The Conspiracy Journal
Grab your tinfoil hat and join your hosts Michelle, Greg, and Bobby as they open the Conspiracy Journal archives and explore the unexplained with enthusiasm. Every week they take you deep into the paranormal, the political, and the downright absurd.
Unfiltered conversations. Modern psyops. Hidden technology. Abductions. Suppressed science. Coverups. The patterns behind the headlines and so much more! No topic is off the table because if history has taught us anything it’s that today’s conspiracy is often tomorrow’s headline.
The Conspiracy Journal
015 THE MOTHMAN PHENOMENON - RED EYES OVER AMERICA! Is the Mothman Still Appearing Before Tragedy Strikes?
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
The Henchmen are heading to Point Pleasant to investigate one of the strangest cases in paranormal history. Was the Mothman a terrifying cryptid, an interdimensional warning, or a misunderstood messenger trying to save lives before disaster struck? From glowing red eyes and Men in Black to creepy phone calls and a bridge collapse that shocked the nation, this episode has it all. Was Mothman the monster, or the hero? Tune in to find out.
For more about mothman check out WINGS BEFORE THE FALL by Kia Larson available now on ConspiracyJournal.com & amazon.
If you've seen or experienced anything unexplainable call us at the Strange Exchange +1 (929) 445-3705 we want to hear about it!
Yeah, this is gonna be fun when I was just thinking about this. It's funny to be like, what are we talking about today? Everyone can just read the episode title. Yeah, we know already. It's not like it's a surprise.
MichelleYou know what's fun though? I don't know.
GregOkay. Yeah. And that's what it's about. Well, today we're we're gonna talk about one of my absolute favorite cryptids Bigfoot. No.
MichelleMessi.
GregMothman.
MichelleI love Mothman.
GregMothman. Mothman. Mm-hmm. Mothman. I think a lot of people found uh Mothman through the Mothman Prophecies. 2002 film with Richard Gere, directed by Mark Pellington.
MichelleYep, yep, yep. So our founder, the late great Timothy Green Beckley, was a decades-long friends with the author John Keel, who wrote the book that the movie is based off of. Yeah.
GregI have like a weird attachment to Mothman. Well, specifically the movie. I remember watching the movie and just realizing that the town that it was shot in looked incredibly familiar.
MichelleIs it the town you grew up in?
GregNo, no, no, no. But like yes and no, it was in Cataning, Pennsylvania. And I used to spend summers in Catanning.
MichelleOh, no, sure.
GregI had family that lived in like West PA there. It's like a little bit outside, it's a little north of Pittsburgh. But yeah, we would just take trips out during the summer. They used to have like this art festival we used to go to all the time. And it was I'm sure it still happens. Um, my brother and I always like talk about like, oh, we have to do a trip, go back out to Catanning.
MichelleWe should go.
GregI drove through not too long ago. It's a a different town for sure. I mean, it's always like a blue-collar working class type of town, but it's definitely more so that I think it's just it's sad to see parts of your past and history kind of like degrade, but yeah, but that's like essentially my uh attachment to Mothman Prophecies from 2002 at Richard Year. That movie did it sucks because that movie did like mediocre at the box office. It wasn't like a big smash, but then it has like a giant cult following.
MichelleYeah, we definitely gotta do an M files on the Mothman prophecies. Oh, yeah, we will definitely do that.
BobbyYeah, it's I haven't seen it since it came out. It's been it's been some time. Yeah, I have however been to Point Pleasant, West Virginia.
GregThat's cool. Well, like going back to my original idea of just I think that's where like a lot of people were introduced to Mothman was just through that movie, and like not like not too many people know that it was based on a book by John Keel written in 1975 of the same name. But it was cool, like in the book, John Keel kind of brings up the idea of ultra-terrestrials, not extra. Um, and the idea of that is they ultra-terrestrials use some sort of psychic power to create hallucinations, um, such as the Mothman and UFOs and aliens, and that's how we have these in our like consciousness. Um, and it's like him along with Jacques Vallée, Vallet. Um, he's a professional astronomer at the Paris Observatory, Alan Heinick. Oh, homie. He's an American astronomer and professor, and like many other ufologists, they all kind of subscribe to this idea, including Kai Larson, author of Wings Before the Fall, the True Story of Fear, Disaster, and the Mothman Phenomenon.
BobbyIn the I just got a for my own personal edification, in the Biz, as it were, is it uFologist or ufologist? Are both acceptable? Do we know?
GregI would say uFologist. And so do I. Uphologist is fun, though.
MichelleI've heard both, so I don't know which one is right.
BobbyOkay.
GregThank you. And I think going to his idea of ultraterrestrials, it's not that this is like a new concept, it's kind of what like pre-modern history would equate to I don't know like mythological or supernatural creatures. So whenever you hear things written down about like these types of creatures, it's like it's usually in reference to ultra-terrestrials.
BobbyLike somebody could be like, You mean an extraterrestrial?
MichelleYeah.
BobbyYeah. Once you try an ultra-terrestrial.
MichelleWhat's the difference exactly though?
GregUh interdimensional or from coming from outer. So like interdimensional would be like the ultra-terrestrial, where the original or like the generic concept of aliens coming from another planet to here would be considered like extraterrestrial. They're from off-planet where ultra is more like interdimensional.
MichelleCool, cool, cool, cool. What the fuck would an angel be, you guys?
GregUltra-terrestrial.
MichelleRight? We have okay.
GregThey're coming from another realm. Yeah, yeah. That too is kind of like how like part of the story is where um all stories of angels and like demons and other things that seem other otherworldly are just aliens, essentially, interdimensional beings coming from other places.
MichelleI believe that to be true. Like, what's the difference? You know what I mean?
GregYeah, yeah. Yeah, we come up with different words for the same things throughout human history.
BobbyI like this is like a fun twist. Like, we, you know, we in a lot of the stuff we talk about, we uh, you know, we're talking about skeptics quite often, and people have to dismiss things. I just love that as like a twist of dismissal. People are like, maybe it was an angel, and you're like, Yeah, you mean like an alien?
GregYeah, like that wasn't an angel, it was just an alien. Yeah, people get so caught up in like semantics of just like how things are labeled, it's just like you guys both are you sound the same, you're saying the same thing. Yeah, you just don't prefer this word, you like this word more. No, this guy's a fool.
MichelleYeah, idiot.
GregBut that it's like kind of why I love the Mothman story so much more than like other cryptids, because like it covers so much, it covers aliens, UFOs, it explores like just the psychology of fear and like how like a whole town and essentially like a ton more people, like after the story is released, like get enveloped into all of this, and they can like all get to they all get to experience it. I've I made a note here, it's like the Barnum and Ballies of the paranormal. Yeah, it's a little something for everybody.
MichelleHuh. I mean, okay. What's um no, you know what? I'm not gonna say it. You can't make me say what I was gonna say. I'm not gonna say it.
BobbyAll right. Or are you saving it for the pod? Or on the pod now. Say it.
MichelleNo, I'm gonna wait for you to tell the story before I try to put the entire story into a five-word sentence.
BobbyYeah, you're not gonna reveal that you were the Mothman the whole time.
MichelleYeah, yeah, yeah. I'm not gonna let you guys know. I'm about to take my mask off and let you know that I am the Mothman.
GregYeah, yeah, yeah. One big thing, and if uh you guys like the story, um, I'm sure again, a lot of people know the story of the movie, but the movie itself isn't really a canon for the tale. So I'll go through the actual events of what actually happened. Um, I'll try to be brief and summarize as much as I can. If you do like it or you are familiar with the Mothman story already, I do recommend this year's Mothman Festival will be held September 19th and 20th in Point Pleasant, West Virginia, where our story takes place today.
BobbyIt's a great little town. They love the Mothman, they've got a great museum there, they've got a great, a really badass statue of the Mothman. Oh, yeah. And uh, it's just a cool little town with really nice people.
GregSo if you're in the neighborhood or not, and if uh if you want more information on that, you can go to Mothmanfestival.com. They have a bus tour of the TNT area, which we'll get into. Again, the world famous Mothman statue. They'll have guest speakers, uh, the Mothman Museum, a ton of vendors lining the streets. I even think there's a Mothman 5K.
MichelleOh, yeah, I want to run for Mothman.
GregHelp support Mothman.
BobbyI would I hope that that's like the sweeper in the race is there's a Mothman at the end. Oh, yeah, that'd be amazing. Yeah, yeah. Last one dies.
GregBut yeah, all that said, for those who don't know the official story, I'm gonna catch you all up to speed. Catch and also stick around after because I'll fill you in some more sightings. Mothman's been doing essentially a world tour since the 60s. Mothman busy. Yeah, it's sort of like a stones, man.
MichelleI did not know that. Right on, dude. Right on, right on.
BobbyCatch the Mothman at the Prudential Center this May.
GregYeah, yeah, yeah. Before it collapses. Yeah. All right, so we will start a little bit here. In the autumn of 1966, Point Pleasant, West Virginia was the kind of place where very little ever changed. Town sat quietly where the Kanawaha River meets the Ohio River.
MichelleThe what river?
GregKanawaha. Kanawa? It could just be Kanawa.
MichelleI don't know. I'm just fucking.
GregIt's probably Kanawa. Surrounded by wooded hills and farmland. Uh, fewer than 5,000 people lived there at the time. Most worked in nearby factories on river barges or across the now infamous Silver Bridge and Gallipoli's. Oh, nice. Ohio.
MichelleNice. You have said so many different things already in this episode. You did a French thing. You just did, I think, an Italian thing. You did a Native American thing. Right on. I can't do any of those things.
GregUm, yeah, so it was the sort of town where the biggest news of the week might be like a school football game or a church fundraiser. Like it nothing was happening there. It was just a typical small town, West Virginia. Um, outside the town lay a strange and largely abandoned stretch of land known as the TNT area. Uh, during World War II, the United States government had built the West Virginia Ordnance Works there to manufacture explosives for the war effort.
MichelleOkay, so when we say TNT, we mean like Looney Tunes, dynamite barrels with TNT written on it. Yeah, what does TNT stand for?
BobbyUm I think that's the chemical name.
MichelleOh, cool.
BobbyYeah, I'm sure there's nitrogross. Tetra, nitro, tetra-tight. Yeah, but effect.
MichelleThat was it.
GregNailed it there. Yeah. You could let us know in the comments.
MichelleYeah. Yeah.
GregWe could just look it up too, but you know, not prepared for this type of scrutiny with the TNT. Sorry. Yeah. Dynamite. Yeah.
BobbyA C D C.
GregYeah. That's right. Bombs. Um the facility covered thousands of acres. Concrete bunkers called igloos were scattered throughout the forest where munitions had once been stored. By the 1960s, the military had abandoned the site, leaving behind rustic buildings, wonderfully scenic chemical ponds, and uh just miles of empty roadways winding through the woods.
MichelleI do like strangely colored ponds.
GregYeah.
BobbyI love an abandoned military installation.
MichelleWe should go on a field trip.
BobbyYeah, there's some some pretty cool ones. Yeah.
GregWe dig around through some, yeah. Teenagers sometimes drove through the area later. Yeah, they did.
MichelleOf course. They were getting so stoned.
GregYou know the one dude who was always like, I know a spot.
MichelleYeah, for sure.
GregWell, this was the spot.
MichelleLike this was the party at the TNT, dude. Yeah. Listen to ACDC.
GregThat's right. That's right. Drink some beers. Hang out on the fucking TNT igloos. Yeah.
BobbySmug a little grass, tip beers.
MichelleRight on, right on. Maybe a girl take her shirt off. Sorry.
BobbyCop of Peel.
GregSorry, Mom. People just do things out in the fucking TNT area.
BobbyI don't know what to do. We know what those kids are up to out there. Yep. Yeah.
GregUh before the events connected to what we would now what would now become known as the Mothman did not begin in Point Pleasant, though.
MichelleWhat?
GregIt began 70 miles north. What? You all your money back?
MichelleI do. Everything is a lie. That's gonna be my everything that I've ever known is a lie.
GregOn the evening of November 2nd, 1966, at approximately 7.15 p.m., a man named Woodrow Derenberger. What do you Derenberger? Uh he was driving home from work along Interstate 77 near Parkersburg, West Virginia. Derenberger was a sewing machine salesman. It had been a normal work day, and he was driving uh alone in the dark. As he drove south, he noticed a bright object approaching from behind him. He's like, Maybe I can make a sale. Yeah. Yeah. He's like, I got I got three more I have to offload.
MichelleThis guy needs a sewing machine?
GregYeah. Uh at first he thought it was another car catching up to him, uh, but when the object passed, he realized it was not a car at all. It was what was it? He described the object as metallic gray and shaped somewhat like an old kerosene lamp. What? He estimated it was about 30 to 40 feet long. The object moved ahead of his truck, then descended directly onto the highway. He then slowed to a stop. A door opened on the side of this craft, and a man stepped out.
MichelleA regular man? A regular human man?
BobbyYep. Hey, friend, you need a sewing machine? That suit you got on looks a little tattered, brother.
GregThat's right.
MichelleYou want to tailor it yourself?
GregWell, the figure walked calmly towards his truck. Derenberger uh later described the man as about six feet tall with dark hair, olive complexion, and wearing a dark coat and trousers. Nothing else. He was it was kinky. Swipe right.
MichelleUm left. I don't know which way is the right way.
GregOne deep one detail that disturbed him though, the one thing that like and this would scare the shit out of probably anybody, was just that he was just smiling.
MichelleEw, creep, sweep, left, left, no, no, bad, block them.
GregAnd do a swipe.
MichelleYeah.
GregHe was, and it wasn't just a casual smile. Um, the smile stretched like wide across his face. Um, and he also described it as like being and looking unnatural. So he was like the the mouth was smiling, but the eyes were not.
MichelleUncanny valley in that face. Yeah, nope.
GregSo apparently aliens get Botox. Like it's just uh that's where we got the technology.
MichelleFull of fillers.
BobbyUm, the man didn't even speak to him. Derenberger reported. His smile said it all.
MichelleYeah, and his kerosene lamp shaped shit. What kerosene? I've never heard there are a lot of shapes that I've heard of. Kerosene lamp shaped is not one of them. I wasn't expecting that.
BobbyWhat what shape is that?
MichelleI think it's like um, you know, it's like stout and then it opens up into like a lady like if a lady's figure uh oh one of the like the hourglass things with the whip that you turn, one of those.
BobbyYeah.
MichelleOherglass without the hour on top.
BobbyThat's uh interesting aeronautical shape.
MichelleThat's a it's fucking up my mind, I gotta say.
BobbyYeah, yeah.
MichelleAt least that's the that's the only kerosene lamp I know of.
GregYeah. Well, Derenberger said he heard a voice in his head.
MichelleMm-hmm.
GregAnd the voice the voice introduced itself. It said, My name is Indrid Cold. What? Inrid Cold.
BobbyYes. Can you spell that for me? I-N-D-R-I-D-C-O-L-D. Alright, that's what I thought you said.
MichelleI think she's uh related to Stone Cold.
BobbyWhy uh do you say she? He just said it's a man.
MichelleYeah, but Ingrid is a name. Ingrid. Any relation to Stone Cold.
BobbyHe just comes out smashing beards on his head. Turns out this is Stone Cold Steve Austin's father.
MichelleYeah. That tracks.
GregThe man uh explained he was a traveler from a place called Lanolos. Oh, I was described as a place called Lanolos.
MichelleI'm cut off from sound effects. Never let me do that again.
GregHe described it's a it's a peaceful world in the Ganymede galaxy. Lanolos was said to be settled by earthlings long ago. It has three seasons planting, harvest, and cold, and a government run by 56-person council. Uh he then asked Derenberger simple questions about life on earth. What do humans eat? How long do they live? What kind of work do they do? What that pee-pee do. No, that's uh I threw that one out.
MichelleI don't know what that's from, but I'm not I'm not familiar with whatever the fuck you just referenced.
GregHe's just curious. He is an alley. He just wants to know what that pee-pee do. Okay. Um, yeah, things took a real horny turn. Uh the conversation lasted only a few minutes. Uh, then the man returned to his craft. The door closed. Object rose silently from the highway and disappeared into the night sky.
BobbyDo do we know, did Woodrow Woody to his friends? Did he did he answer him? Was he like, here's what we're about, here's our gross domestic product, here's here's what that PP do.
MichelleOh, he fucking told all our secrets. Yeah, gave him right up, I bet. Okay. Fucking Woody.
GregSo he got home and then within days, the story spread across West Virginia. Police interviewed him, local newspaper ran the story. Eventually, the account reached paranormal researcher John Keel, who would soon travel to this area of the country himself.
MichelleHomie.
GregUh, but no one yet realized that a far stranger change of chain of events was about to begin just 70 miles south.
MichelleOkay, hold on, pause. So is the fact that John Keel is getting involved is what makes us related to the Mothman? Or are we saying that that dude who came from the land of like Lapalosa or whatever is the Mothman?
GregWell, it goes back to what John Keel was saying that ultra-terrestrials give people this um hallucinations of aliens and UFOs and these other like cryptid beings and stuff.
BobbyPerhaps it's like a you see what you want to see situation. Yeah. So maybe Woody was like, I want to see an attractive man with an unnerving smile. Yeah. These other people were like, I want to see a moth man.
GregAnd like we could get through this story without the uh injured cold, but I know that they brought it up in the Mothman prophecies.
MichelleWhat? No, I need injured.
GregI thought you were gonna be like, we can get through this story without all your little comments.
MichelleI honestly did I really, really thought what you were trying to say was like we're never gonna get through this story if you don't shut the fuck up.
BobbyNo, no, no, it's uh super like I no, I love I love this stuff. I love so many of these things have other things around them before and after, and these little these little things that like honestly like really like make them so much more interesting in and so much more robust is is legends and tales themselves. So I'm I'm all for it. It's super interesting to hear that stuff.
MichelleYeah, I need I need the information, and then I need to be able to reference it later or get it in a joke. If somebody's like you got an injured cold smile right now, I'd be like, Oh my god, I get it.
GregThere are if you go online, you can find sketches of what he looked like, and uh like you can find them also in it's called Beyond the Lanolos, Our 50 Years with Injured Cold. It's by Tanya Derenberger, it's his daughter. Yeah, published a book on everything that happened.
MichelleUm, call us.
GregAnd it also fills in like a bunch of the gaps of like because obviously there was more that happened, and then what followed was also like pretty profound.
MichelleYeah, yeah. All right, go, go, go. All right, I'm gonna be set up. Yeah, I'm gonna listening.
GregSo we now from that, again, we I I bring that up because it was within the movie itself, but it was presented as if it was happening during the at the same time, yeah. The events of Mothman, but like it was a separate kind of a separate instant, but but it was still relatively close to everything that happened in the story we're about to get into. And with that, at approximately 11:30 on the night of November 15th, 1966, two couples were driving through the old TNT area along West Virginia Route 62. The group consisted of Roger Scarberry, Linda Scarberry, and their friends Steve Millet and Mary Millet. They had been driving past the abandoned power plant building where Roger slowed the car down. Standing near the old structure was something none of them could explain. The figure appeared six or seven feet tall, its body looked gray in the headlights, behind it were large wings folded tightly along its back, then it turned toward the car. Two bright circles reflected the headlights back to them. Oh, like a cat or a dog, uh like um whatever that's Linda Scarberry later described them as looking like bicycle reflectors glowing in the dark. For a moment, the four teenagers just sat there in silence, then the creature spread its wings. Roger fucking hits the gas. Yeah. Uh, and then they're speeding away down 62 back towards Point Pleasant.
MichelleYeah. Later.
GregAnd then within seconds, Roger looked into the rearview mirror just as the creature was rising into the air behind them. No, it was fucking following them.
MichelleNo, but flying. But in the air. In the air. No, no, no, no. It just takes off. It's like car, don't fail me now. Go faster, Roger.
GregFaster. Roger fucking haunches it down the road.
MichelleWe out.
GregUh the speedometer climbs past 80 miles an hour. Um, they know this because when he looked to see where the creature was again, it was keeping pace with them. At 80 miles an hour. Anyway. No. Um, even more disturbing was how it moved. The wings did not appear to flap. Instead, the creature seemed to glide effortlessly through the air.
MichelleNo, that's a creep factor that I was not just familiar with.
GregSorin at them.
MichelleNo, yeah. I mean, I expect I expected flapping. Powered on fear. Yeah, I expect it flapping. And and yeah.
BobbyI like this, is this is really what you take issue with. You're like everything, not a problem, but the fact that it's not flapping its wings is very scary. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
GregYeah. Yeah. Okay. When uh The car finally reached the outskirts of town. The creature suddenly veered off and disappeared into the darkness. Shaken and terrified. The four drove straight to the Mason County Sheriff's Office just before midnight. Sheriff George Johnson listened carefully.
MichelleNice name.
GregGee. Johnson later told reporters too that he knew all four of them personally and did not believe that they were the type to just come up with a story like this. And because of that, he was now curious. He drove out to the TNT area to investigate, but as we can all expect, found nothing unusual. Not a true believer. And that kind of happened, so I don't know. You tell people a ghost and stuff. It's like, no, it was there.
MichelleBut yeah, I hate when that happens. I'm always telling everybody to look at my ghost.
GregSo the next morning, November 16th, 1966, the Point Pleasant Register published a front page story with the headline, Couple C Man Size Bird Creature. Something.
MichelleThat's the that's the full title.
GregThat's the title. That's the headline.
MichelleI wrote that. You're welcome.
GregYeah. Just they saw something.
BobbyCouple see man-sized bird creature, something.
MichelleYeah, Path Life. I was writing for that paper for sure.
GregWhat's funny is like at this time a reporter was joking around, but he referred to the creature as the Mothman.
MichelleOh, so he accidentally made up the name?
GregWell, it was like a Batman villain on TV at the time. It was. So it was just like, oh, like the Mothman. And then that nickname just stuck.
MichelleWell, give that man a politzer prize.
GregDefinitely. A legend was born. Later that same night, another strange encounter occurred. At approximately 10:30 on the night of November 16th, a man named Newell Partridge was sitting inside his house along Salem Road watching television.
MichelleThat name was upsetting to Michelle for some reason.
GregNewell Partridge?
MichelleWhat the fuck kind of fake ass name is that? I just say no. That's all I have to say.
GregHard pass from Michelle.
MichelleUnbelievable.
GregWell, without warning, his television filled with static, and at the same moment he heard a high whining sound outside.
MichelleWhat kind of whining? Like a dog? Or like a like electric wine? Just something.
BobbyProbably, I would imagine like an electric, like an electric wine.
MichelleI feel like his electric just went out or something.
GregWell, his dog Bandit didn't think so.
MichelleIf Bandit dies, I'm leaving.
GregBandit began barking furiously.
MichelleGet him, Bandit. Get him.
GregPartridge stepped outside with a flashlight, as you do. Yeah. At the edge of the property, he saw two glowing red circles. He also later told investigators that the eyes looked exactly like bicycle reflectors, catching the beam of his flashlight.
MichelleI must have forgotten that.
GregThis is where it's gonna get a little it's gonna get a little hard for you, Michelle. But Bandit ran toward the creature.
MichelleNo bandit barking. No bandit.
GregDon't go back. Partridge called for the dog to come back. The dog disappeared into the darkness and was never seen again. Can we take a moment of silence for bandit?
BobbyHe's on a farm upstate in Lantolos.
MichelleI think Bandit's fine. I think he's fine. He's living it, he's free range now.
BobbyHe's an ultra dog. He went into another dimension.
GregHe's living his best life.
MichelleYou know what? I pray to Bandit every night.
GregHe ran he ran right into the singularity into a wormhole.
MichelleThat's right.
GregYep. Like right around this time, too. Uh sightings of this winged figure just spread fucking wildfire through town. Everyone was seeing it.
MichelleAll right. Were they though?
GregI don't know.
MichelleOkay.
GregThis is the this is the account and what was reported on.
MichelleUm I'm not attacking you.
GregOne big thing was on uh on Thanksgiving night, November 24th. Witnesses reported seeing a large winged creature near the silver bridge at around 7:30 in the evening. Drivers crossing between Point Pleasant and uh Gallipolis claimed they saw a dark figure perched high on the steel beams of the bridge. Most likely. Um vengeance. Yeah, yeah, yeah. That's right. He's here. He's protecting the town. Yeah, yeah. Yeah. Headlights illuminated the structure as they were driving. They they all said they could see glowing red eyes staring down toward the traffic glow. And this is many people now. Like a lot of people saw those.
MichelleI believe every single one of them.
GregTwo nights later, on the 26th, at approximately nine in the evening, two young men driving near the Gallipolis airport reported seeing a large winged figure walking along the runway. When their headlights struck the creature, it spread its enormous wings and lifted silently into the sky.
MichelleWith flapping or no flapping?
GregUh, I don't think flapping. A lot of these counts are it's just like it just fucking jumps and that's it. They estimated the wingspan was uh at about 10 to 12 feet.
MichelleThat's so scary.
GregAs the week passed, the sightings continued. This is gonna take a another interesting turn in the story, but like um the creature was not the only strange thing happening.
MichelleWhat do you mean?
GregBy December, this is just now a few days after. Residents began reporting disturbing phone calls.
MichelleWhat? The Mothman's not calling you.
GregYeah, on the phone.
MichelleUh-uh. Hey, ring ring, there's the Mothman. Rang rang. Nuh-uh. I already blocked him.
BobbyHe would be he'd hit you up on the two-way.
MichelleNope. I already blocked him.
GregYeah, you can't star 69 news. Yeah, yeah, that's great.
MichelleOh, I didn't know Mothman was on the phone. Fuck. All right, tell me.
GregThe calls they came in late at night at the worst fucking times. Creep. People answered. They said they heard mechanical voices crackling through the line. What are you wearing? Kind of, dude. Like you're not far off. But here's the weird thing. They knew what you were wearing. Oh you look hot in that. It was like long stretches of uh like static, then punctuated with like like strange phrases. And one particular case was interesting. Mary Heyer, a reporter at Point Pleasant Register, began documenting the incidents. Her phone rang repeatedly at odd hours. Uh one night, while paranormal investigator John Keel was visiting her office in December. Um, the phone rang again. Heyer picked up and said hello. After a brief pause, a mechanical voice cracked through the line and said, Stop talking to your New York friend. Ooh, he cannot help you.
MichelleOh, the mothman hates Keel and it's not.
BobbyKeel's trying to take him down, dude. Keel's trying to expose him. You know what I mean?
MichelleDamn.
GregShe slammed the phone down. The voice appeared to know exactly um who it was speaking with. It like called her out by name. And then another witness named Connie Carpenter reported receiving calls in which the voice on the other line described what she was wearing, what books were sitting on her nightstand. And then disturbances escalated further into 1967. Residents began reporting visits from strange men dressed in black suits.
MichelleOh, the old men in black. We know those fucking guys.
GregWitnesses described them as pale, unnatural looking, with awkward movements and strange speech patterns. Typical. Yeah.
MichelleTypical MIB.
GregYeah.
MichelleYeah.
GregAbsolutely.
MichelleYeah.
GregOne of these encounters involved a factory worker named Roger Martin.
BobbyOh, Michelle's had like a visceral reaction to every name in the story except for that one. That one she'll allow. That one's normal. Roger Martin. She's like, no, that's fine.
MichelleConnie Connorson? Get the fuck out of here.
GregConnie, what was it? Connie Carpin.
BobbyEvery time Greg says a name, I look at Michelle and she'd be like, that's a little bit more.
GregBut the Mothman spot.
MichelleYeah, I believe that.
GregYeah, so Roger Martin had also received several of the bizarre phone calls. And one evening, a man approached him outside of his home, the visitor who wore a black suit that appeared too large for him and had the complexion of someone who had never seen sunlight.
MichelleZoot zoot, right?
GregUh he asked Martin if he enjoyed receiving messages, quote, from the other side.
MichelleWhat a weird way to phrase that, buddy. You know, do you enjoy it? Do you enjoy receiving messages? Do you?
GregYeah. Is that how you get off, Roger? Yeah.
MichelleThat's what I heard. That's what he's saying.
GregThere's like a lot of like ideas of like the men in black just coming to like they know essentially what's happening, but and they're just trying to bully you into staying. Like, just shut up. You're not gonna talk about this. And that's kind of what they do during all of this. It works. It's just like you stop fucking talking about this. And like they bully everyone who came forward that said they had an experience, they're having these phone calls, they saw this being, whatever it was. Um, they were all visited by these men in black to just tell essentially tell them to shut up.
BobbyGalaxy's not gonna defend itself.
MichelleBiggest lie of all, trying to make it seem like the men in black are our friends. They're not.
GregUh at a certain point, Martin demanded to know who he worked for, and the stranger simply smiled and walked away. Said nothing.
MichelleThat was it. I'm gonna do that to somebody sometime.
GregAround the same time, uh, residents also reported seeing black sedans parked outside their homes. Inside the vehicle, shadowy figures sat motionless watching the houses.
BobbyI know you don't have like access to the historic whole historical record of everything that ever happened, but like, is this I do.
MichelleIt's called the internet.
BobbyIs this the first like kind of like widely known reference to men in black? Or have I I know there's many throughout the years, but is this the first one that we are aware of?
GregUm I think on on this sort of level, like they they were always around when like like uh paranormal things happened and whenever like people went to the news and it was being reported on. Yeah, because back then too, like the but even pre pre-1966, yeah, there are reports of there were reports of like people like they were I don't think they were labeled as men in black until like government men showing up the G-man showing up telling people to fucking shut up. I got you. Okay.
MichelleUm my uncle took a picture of the men in black in New Brunswick, New Jersey. It's uh like a really famous, like the first photo of the men in black taken.
BobbyOh, yeah, I've seen that photo. It's they were just creepy. They were lurking on them. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
MichelleIt's crazy. Well, it's true. All this is true, except the names. The names are fake.
BobbyYeah, have they been changed to protect the innocent?
MichelleYeah, well, you're supposed to say that in the beginning. Okay. Okay.
GregOur protagonist, John Keel, himself experienced strange events. Uh one night he returned to his motel room to find his door slightly open. Uh, nothing appeared stolen, but his notes had been like disturbed and gone through. Of course. And meanwhile, the sightings of the winged creature were still happening. Like all of this is kind of now happening together at the same time.
MichelleThere's a lot. Yes, a lot of stuff going on right now.
GregThis story has so much. It's one thing when you have a uh something paranormal happening or something happening to this level where it's just like, oh, it's here's the thing, and that thing happened. This has like a lot of things wrapped into one. Um, drivers then traveling near the TNT area again reported glimpsing this beast standing beside the road or perched in trees. Uh, several witnesses claim they saw it rise straight up into the air without moving its wings. And then by 1967, sightings near the silver bridge became more and more common. Truck drivers reported seeing a large dark figure sitting high above the roadway on the steel structure of the bridge. Some said they heard faint rustling sounds over overhead as if wings were brushing against the metal beams. Then came December 15th, 1967. It was a cold Friday evening. Oh my. During the Christmas shopping season, uh, traffic moved steadily across the summer bridge as residents traveled between Point Pleasant and Gallipolis. And exactly at 5 04 in the evening, the bridge suffered a catastrophic and cascading failure and collapsed.
BobbyDamn, dude. Was anybody on it? Yes. Christmas traffic.
GregChristmas traffic. No. Witnesses described hearing a sharp metallic crack followed by a thunderous roar as the entire structure gave way. Cars and trucks plunged into the icy waters of the Ohio River below. Forty-six people lost their lives in this disaster. Mothman?
MichelleNo, be nice.
GregInvestigators later determined that the collapse was caused by the failure of a single steel I bar uh within the suspension chain of the bridge, causing a complete failure of the structure.
MichelleI'm sorry. You can fuck up one piece and the whole thing will fall down.
GregI think if it's uh I'm I'm pretty certain it was a suspension bridge. And that's like one of those things, like just one, it just be everything becomes off and things start breaking, and then it becomes a cascade effect.
MichelleBummer, dude. This um this was really all fun and games until you killed a bunch of people, and now I'm bugged.
GregThat's kind of where the story goes. And um, there's a little bit more, obviously, but this is the the mythos of the Mothman.
MichelleYeah, yeah. The way I remember this story that I was gonna say earlier that was like one sentence long, I just like forgot that people died, you know? I was like uh like a bridge fell, and there is uh Mothman.
BobbyPerhaps the frequency with which Nikola Tesla was trying to split his building and the world in half, the high wine of the Mothman's frequency, perhaps to compromise the structural integrity of the bridge.
MichelleNo, I think he was up there like uh with a cutting torch? Like, no, more like a shawl shank, like a little bit at a time, just file like that one eye bar a little bit at a time, a little bit at a time. And every night everyone's like, I see the fucking Mothman up there. I mean, what's he doing? Yeah, he's uh sabotaging.
GregWell, for the people of Point Pleasant, another fact stood out as clear as the eyes of the Mothman itself. After the collapse of the Silver Bridge, the sightings of the Mothman stopped immediately. There were no more reports of red eyes in the woods, no more winged figures near the TNT area, no more shapes perched on buildings. Even the mysterious men in black seemed to vanish. The phone calls ceased, the black sedans were no longer seen. It was as if the strange presence that had haunted Point Pleasant for more than a year had simply completed its purpose and moved on. To this day, no one can say with certainty what the people of Point Pleasant experienced during those months between November of 66 and December of 67. Some believe the creature was an unknown animal or um just a misidentified bird. Others believe it was something far stranger, a messenger, or perhaps something that only appears when disaster is already on its way.
MichelleHere's what I like to believe two things. Yeah, you know what? I have to say I have Googled many times in my life in the last two years when I first found out about the harpy eagle. What I choose to believe is there was a tragic bridge failure, and a harpy eagle happened to be flying around at that time.
BobbyWhat about injured Cole?
MichelleThat was probably a lie.
BobbyAnd the phone calls and the men in black.
MichelleYeah, that was probably the same guy who is like, I'm gonna dress in black, I'm gonna call people and be a scary boys.
BobbyWhat about what about bandit? Where's bandit? The harpy eagle guy?
MichelleNo, bandit is free range now, dude. He ran. He totally took his opportunity to get out of there. Yeah, yeah, totally. I mean, Google Harpy Eagle and tell me that thing ain't fucking what we're talking about right now.
BobbyIt is crazy looking.
MichelleIt is insane. I don't know if it can do the no flapping of the wings move, but like, and I don't know if its eyes are red, but it is terrifying.
BobbyIt can be big and scary as hell. Yeah, it's big and scary as fuck.
MichelleYeah, that'll that'll shake up a whole town for sure. Okay, so that's option one for me. Um, option two is all of this is true. And the Mothman is a good guy, and he was trying to warn us. He's like, How long do I have to sit on this bridge? Yeah, for these five. Am I not scary? Exactly. Yeah, get out of here. This is a bad bridge.
GregThat's what uh a lot of people think, too, where he is like a harbinger.
MichelleYeah.
GregHe's just trying, he's uh essentially there. I I'm labeling it as a he, um, but it's there to try a lady. We all know it. Essentially give warning, but uh also if it's just ambivalent and it's just there to watch or something.
MichelleOh yeah, that's a Greg move right there.
GregI think in the movie too, it's kind of funny how they they place it or like they word it, but like imagine um trying to explain yourself to a cockroach. Yeah, and it's just like why doesn't like this just come out and tell us what what's gonna happen or try to and it's like it doesn't have the communication or the ability to do that, it just kind of knows and it's just there to watch it. Okay, yeah, because and that's like the basic story, and it's abbreviated for sure. I would definitely recommend everyone doing their own little research and find all the information they can because it it's a it is a really fascinating story.
BobbyAs our resident mothman expert, Greg.
GregYeah.
BobbyWhat do you think? What do you think, Evan? What's going on? I have a lot of ideas as to what it could be. What do you believe to be true in your heart? Top three, and also what you believe to be true in your heart.
GregUh top three, it was there is something there. It could be an interdimensional thing, it could be something just looks a certain way that might be familiar to us, so it doesn't scare the shit out of us. Um, so it takes the shape of something, even though it's like, oh, this won't be scary, and it's just immediately fucking scary to everybody.
MichelleIt's like some AI shit, got it really wrong.
GregLike it needs to take a shape to exist like on this plane or something. Then there's also the idea of it just being collective fear. I have this idea of it like mass hysteria. Yeah, like it's being seeded to people of like what this thing looks like. So everyone's going to start seeing it. And then you institute this fear into people, and now more people are just imagining it and seeing it. And then there's this collective fear that happens. And like if there are people like the men in black showing up, if there were out-of-towners, there's a business meeting somewhere nearby, and like there's just these weird people that are in suits, and like your brain is immediately like they're not supposed to be here. This is a weird thing that's happening.
MichelleUm, and then God forbid one of them's like autistic and smiles weird.
GregYeah, yeah. And also likes making prank phone calls.
BobbyI did stay at a hotel once on like a business trip, and at the same hotel at the time, unbeknownst to us, was PirateCon. So just walking around the hotel was a lot of pirates and wenches. And this was just happening, but my favorite part was that it was in Denver, which is very far from the sea.
MichelleFrom water of any kind, yeah. Pirate con. Yeah. Um that's so crazy. Being from New York City, I wouldn't even blink an eye.
GregYeah. Yeah, we have all kinds, we have like furry conventions.
BobbyThere's Comic Con, there's SantaCon, there's but I could see that if you don't have access to the internet, as it were, or you know, the the happenings in the the local paper, the little nickel, if there was a just some sort of convention nearby. You're seeing all this like surplus of businessmen that's uncharacteristic. I could see you taking note of that and that's strange and seems strange.
GregBut yeah, there it there's just so much of the story though that's just bizarre and multiple people saying multiple things before like the word got out about it. Like not multiple things, but like multiple people saying the same thing.
MichelleMultiple reports before it was like in the new knowledge. Yeah, yeah.
GregSo like that's the one thing that like would like tear a hole in that other right idea that I'm having.
MichelleRight. You can't have mass hysteria if the masses don't know about it first. Well, let's mass hysteria is the only way that I can like make sense of what you're saying. Because it's yeah, uh that's kind of the way I'm thinking of it. Yeah. Okay, cool.
GregJust made sure it's and like with that, like let's uh I will now we can dive deep, not deep, but we'll get a little bit into the world tour.
MichelleOh, right. You said that he wants okay, so okay, all right. So he leaves West Virginia and goes off somewhere in the world.
GregOkay, I'm done here.
MichelleDon't he's opening for the stuff. Yeah, got it.
BobbyOkay, he's like, I'm too big for this town.
MichelleThat's right.
GregIt's like the way like Acid used to follow uh the Grateful Dead through the country. Yeah, it's just the moth man's there and then fucking disasters everywhere.
MichelleMan, give it to me.
GregAll right, so first we're gonna jump pretty quick up to 1985. September 19th, 1985. Mexico City, shortly before there's an earthquake. Um, witnesses reported seeing a large winged humanoid silhouette moving through the skyline. Description matched earlier Mothman reports with massive wings, dark humanoid shape, silent flight. We're gonna skip ahead now to 1986. Workers at the Chernobyl nuclear plant reported seeing a large winged creature flying above reactor 4 in the days before the explosion. Some workers also reported disturbing nightmares, strange phone calls, sightings of glowing red eyes and like above the plant structures. And then the sightings reportedly stopped right after the Chernobyl meltdown. We're going to jump a little bit ahead to something a little more local. The summer of 2001, prior to September 11th, there's an account that describes a woman seeing a winged figure standing atop a construction crane overlooking Manhattan facing the World Trade Center.
BobbyNot if man work for Al-Qaeda.
GregBefore it flew east towards the East River. The sighting was briefly described online before disappearing. Researcher Timothy Green Beckley uh remarks about seeing uh these types of patterns and sightings before disaster with when these winged watchers appear, history is about to turn a very dark page. We're gonna skip ahead to 2011, to Fukushima, Japan. Witnesses reported seeing large large winged shadows moving across industrial areas near the coast before the March 11th, 2011 earthquake, tsunami, and nuclear disaster. Descriptions again matched the earlier reports. Moving ahead a little bit, there are, I don't know why, but there are a ton of sightings and Chicago. Whoa. I don't know what it is.
BobbyA lot of tall buildings to perch upon.
GregIt's it's literally from 2017 to like today. They they span a weird amount of time.
BobbyYou got a sweet relocation package. Yeah, he loves the Chicago area. Yeah, a lot of the deep dish. Yeah.
GregA lot of the documentation comes from investigator Lon Strickler at the website Phantoms and Monsters. More than 100 sightings have been reported since 2017. Descriptions of the creature remain remarkably consistent with the original Mothman reports. Witnesses describe a large winged humanoid, six to eight feet tall, wingspan estimated between 10 and 15 feet, dark gray or black body, sometimes glowing red eyes, silent flight, ability to rise vertical into the air. The first major modern sighting was at O'Hare Airport, November 7th, 2017, about 6:30 p.m. Uh, two airline employees working near a cargo building at O'Hare. Uh the workers reported seeing a large dark humanoid creature with enormous wings standing near a fence, just chilling. What year is this?
Michelle2017. Is this on camera? This has got to be on many, many cameras.
BobbyI was just wondering if this was around the time that there were all those uh Rocket Man sightings at LAX. Oh, yeah, I remember that. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
GregGuy flying his little jetpack. Yeah. Perhaps a mothman. Yeah. You know?
MichelleOkay. I was like, I don't know what you're talking about, but I I do.
GregThese workers said when it noticed them, the creature spread its wings and shot straight up into the sky. Without flapping them to show.
MichelleStop doing that. I don't like that part.
GregYeah, they said the uh the wings did not flap. The vertical takeoff detail was one of the most commonly repeated, repeated items or elements of the whole Chicago sighting stories.
MichelleEveryone's story seems to have that really disturbing fact in there. I don't like it.
GregI won't dive too deep into all of them, but then there was the Lincoln Park sightings. Lincoln Park, not the not the band, the area of Chicago. But that was in the spring of 2018. The Clyborne Corridor sighting, that was in April of 2018. Again, all these stories all say the same thing. It was just a large black winged humanoid standing near a warehouse or like on the road, or it all of them are the same sighting.
BobbyBlue collar, man of the people, mothman of the people. Mothman warehouses.
GregThen there was on the Chicago Lake front trail, August of 2019. Mothman getting fit.
MichelleYeah, he's just doing his walking routine. Surely, yeah. Gotta have a routine, guys.
BobbyGet those steps in. Flying doesn't count.
MichelleFlying doesn't count.
GregYeah.
MichelleEspecially when you don't have to flap.
GregThat's right. And one of the more later ones, I I know there was one a couple years ago. Wait, it was on the news.
MichelleWhat was he doing on the trail? Just being there?
GregJust being there.
MichelleOkay.
GregYeah.
MichelleOkay, fine.
GregSo what so on the trail? It was two cyclists riding along the lakefront uh reported seeing a huge winged creature gliding over the water before turning towards the city skyline. They scribe they described the wingspan as larger than a large bird or bat, and said the creature appeared humanoid in shape.
MichelleUh they suck at telling me size. Just saying.
Greg2020, back at O'Hare, just another dark-winged figure flying near the runways. Yeah, uh for whatever reason, a lot of these sightings are in Chicago. And there are actually a ton more. I just wanted to give some sort of an example. Um, that it did show up two places right before disasters. Yeah. I don't think anything catastrophic is yet to happen in Chicago, but it seems like there might be something coming soon.
MichelleRight.
GregUm, and I know there were yeah, there was one like a couple years ago. I remember it being on the news, and I was like, yo, like yeah, like the fact that it was even like on the news was was kind of crazy. Right, it being labeled as Mothman.
MichelleYeah, I think I might be having a false memory, but I fucking remember that. I do want to or maybe I don't.
GregI do just want to end all of this with a little quote from John Keel himself. Um, the universe does not exist as we think it exists, we do not exist as we think we exist.
MichelleDamn, damn, that's good.
GregYeah, yeah, there is there are a lot of like wild stories out there. It's one of those things too. Like I it's hard to parse out like what's fake, what's not. And again, going back to the idea of like kind of being pre-programmed with this idea, it's in our it's in like our subconscious now, and now we just want to see that. So anything that looks weird, I think people are going to just like attach right this like iconic idea to it. And it doesn't necessarily and it could be a bird, it could be whatever, especially given how many sightings, especially in Chicago, there might be some fucking giant bird flying around.
MichelleBut I mean it's big old scary harpy eagle.
BobbyThey do have some pretty awesome gargoyles in Chicago. Yeah, so maybe they're coming to life. That's a whole nother story. Yeah, yeah, absolutely. Separate episode.
MichelleMm-hmm. Gargoyles are gold.
BobbyYeah, but yeah, I mean, it's such an interesting quote by by John Keely, you know, and there's like does seem like the way we exist in the world and the way that we use our brains is a is a fraction of both.
GregOh, definitely.
BobbyYeah.
GregYeah. And like everything is way more interesting.
MichelleIsn't that a fact though? Like, I've I feel like I remember learning in like elementary school science that we only use like a the 10% of our brain.
GregI think that's I think it's just like a weird saying.
MichelleAnother lie they fucking told me.
BobbyWell, they do say that, but I mean it's like how do you it's how do you immeasurable? Yeah, you know, like we do I do think we use not it to its full capacity by a large degree.
GregI think definitely we use our entire brain, but I think for individual tasks, we use smaller, we use different areas of brain. So we're we're probably only using that that phase. 10% at a time. 10% at a time. But like the reason we have areas of our brain is because we need that area of our brain for something.
MichelleI really thought we would be ultra. Like, I really thought if we could use more of our brain, we'd like uh ultra.
BobbyTime traveler, shapeshifter. Perhaps they're just using their whole brain.
MichelleThat's what I mean. That's that yeah, that's right. Yeah, that's a person using their whole brain.
BobbyYeah, applying themselves.
MichelleI like to think that I'm not a person that needs things to be explained, but apparently I do. I need to fix something to to make order in this chaos that we call life. Yeah, and so I choose that all of these things are just people using their whole brain. Most things.
BobbyI like, yeah, that's a that's a real positive outlook on on all these, you know, is that these are just real, you know, super superhumans, you know, operating at a really high level.
MichelleThat's right.
BobbyLiving their life to the fullest.
MichelleWell, damn, you really got me.
GregYeah, there's a personal mantra I use just for myself throughout like life in general, but it's like expect nothing and receive everything. So it's just like I don't know what's about to happen. I don't every time I wake up, it's like it's it's going to be fascinating, regardless of what it is I'm doing. And then because I go into everything with that outlook, everything becomes awesome. Right.
MichelleEverything is awesome, everything is cool when you're Greg.
GregBut yeah, it's just I don't think a lot of people take the time to like appreciate stuff. So like when information like these stories come out, like they want to just dismiss it. Right. It's bullshit. Yeah. And it's like, if it's not, it's or life is like kind of awesome and interesting, and it's just weirder than we ever thought we would ever know.
MichelleYeah. I love it. The power of gratitude and positivity. Power of positivity. That's what I think I'm trying to say.
GregWe can also say if you've ever seen the Mothman, oh my god, call us. Please, yeah, please call us. Yeah, give us tell us a story. Just give us a a qu a quick little glimpse into what happens. Call the strange exchange. It's 929-445-3705. Just let us know. Yeah. If there's something flying around your house, you see red eyes. You know, if it's not a bird or you don't know what it is, just give us a little shout. Just give us a leave us a message. I need to know.
MichelleAlso, buy wings before the fall by Ky Larson.
GregKyle Larson has a lot of information in his book too. Yeah. Um, you can find that on conspiracyjournal.com and Amazon.com.
MichelleThat's right. That's right. Friend of the pod, Kyle Larson. Yep, yep, yep. I think uh I think that's it for me. How about you, Bobby?
BobbyI I love this story. Uh I love the Mothman. I think it's super interesting. And uh yeah, if you're if you're a little bit of a wanderer, if you're out and about in America, cruise on through Point Pleasant, West Virginia. You won't regret it.
MichelleOh, yeah, right on.
GregAll right, maybe a big uh Mothman Festival. Mothmanfestival.com. I would definitely recommend everyone go check that out. Are we gonna go this year? We should we should go this year. We should go. We should go. We'll see you there. Yeah, we'll we'll make it. We'll be around. Awesome. All right. Okay. Bye guys.