Cinema Social Club
A weekly discussion on all things moving pictures. Join us in Season One as we review every Academy Awards Best Picture winner.
Cinema Social Club
S01E04: Cimarron
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
It's our first western as we work our way through reviewing all the Oscar Best Picture winners. And let's just say there were some divided opinions among the cohosts. We also take a few moments to discuss what makes a film timeless and, as per usual, don't really come up with an answer.
Hello and welcome to Cinema Social Club. I'm Cameron, and joining me this week are Glenn, Sarah, and Elisa. And on this week's episode, we'll be looking at the fourth best picture Oscar winner and the first Western to win, Cimarron. But before we get to that, some entertainment news for you. A new song for the latest Toy Story film debuted at number one on the charts this week. It was written by a Taylor Swift. Nice to see Disney giving a break to some up-and-coming talent. The Devil Wears Prada 2 has driven the film franchise past the $1 billion mark, so prepare yourselves for the Devil Wears Prada 3, only joking it's Louis Vuitton, coming soon to a theater near you. And finally, it's been announced that the Duffer Brothers, best known for helming the Netflix hit Stranger Things, are working on a film for Paramount, set to be released in 2028. Paramount refused to share any information other than to say it would be an event picture. What exactly is an event picture, you ask? I've got absolutely no idea. And now this week's Top 5 at the box office. At number 5, down from number 2 and fading fast, is Masters of the Universe, likely to be one of the biggest box office flops this year. It's Mattel's first movie since their huge success with Barbie. It remains to be seen how this will affect its upcoming release, Matchbox the Movie. Sadly, I am not making that up. At number four, it's the interm internet-based horror film Backrooms, which I will never see. At number three, it's the comedy horror film Scary Movie. The latest, and I would suggest not the last in that movie franchise. At number two, climbing back from number four and on a bit of a roller coaster at the box office, it's the horror movie Obsession. And finally, at number one, by a large, large margin, it's the new release from the box office certainty Steven Spielberg, the sci-fi What If Film disclosure day. And with all that out of the way, we turn to our topic of discussion for this week. And this one was provided by loyal listener Alisa, who also happens to be one of the co-hosts on this very podcast. And her question is what makes a movie timeless? And here are my co-hosts to discuss that very topic.
SPEAKER_03Dead air. I will go first. I think you should.
SPEAKER_05You looked up the word timeless, didn't you?
SPEAKER_03I did. I asked AI what makes a movie timeless.
SPEAKER_06And and the first it came up, it is without time.
SPEAKER_03The first thing it said was, and I quote very slowly. And so if these if these themes like love and you know any universal human emotion or theme is recurring, it's gonna recur through life. So if if a movie is capturing that, it's probably gonna stand the test of time. Because that that never changes.
SPEAKER_06Yeah, I can tell you from the start, love is not a universal theme. There are some of us completely devoid of that particular emotion.
SPEAKER_01And I have more to add when everyone's no no no no I was gonna say. Well, I mean, I I agree with that to a certain extent. I don't think that a movie having universal themes of the human experience automatically makes it timeless because I think the human experience is directly correlated to the time in which a human is experiencing it. So there are certain love stories and certain, you know, justice stories and revenge, like all of those things, those deep raw emotions that do directly link to the time period in which they were experienced that might not hit as much now. And that's not always true. Because, like for me, one of the examples I thought of was like, and this is purely subjective, but like 2005's Pride and Prejudice, I consider to be a pretty timeless film because it has great messaging that I think can be applied to a lot of different time periods, and I think that it's a great message.
SPEAKER_06Also based on a timeless book.
SPEAKER_01It is, and that's the thing. I think the source content has to be considered because it is timeless literature, and therefore the translation was inevitably going to have that, if it was done well, would have that same essence.
SPEAKER_05But what about it makes it timeless? Is it the story? Is it the characters? Is it the recurring themes that all humans have had over millennia? What is it?
SPEAKER_03I can go ahead and say it's probably all of that.
SPEAKER_01I would yeah, I would say it's a mix of everything with those things. And I think, because I don't necessarily think that a movie, like specifically Elizabeth's story, for in for example, in Pride and Prejudice, like yes, like clinging hard to this pride and prejudice. But just like, yes, specifically, she is looking for like she's being pressured to find a husband. That is the particular moment of the time. But what is happening and what the story is about is getting out of your own way and being willing to be open to the whether it's love, acceptance, friendship, anything, getting out of those prejudices. And I think that's the part that feels really timeless is that message because that can be applied anytime.
SPEAKER_06My only thing here is I I feel like 95, 98% of all films have some sort of universal emotion in them because that's just what Hollywood does. And that's not, I mean, there's not 95% of timeless films. No, it's also Caddyshack, which have absolutely no universal emotions in them, but are also a timeless film because it's Caddyshack.
SPEAKER_01So there's yeah, I don't think timeless and quality are mutually exclusive, right?
SPEAKER_05And then there's a broad, there's a broader sense to what is timeless, obviously, um, just the human experience. And then you have the narrower parts of varied various human experiences that can be timeless. Um, that I think that's what because it's a it's a really it's a great question to ask, first of all. It's a really difficult one to pin down because it's not one thing. No, absolutely.
SPEAKER_03It's not. And the discussion I had with my friend on the train, shout out to Wendy. Shout out to you.
SPEAKER_05Hi, Wendy.
SPEAKER_03We talked about it, and and that's what we said. We we came up with a couple things, and she was like, but what about the characters? But what about the plot? And and we decided, yeah, it has to encompass a lot of things. Just about anything.
SPEAKER_05I mean, if you go back to the earliest, you know, Greek plays, you know, there are there are things that happen in them, there are characters and archetypes that still exist in stories now. Correct. In a way we retell the same stories, but for a different audience and for a different uh set of ethos and tenets and ethics and morals.
SPEAKER_03And that that's another thing in and of itself, is that if people are remaking the movie with the newer um technology and characters and and and all that, if it's remakable, they probably thought pretty highly of it, you know.
SPEAKER_01Or or they recognize it as a mass popular movement.
SPEAKER_05There's also a cash grab factor to that. But that's not always true. That doesn't mean it's not timeless.
SPEAKER_01100%. Yeah.
SPEAKER_06So well, they also remake bad movies.
SPEAKER_05Yeah. Yeah. But uh there and I was listening to a different podcast today and uh Ben Mankowitz was having a conversation with Sally Field about timeless films, and they they brought up Gone with the Wind, and they said it has they have both of them have many issues with Gone with the Wind in that what was appropriate, what they felt was appropriate in that while they were making that movie. But they felt that the story in that was absolutely timeless. The story about uh individualism in hardship, war, how people cope, um, a strong female character that again has been happening in in uh sh uh movies and plays since Greek trag tragedies. Um so it's it's timeless, but at the same time, there's issues with it. Sure. You know, it's kind of funny. So you yeah, I I thought it was really hard to pin this one down, but worth talking about.
SPEAKER_06I mean, at the end of the day, it also, like everything else in life, it boils down largely to luck because 100%. Whether your film is remembered is based on whether it was successful at the time, whether it was critically successful at the time, and all of that is a crapshoot. I mean, because there are very well-made films that were forgotten about because they didn't have the luck of being a gone with the wind that for some random reason is Jezebel, which is a very similar film to Gone with the Wind, and I would argue a better film than Gone with the Winds.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, maybe even a better film.
SPEAKER_06Mostly forgotten. Yeah, I mean, it's still held up by the sort of film nerd people, but I mean it's not Gone with the Winds.
SPEAKER_05Yeah.
SPEAKER_01But I also think like I I would be willing to bet that if you asked a room of people whether or not they thought Star Wars was a timeless film, they would say yes. And I think it would largely be due to the cultural impact that it had at the time and the legacy that that then created. Because I mean that's a film that generationally people talk about and experience.
SPEAKER_06Well, and arguably it's not a great film. I mean, exactly. That's what I mean. Like it's not a great film, right? It's not great, but it would be timeless.
SPEAKER_01It would be considered timeless. So I don't think quality is necessarily as big a factor in timelessness, especially when you're looking at older, some older films.
SPEAKER_05What's funny, and it I'm sorry, it reminded me, it's making me go back to Gone with the Wind again. Sure. Gone with the Wind was timeless for decades, but it's in a way it stopped being quote unquote timeless because of the ethics involved and how much society was unwilling to overlook the dark parts of that.
SPEAKER_04Yes.
SPEAKER_05And you have a movie like Star Wars, okay, it's it's not gonna suffer the same problem. It won't, no. You know, it's so funny because it'll it may suffer different problems.
SPEAKER_06Well, not the first Star Wars film. Yeah, some of them start suffering from that period.
SPEAKER_05But both of them are like timeless, but for completely different reasons, and and then they can they can be forgotten, you know.
SPEAKER_06Well, there's also cultural culturally significant films that aren't timeless. Birth of a nation arguably is a culturally significant film, yeah, but I would argue not timeless.
SPEAKER_01100%.
SPEAKER_06Yeah.
SPEAKER_05And it goes hand in hand with movies that simply don't age well. And yes. There you go.
SPEAKER_06Yeah. Well, and a lot of films that don't age well probably weren't that great to begin with. Right. I mean, the reason Birth of a Nation is good is because it's technically well made.
SPEAKER_05Right.
SPEAKER_06The the the story behind it is now reprehensible and sort of reprehensible then, sure, but it's technically very well done. Well, it's the same with Lenny Rufenstall and her film German Nazi films, yeah, which are horrible propaganda for the Nazis, but are really well made.
SPEAKER_05Yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. I would consider a lot of Pixar and Disney films to be pretty timeless. I mean, you look at something like Toy Story, I don't think that anyone could really look at Toy Story 50, 60, some odd years from now and find reasons to dislike it. Although I mean the core message is important.
SPEAKER_06Toy Story may start to suffer by the fact they're making so many.
SPEAKER_01And that will be the issue with Toy Story is the fact that we're now on like five.
SPEAKER_06I think they're slightly they're oversaturating the market.
SPEAKER_01But if you go back to that first one, or like Monsters Inc. or show like those first movies that really kind of capture the magic, I hesitate to go older Disney because then you do get into the issues of just the fact that, you know, you look at Dumbo, for example, and all those types of films. There is a lot in old school Disney that is now really not culturally acceptable.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_01But you look at something like Beauty and the Beast. I mean, I as a 30-year-old watch that and still really love it. And there is just something really magical about it that's but you're also very sad. I am true. I am. I am a sad millennial, and I really respond to those films.
SPEAKER_05It's all right. I I get it. I get it. I go to Bad for Bambi. I'll go to Bad for Bambi every time.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, there's a deal.
SPEAKER_06I would argue Bambi of the Walt Disney films is not the timeless one of the early ones. Is that right? I don't think so. I think it's more like a Snow White, is the timeless.
SPEAKER_05How about that?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I would say it would probably land somewhere in like Snow White would be considered. I mean, a lot of people have seen Bambi. Bambi is definitely one of those ones that you cannot escape seeing as a child. I think everyone at some point has been exposed to it. But in terms of the ones that you like really talk about going into adulthood and the ones that continue to be retold, it's like Cinderella, Beauty and the Beast, like all of those timeless fairy tale stories that again, the messaging is like a bit questionable in places, but it has managed to remain a classic.
SPEAKER_06This is slightly off topic, but correct me if I'm wrong, Beauty and the Beast is not that old a Disney film, right? It is now. It's like the 90s, though. Yeah. It's not like it's not old.
SPEAKER_01There's a big, big gap.
SPEAKER_06Well, and at the end of the day, Bambi is timeless in as much as any film from that era that's still talked about is by definition timeless.
SPEAKER_05And the reason I called Bambi timeless is because it contains what's known as a hero's uh journey. And that's as old as stories. Absolutely.
SPEAKER_06Well, and they just asked a trivia question about it at trivia the other night. What was the first word that Bambi spoke in the film? First word.
SPEAKER_01I'm I shouldn't have this. I was gonna say, wasn't it mom or mother?
SPEAKER_05No, it isn't. It's um it was not it wasn't pretty. Um was it flower? No, what was it? Bird, bird, bird.
SPEAKER_03Look at that. Yeah, would you ever equate rewatchability with timeless, as in like Jaws? Again, it doesn't have to be rewatchable. Is that immediately timeless?
SPEAKER_05I think if it's highly rewatchable, there's some element of timelessness to it. I don't know if it's the same as I I don't know. I mean to I to me, yes. There has to be some element of timelessness to it.
SPEAKER_01I think rewatchability is a lot more subjective. Right. Well, let's be honest, timelessness is. I think there's some with timelessness that just sort of like gone with the wind. Perfect example. I have no interest in seeing that film again. I saw it one time and I was like, that is more than enough for me. Yeah. But I can also objectively acknowledge the timelessness of it and the cultural and social impact of it, but that does not mean I want to watch it.
SPEAKER_06I mean, 2001 is timeless, but Forest Gulf would probably be a little bit more. It also seems to take up a lot of time. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01So there I think rewatchability and enjoyment and timelessness do not necessarily go hand in hand.
SPEAKER_05Right.
SPEAKER_01But it can. Yeah.
SPEAKER_05Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_05I love the question.
SPEAKER_01It's a go, it's a hard one to answer, but it's a very good question.
SPEAKER_05I would love to hear what our audience thinks.
SPEAKER_01No, I don't. Give us some timeless examples, please.
SPEAKER_06I end up with like, uh, I think uh every Adam Sandler movie is timeless.
SPEAKER_01I mean Shrek is pretty timeless, I have to say. And I actually mean that genuinely. I think Shrek is pretty timeless. It's pretty awesome.
SPEAKER_06Timelessness is a very subjective thing in that regard.
SPEAKER_03But is it because I'm trying to think now, what if there was some type of rubric for a movie and you rated it on all of the things you think create a timeless movie?
SPEAKER_06Could you come up with a movie is what makes a timeless movie?
SPEAKER_01I think that's the thing. So then you get into like Turner classic movies, and then there are a lot like Criterion collections. It's they're all wildly based on different people's opinions, like analytical and scientific opinions, so to speak, but it's all for different reasons. So I think there are a ton of those lists settings.
SPEAKER_03Maybe we should make a list of movies.
SPEAKER_06We yeah, but that would be timeless to us. Yes, but that doesn't have timeless to the other. Oh I know.
SPEAKER_03I'm just saying, what do four the four of us think are timeless movies?
SPEAKER_06Oh, well, I guarantee you the four of us aren't going to agree on it.
SPEAKER_03But I'm excited to try. Empirically, Jaws is always mentioned. Sure. Space Odyssey is always mentioned. I would say so.
SPEAKER_06Jurassic Park, again, but then I can I can clearly admit there are people who would not find 2001 a timeless.
SPEAKER_01Oh yeah, I agree. Yeah, I agreed. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_06But I do think it's so again, I don't think there's anything you can be empirically about when it comes to whether something's time was very difficult. Yeah, very difficult.
SPEAKER_01It's a very sort of and it's also a moving target, I think. It's what? It's a moving target.
SPEAKER_06It is a moving target, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_06Well, uh, on that on that riveting conclusion to our topic that we didn't really come up with an answer for. But maybe that's the planet. That's the answer. There is no answer, is the answer. Uh, we now move on to the real meat and potatoes of this podcast, where we talk about uh the Oscar-winning picture that we watched this week. And this week it is 1931's Western Cimarron. The film is directed by one-time Charlie Chaplin shorts actor Wesley Ruggles and is based on a novel by Edna Ferber. It stars Richard Dix, one of Glenn's favoritely named actors, and Irene Dunn, and tells the story of a young couple chasing success in an Oklahoma land rush before eventually becoming a melodrama about the newspaper business. It's a film that most is most notable for being the first Western to win best picture, and also for the last Western to win best picture for 60 years until Dancing with Wolves in 1990.
SPEAKER_00My god.
SPEAKER_06It is also the first picture to win uh to be nominated for every category at the Academy Awards, but that's also because there was only eight categories at the time.
SPEAKER_01I was gonna say, good lord.
SPEAKER_06Um, but is this early Western still worthy of that gold statue? Well, here's what we think as we open it up the floor to my fellow co-host to give our opinions on Cimarron.
SPEAKER_01I God, okay. I mean, I know we're gonna get into our official official ratings, but one of the first things that popped into my head about this film as we were watching it was I I genuinely did not like the look of it. And it's not because it was black and white, because I love a polished, and we've watched a few gorgeous black and white films on this podcast. So that was not the problem. The set was so unbelievably chaotic. And I understand that, like, we were in the middle of the land rush, they're kind of plopping you right in there. I get, and that can work and it can be done the right way, but I don't know what was going on with the audio. I could not make heads or tails of anything that was going on for a good chunk of the first part of the film, and it was just so chaotic to look at, and for me, not in a way that was fine.
SPEAKER_06I fear we've been slightly spoiled by the fact that you know, wings and all quiet on the winter. Really good run. Not all films from 1930s, 20s, and 30s were preserved to the level of them. Uh, I will also say this film screamed of we're filming on a set, everything looked like sets rather than sort of naturalistic kind of and really compressed as a result.
SPEAKER_01Like you're so used to in a western, and I talked about this a little bit while we were watching it. But the one thing, even when it's not a great western that you can typically count on, is you're gonna have some gorgeous landscapes, it's gonna be great to look at. The costuming is typically like you just kind of expect a western to have a lot of people. Yeah, like aesthetic standard, and this just did not hit any of those notes.
SPEAKER_05Kind of honestly, you I was feeling the same thing. I was like, even when they were outside, say they were coming into town for the first time on their little wagon, it felt claustrophobic to be able to do it. Very claustrophobic. You're out in Oklahoma in the wide open west. Why does this scene feel claustrophobic?
SPEAKER_06Yes, it was also not really western. I mean, yeah, they could have changed the plot, they could have changed the characters and location of this, and it would have been basically the same film. Yeah, there's nothing particularly western about it. Yeah, other than there was a land rush at the beginning of it. Right. Yeah, which at least part was quite impressive.
SPEAKER_05At least that was outside, you know, and on a filmed on an open plane.
SPEAKER_06Famously five thousand extras is that what it was and twenty eight cameras. It looked like and the problem was the film kind of peaked there. Yeah, yeah. In the first five minutes. It was interesting.
SPEAKER_03And I think it's because when you say it, you mean the film. The film because it really, it really wasn't a western. It really hit on a lot of things that I know you're giving each other the.
SPEAKER_05No, no, no. You're gonna find out you're not alone in your opinion.
SPEAKER_03Um, I like the fact that they hit on the human emotions and the the struggles of all these people. I would put this, okay. Hold on to your campchairs. I would say this was a timeless movie.
SPEAKER_01Okay, we have not shown you enough westerns.
SPEAKER_05This movie grew on me. I did not like it at the beginning. I was confused by characters. I didn't like the fact that it felt claustrophobic. I didn't like the way it sounded, I didn't like the way it looked, I didn't like the way the characters were acting, but as the movie progressed, I found myself actually enjoying it.
SPEAKER_06I was interested in it. The look of confusion on Sarah's.
SPEAKER_05This is why they make chocolate and vanilla and strawberries. That's totally fair.
SPEAKER_06And this is very vanilla.
SPEAKER_05I found it growing on me. Interesting. I found the characters changed enough. And now some of the character arcs not so believable, others maybe a little bit more so. But I did find myself enjoying the movie and thinking the first of all, I like Irene Dunn. I've seen her in more movies than this. Sure. Always thought she was a great actress, always thought she was beautiful. Did not like her at the beginning of this. Um, but as as time went on, I did see her her character arc changing, and the way she was acting made to me made it believable. Like I believe she was changing more so than you guys did as as she was making her changes.
SPEAKER_06I mean, I think she changed, she just changed so abruptly. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Well, it's only a two-hour move.
SPEAKER_06Yeah, I mean yeah, but it was literally like one day.
SPEAKER_05She was like, Well, I was I was I was okay. There were there were times when you weren't sure. She was she was pondering back and forth. That one that one scene where we weren't sure if she was angry or if she was buying into it. Sure. I think she was in her mind, in the character's mind, she was bouncing back and forth, ended up landing on anger, but she was beginning to change. And that's what I that's why I'm thinking I liked this as it progressed. I I just did.
SPEAKER_01And I think, and I think Cameron will agree with me on this, because I do think that this was trying to be a Western. I don't think it was trying to be anything but a Western. I think it failed in that attempt. And I have seen Westerns that are extremely effective character studies, first case in point, open range. Yes, that is a western that is not a typical Western because it is much more about the characters and the journey of those characters and the arcs and the minds changed, and that is how you tell a character-driven Western. This did not have that for me.
SPEAKER_05See, I didn't feel like it was a Western after once it got as a Western.
SPEAKER_01I think that's why I figured I liked it because it really wasn't a lot of things.
SPEAKER_06To me, it changed. Sarah says I'll agree with her. I don't agree with her on that. I probably do agree with her that it is shockingly terrible. Yeah, I just like to do it. And I don't believe there's any character arcs. I think they are about as one note character as you can pass. That is possible.
SPEAKER_01That's kind of how I felt. Like the moments with um the like the main characters Yancy, which is an insane name, but the moments with Yancy where he had the chance to actually sort of have some solid dialogue and we got to hear his beliefs and ideals. I was 100% on board for him. I thought he was great. The actor and the delivery made it almost impossible for me to root for him. Yeah. And I also like, yes, he's a good person, but also he disappeared for like a decade and a half. Like, yeah, for a period of five years he was fighting the war, but then he literally disappeared for long enough for it to have an industrial. He's just gone.
SPEAKER_05There is, and we and you missed it.
SPEAKER_01Is it just that he's called to the West again? Because that's not an impressive expensive.
SPEAKER_05You caught it when he called her Penelope. You you caught it when when he called his wife Penelope, and that is the name of Odysseus's wife when he goes off on his Odyssey. And that's that's what he was, that's who he was. See, and that to me because Odysseus was successful. He was successful, huh? Sure.
SPEAKER_03That is who he was. He was a go-getter, a pioneer in the truest sense of the word, and he was that's I thought I was going to make it in in life.
SPEAKER_01But he didn't. But he did, but he didn't. His wife had his legacy.
SPEAKER_05But he he made it in his own way.
SPEAKER_01I think my biggest issue with it is that we don't see any of that journey of his. He's just gone. And I fully appreciate the like cultural.
SPEAKER_05Because we're seeing it from the standpoint of his family.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and I fully appreciate the cultural reference of the story of Penelope and Orpheus. But that right there, to me, is the ultimate Western archetype. Is the guy who has that manifest destiny and runs off, like so that is the ultimate earmark of a cowboy western, is the cowboy who just can't be tamed. That's the entire point of the title. So you can't lean on these western ideal like ideas, but then fall flat.
SPEAKER_05Well, that's why I think that's why I don't call it a Western so much.
SPEAKER_01And that's totally fair. And for me, I see that as a failed attempt and not a pivot, not a creative pivot.
SPEAKER_05I love it. This is good.
SPEAKER_03This is interesting. You could have you could have put all those dynamics in a completely different setting. It didn't have to be the wild west.
SPEAKER_06Yeah, that was not a positive for me.
SPEAKER_04I wasn't putting that up as a positive.
SPEAKER_05I think this this explains why this movie is kind of universally disliked because it couldn't, it didn't seem to land on any one thing. It did win the Oscar that year, but it's considered one of the worst movies to win.
SPEAKER_06We also have to remember Glenn was alive when it was made. So he has his life with a review point.
SPEAKER_05I mean, and I did I did invest, I was one of the executive producers, actually.
SPEAKER_06Yeah, yeah. And my problem with the main character, Yansey, and again, well, the problem was with Sarah, half the time I sort of was getting into his acting, was getting better. But then it would just go shift back into like old school, broad, silent movie acting. Yeah. And he also the makeup jobs were bad. They would be not going to be able to do that. I mean the one thing I will give this movie that I thought was impressive was the aging progress.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, the age progression was.
SPEAKER_06They did actually look like older versions of themselves.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, without being silly, but without looking very weird. I I I kept watching um him in this uh the uh Yancey and thinking, boy, I wish Jimmy Stewart would have been around to give this this role a trunk. I really thought like Jimmy Stewart could have nailed a role like that.
SPEAKER_03I also like the way a lot of things we were picking out and and poking fun of was you know, oh, the racism, um, you know, the the political stuff that was going on. It transcended time in that we're we're still now dealing with stuff again. We're dealing with that. Sure. We're dealing with the the the dirty politics, yeah, you know, just again, timeless right.
SPEAKER_05And we're and yeah, and the fact that Yancey's character was a progressive in that one. You want to step up to the bat on this one, Sarah? Do you want me to make it or do you want me to be like?
SPEAKER_01Like the like the Isaiah character, for example. Identifying that racism exists does not make a film timeless, especially if you are playing into a lot of the stereotypes, which is what Isaiah was doing. That character.
SPEAKER_05They weren't supporting those stereotypes.
SPEAKER_01They weren't, but they were using them. And I'm not saying that it's they were pro or against it, but I don't think. Absolutely, but I also don't think that that makes a movie timeless having those themes because it doesn't matter if it's timeless or not.
SPEAKER_03But it's re it's revisited again today. Because the problem has not been solved, right?
SPEAKER_06Yeah, it's revisited today in much better films. We've come so far.
SPEAKER_01We're not talking about all films, we're talking about this film. Sure.
SPEAKER_05Yeah.
SPEAKER_01And it did, it had a lot of themes that are still relevant today.
SPEAKER_05I do think that's another reason I liked it, it is because actually this was a pretty progressive, in my opinion, this was a pretty progressive film and and politically progressive, which was probably a pretty dangerous thing in the uh year that it came out.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. And it was far from perfect. Oh, yeah, yeah. I mean, I'm sure when we get into our ratings, you know, I I agree with a lot of what you're saying.
SPEAKER_05I think it's I think a movie that that engenders this much debate is I that makes it more fun when it's like that. Because there's so many different facets to it that we see different ways.
SPEAKER_03I thought I was gonna be alone against three. Thank you, Glenn. I'm so glad.
SPEAKER_06Uh yeah, let's get on to our uh our four categories in which we rate films. Uh so far we have uh there's four categories. It's out of five for each categories we have to agree on a score.
SPEAKER_00We're gonna be doing some averaging. This is gonna be where I get 100%. We're gonna be in the middle.
SPEAKER_06So the best uh film can get is 20, and the worst a film can get is zero, which the Broadway melody does a real good run at. Just a reminder we have wings at 16, all quite on the Western Front at 15, and the Broadway melody coming in at a staggering 1.5. Uh, and we'll start with visuals out of five. This would encompass a lot of different things, costumes and cinematography, and see for me, this is probably the one I'm going to be the least flexible about.
SPEAKER_01I would not give this more than a two because I think visually this was kind of an absolute mess.
SPEAKER_03Visually a mess. I don't think the the cinematography was that great. No. Um I probably would give it a three.
SPEAKER_05Uh I can't go higher than two on visuals.
SPEAKER_06I I'm actually probably a bit lower. I mean, the the aside from the the aging makeup, which I thought was quite good. The problem is the rest of the makeup was shockingly bad. Yeah. And uh it was it was hard to buy. The boots were nice. The boots were so shiny.
SPEAKER_02All right, a five for the boots. Nice costume.
SPEAKER_06So I'm I'm probably at like a one. One seems harsh.
SPEAKER_05Two, second movie in a row where boots played a part.
SPEAKER_01The boots are important.
SPEAKER_06I would probably go, I would probably yeah, and they kept coming back as well. Uh so we're at about a two for visuals.
SPEAKER_01I think that feels better.
SPEAKER_06Um story. Here's where it starts to go off the rails. I mean, my main problem with the story is it started with a story and then it sort of stopped having a story after a while. Yeah, that is kind of my like there was a whole sort of you're you're up against these these bad guys, and there's some sort of thing that he wants to print in the newspaper, and I'm like, oh, so the story is they're trying to prevent him from announcing this whole, but then they sort of just they wrap it up at the first 45 minutes, and then the movie keeps going, and you're like, Well, I guess that's not the yeah, and I think and then that story sort of fell apart after that. There was really nothing else going on except he would leave, and then she would run the newspaper, and then he'd come back, and then he'd leave again. But there was no real story.
SPEAKER_01No, which is why I think the messaging of the film, there are parts of it that are very like very effective and very important and very progressive, but the the way we tie those pieces together is so important. Yeah, and we just did not do that here. There were some great scenes and essentially no storyline for me.
SPEAKER_05I think that's why we differed on whether or not we think it's a western or something else, because the story didn't really pick. Not really, and it wasn't I I the threads just came apart as the story went along or whatever we were following. Sure. Because it did, it was a different story at the beginning than the middle, than whatever it was at the end.
SPEAKER_06Very uneven time jumps as well. Because it like I will take a movie like Citizen Kane as an example, which is a sort of another movie that takes place over a large period of time, but it's a more seamless sort of travel through time. This was like the first half of the movie took place at a certain time, and then all of a sudden you were skipping all over the place, and you'd spend like five minutes in a vignette at a certain time, and then they'd skip another eight years, and you'd be in another vignette for five minutes. But it just felt like I that was the story now, was just time passing. But because you were never in a time period long enough to develop any sort of story because then they move quickly on to the next. The only real thing was the story was the development of the town, I guess. But that wasn't really yeah, there wasn't a lot of things.
SPEAKER_05And that wasn't even the story. Oh, it wasn't the story, yeah. That's so weird.
SPEAKER_01While yes, it was the only constant in the yeah, and while, yes, like the the wife ultimately did change her mind and get on the right side of it. We don't get to see any of that.
SPEAKER_05No, we didn't.
SPEAKER_01We just land there, which I think again for me is why this felt really hollow because we just end up where we ideally would like to end up. We don't see any of the actual journey to get there because to Cam's point, we have so many time.
SPEAKER_05Interestingly, that can one of the reasons I can see you would not buy her character arc would be that last change when it becomes 1929 and suddenly she's like he was at the beginning. And that's yeah, and I'm like, wait a minute, he's been gone for the last how many years. Yep. What made her change? I wanted to know that exactly. Like I was buying the little tiny changes I thought she might be having, but that wholesale swap over, and again, that has to do with story. It's like what you we you you cheated us out of whatever that story was that did this with her.
SPEAKER_06Well, and and let's not go so far as saying this was like a great feminist track either. She basically changed her name because of the greatness of her husband. Really truly, yes.
SPEAKER_01Like she was she was chasing his legacy, not her own. By her own admission, she was doing that.
SPEAKER_06Uh story.
SPEAKER_01Anyway, story.
SPEAKER_06Story revive. Sorry, we went back into general discussion.
SPEAKER_01And I'm willing to bump this, but this would probably be because of just how hard it was to kind of pull all of it together in the end. I would probably be between like a two and a half and a three.
SPEAKER_05You're actually gonna give it better than I would. Oh wow, I'm sure. I'm sure I could as as much as I overall liked it, the story was kind of hard for me to find out. I had given a two for the story.
SPEAKER_01Hey, I'll be happy to land.
SPEAKER_05I I there was a story in there that I wanted that I wished for, that I was imagining in my mind that wasn't that wasn't actually on that screen. Yes. So my story is was like a three there, but they didn't give me a three, they gave me a two.
SPEAKER_03I'm still gonna give it a three. Okay.
SPEAKER_06Okay. I'm at it. I'm again, I think I'm thinking I'm being generous with a two, but should we say two and a half?
SPEAKER_01Or two. I'm honestly fine with two.
SPEAKER_06I think it's a well, I mean, there's three twos and a three. I think on average, it's probably a two. Yeah, I think.
SPEAKER_05Oh, it's a two? Okay.
SPEAKER_06That's fine. I mean, it's like a two point one. Like not real great at maths, but we need it. Uh okay, this might be controversial.
SPEAKER_03Well, I don't know.
SPEAKER_06Acting.
SPEAKER_03Hmm. Some of it was good, some of it wasn't. Yeah, that's honestly very true.
SPEAKER_06This movie certainly had the holdout of silent movie acting still in it.
SPEAKER_03Yes, it did. It definitely did.
SPEAKER_06And there were parts of the movie where it felt like a silent, like the score would drop off, and it felt like a silent movie. Yes, we'd be like, right after the land rush when they were just sort of traveling through the country. There's like no sound at all. Yeah.
SPEAKER_05Acting was uh it was rough, it was uneven. Um I did think he got better. He got a lot of better, yes. And I don't know if that's I don't know if that was supposed to happen like for his character, or he just like got into it. Did they film this thing in sequence and he actually became a better actor?
SPEAKER_06And Irene character he choice he made to make himself seem older, yeah, made him better. I don't know.
SPEAKER_05I thought Irene Dunn was pretty steady throughout as far as her professionalism and her ability to convey, although she confused us one or two times.
SPEAKER_06So well, I think that's the difference between acting and the words she's been given to say. Yeah, I think she was given anything to work with. I agree with that.
SPEAKER_05So I mean I think the acting was pretty good for me. Uh I it's some of the better acting we've seen so far in the movies that we've watched. So I would have to give it a three overall.
SPEAKER_03I liked her, I liked uh Saul Levy. I thought he was pretty sick. Saul was great. Honestly, Saul was my highlight.
SPEAKER_01Saul was for sure my highlight.
SPEAKER_03We we laughed at her every time, but whoever that snooty lady was really good.
SPEAKER_06She couldn't settle on an accent, though. She was all over the map with her delivery. It was her irony. I loved it.
SPEAKER_01Well, and the woman who and we didn't talk about her much, but I actually thought she was a very good actress. The woman who played the Dixie Lee. Dixie Lee. Dixie Lee was very good.
SPEAKER_06I think Dixie Lee was better than the Irene Dunn could be.
SPEAKER_01I actually don't disagree with that statement. Like the scene with her in the courtroom, the amount of nuance that she was able to show without saying a word compared to everyone else who was just hammering.
SPEAKER_06Yeah, I would actually argue Irene Dunn in those scenes was overacting. I agree. And Dixie Lee was sort of doing the most naturalistic of the things.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so I like Dixie Lee and Soul Levy would for me be the two standout characters in terms of acting, but uh they would swing it to like a three for me because they didn't.
SPEAKER_06I'd also rather watch a film on either of those.
SPEAKER_01Honestly, yeah, it's really the two of them together would be even better.
SPEAKER_05We need backstories for both of them. Let's make that movie.
SPEAKER_06Because really, Yancey's character is the equivalent of Sean Bean on uh what was that show that everyone was obsessed with?
SPEAKER_05Uh Game of Thrones. Game of Thrones.
SPEAKER_06He's like this moralistic sort of perfect character. Yes. And you're like, okay, well, this is getting real boring after a while.
SPEAKER_03True. They also the the guy who did the printing press stuff was um I thought he was pretty. He was very underutilized. No, but I mean he was he was even throughout the whole thing. He was consistent.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, yeah, I didn't like that they did the stutter thing with him, but you know.
SPEAKER_01No, that was a different one. That was not the newspaper. See, this wasn't the same guy. Three men in her life other than her husband. I thought it was the same. I thought it was a good one. I thought it was the same guy, too.
SPEAKER_06Well, anyway, acting. Yeah. Glenn's at a three. Glenn at three feels fair. Okay. Okay, three. Three feels fair. Uh, and rewatchability.
SPEAKER_01This is where the agreeing is gonna get tricky.
SPEAKER_06I'll walk out on the dock by myself on this one. It's not gonna be high.
SPEAKER_01No, it's not. And I've seen this before.
SPEAKER_06This is like my second time watching it, and uh it was tough the first time. Yeah, wow, and it was tough this time.
SPEAKER_01For me personally, it is a one. I am happy if the average.
SPEAKER_06By the way, you are you are able to give zeros, but ooh. I'm just saying, zero is a score you can give. Because we obviously it is because we gave uh the one movie a one.
SPEAKER_01We did get probably both that was definitely a zero across the board. Um this is a tough one for me because I'm trying to be fair. You just gave it a one. And there were well, no, now I'm debating about the zero. Um I'm playing the zero option. Um, no, you know, I'll still give it a one because there were parts of it that I would, I mean, I would never seek to put this on. But if someone else was like, hey, I'd be like, all right. Like, I you know, one or two shining moments of some halfway decent speeches I could sit through again.
SPEAKER_06Okay.
SPEAKER_01So I'll probably give it.
SPEAKER_06So you basically want a YouTube clip version of the page. I'll put it this way.
SPEAKER_01If I had if I was locked in a room, this is like Elisa style. If I was locked in a room tied to a chair forced to watch a film, and it was between this and Broadway Melody. All right, probably that may be a coming test for me.
SPEAKER_06It's very I think the rewatchability is is equally low on both of those.
SPEAKER_01But so for that reason, it's gonna be a one.
SPEAKER_06Okay, but it does make me appreciate Alkway unless I run a lot.
SPEAKER_03It's a three for me.
SPEAKER_06Okay, uh, Glenn.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, I I can't honestly can't think of people I would say, hey, you should sit down and watch this movie. And for me, watching it again would be tough. I I I'm not gonna give it a one, I'll give it a two. Okay. But that's a pretty generous.
SPEAKER_06Well, you could tell them there's way better irritating on films. That's true. Yes.
SPEAKER_01Well, yes, across the board.
SPEAKER_05But I'll give it a two.
SPEAKER_06Um in your one, three, two, so six, and I met up. I don't really want to do math. I mean, I'm at a one. But seven. So that makes seven, but seven divided by four.
SPEAKER_01Seven divided by four is math.
SPEAKER_06Yeah, that's math. Is it one point seven five? I think it's one point seven five. There you go.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, there you go. It's one point seven five.
SPEAKER_06Okay, so uh on that uh epic showing of our abilities, wow uh we give the a grand total of nine out of twenty. So I mean, I honestly going into the recording of this podcast, nine is more generous than I thought.
SPEAKER_01To be totally honest, I went into this a lot more confident that we were all on the same page.
SPEAKER_06I mean, we sort of all ended up with the water. We did mathematically, our breakdowns were pretty much. It's not like Glenn thought it was like the greatest Western ever made, and we thought it was thoroughly trashworthy.
SPEAKER_01Yes. We landed we thought it was thoroughly trashworthy.
SPEAKER_06Glenn just thought it was okay.
SPEAKER_05I think it's we both ended up enjoying it a little bit more than you. Yeah, that's totally fair.
SPEAKER_01Because you're the two old people on the podcast. And that's because it was the least western western we could have showed you. That is correct. Probably. Which is so ironic because that's why I didn't like it. Because it was the least western western I've ever seen.
SPEAKER_06But I will go out on a limb and say this is probably going to be one of the the our least liked best picture winners. Yeah, it's probably true. Yeah, I think until we get to the next western. Um and for our last segment, it's fun and games. And this is where I hit my co-host. You are pitted against each other this week. In a game of uh, I'm I guess I'm calling Witches Higher. Witches in which they will be asked to compare two things and try to guess which is higher.
SPEAKER_01Oh, it's not like witches and we're hiring for like potions. Okay, I got it. Thought it was totally.
SPEAKER_06No, we have our our quotient of witches already on this podcast. Uh it's gonna work this way. Each podcast co-host will be given five pairings. The person with the highest correct guesses wins the game.
SPEAKER_03Okay.
SPEAKER_06Pretty straightforward. And we will start this week with Alisa.
SPEAKER_03Okay. Oh god.
SPEAKER_06Alisa, which of these two films has the higher audience rating on Rotten Tomatoes? Is that A, the Exorcist, or B, Psycho?
SPEAKER_03Oh man. Wow. Two excellent films.
SPEAKER_06Oh, Rotten Tomatoes. I have my issues with the Exorcist, but it is a good film.
SPEAKER_01I had my immediate one, and I have a feeling I'm gonna be right.
SPEAKER_06Actually, I have my I I hate to say this about Alvard Hitchcock. I have my issues with Psycho.
SPEAKER_05Yeah.
SPEAKER_06I think it's a good film, but uh, it's not one that I return to that often.
SPEAKER_01Of his, no.
SPEAKER_06Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Like I think it is because he's got such a great expansive films, I think it's a little overrated.
SPEAKER_03I return to that a lot. So I'm gonna go with Psycho.
SPEAKER_06I mean, you're you're basically the Bates character. Um you are correct. Psycho has a 95% audience rating on Rotten Tomatoes, The Exorcist has only an 87%. That's ridiculous.
SPEAKER_01That should be higher. Yeah.
SPEAKER_06Uh Sarah, which of these two films has the higher audience rating on Rotten Tomatoes? Uh your two films are A, Star Wars Episode 4, A New Hope, which is the first one, or B, Dune Part 2.
SPEAKER_01Oh.
SPEAKER_06Man.
SPEAKER_01Because it's audience ratings. It's audience ratings. It is not critics ratings.
SPEAKER_06Well, uh uh, spoiler alert, we may get to the critics' ratings, but these are audience ratings.
SPEAKER_01I mean objectively, Dune 2 is a much better film. Um, and I think most people would probably agree with that. But I I do still kind of think it's New Hope. So I'm I'm gonna go with New Hope, but I do think Dune is a better movie.
SPEAKER_06Uh well, you're uh you are uh well, I'll say you're correct.
SPEAKER_04Okay, good.
SPEAKER_06Uh Dune Part 2 has 95% audience rating. Uh Star Wars episode 4 has 96 first rating rating.
SPEAKER_01I figured it'd be so tight. I was like, I gotta go the nostalgia factor because that will buy a lot.
SPEAKER_06And Glenn, which of these two films has the higher audience rating on the room? 2001 a space odyssey. Is that a Berdemic Shock and Terror?
SPEAKER_01The opposite ends.
SPEAKER_06Or B the room.
SPEAKER_01Oh man.
SPEAKER_06It's gotta be the room.
SPEAKER_01It has to be.
SPEAKER_06Uh, I could tell you you are correct. Yeah. Oh, Berdemic Shock and Terror has a 28% audience. Ridiculous. And the room's gonna be high. Shockingly, the room has a 47% audience.
SPEAKER_00Oh my god.
SPEAKER_06Alisa, by the way, all three of you correct so far. Heck yeah. Alisa, which of these two oh sorry, uh which of these two films has the most Academy Award nominations? Oh is that A Gladiator or B Godfather Part 2? Oh, that's tough.
SPEAKER_03This is purely a guess, but I'm turning with Godfather Part 2.
SPEAKER_06Well, I could tell you, Godfather Part 2 has 11 Academy Award nominations. Gladiator has 12 Academy Awards.
SPEAKER_03That is so unfair. It's right in there. Right. Sarah is. It has to be a five-point spread. You can't do that.
SPEAKER_06Well, you didn't make the rules. Sarah, which of these two films has the most Academy Award nominations?
SPEAKER_01Okay.
SPEAKER_06Is that A, Chicago or B, La La Land?
SPEAKER_01Oh. Oh.
SPEAKER_06Both highly overrated musicals.
SPEAKER_01I actually do think one is much better than the other.
SPEAKER_06Uh Chicago? Yeah. Okay. I do think Chicago is.
SPEAKER_01I mean it was a coin toss, but it's much better than La La Land. I'm gonna I'm gonna go Chicago.
SPEAKER_06Okay. Well, I could tell you.
SPEAKER_01La La Land is a lot more Oscar fan. I'm still gonna go Chicago.
SPEAKER_06Chicago has 13 Oscar nominations. La La Land has 14.
SPEAKER_01I was so close. Be careful, Black. Yeah. Be very careful. Because to me, Chicago is the more Oscar-y film than the great.
SPEAKER_06I could not La La Land literally takes place in Hollywood.
SPEAKER_01I did not like that movie.
SPEAKER_06Yeah. Which of these two films has the most Academy Award nomination?
SPEAKER_01It's gonna be within one.
SPEAKER_06Is it A, Patton? Oh, or B, Cleopatra.
SPEAKER_01Oh okay.
SPEAKER_05Okay. Oh man, oh man, oh man, oh man, oh man.
SPEAKER_01You can do this.
SPEAKER_05This is tough. This is tough.
SPEAKER_01I have no clue. I wouldn't even know where to guess.
SPEAKER_05The one I want to have more Oscar nominations is probably not the one that has more. And that would be Patton. So I'm gonna say Cleopatra.
SPEAKER_06Okay. Well, I can tell you, Cleopatra has nine Oscar nominations. Everybody repeat after me. Patton has ten Oscar nominations. Should have gone with my gut. Well, all three of you correct on the first one. And then immediately fell apart. All three of you correct on the first round, all three of you wrong on the second round.
SPEAKER_01Because we know what the audience thinks, because we are just peons in the audience. We don't know what the academy is considering.
SPEAKER_06Alisa, which of these two films has the highest critics score on Rotten Tomato? Is that A, Joker? Or B walk the line? Battle of the Joaquin Phoenix films.
SPEAKER_01For critics.
SPEAKER_06I think this is gonna be an easy one.
SPEAKER_03I agree. You think it's an easy one? I do.
SPEAKER_06Yeah. I mean Well, let her answer first, and then we'll see if you're gonna go.
SPEAKER_03Well, I'll see if I'm right, but yeah.
SPEAKER_06Imagine you and Glenn both have different things. You're both like, oh, this is so easy.
SPEAKER_01Watch that be what happens. One of us is gonna go, like, yeah.
SPEAKER_03I think it's going to be, even though I don't agree, walk the line.
SPEAKER_06Okay, so you think walk the line has a higher critic score than yes, I do. Okay. Is that how you would go? Joker.
SPEAKER_01Same. I was like very sure it was Joker.
SPEAKER_06Well, I can tell you, Walk the Line has an 83% critic score on Rotten Tomatoes. Joker, 68%. Oh, wow. Way to go.
SPEAKER_01Well done. I thought it was just because it was all artsy and stuff, and critics love that.
SPEAKER_06Yeah, they saw right through it. Thank you.
SPEAKER_01Lisa nails the question.
SPEAKER_06Sarah, which of these two films has the highest critic score on Rotten Tomatoes? Okay. Is that A, The Witch? Or B, The Lighthouse? This is a Battle of the Robert Eggers films. Both weird films.
SPEAKER_01Both are super weird. One of them I do think is better.
SPEAKER_06Basically, all of Robert Eggger films are weird.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And one of them I do genuinely think is better, but I also don't think that's the one that did it. So I'm gonna go with Lighthouse. Okay, well. Although I do think The Witch is a better film.
SPEAKER_06I can tell you The Lighthouse has a 90% critics rating on Rotten Tomatoes. The Witch has a 91% rating. The Witch is definitely better.
SPEAKER_01The Witch is a significantly better film, but again, I'm like The Lighthouse was so many things that were.
SPEAKER_06Whereas I didn't even hear about the water. The witch flew right under the radar. I was subsequently told about it. And still have nothing.
SPEAKER_01Are they both spooky?
SPEAKER_06The Lighthouse is just weird.
SPEAKER_01The Witch is like proper horror. The Witch is like actually a very, very good gothic horror film. And the Lighthouse is just like, let's be super weird in the Lighthouse.
SPEAKER_06Yeah, The Lighthouse seems vaguely like a vanity project. It is a vanity.
SPEAKER_01And it did a lot of things creatively and technically that were very clearly meant to be like a ooh, look at how impressive and weird I'm being, which is why I thought maybe the critics would go for it.
SPEAKER_06Uh well, they sort of did. They kind of did. Honestly, I know that far about it. Glenn, which of these two films has the highest critic score on Rotten Tomatoes? Is that A, 1917, or B, Hacksaw Ridge?
SPEAKER_01Oh, two very good film higher critics score.
SPEAKER_05Critic score. Oh man.
SPEAKER_01That's a tough one.
SPEAKER_05I love both these movies.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_05Um, I've seen one of these.
SPEAKER_01You've seen 1917. I have seen 1977. You didn't see Hacksaw. Neither did I. Hacksaw is Axel Ridge.
SPEAKER_05Hacksaw Ridges.
SPEAKER_01That's war too, right? It is. But it's like, again, it's like a different kind of work.
SPEAKER_06And it's not because I'm anti-Mel Gibson. Well, I mean anti-Wel Gibson as a big thing. It is crazy to think about. I quite like him as a actor.
SPEAKER_01It is crazy to think about that. That's a Mel Gibson.
SPEAKER_06Yeah.
SPEAKER_05Not in it, directing it.
SPEAKER_01He directed it. Yeah. Okay.
SPEAKER_06I mean, he's he's a good director. I don't always like the things he chooses to direct.
SPEAKER_01That one is Frenny shot for shot phenomenal. I don't know that there's much I'd criticize about Hacksaw Ridge. Honestly, they feel the same way.
SPEAKER_05I have a feeling I have a feeling because of what they did with the artificial one-shot film that it's going to be 1917, but it should be Hacksaw Ridge. It should be. But I'd say 1917.
SPEAKER_06Well, I can tell you, Hacksaw Ridge has an 84% audio or critics rating. 1917 has an 88% critic rating.
SPEAKER_01Oh, nicely done. I believe they are right there.
SPEAKER_06Current scores are Glenn and Elisa on two and Sarah on one.
SPEAKER_01Me on just one. That 1% really screwed me.
SPEAKER_06Alisa, which of the following actors has the most acting credits on internet movie database? Now keep in mind, acting credits is everything. I mean, if they appear as themselves in some sort of I don't think not commercials, but any cameos count out. And appearing as themselves count? Correct. Okay. Okay. Which of these two have the most has the most acting credits on internet movie database? A Mike Alkane. Or B John Wayne.
SPEAKER_03Well, John Wayne's been around longer.
SPEAKER_01Or not really because they're not contemporaries.
SPEAKER_06I was gonna say, given that one is currently dead, although fun fact, and I this was not where I picked these two, but fun fact the first Hollywood uh star that Michael Cain met in Hollywood was John Wayne. Oh, that's fine. Came up to him in a hotel uh lobby and complimented him on Alfie.
SPEAKER_05He encouraged him, he was very encouraging to him.
SPEAKER_03I am going with Michael Cain.
SPEAKER_06Okay. I could tell you Michael Cain has 176 acting credits on internet movie database. John Wayne has 184 acting credits.
SPEAKER_01Yes.
SPEAKER_06Which of the following actors has the most acting credits on Internet Movie Database? Is that A, Emma Thompson? Or B, Olivia Coleman?
SPEAKER_01Oh. Oh man. That is a really hard one. I am leaning toward.
SPEAKER_06Well, you should stand upright.
SPEAKER_01I'm leaning toward, I think, because of I because I know for a fact that she has done a ton of television. And I do not think Emma Thompson has stayed nearly as busy with TV the way that it's a good idea.
SPEAKER_06But Emma Thompson's also a screenwriter.
SPEAKER_01Which is also fair. Oh, I still think I'm gonna go Olivia Coleman.
SPEAKER_06Okay, well, I can tell you, Emma Thompson has 102 acting credits. Uh Olivia Coleman has 139.
SPEAKER_01Because she does TV, and I don't think I've ever seen Emma Thompson do TV.
SPEAKER_06Although technically I think in Internet Movie Database, TV only counts as one acting credit.
SPEAKER_01Oh, interesting. I think. Well, she's been in a lot of shows.
SPEAKER_06Oh, yeah. If you're in a show, that's one acting credit. So she could be on for six seasons, but it's still only one acting credit. Uh Glenn, which of the following actors has the most acting credits on internet movie database?
SPEAKER_05James Hong.
SPEAKER_06Is it A, Werner Hertzog? Or B? I think you'll know who B is David Lynch.
SPEAKER_01Oh.
SPEAKER_06Both act both directors who occasionally took on very weird acting roles.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, they did. They did. Oh man. And also made documentaries in which they my immediate reaction was Werner Herzog, so I'm going to stick with that.
SPEAKER_04Okay.
SPEAKER_06I can tell you uh Werner Herzog has 34 acting credits on Internet Movie Database. David Lynch has 36 credits. So I think if we're tying up the scores, tied up. Everyone has two.
SPEAKER_00Look at us go.
SPEAKER_06Alisa, which of the following actors has the most Academy Award nominations? By the way, this is the last round.
SPEAKER_01Oh wow. Nicely done.
SPEAKER_06I think, right? We did two.
SPEAKER_01You said five, right? I think this is five.
SPEAKER_06Yeah, yeah. Which of the following actors has the most Academy Award nominations? Is that A Steven Spielberg? Or B, Martin Scorsese. I say actors. I mean directors in this case.
SPEAKER_03Spielberg and Scorsese. Scorsese.
SPEAKER_06Who has the most Academy Award nominations?
SPEAKER_03Oh, damn. I think I'm gonna have to go with Spielberg.
SPEAKER_06Okay.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_06Interesting. I can tell you Martin Scorsese has the most directing nominations of the two of them. However, Steven Spielberg is also a producer. Uh Martin Scorsese has uh 16 Academy Award nominations. Steven Spielberg has 24. Wow.
SPEAKER_01Nicely done!
SPEAKER_06Because he was nominated for a lot of producing best picture.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah. That's what I was thinking. Yeah.
SPEAKER_06Sarah, which of the following actors has the most Academy Award nominations?
SPEAKER_01Okay.
SPEAKER_06Is that A, Colin Firth or B, Bill Nye?
SPEAKER_01Oh. Oh man.
SPEAKER_05I'm glad he asked you this one.
SPEAKER_01I was gonna say, I genuinely.
SPEAKER_05You English gentlemen. You're getting all the English actors.
SPEAKER_01I am, and I genuinely I'm going to go with who I feel like will have done to me more performances worthy of such accolades, and that's gotta be Bill Nye. But I have a feeling it might be Colin, but I'm gonna go Bill Knight.
SPEAKER_06Well, I can tell you only one of them has an actual Oscar.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_06And that is Colin Firth.
SPEAKER_01Dang it.
SPEAKER_06Uh that's so good. Colin Firth has two Oscar nominations. Bill Nye has one Oscar nomination. That's a crime.
SPEAKER_01That is such a crime. I mean, and I like both of them as actors, but I genuinely like Bill Nye more. And I do feel like he has had such a broader expanse of roles, so I figured just statistically, take it up with the Academy of Motion Arts. I'm mad at the Academy now.
SPEAKER_05I want to know who has more BAFTAs of those two. Uh probably Bill Nye.
SPEAKER_01I was gonna say surely Bill in the right environment. It's gotta be Bill.
SPEAKER_06And Glenn, which of the following actors has the most Academy Award nominations? Is that A, Sidney Portier, or B, Rod Steiger? And this is not at all because I was watching in the heat of the night.
SPEAKER_04Excellent film.
SPEAKER_05Who has more nominations? Nominators. More nominations is going to be Rod Steiger.
SPEAKER_06Well, I can tell you, Rod Steiger has three Oscar nominations, which, by the way, also seems like a crime. Yeah, is that he has been in a way better in a lot of things than that's why I went with him immediately. Sydney Portier has two Oscar. Both crimes tied. Both crimes, yeah.
SPEAKER_01So you two tied.
SPEAKER_06So yes, we have a tie between Alisa and Glenn.
SPEAKER_03What's the prize?
SPEAKER_06Um dignity. The prize is that you get to be better than Sarah.
SPEAKER_01I gotta tell you, that's like the equivalent of getting a rip, like a participation ribbon at a soccer tournament. It's not hard to do.
SPEAKER_06I'm sorry, I've lost my. And with that, we've reached the end of another episode of the Cinema Social Club. Thank you all for listening. If you'd like to write in to us, you can do so at cinemasocialpod at gmail.com. That's cinema socialpod at gmail.com. And be too sure to tune in next week when we'll be reviewing the next Best Picture Oscar winner, 1932's Grand Hotel. But until then, and on behalf of my co-hosts, it's goodbye for me. Goodbye.