253 - Done With Diets but Still Overeating? How to Break the Cycle

You’ve done the diets. You know the rules. You can list calories and carb counts in your sleep. But somehow, you still find yourself standing in front of the pantry at 10:30 pm, finishing the bag of pretzels and asking, “What is wrong with me? I know better than this.”

In this episode we’re talking about what’s really going on when you’re done with dieting… but still overeating. We’ll look at why all the plans, macros, and rules haven’t fixed this pattern, and why your late-night snacks, weekend overeats, and “village-sized” takeout orders aren’t actually proof that you’re broken—they’re clues.

You’ll learn how to recognize the moment you’re truly ready to stop overeating (it’s not just “I hate my body, I need to lose weight”), and we’ll unpack the three quiet thoughts that keep smart, high-achieving women stuck: “I should be able to do this on my own,” “It’s selfish to spend money on me,” and “What if it doesn’t work?”

If you’re tired of waking up with food regret, feeling like you “blew it” again, and wondering if you’ll still be doing this at 65 or 70, this episode will help you see your overeating in a new light—and show you the first small step out of the cycle.

The Listener Takeaway: Why This Episode Matters

This episode matters because most midlife women secretly believe they should have “figured this out” by now. They’re juggling careers, caregiving, relationships, and aging bodies—yet they still feel out of control around the snack drawer. That disconnect creates a painful story: “If I can’t handle food, what does that say about me?” By the end of this conversation, you’ll understand that your overeating is not proof that you’re broken. It’s a learned response to a life that has demanded too much of you for too long.

When you shift from blame to understanding, everything changes. Instead of measuring success by perfection—never overeating again—you start measuring it by self-trust: fewer episodes, less intensity, less shame, and faster recovery when it does happen. You’ll walk away with a clearer picture of the future you want—one where your 65- or 70-year-old self is not still going to bed angry about what she ate—and a concrete, doable first step to start becoming that woman today.

WHAT YOU’LL LEARN

• Why you still overeat even though you “know what to do” (and why it’s not about willpower)
• The 3 quiet thoughts

Free Quiz: Still saying "I know what to do, I just don't do it"?  You don't need more information. You need to know why you're not applying the information you already have. This free quiz identifies the exact reason your healthy habits keep breaking down, and it's not willpower. 15 questions. 3 minutes or less. 4 possible patterns. 1 honest answer. 

Go to https://elizabethsherman.com/quiz

If you’re a woman in midlife who wants better health without obsessing over weight, you’re in the right place. I’m Elizabeth Sherman, a life and health coach and host of the Total Health in Midlife Podcast.

After coaching hundreds of women, I know the real problem usually isn’t “not enough information” – it’s too much of it, and not knowing where to start. With close to 300 episodes, this show can feel that way too.

To make it easy, I created a free Listener’s Roadmap that helps you figure out which episodes are right for you right now. Tell me what you’re struggling with – low energy, emotional eating, stress, sleep, exercise, or all of the above – and I’ll point you to a curated path of episodes and resources to get you moving.

Download your free roadmap at https://elizabethsherman.com/roadmap.