The Crisis of Borrowed Faith

The Crisis of Borrowed Faith

Are you navigating your life with someone else's map? In this episode, Pedro Garcia explores one of the most terrifying milestones in a person's spiritual journey: the moment you realize your faith isn't actually yours. Whether it was handed down by parents, a youth pastor, or a tradition, "borrowed faith" often works—until the storm hits and the map no longer matches the terrain.

In this episode, we dive into:

• The Psychology of Offloading: Why our brains are biologically hardwired to "download" the beliefs of our caregivers for survival and efficiency.
• The "Imposter" Burden: Understanding the emotional exhaustion of wearing "someone else’s armor" and why feeling empty in your faith isn't a sign of failure, but of growth.
• From Testimony to Encounter: Looking at the Samaritans in John 4 to see how Jesus invites us to move past "believing because of what others said" into knowing Him for ourselves.

If your inherited beliefs are breaking down, don't panic. This isn't the end of your faith—it’s the beginning of an owned one.

The Challenge: Identify one habit or belief you maintain only because you were taught to. Bring it to Jesus this week and ask: "Is this You, or just something I inherited?"

Connect with me:

Email me: isitbecauseofjesus@gmail.com

Buy the book.

Website: isitbecauseofjesus.com

Support the show on Patreon.

If you found this episode helpful, please rate the show, leave a comment, or share it with a friend who is wrestling with doubt. For more resources, visit the links in the show notes.

Transcript

SPEAKER_00 0:16

Hey, welcome to Is It Because of Jesus. I'm your host, Pedro Garcia. Before we start today, I'd like to ask you for a favor. If you like this show, it would be great if you can rate us on your podcast feed or even leave a comment or share it with a friend. That always helps tons. If you have a friend that is doubting, Christians who have doubts, they don't have anyone to talk to, that's a friend to share it with, or if you like the podcast, as I said, you can you can help us by doing those things. But hey, welcome to episode three. Today we're gonna talk about the concept of borrowed faith. So imagine this you are driving in the middle of the night through a terrible storm. The road is getting rough, the visibility is zero, and you hit a dead end that shouldn't be there. You panic, you reach into the glove box and pull out the map you have had your entire life. It's the map your parents gave you. It's got their highlights, their notes in the margins, the safe routes all clearly marked. So you trace your finger along the paper, but there is a terrifying problem. The map doesn't match the terrain outside your window. The map says there should be a bridge here. You are staring at a washout. And in that moment the elephant in the room finally makes itself known. This isn't your map. You didn't draw it. You've just been blindly following it. We hear these moments in life a devastating loss, a moral dilemma, a profound season of doubt where the answers we were handed in Sunday school suddenly feel painfully inadequate. We realize that we don't actually have a relationship with God. We have a relationship with our parents' relationship with God. Or our youth pastors' relationship with God, or many other options. So today we're going to talk about the crisis of borrowed faith. We often mistake knowing about God from others for actually knowing God ourselves. We think that carrying our parents' map makes us safe travelers. I want to tell you right now, this episode isn't about tossing out everything you were taught. It's about the terrifying yet necessary realization that a borrowed faith will eventually break down. And more importantly, I want to show you why that breakdown is actually the beginning of real faith. So let's talk about the psychology of all of this, okay? Let's start with the brain. Why do we borrow our faith in the first place? Why does it feel so catastrophic when we realize it's borrowed? So in psychology, there is a concept called cognitive offloading. The human brain loves efficiency, it burns a lot of calories, trying to figure out the universe, the meaning of life, and what happens after we die. Building a worldview from scratch is exhausting. So our brains do something very clever. They offload the work. We rely on the expertise of authority figures to save mental energy. It is infinitely easier to download a preset playlist of beliefs than to curate your own. But it goes deeper than just being mentally efficient. It's about survival. Let's see, if we look at attachment theory, we see that as children, we're biologically hardwired to adopt our caregivers' beliefs. Your parents are your source of food, shelter, and love. To a child's brain, maintaining a secure bond with the people keeping you alive is the prime directive. Subconsciously, disagreeing with your caregivers feels like risking abandonment. If you reject their worldview, your brain tells you that you might get left out in the cold. So you grow up, you leave the house, but you keep the map. Then the crisis of individuation hits. Adult experiences clash with your childhood answers. You pray for someone to be healed and they die. You do all the right Christian things, and your life still falls apart. When this happens, your brain panics. You are not just losing a theological belief. You're losing the psychological safety net your caregivers built for you. Your alarm bells are ringing because you are stepping outside the protective walls of the tribe. So I need you to hear this. That feeling of being utterly lost and terrified, that isn't a sign you are losing your salvation. That is the psychological growing pain of individuation. It is simply your brain waking up to the fact that it has to start navigating for itself. So let's move from the brain down to the heart because intellectually understanding why we borrow faith doesn't make the emotional reality any less painful. The emotional core of borrowed faith is a profound sense of spiritual emptiness. It's waking up one day and feeling like an absolute imposter in your own Christian faith. You know the drill. You know exactly when to raise your hands during the worship sets. You know the Christian jargon, you know how to say, you know, we're protected, we're doing life together. You know when to bow your head, but internally, internally it feels like a performance. You're wearing someone else's armor and it doesn't fit. It's heavy, it's clunky, and you cannot move in it. There is a deep hidden grief in this realization. There is a profound sadness when you look at the map, you trust it your whole life, and realize it cannot cover your current storm. You might feel angry at the people who handed it to you, feeling like they didn't prepare you for the real world or worse. You might feel an intense, crushing guilt. You feel ungrateful, your grandma prayed over that Bible, your dad gave his life to that church, and here you are, feeling absolutely nothing. So I want to ask you a difficult question. I want you to really sit with it. Are you clinging to your current beliefs because you have experienced them to be deeply undeniably true? Or are you clinging to them because it's the only hand me down sweater you have out here in the cold? A borrowed faith cannot sustain a personal crisis. It just cannot. You cannot truly love Jesus if you are only dating him to make your parents happy. The breakdown of your inherited faith isn't the end of your spiritual journey. It is the mandatory, painful first step to an owned faith. Okay, so where is Jesus in all of this? Does Jesus want us to just blindly accept what the previous generation said about him forever? Does he want you to just shut up, put the hand me down sweater back on and pretend you aren't freezing? Okay, so let's look at the book of John, chapter four, the story of the Samaritans in Sikar. I hope I'm pronouncing this well, Sichar Sikar. Jesus meets a Samaritan woman at the well. Now we know where we are. They have this incredible, life altering conversation. She's so blown away that she leaves her water jar, runs back to her town, and tells everyone, Hey, come see a man who told me everything I ever did. Could this be the Messiah? Now look at what happens next. John 4 39 says, Many of the Samaritans from that town believed in him because of the woman's testimony. Okay, this is phase one. This is borrowed faith. They believed because someone else told them it was true. And honestly, that is a perfectly fine place to start. Most of us start here, by the way. We start with our parents' testimony, or our pastor's testimony, or someone we love's testimony, but it doesn't end there. The story continues. The Samaritans go out to Jesus and they ask him to stay with them, and he does. He stays for two whole days. They spend direct and filter time with him. And then comes the transition. Phase two, own faith. Look at John 4 42. They turn to the woman and they say, We no longer believe just because of what you said. Now we have heard for ourselves, and we know that this man really is the savior of the world. Do you do you see the pivot? That reminds me of their friend's uh episode with the pivot. But do you see it? Jesus actually invites the transition. He doesn't want you to he doesn't want you living off your mom's testimony or your favorite pastor's podcast forever. He isn't threatened by you setting down your parents' map. Jesus is not standing there demanding you blindly trust the brochure. He's inviting you to take the trip. He wants to be known firsthand. So if you're terrified right now that questioning your inherited beliefs will leave you with absolutely nothing, I want you to look at Jesus standing right there in the wreckage of your borrowed faith, invites inviting you to stay with him to see for yourself. Waking up to the reality of a borrowed faith is terrifying. Psychologically it triggers all our survival alarms. Emotionally, it makes us feel like lonely imposters. But spiritually, spiritually, it is the exact moment Jesus invites you out of the safety of the crowd and into a first hand encounter with him. I have a challenge for you this week. I want you to identify just one core belief or one Christian habit that you maintain only because you were taught to. Not because you have experienced its truth, but just because it was on the map you were handed. Take that one thing, hold it up, and pray a very honest and a very scary prayer. Say, Jesus, I want to know if this is you or just something I inherited. Show me for myself. Hey my friend, thank you so much for joining me today. And remember, if you're a Christian who is doubting and deconstructing, really make sure to ask yourself the ultimate question Is it because of Jesus?