The Fear of Relational Rupture

Have you ever sat in your small group, nodding along to something you disagree with because you're terrified of losing your friends?

In this episode, Pedro tackles the "Fear of Relational Rupture." Instead of blaming the church for our silence, we look in the mirror to explore why we often "pre-reject" ourselves out of fear. We break down the heavy toll of hiding your doubts and explore how Jesus meets us in the dark—just like He did with Nicodemus—while gently inviting us to step into the light.

What we cover:

• The Science of Fear: Why our brains process the threat of social rejection exactly like physical pain.
• The Cost of Hiding: The exhausting emotional weight of Sunday morning imposter syndrome.
• Grace in the Mess: How Jesus handles our worldview-shattering questions without intimidation.

This Week's Challenge: Step out of hiding. Find one safe person who loves you and Jesus, and share just one question you've been keeping to yourself.

Connect with me:

Email me: isitbecauseofjesus@gmail.com

Buy the book.

Website: isitbecauseofjesus.com

Support the show on Patreon.

If you found this episode helpful, please rate the show, leave a comment, or share it with a friend who is wrestling with doubt. For more resources, visit the links in the show notes.

Transcript

SPEAKER_00 0:16

Hi everyone. This is Pedro, and I'm very excited to dive in into another episode of Is It Because of Jesus? As you know, we're here to help uh Christians who are doubting and deconstructing to really know what's happening with them at the psychological, emotional, and Jesus level of the conversation. So thank you for being here. Remember that if you share this podcast with everyone that needs it, that would help tons. And also, you can write a comment and you can do whatever you want. It would help us a lot, you know, it will help me a lot to help uh others. So thank you so much. So let's dive in. Uh today the episode is called The Fear of Relational Rupture. Okay? Um so picture this. You are sitting in a living room with your small group, let's say. It's a Wednesday night and you've got a half empty mug in your hand, and someone shares a perspective that you know everyone nods at, but you feel a sudden sharp knot in your stomach. You realize that you don't agree. And you have a massive glaring question about it. But you don't say a word, you just nod along. You take a sip of your tea or coffee. But why? It is easy to blame the room. It is easy to tell ourselves that they're too close minded, they wouldn't understand. But if we are brutally honest, the silence isn't always about them. Often it is entirely about us. We look around at the people who have brought us meals, the people who have prayed for our kids and family, and a terrifying thought flashes through our minds. Well, if I tell them who I really am right now, I will lose them. Today we're going to talk about the fear of relational rupture, the absolute terror of losing your community if you admit that you are wrestling with doubt. But instead of pointing fingers at the church, we're going to look in the mirror. We're going to explore how we often ghost our own communities emotionally before they even have a chance to respond. We pre reject ourselves. I guess that's a way to say it. Let's talk about why the fear of being truly seen feels like actual death and where Jesus meets us in the middle of our hiding. So to understand why this fear paralyzes us, we have to look at how our brains process survival and vulnerability. When you sit in a in that small group and contemplate speaking up about your doubts, your heart rate spikes and your palms sweat. So apparently in the fields of psychology, researches know that the human brain processes the threat of social rejection in the same exasp region that processes physical pain. So to your amygdala, being cast out of the tribe is a lethal threat. Because of this intense biological fear, our brains engage in a defense mechanism called catastrophizing. We imagine the absolute worst case scenario to protect ourselves. I do that, you do that, we all do that. We project our own insecurities onto our friends and our church. We tell ourselves that their love is too fragile to handle our questions. But in reality, it is our courage. Listen to that closely. It is our courage that feels fragile. By assuming the community will turn its back on us, we create a self-fulfilling prophecy of isolation. We become the closed minded ones, closed off to the possibility that our friends might actually possess the grace to sit with us in the mess. Our brain's survival instinct traps us in a silent echo chamber of our own making. So let's move from the mind down to the heart because the emotional toll of this self-imposed isolation is staggering. The deepest pain of the relational rapture is an actual rejection. It is the imposter syndrome again. It is the crushing, exhausting ways of smiling on Sunday mornings while feeling completely hollow inside. And you know that you love these people. But every time you withhold your true self, it feels like a betrayal to yourself. You start to feel like a fraud. You let's say you preemptively mourn relationships that haven't even ended. Grieving a loss that exists only in your head. This is the raw internal heartbreak. You are starving for connection while sitting at a table surrounded by spiritual family, refusing to eat because you have convinced yourself you no longer belong there. You're terrified of conditional love. So you hide your conditions. So it is time to ask yourself a hard question. Are you really protecting the peace of your community or are are you just protecting yourself from the vulnerability of being truly known? We many times rob our friends of the opportunity to love the real us because we are too scared to let them see that we are under construction. So where is Jesus in our hiding? When we are terrified that our questions will cost us our seat at the table, how does Jesus respond? Okay, in our culture it is popular to talk about finding our truth, but as Christians, we know there is no such thing as our truth. There is only the truth, and his name is Jesus. And because he is the absolute truth, he's never intimidated by our honest searching, even when we are too scared to do it in the open. So think about Nicodemus in the book of John, chapter three. Nicodemus was a Pharisee. He was a respected leader, he belonged to the ultimate religious insider group. But Nicodemus had questions, deep worldview shattering questions about Jesus that definitely did not align with his small group's theology. He was terrified of the relational rupture. He knew that if he asked those questions out loud, he would risk his status, his friends, and his entire support system. So what does he do? He hides. He goes to Jesus at night under the cover of darkness, where no one from his community can see him. And how does Jesus react? Well, he doesn't roll his eyes. He doesn't say come back in the daylight when you're brave enough to say this in front of your friends. No. Jesus meets him right there in the dark. He sits with Nicodemus in his fear and answers his questions with profound, universe altering truth. Jesus does not demand that we suddenly become fearless overnight. He knows our frame. He knows how terrifying it is to risk our community. If you are only brave enough to bring your questions to him in the dead of night, he will meet you there. But he loves you too much to let you stay in the dark forever. He invites us to step out of hiding, to stop pre-rejecting ourselves and to bring our whole doubting selves into his light. So the fear of losing your people is biologically terrifying and emotionally exhausting. But the prison of hiding is a prison with an unlocked door. Okay, so this week my challenge to you is to take a step out of hiding. Find just one safe person, someone who loves Jesus and loves you, and give them the dignity of knowing the real you. Share one question you have been keeping to yourself. Give your community the chance to be the hands and feet of Christ to you. Thank you so much for joining me today. Remember that if you're a Christian and you're doubting or deconstructing, remember to ask yourself, is it because of Jesus?