EP5 圣经的充足性：再思九标志事工的神学基础

我们是否正在让圣经“失业”：再思九标志事工的神学基础

这几年，狄马可牧师和他的“健康教会九标志”事工，在中国大陆教会中引发了广泛的关注与学习。但随之而来的是一个普遍现象：许多人习惯用实用主义的眼光去看待它，把它当成了一套应对教会问题的“操作手册”，甚至当成“灵丹妙药”。今天，我们邀请了“九标志”事工的主要推动者谢牧师。让我们和谢牧师一起，撕掉实用主义的标签，重新去挖掘“九标志”背后深厚的神学根基。

Q1: 你个人是在什么样的经历或阶段开始认真对待“圣经是足够的”这句话？

Q2: 如果用一句话向一位初信者解释，你会怎么说“圣经的充足性”是什么意思？

Q3: 你会怎样区分圣经的“权威”“无误”“充足”这几个属性，各自强调什么？

Q4: 哪几段经文最帮助你确知：圣经真的已经给了我们得救、信靠和顺服神所需要的一切？这些经文在你牧会中发挥过什么作用？

Q5: 对圣经“充足性”有哪些误解？（两个极端：认为圣经只是关于“教义”，或者任何事情都需要有“圣经依据”）

Q6: 有人听到“圣经是足够的”就以为“不需要读别的书”“不需要神学、不需要教会历史”，你同意吗？为什么不是这样呢？

Q7: 福音派教会都声称自己高举圣经、尊崇圣经，以有别于自由派，为什么你仍然认为圣经的充足性是我们所缺乏的？

Q8: 在这个问题上，中国教会的独特挑战是什么？

Q9: 从你看见的情况来看，中国教会在哪些方面最迫切需要重新学习“圣经已经足以指引我们如何作教会”——比如在教会治理、会籍、纪律、聚会形态上？

Q10: 为什么你认为“圣经的充足性”是九标志理念背后最重要的神学支撑？不该是加尔文主义或者浸信会吗？

书籍推荐

狄马可（Mark Denver），《健康教会九标志》。

狄马可（Mark Denver），《何谓健康教会》。

Jonathan Leeman，《以圣道为中心的教会》。

Transcript

unknown 2:49

But we have to be able to do it.

SPEAKER_00 6:39

So it has to changed the go the so at the girl, Jiu Jiang Chuan, Shengua, Sengin the Chango, Chido Jia Chantal, Thao Guo, Song Hat the J the Gin, Chao Go M the Lichin, Chao Gua Jiaquan Shield. So send in the Changin, Jose, Ju to Doddin getting shed, to Jung ying getting shed. So Jin Shenjin Dalai, Dirty or the Chihuahua. What is happening? Tata Gonzo Chu Jin or Bimple. Does Chiquit Chin shield the push some total moose? No Bing Bushin Long Janja, or a Kia Hurtada, Tanghua, Kendo Chia, or two Muso Ingas sent in Janja, the modern issue. So in gang and go bang to ta changing show sending in dots. So woman Siguan Bush one son google project AI, I suang one such in service one who semin her changing. Oh, you fit on Sidon is the Ju Virus? Rugo Your Rembo Mai Tadio, Siddharth Shuvan carriage with the sending eachone Xianfa Tushi Lingwai Juai. That's a rubo to ring general machine. No may see or one qua man. So the linting bear and the banchu. That's all clear the Ligia Gunk Kaida. Not Woman Jochia Chia Shenling Gonzo. In my Sunling Guangzhou, so we mean by Shenji. Not selling some Guangzhou. Sending Togo Chi do the Senti. In way Sun in the Jiawe Dong Jong. Er chick Chido the Santi puts the woman yen chances of Jacques, tie a bow leash lit the jaho. Umbocano sending the send the gungo go to me of gonzo. So it womes sent in the chunto sint touch three goddessing the leash down jung that she tasted to shun the gonzo, like putting the children, won't do sending the each year. So you look at eagerly sent in to go, so each. That Hong Sitty went to the show. Um, Birusha woman jumped out the show. Woman Connan so she's in the younger Timota colour as the machine. So eager one changed, that's the guilty other sending woo. Number Z and Hather Jose touch is two of the her, Nancyo, Quadi K, uh Liu Shia Hui, uh Chuang Yu in Don Sinfu, she's the Banza Jukotami Yang, Jesus that Juicho either, Haran Jiahu and the other. So being bush so the tongue, that's a touch on the Juhua Hung Bush, Chung to each other who changed with your belgier, so it's a tropha. Um by shan, she going, dans the xi the chang with the fang hide copy it. Now what's the natural thought? Wal know lung, like the woman won't change, gas in the chung dial channel. Uh the equals chung to each other. So the xiangui should be sending the chung. So it nominant down function sh woman full bay pin jai seaching the hersing beljo. Now the darn woman tickle wood the fum full on book on the downfansh. That's the child shall down which a yoko shell my job at the gentle shooting. Cojo, Chiang Jama Chiang and Young can do into Juma. So yeah, say Chio Shin Shang Coachian Woman does that mean you shall be a within jamshua, Rahul Shinigan Bia Gan, Rahosil Sicho, twijing the Shinia Jose Shin Fush, or Sibosha to Jia Hui Shawn is Shugon, out twitching or shenga antigon, uh anti amoshold. Times one chit you won't treat on the show on the chosen jing I should not have the changon who shall she ta Xiung Sing Hodge had a cho. Yangho woman say or touch the ho, say yum bali meant ling s and a jing one. Say good and went. So it's hungry. So don't jal with the T she hasin or when she wanted to tell you to number the C1T. So meaning equal Bel Chin, uh you don't mean you down die the Bel Chang, you should mean leash in the Bel Chen, Chale, Chen Jung Fashion Jump and Sensing like Chongsu, woman the Jia Guangguan. So the woman leases upon J. Rav de Arna woman should I go do the change of guys down jungle? Woman saying I charge but the be poor. No being for sure, he puts on yet jong that chemist or should woman to send in the each woman connection. That's woman yo yao to sendin jung shing, not your dialogue should send the chamaso jan daughter just. No huifu sendin' to go shin, justong the changes, woman, xiang daughters ho, sifu to go to go sendin, sifo tong sendin to fat, her dai sendin the two that did the jung pinji by the in the woman the tingls. A bush ba sendin down to child bag to xiang, woman to the down sha job with shield hot shia changing. Was um twia chic uh her pushin and tiny eye that chun depends. Dong woman ton se yi diang Kai so the so. Dom ki gaibi and hui jung three di send in the type. Now D R Wom Ki Gaibi and Hui Jung Du Chuan D type. Yo Chwandar and the Changui Bimbo lights the Yu Hui thermom to the Chandler and Changway Bimpolite the Hujon Shang. Chandler Changway Yapulite the one you push without ye push lights the chuch to judge the pite shield. Chandler and Chang lights how the dog is a very good idea. Domin Yin the Zug the Single Young Time and the Yang Guangdong Chi that Sengin Shan Sho. Woman that Genji Sengin Chi Chia Daw Shin Sama Jang. Sentin Sam Jang Chi Du Two Define Jia with the Gwen Chi. Woman Samatu Jangli Mangui High Matter French Bajangui Chia Hu Chi with the Jiao Da. Shenjin Samui Fan Jia with the Chinpa. Number woman's dialyder guy bien tie to the Tangai Chin Lugo Yo Nidi Kala who just a good jung that Zia Huj donju high dollar yan which is simian to chandal gonzo from Taiwan, Simian trusting or G some Jung that's young yao, Shobelju Nanisho, Shuisi Ruka Jin Sjanda, you would just be a very good idea. A light Han Jobelts Hui the Mushro Jana Huida, your Shenda Huida, your Menodishon Huida, your Duri San Jin Jia Huida. Good on can Mush do Jokobelch, don't meet on Pati. The Jokobelji Dos Jaro Yahuiton either. Yet Dosigan Charles Fany. Lung Higger Sending the Chandale. Dogiton in the Jokobelch.