QualiTea: Episode 4 - SCARF

Join Becca Lunn and Sarah White from Health Innovation West of England's Academy team for the forth episode of QualiTea.

So what is QualiTea? Quite simply, it's time for a cup of tea and a useful conversation. Each episode is a short, informal chat between Sarah and Becca, focusing on one simple improvement tool. They'll use relatable examples and talk about how you might actually use it in your day-to-day work to help you think a bit differently about a problem. Not in theory, in real life. 

In this episode, we're looking at SCARF - a neuroscience-based framework explaining how social interactions trigger the brain's "threat" or "reward" responses. SCARF stands for: Status, Certainty, Autonomy, Relatedness, and Fairness. Understanding this model helps managers and leaders improve engagement, psychological safety, and team collaboration

So grab a brew, get comfortable, and let's get started.

Got feedback or an idea for a future programme? 

Contact us at healthinnowest.communications@nhs.net or via our socials: Instagram, LinkedIn or Bluesky

Find out more about Health Innovation West of England

Transcript

QualiTea - Episode 4 - SCARF

Becca: Hi, I'm Becca, and I'm here with Sarah. Between us, we run a lot of the West of England Academy sessions and programs around improvement, leadership, and change in the NHS. 

QualitTea is exactly what it sounds like. A cup of tea and a useful conversation. These are short, informal podcasts, around fifteen minutes each, each focusing on one simple improvement tool. 

We'll use relatable examples and talk about how you might actually use it in your day to day work. Not in theory, in real life. Think of it as a calm, practical chat to help you think a bit differently about a problem. So grab a brew, get comfortable, and let's get started.

Sarah: Hello and welcome back to QualiTea where improvement happens, one cup of tea at a time. I'm Sarah,

Becca: And I'm Becca, and today's topic is all about the psychology of change. We often say we want things to change, but when it comes to the crunch, we often resist change when it actually happens. 

Sarah: But why is that? Well, have you ever walked into an office and someone is sitting at your desk? Technically, it's hot desking and it belongs to no one, but suddenly you're wandering around looking lost. Your coffee isn't quite the same, the monitor is wrong, and your days off to a bad start. Why is that? Well, it turns out because it brings out something primal in us all. 

Becca: Today we're talking about Scarf, which is a model developed by a leadership researcher, David Rock, after looking at how our brains respond in social situations. And here's the interesting bit, our brains don't just react to physical danger, they react to social danger too, and often they react in exactly the same way. Which is why your heart sinks when your manager says to you, can I have a quick word? Even if you've done absolutely nothing wrong, your brain doesn't know what's coming and uncertainty feels like danger, not because we're dramatic. 

Sarah: Well, not just because we're dramatic. Our brains are constantly asking one question: am I safe here? SCARF breaks that down into five things. Our brains are always checking for status, certainty, autonomy, relatedness, and fairness, which conveniently spells scarf.

Becca: Let's start with status. Those are the questions like, do I matter? Am I respected, am I valued? And this isn't really about job titles.

Sarah: No, it's much more about how we compare ourselves with other people or how valued we feel.

Becca: Imagine you've spent hours making your world famous lasagne, a family recipe perfected over generations. Everyone sits down, one guest reaches straight for the salt before they've even taken a bite, excuse me?

Sarah: Well, technically, they've done nothing wrong, but somehow you've been emotionally wounded. Your status as lasagne Queen has taken a bit of a knock, and your brain thinks hang on, am I not appreciated here? And the next thing is certainty, our brains absolutely love to know what's going to happen next.

Becca: Oh yeah, I love a routine and I love traditions. And you know what? Even an annoying process at work can become oddly comforting if it's familiar. Change brings uncertainty, and uncertainty feels threatening. Take online shopping. I love it when the tracking says your parcel will arrive Tuesday between nine and eleven, perfect, I can plan my day. If it says your parcel will arrive today between eight am and eight pm - well, that's it, I'm under house arrest. I'm scared to pop out for milk because they'll undoubtedly leave it in the recycling bin... and it's bin day... yeah.

Sarah: Think about when you're waiting for the outcome of a job interview. You'd almost rather know that you haven't got it than spend days wondering. Our brains don't like uncertainty, and I'd often have a bad answer as a no no answer at all.

Becca: Oh. Me too. Every time. Now the next is autonomy, and that's our sense of having control or choice. 

Sarah: And it's amazing how little it takes to threaten it. You wake up on Saturday thinking I'll mow the lawn later, and then your partner says, can you mow the lawn today? Instantly. no, you weren't against mowing the lawn five seconds ago, but now it's a matter of principle.

Becca: Mine's more like, I was going to tidy that cupboard right up until someone suggested I tidy the cupboard, and now it'll have to wait till next month. But why do we do that?

Sarah: This is because our autonomy has been threatened. When our brain senses threat, it becomes defensive. It's much harder to solve problems, be creative or collaborate when we're in that state. And the next is relatedness. Friend or foe? Do I belong here or am I on the outside of things?

Becca: Yeah, we've all had the experience where you walk into a room and everyone else seems to know each other, and they stop talking just for a second and perhaps smile politely, then carry on. My brain instantly decides, oh, they obviously all hate me. The reality? They're probably arguing about whether pineapple belongs on pizza.

Sarah: Pineapple does not belong on pizza. but on that point, the opposite is true as well. Think about walking into a room and someone smiles and waves, saves your seat or says brilliant, you're here. Nothing else has changed. But suddenly you relax. Your brain has decided I am part of this group. And then finally, we've got fairness, which is probably the easiest one to recognize because unfairness really sticks. 

Becca: Imagine you've been patiently queuing, someone walked straight to the front, oh, I'm only here to get one thing. Uh, no, you're joining the queue like the rest of us.

Sarah: Or you've all agreed to bring something to a shared lunch, you've spent all morning making homemade brownies, and then someone else turns up with a meal deal bag of crisps still in the petrol station wrapper. Somehow, that doesn't feel entirely fair.

Becca: No, and it's really hard to engage positively with someone or something when you feel it's unfair. Unfortunately, it brings out the petulant child in all of us. What scarf reminds us is that people aren't usually resisting the change itself. They're responding to how the change makes them feel, and that's a really important distinction. SCARF gives us clues about what's happening underneath the behaviour.

Sarah: So if someone feels a bit defensive and maybe their status has taken a knock.

Becca: Or if they're asking endless questions, perhaps they're just looking for some certainty.

Sarah: And if they're really resistant to change, maybe they're feeling a loss of autonomy.

Becca: If they're quiet, perhaps they don't yet feel like they belong.

Sarah: But if they're frustrated, then maybe they feel something isn't fair, instead of asking, why are they being difficult, try asking what might be feeling threatening. That's a completely different conversation, and the clever bit is that small actions can reduce those threats.

Becca: Yeah, even taking the time to explain why change is needed, giving people choices, recognising their efforts.

Sarah: Or introducing people properly and being consistent, they're all small things, but they help move people away from threat and towards trust.

Becca: So this week, have a little think. The next time someone reacts negatively to change, ask yourself which part of their scarf might be feeling threatened.

Sarah: And perhaps you can ask yourself the same question because once you start spotting SCARF, you really do see it everywhere. So thanks for joining us for another QualiTea and we'll see you next time.

Becca: Hi. I'm just popping in to let you know that in our Change that Works session, we go through SCARF as an activity along with other techniques that help you create, well, change that works. Keep an eye on the Health Innovation West of England event page to see when our next session is running.