.

Holly

So instead, I want to talk about four interesting ways psychology and sociology influence our spending in ways you may not have considered before. And then I'll give you an easy action plan to look at your personal spending patterns.

Holly

I want you to imagine this for a moment. You're out for dinner with friends, the bill comes, and you immediately drop your card without a second thought and insist this one's on me. I've done this myself. And at the time, it doesn't feel reckless. It's just dinner. It's totally normal to want to do something nice for the people that you care about.

Holly

And that's the thing. Spending more than we earn doesn't often happen in big, dramatic moments. We usually think that overspending looks like those crazy images we see on social media of walking into a room in your floor-length fur coat, dripping in diamonds with money guns on full blast. And while that would also be fun, the reality is that spending more than we make more often looks like just another boring day, shaped by a bunch of psychological and social expectations.

Holly

It's not just about the dollar bills, it's about how we see ourselves, the messages we've absorbed, and what it means to succeed, and the unspoken rules of belonging in our communities. Let me share four stories that show how psychology and sociology sneak into everyday spending. Notice if any of these sound familiar for you. I know they do for me.

Holly

1) I had a client once tell me, Holly, when I bought that outfit, it wasn't really about the clothes at all. It was about walking into a room and feeling like I belonged there. She could afford nice clothes, but this big designer purchase tipped her budget over the edge. The purchase wasn't about practicality. It was about status and identity, the first psychosocial expectation that influences our spending.

Story 2: Present Bias Explained

Holly

And we do it all the time to signal who we are or how we want to be seen. It's not just clothes. It might be a car, the ticket to the right event, the reservation at the new it restaurant, living in the right neighborhood, or the latest phone or device.

Holly

2) For our next example, the other day I overheard a woman talking about scrolling online the night before when she saw a huge sale and she said, "it was like it read my mind. After the day I had, I deserve it". She told her friend that she knew she was supposed to be paying off her credit card, but she just wanted that quick hit of happiness. She described it perfectly when she said, "it felt like the real me had nothing to do with it, like she was someone else's problem".

Holly

And that one I've heard before. The idea that it's not real if you don't pay too close attention to it. That's called present bias. Our brains are wired to give more weight to the present than to the future, even if the future cost is much greater. The present is certain. The future just doesn't seem real.

Holly

Research on behavioral economics, like the marshmallow test, has found that people will often choose a smaller reward today than a larger reward in the future. Like the children who were offered one marshmallow now or two if they waited. Of course, most chose the immediate reward of marshmallow and tummy.

Story 3: The Success Paradox

Holly

3) Now for my next story. She had just wrapped up a huge project at work that had taken months of long hours and late nights. When it was finally over, she decided I deserve something nice for all that hard work. So on her way home, she stopped at her favorite store and went on a little shopping spree. Was that a bad decision? No, not at all. She has the money. But she said that when she got home, there was an immediate feeling of what else could I have done with all that money? This is where the success paradox comes in.

Holly

It's almost like there are two voices in the room. One voice says, you did it, treat yourself, you've earned this. The other says, remember you're saving for that trip you dreamed of, that down payment on a house, or retirement that's getting closer and closer every day. Both voices are valid and they both come from a good place.

Holly

Recognizing the success paradox isn't about feeding into that buyer's remorse guilty feeling. It's about seeing how our brain links hard work with immediate reward. So then we can choose when we want that quick gratification and when we want to hold out for the bigger, longer lasting reward. Hmm, back to the marshmallow.

Story 4: Invisible Social Contracts

Holly

4) And that brings us to our last story. About six years ago, I was invited to a conference that I really had no interest in attending. It was a week-long trip in a very pricey hotel with dinners every night and countless group events. All that cost a lot. And I didn't even want to go. But I knew that some heavy hitters in the industry were going to be there. I would get to be in the room with them and they would know my name. I was already getting texts from colleagues saying, you have to go! And the FOMO was at 100. For some reason, I was willing to pay thousands of dollars for something I didn't even want to do, just to say that I was there too. This is a perfect example of what's called invisible social contracts.

Holly

An invisible social contract is the unspoken agreement we believe exists between ourselves and the social groups we belong to, our friends, family, colleagues in the community. It's not written down, no one signs it, and most of the time it's never directly talked about. But the expectation feels very real.

Holly

Invisible contracts sound like this. If all of my friends are buying nice homes in the ideal neighborhood, I should buy there too. If everyone else is splitting the bill equally at dinner, I should too, even though I just had a salad and water. If all of my family is going to the reunion in Hawaii, I should go too, even though I can't afford it.

Holly

So many shoulds in there. The expectation is that belonging, acceptance, and respect mean keeping up. We think that if we don't follow the unwritten rules, we'll stand out in a way we don't want, look like we don't belong, or risk being judged.

Holly

The thing is, people around us aren't really thinking about what we're spending at all. They're too busy thinking about whether they're keeping up. And that's why the invisible social contract is so powerful, because it plays on our strong human need for connection and belonging.

Why Awareness Beats Guilt

Holly

Sociologists like Robert Merton have shown that our spending isn't just about what we need. It's influenced heavily by the people we measure ourselves against. If everyone in your circle is upgrading their home, their car, or their vacations, it suddenly feels natural to do the same. It's not about actually wanting the material thing or fancy event at all. It's about staying aligned with the group we compare ourselves to.

Holly

I'm not sure who said it, but I love this quote: "Keeping up with the Joneses is the world's longest and most expensive marathon. And nobody actually knows who the Joneses are".

Holly

In the end, spending more than we have is fundamentally about basic human needs. And once you can see it through that lens, you can step out of guilt and shame and into awareness. You have the chance to ask yourself, what do I need at this moment that I am trying to get from this thing I'm about to spend my money on?

Holly

So why does it even matter if we understand how these psychosocial factors influence our spending? Well, when we don't recognize these forces at play in our spending, it's easy to believe the problem is just about willpower or discipline, and that leaves us feeling ashamed and guilty, like something is wrong with us.

Holly

The truth is, without awareness, we get swept along by invisible pressures, things like present bias, the success paradox, social contracts, and our reference groups. And those forces can quietly chip away at our savings, keep us in cycles of debt, or make our bigger financial goals feel further and further away. Over time, not seeing what's driving our behavior can even erode our sense of control, leaving us feeling like our money is running us instead of the other way around.

A Simple Technique

Holly

Here's the real shift. Spending more than you earn isn't about discipline at all. It's about being human. Once you see that, the guilt lifts and you step into choice.

Holly

So now that we know what do we get from that? Well, that's a million-dollar question, isn't it? When we start to understand what's really behind our decisions, something shifts. We stop labeling our spending as good or bad and start seeing it as just normal. That alone can be a huge relief. Then we have the power to pause. Instead of plugging along on auto, we are in the driver's seat and we get to make all the decisions.

Holly

So by naming the factors, we reclaim our power of choice. We can say to ourselves, oh, this is present bias talking. Do I actually want to buy this now, or would I rather hold on to that cash? That's where confidence grows because we move from simply reacting with our money to responding with intention. And that's the moment when we feel like our money is working for us instead of against us.

Free Guide

Holly

So now that you know that your brain is the key player in your spending decisions, I want to make sure that you have one easy thing that you can do right now to notice those nudges in real time. So you get to choose whether to follow it or shift it.

Holly

Now, you know that your gut instinct is gonna be to cut up your credit cards or force yourself onto a stricter budget. Go big or go home. But you also know that there is no way that that is sustainable for your real life. And you've already learned that all the psychosocial factors that influence our spending is just human wiring.

Holly

Instead, one simple step is all it takes to start to make a noticeable shift. Pause and ask yourself any of these three questions:

Holly

What am I giving up if I buy this now?

Holly

What else could this money do for me?

Holly

What need am I really trying to meet? And is there another way?

Holly

You don't have to change or stop the purchase unless you choose to. It's your money, your move.

Holly

And if there's one thing you take from this episode, I want it to be this. Awareness is what creates the opportunity for choice. That pause, that space is where your power lives.

Closing Remarks

Holly

To help you build that awareness so you have the chance to realize all the choices you have with your money, I've put together a free guide with all the steps you'll need to get started. Go to the link in the show notes and download three easy steps to look at your money even when you'd rather not. My favorite part about this guide is that it helps you identify all the factors that keep you from looking at your money. That's where the awareness is really created. And it gives you really easy to implement steps to break the avoidance loop for good. So go to the link in the show notes and grab your copy.

Holly

So today we explored spending through a different lens, not as a math problem, but as a human condition. Through real life stories, we saw how purchases can become signals of status and identity, how our brain leans towards the quick win of immediate gratification, how success can paradoxically lean to overspending, and how invisible social contracts quietly shape our choices. When we bring these influences into the light, we stop seeing them as personal flaws and start understanding them as part of life. And that's where real choice begins.

Holly

Remember, it's not just about moving your money, it's about choosing what move is right for you.

Holly

And that's today's episode. I hope you found a little something that you can take with you and try out on your own. Let me know how you're enjoying this podcast, and if you're new here, make sure you hit the subscribe button so that you'll get past and future episodes right on your feed. Also, if you enjoy my content, make sure you give me a rating. I read every testimonial and comment personally, and I love to interact with all of you. Keep listening to upcoming episodes because we've got more conversations ahead to help you make big money moves in your life. And with that, I'm Holly Wallis, personal finance and profitability coach, and this has been Your Money, Your Move. Talk to you on the next episode.

Head Shot

Holly Wallis

Host