The Tennessee History Nerd

TTHN Ep 4 - Singing for Glory

• Big John Summers • Season 1 • Episode 4

Share episode

Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.

0:00 | 42:25

Send us your comments. We'd love to hear what you think about the episode!

In the years after the Civil War, freedom had come—but stability had not.

In Nashville, a small group of students at Fisk University faced an uncertain future. Their school was struggling. Resources were scarce. The path forward wasn’t clear.

So they did something unexpected.

They sang.

What began as a desperate effort to raise funds became something far greater. The Fisk Jubilee Singers carried the spirituals of a people—songs born out of suffering, faith, and endurance—across the country and eventually across the world.

In this episode of The Tennessee History Nerd, we tell the story of the Jubilee Singers—how they preserved a musical tradition, helped save their university, and introduced the world to a sound that could not be silenced.

Because sometimes the most powerful voices rise not in comfort—but in hardship.

So grab your favorite beverage, find a comfortable place, and listen to a story that was meant to be heard.

Sources

Links & Support

Premium tier Patreon subscribers have exclusive access to bonus content, including interviews that tell the stories behind the stories.

We have great episodes coming your way in the month of April!

Buy branded The Tennessee History Nerd merchandise at https://www.summersmediaenterprises.com/merch

If you enjoyed this episode, follow the show, share it with someone who loves history, and leave a review—it helps more folks discover the stories of the Volunteer State.

SPEAKER_00

Welcome to the Tennessee History Nerd. This is a podcast dedicated to Tennessee's past. Every week we bring you a new story about the people, places, and events that have shaped Tennessee and made it and us who and what we are. So grab your favorite beverage, find a comfortable place, and sit back and enjoy. In the early eighteen seventies, Fisk University in Nashville stood on the verge of collapse. Founded in 1866 by the American Missionary Association, the school had been created to educate formerly enslaved men and women in the uncertain years after the Civil War. It operated out of a former Union Army barracks, buildings that were never meant to serve as classrooms, much less as a university. Conditions were rough, resources were scarce, and the institution depended almost entirely on donations from northern churches and philanthropic societies. For a brief time that support had been enough, but by eighteen seventy one the financial situation had become critical, funds were dwindling, expenses continued to mount, and without new revenue, Fisk wasn't going to survive. At the center of that crisis was George L. White, a treasurer, teacher, and musician who believed the school's future might rest not in its accounts, but in its voices. White had been working with a small group of students, training them in vocal performance. Many had grown up in slavery. They brought with them a musical tradition rooted in spirituals, songs shaped by faith, endurance, and memory. What White recognized and what others had not yet fully seen was that these songs carried a power that extended far beyond the campus. So in 1871, with the university facing closure, he made a decision that would alter the course of American musical history. He was going to take those students on the road. They would sing to save their school. Now, to understand why Fisk's crisis mattered, you have to understand Tennessee in the years just after the Civil War. The war ended in 1865, but peace did not mean stability. Tennessee had been one of the most contested states of the war, and the struggle over what the post-war South would become began immediately. In July 1866, Tennessee became the first former Confederate state readmitted to the Union after ratifying the Fourteenth Amendment. On paper, that made it appear that Tennessee had moved ahead of the rest of the South. In reality, readmission did not settle the deeper questions of power and race and citizenship. Those questions remained fiercely contested. During these years, Tennessee politics were shaped by sharp conflict. Governor William G. Parson Brownlow supported black civil and political rights and aligned with radical Republican policies. Meanwhile, many white Tennesseans, especially former Confederates, viewed Reconstruction governments as punitive and illegitimate. The result was not calm restoration, but continued tension. That tension was not only political. In Pulaski, Tennessee, in 1866, former Confederates organized what became the Kukux Klan. What began at first as a fraternal society quickly evolved into part of a broader pattern of intimidation and violence during Reconstruction aimed at suppressing black political participation and reinforcing and reintroducing white control. This was the environment in which Fisk University was founded. The school opened in Nashville in 1866 under the sponsorship of the American Missionary Society, and its purpose was clear to educate formerly enslaved men and women and to provide opportunities that slavery had denied them. Fisk began in former U.S. Army facilities, practical buildings, not purpose-built classrooms, reflecting both the urgency of its mission and of the limited resources available at the time. From the beginning, FISC represented more than education. It stood as part of a broader effort to define what freedom would mean in the post-war South. Would emancipation be followed by literacy and citizenship and opportunity, or would it be constrained and resisted? That question had not yet been answered. So when FISC faced financial collapse in 1871, the stakes extended far beyond that single institution. This was a young black university in the Reconstruction South, dependent upon the fragile networks of northern support, trying to survive in a region where its very purpose was still contested. And that's the world in which George White and his students made their decision to go on the road and sing. Now, at this point, I probably need to provide a little more background and context. Fisk University opened its doors on January 9th, 1866, in Nashville, Tennessee. It was established by the American Missionary Association under the leadership of John Ogden, Erastus Milo Kravith, and Edward Parmerley Smith. These were men committed to educating formerly enslaved people in the uncertain aftermath of the Civil War. From the beginning, their mission was ambitious. Fisk was not designed to offer only basic literacy. Its founders envisioned a full course of study, reading, writing, mathematics, theology, classical languages, and teacher training. This was a curriculum intended to prepare students not just for survival, but for leadership. The demand was immediate. Students came from across Tennessee and beyond, many of them adults who had been denied any formal education under slavery. Enrollment grew quickly in the school's early years, which was a reflection of both the hunger for learning and the lack of educational opportunities available to freed people in the South. But growth did not equal stability. Fisk was a private institution, and that fact shaped everything about its future. Unlike publicly supported schools later, Fisk received no consistent state funding. It depended almost entirely on donations, primarily from northern churches and missionary societies and philanthropic supporters who believed in the cause of black education. In the immediate aftermath of the war, that support had been strong. But as Reconstruction progressed, Northern attention began to drift and shift. Financial contributions declined even as the needs of the school continued to increase. Expenses were constant. Buildings required maintenance. Faculty needed salaries. Students, many of whom lived in poverty, often required additional support just to remain enrolled. By the early 1870s, those pressures began to converge. Enrollment had grown, but income hadn't kept pace. Donations no longer were sufficient to sustain operations. The institution that had expanded so quickly now faced the possibility of closing within its first decade. And this was not a distant concern or a gradual decline. By 1871, Fisk's financial situation had become urgent. Without new funding, the school wouldn't survive. And it was at this moment, when the numbers no longer worked, when traditional support had begun to fail, that George L. White began to consider a different approach. He'd been working with a group of students, training them in vocal performance. And what he saw in them was more than musical ability. He saw a possibility. Before the Fisk Jubilee singers ever set out on their historic tour, Fisk students were already performing beyond Nashville. By the late 1860s and early 1870s, the university had staged musical productions, including the cantata Esther the Beautiful Queen, as part of its efforts to raise funds. These were formal performances presented to paying audiences and intended to demonstrate both musical ability and institutional credibility. One such trip took the students to Memphis. The opportunity seemed promising. Travel itself it suggested expansion. It was proof that Fisk's efforts could extend beyond Nashville. But the results were sobering. The audience at Memphis's Greenlaw Opera House was smaller than expected, and the financial return fell short of what the university needed. If Fisk was going to survive, local and regional performances would not be enough. But it was the journey home that revealed something even more important. On the return trip, White and his students found themselves stranded between trains at a small town stop. While waiting, they drew the attention of a group of white political agitators, men described as intoxicated and openly hostile. The crowd began to mock and threaten them, directing particular scorn toward White. The situation was unstable. There's no indication that violence ultimately broke out, but the danger was real enough that the group withdrew to the train platform. There, instead of responding in kind, they prayed, and then they sang. White placed himself between the crowd and his students, steadying the group as they began a hymn. Gradually the tension began to shift. The jeering softened. The crowd thinned. And as the moment passed, one of the singers later recalled the instant of relief when we saw the bullseye of the coming engine and knew that we were saved. The train arrived and with it escape. It was a small moment, but a revealing one. The students had just experienced two hard truths in rapid succession. First, that traditional performances like Esther, even when well executed, couldn't generate the level of support that Fist required. And second, that their presence as black performers in the post-war South carried real risk. But they also witnessed something else. In the face of hostility, their music had changed the atmosphere. It hadn't guaranteed safety, it hadn't erased danger, but it had shifted the moment. And for George White, that mattered. He'd already been working with a select group of singers, training them for disciplined performance. Now he'd seen firsthand what their voices could do, not just in a concert hall, but in a moment of tension. If Fisk was going to survive, it would require something more than local concerts and conventional programming. It would require taking that sound beyond Tennessee. And this time the plan would be different. In October eighteen seventy one, the group left Nashville. They weren't yet famous. They weren't yet fully formed in identity, and they weren't traveling with the repertoire that would later define them. They were simply a small group of Fisk students led by George L. White, setting out to raise money for a university that was running out of time. The early days of the tour were difficult. Audiences were uncertain what to expect. In many places attendance was small. Financial returns were inconsistent, travel expenses continued whether the concerts succeeded or not, and the group often found themselves moving from town to town without any guarantee of meaningful support. There was also a problem of expectation. Many audiences, especially in the North, associated black performers with menstrual entertainment. They expected humor, caricature, or exaggerated performance. What White's group presented instead was formal, restrained, and serious. That difference created a disconnect. The music was competent, the intention was clear, but the response was limited. For a time the tour teetered on failure. At several points, White considered abandoning the effort altogether. The financial pressure remained severe, and the reception did not yet justify the risk. Something had to change. The turning point came gradually. Members of the group began introducing spirituals into their programs, songs they had known long before arriving at Fisk. These were not part of the original concert structure. In fact, there had been hesitation about presenting them publicly at all because of their association with slavery and the fear that audiences would not receive them with respect. But the situation demanded adaptation, so they began cautiously to include them. Not as novelty, not as performance for amusement, but as music offered with discipline and dignity. The effect was immediate and different from anything that they had experienced before. Audiences who had remained distant began to respond. The music carried something that the formal repertoire hadn't. It was direct, unembellished, and deeply rooted in lived experience. These weren't compositions learned in the classroom. These were songs that had endured through slavery, preserved in memory, shaped by faith, and carried forward into freedom. When the singers performed them in concert form, arranged, controlled, and presented without caricature, the result was something unfamiliar to Northern audiences, and it demanded attention. And increasingly it received it. The shift didn't solve everything overnight. Financial struggles continued. Travel remained difficult, but the response to the spirituals marked a clear change in direction. The group was no longer simply a student choir trying to raise money. They were becoming something else. They were becoming interpreters of a music tradition that many Americans had never truly heard, and certainly had never heard presented this way. And as that realization took hold, so did a new identity. They began to be known as the Fisk Jubilee Singers. The name itself was deliberate. Jubilee drew from the biblical concept of liberation and restoration, a fitting expression for a group whose music had been born in bondage and was now being carried into a wider world. The tour that had begun as an act of necessity was becoming something far more significant, not just a fundraiser, not a performance circuit, but the beginning of a movement. As the tour continued, the response to the spirituals began to change the trajectory of the entire effort. In earlier performances, audiences had been uncertain, sometimes polite, sometimes indifferent. But as the singers refined their presentation of spirituals and made them a more consistent part of their program, reactions grew stronger and more sustained. This shift didn't happen all at once. It built gradually from town to town. Church audiences were among the first to respond. In those settings, the spirituals were more easily understood, not as entertainment, but as expressions of faith. That context helped listeners recognize the seriousness of what they were hearing. From there, the response broadened. In northern cities, audiences who had previously encountered black music primarily through menstrual shows began to experience something entirely different. The Fisk singers presented spirituals without caricature, no costumes, no theatrical exaggeration, no attempt to entertain at the expense of dignity. And that distinction mattered. It challenged expectations, and over time it began to reshape them. Reports from the tour indicate that audiences grew quieter during performances, more attentive, increasingly receptive. Where there had once been distance, there was now enthusiasm. With that change in reception came something that Fisk desperately needed financial support. Donations began to increase. Collections taken after performances became more substantial. Invitations expanded beyond small towns into larger cities, and more prominent venues. The tour, which had once hovered near failure, began to stabilize, and then gradually to succeed. The singer's reputation spread through word of mouth, church networks, and local press coverage. They were no longer unknown students traveling out of necessity. They were becoming recognized performers with a distinct and meaningful repertoire. One of the defining elements of that reputation wasn't just what they sang, but how they sang it. George White insisted on discipline and presentation. The singers appeared in formal attire. They entered without spectacle. They performed with restraint and precision. The goal wasn't to entertain in the conventional sense, but to present the music with seriousness and respect. That approach reinforced the shift in perception. Audiences weren't being asked to watch a performance. They were being asked to listen, and increasingly they did. By the time the group reached major Northern centers, their concerts were drawing wider attention. Clergy, educators, and civic leaders began to take notice. Support for Fisk was no longer confined to a narrow circle of donors, it was expanding into a broader network of individuals who saw both the musical and educational significance of what the singers represented. The transformation wasn't just financial, it was cultural. The Fisk Jubilee singers had begun to change how audiences understood the music they carried and in doing so, how they understood the people who created it. What had started as an effort to save a struggling university was becoming something larger. A new kind of musical voice was being heard, and it was being taken seriously. As the Fist Jubilee singer's reputation grew, their tour began to reach beyond local and regional audiences. What had started as a fragile effort to raise funds was becoming a recognized presence within northern religious and educational networks. Churches continued to provide the foundation of their support, but their reach was expanding into larger cities and more prominent venues. With that expansion came increased visitors. Clergy, educators, and civic leaders began to take a more active interest in the group, not only because of the music, but because of what the singers represented. They were students from a newly established black university in the Reconstruction South, presenting a form of music that many audiences were encountering for the first time in a serious setting. Their concerts were no longer isolated events. They were becoming part of a broader conversation about education, race, and culture in post-war America. Financially, the impact was becoming more tangible. Collections and donations continued to grow, providing a steadier stream of support for Fisk. While the university's long-term stability was not yet guaranteed, the immediate crisis that had prompted the tour was beginning to ease, and just as importantly, the group had proven that the model could work. Music, presented with discipline and purpose, could sustain the institution. As their visibility increased, so did the range of their audiences. They performed before a variety of gatherings, including religious assemblies, academic audiences, and public events. These appearances helped to broaden their base of support and reinforce their identity as more than just a touring choir. They were representatives of Fisk University and, by extension, of a larger educational mission. Among these appearances were performances attended by individuals of national prominence, including political and public figures. Such occasions reflected the growing recognition of the group's significance, even if the primary driver of their success remained grassroots support through churches and local communities. It's important to understand the nature of that recognition. The Fisk Jubilee singers did not achieve success through a single defining moment or endorsement. There was no instant transformation from obscurity to fame. Instead, their legitimacy was built incrementally, concert by concert, audience by audience, donation by donation, and that gradual growth mattered. It gave their work credibility. It rooted their success in sustained response rather than momentary attention, and it created a foundation strong enough to support what would come next. For the first time since the crisis began, the university's future no longer depended on a single uncertain outcome, but on a broader and more stable base of support. Now the question became how far could their message and their music actually travel? By eighteen seventy three, the success of the Fist Jubilee singers in the United States had opened the door to something larger. Invitations began to come from abroad, particularly from Britain, where interest in American culture, religious music, and the story of emancipation created a receptive audience for the group's work. And that year the singers crossed the Atlantic. For many of them, maybe even all of them, it was their first time leaving the United States. The journey itself marked a transition from a regional fundraising effort to an international mission. In Britain, they performed in churches, concert halls, and private gatherings. As in the United States, their reception was not built on a single moment of acclaim, but through repeated performances. Audiences responded to the same qualities that had begun to resonate in the North discipline, restraint, and the presentation of spirituals as serious musical works rather than entertainment. They were invited to perform before increasingly prominent audiences, including members of the British social and political elite. These appearances reflected a widening recognition of both their musical ability and the significance of the tradition they represented. Financially, the tour proved significant. Funds raised abroad contributed directly to the long-term stability of Fisk University, extending beyond the immediate relief provided by the early American tour. The impact, however, wasn't only financial. In Britain and later in parts of Europe, the Fisk Jubilee singers introduced many audiences to spirituals for the very first time in a formal concert setting. These songs, rooted in the experience of slavery and shaped by faith, were received not as novelty, but as music of depth and meaning. That reception reinforced what had already begun in the United States. The singers weren't simply raising money, they were reshaping how this music was heard. One of the most frequently repeated stories from this period involves a performance before Queen Victoria. According to later accounts, after hearing the singers, she's said to have remarked that they must come from a music city, a phrase often cited as the origin of Nashville's nickname. However, historians treat this story with caution. While the Fist Jubilee singers did perform for distinguished audiences in Britain, and while their reception there was well documented, the specific wording and even the occurrence of this exchange cannot be firmly verified in the contemporary primary sources. What can be said with confidence is this by the time their European tour concluded, Nashville had become associated, at least in part, with the musical tradition that the singers carried, not through a single remark, but through sustained exposure to a sound that audiences had come to recognize and respect. The success of the Fisk Jubilee singers was never measured only in applause. From the beginning, the purpose of the tour had been clear to secure the future of Fisk University. By the mid eighteen seventies, that goal was beginning to take tangible form. Funds raised to the singers' tours, both in the United States and abroad, made it possible for the university to move beyond its temporary facilities and to begin construction on a permanent building. That building would become known as Jubilee Hall. Construction began in the early eighteen seventies and was completed in eighteen seventy six. Designed by architect Stephen D. Hatch, the structure rose on the Fisk campus in Nashville as a multi-story brick building in the Gothic Revival style, distinct, substantial, and intentionally permanent. This was a turning point. Until that moment, Fisk had operated out of former military barracks and other buildings, structures that reflected urgency, not permanence. Jubilee Hall represented something different. It was built for education. It was built to last. And it was built quite literally from the results of the singer's work. The connection between the tour and the building was widely understood. While funding came from multiple sources, including donations, church collections, and private contributions, the Jubilee singers' efforts played the central role in making construction possible. That mattered not just financially, but symbolically. Jubilee Hall stood as evidence that the university had moved beyond survival. It demonstrated that an institution founded to educate formerly enslaved people not only could endure, but also could establish itself with permanence and purpose. The building quickly became the center of campus life. Students lived, studied, and gathered within its walls. Its presence reshaped the physical identity of Fisk, giving the university a structure that matched the seriousness of its mission. And over time its significance extended beyond the campus. Jubilee Hall came to represent a broader idea that education, sustained by discipline and supported by faith and community, could produce something lasting in a place where such permanence had once seemed uncertain, perhaps even unlikely. It wasn't simply a building. It was a result. A result of voices carried across towns and cities and oceans, a result of audiences who listened, a result of a university that refused to close its doors. By 1876, what had once been a desperate effort to stay alive had taken visible form in brick and stone. And Jubilee Hall still stands today, not as a monument to a single moment, but as a reminder of what made that moment possible. History remembers the Fist Jubilee singers as a single unified sound, but that sound was carried by individuals whose lives had been shaped by slavery, freedom, and the uncertain years that followed. Most of the original singers had been born into slavery. They had brought with them not only musical ability, but lived experience, memories of hardship, faith, and endurance that gave depth to the songs they performed. Those songs, the spirituals, weren't newly created for the stage. They'd been preserved through the generations, passed down orally, shaped in the fields, churches, and communities where formal expression was often denied, but faith endured. What the Jubilee singers did wasn't to invent that music, but to present it differently. Under George White's direction, spirituals were arranged for concert performance, structured, disciplined, and delivered with intentional restraint. There wasn't any attempt to imitate menstrual traditions or to meet the expectations of caricature. Instead, the singers stood before their audiences with dignity and allowed the music to speak for itself. And that decision changed everything. For many listeners, it was the first time they'd ever encountered these songs in such a setting, removed from the stereotype, presented as serious expressions of faith and experience. The impact extended beyond the success of a single tour. The Fisk Jubilee singers helped to establish the spiritual as a recognized form of American music, one that would influence later developments in gospel and blues and the other traditions that followed. They also reshaped perception. Audiences who had come expecting entertainment encountered something else entirely, discipline, depth, and a form of expression rooted in history and belief. In doing this, the singers did more than raise money for a university. They carried a cultural inheritance into spaces where it hadn't previously been heard, and in many cases, it hadn't been previously understood there either. The Fisk Jubilee singers set out in 1871 to save a struggling university, and that alone would be enough to remember them by. But what they accomplished extended far beyond that original purpose. They helped to secure the future of Fisk University. They established a permanent place for spirituals in American music, and they carried a sound born in slavery onto stages where it was heard and taken seriously by the wider world. Their success wasn't immediate. It wasn't guaranteed, and it was never built on a single moment. It was built step by step through discipline and persistence and a willingness to present their music with dignity in a world that didn't always expect it or accept it. Jubilee Hall still stands in Nashville as a reminder of what that effort made possible. But the legacy of the singers isn't confined to a building. It lives in the music they carried. Every time a spiritualist sung in church, a concert hall, or a classroom, it echoes a tradition that the Fist Jubilee singers helped to bring into the public ear. They didn't invent those songs. They gave them a stage. And in doing so, they ensured what had once been confined to a memory would be heard far beyond it. This is such a remarkable and inspirational story. Well known, yes. Often told, perhaps, but it's no less compelling due to its fame. It's a story of perseverance, faith, and triumph over a myriad of obstacles and challenges, and a legacy that continues to live on as Fisk University continues today with its mission and is consistently ranked among the top ten historically black colleges and universities in the country. That's going to do it for today's episode. But we have another one coming very soon. And in our next episode, we're going to examine a very different story of how one individual overcame tremendous odds to achieve something that had never been done before and eventually became an elder statesman among his people. Be watching for episode 5, The Talking Leaves. Until then, I'm Big John Summers, the Tennessee History Nerd, and I am history. For this episode, I drew from a combination of primary and secondary sources, including the work of Andrew Ward and G.D. Pike on the Jubilee Singers, along with research on Reconstruction and Nashville's history from historians like Eric Foner and Bobby Lovett. I also relied on entries from Tennessee Encyclopedia.net and historical documentation related to Fisk University and Jubilee Hall. I've included the full list of sources in the show notes if you'd like to explore further. These stories are built on the work of historians, archivists, and preservationists who have kept them alive.